Effect of Electrofishing Effort on an Index of Biotic Integrity

Abstract

We sampled fishes at 15 stream sites in the Ozark Highlands ecoregion of Arkansas and examined the effects of sampling effort on an index of biotic integrity (IBI). We found that sampling effort affected component metric scores, IBI scores, and qualitative site classifications. The scores of taxonomic richness metrics increased with increasing effort, while relative abundance metrics were inconsistently affected by sampling effort. The scores of all metrics stabilized with increasing effort. Although some deviation from the sampling effort designated for the IBI appeared acceptable, we found that even a sampling effort deviation of 10 mean stream widths from the designated effort (19.6%) caused one qualitative site classification to change. Our results showed that differences in sampling effort can affect IBI scores and result in erroneous stream assessments. They also indicated that an accurate assessment of regional stream conditions relies on incorporating the specific sampling effort designated for the Ozark Highlands IBI.