Classroom justice: student aggression and resistance as reactions to perceived unfairness

Abstract

The present study examined the relations between students' perceptions of distributive and procedural justice in college classes and student aggression and hostility toward their instructors and resistance of their instructors' requests. Although perceptions of both distributive and procedural justice were negatively correlated with student aggression and hostility, hierarchical multiple regression analyses indicated that only perceptions of procedural justice predicted these two criterion variables. The relationships between perceptions of justice and students' use of resistance strategies were less consistent. Hierarchical multiple regression analyses indicated that perceptions of procedural justice negatively predicted student revenge and deception. Contrary to predictions, perceptions of procedural and distributive justice did not interact to predict student aggression, hostility, or resistance. In short, students' perceptions of procedural justice in the classroom—for example that grades were distributed on the basis of fair evaluation criteria—appear more important than students' beliefs about the fairness of the assigned grade in determining student compliance and civility.

Keywords:

• justice
• aggression
• hostility
• resistance

Notes

Rebecca M. Chory‐Assad (PhD, Michigan State University, 2000) is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Communication Studies at West Virginia University. Michelle L. Paulsel (MA, Southwest Texas State University, 2002) is a doctoral student at West Virginia University. An earlier version of this manuscript was presented as the Top Paper to the Instructional and Development Communication Division of the International Communication Association at its annual meeting, San Diego, CA, May 2003. Rebecca Chory‐Assad can be contacted at [email protected]

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Rebecca M. Chory‐Assad

Rebecca M. Chory‐Assad (PhD, Michigan State University, 2000) is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Communication Studies at West Virginia University. Michelle L. Paulsel (MA, Southwest Texas State University, 2002) is a doctoral student at West Virginia University. An earlier version of this manuscript was presented as the Top Paper to the Instructional and Development Communication Division of the International Communication Association at its annual meeting, San Diego, CA, May 2003. Rebecca Chory‐Assad can be contacted at [email protected]