Adaptation of Medical Students During Clinical Training: Effects of Holistic Preclinical Education on Clerkship Performance

Abstract

Theory: Taiwan’s medical undergraduate program at a university or medical center is a continuation of 12 years of compulsory citizenship education rooted in holistic philosophies. Students acquire both technical knowledge and nontechnical attributes, which are necessary for success in further work and life. The early clinical learning experiences of medical students are primarily acquired through clerkships. These clerkships require medical students to apply and extend what they learned during their preclinical education; however, previous studies have explored this issue through examining fragmentary factors such as preclinical course grades and traits but not undertaking comprehensive, whole-person investigations. Hypotheses: To account for the potential benefits of a holistic approach in medical students’ learning, we propose three hypotheses: Medical students’ preclinical performance on Taiwan’s technical and nontechnical higher education assessments are positively associated with their clinical competence (Hypothesis 1) and psychological well-being (Hypothesis 2) during clerkships, and medical students’ psychological well-being during clerkships is positively associated with their clinical competence (Hypothesis 3). Method: We studied a cohort of 65 medical students engaged in clerkships from September 2013 to April 2015. Their preclinical technical knowledge scores—formal curricular grades received from course instructors—were obtained from their medical school’s archival dataset. Their nontechnical attributes—moral and social performance scores received from student mentors and physical performance scores received from course instructors—were also obtained from the school’s archival data set. The medical students’ competence in their 2-year clinical clerkships was measured using the objective structured clinical examination scores from the end of both clerkship years. The medical students’ psychological well-being during their 2-year clerkships was measured according to burnout level, which was determined using routine online surveys that employed validated, structured, and self-administered questionnaires at each specialty rotation. Multiple regressions and linear mixed-effects model were employed for statistical analysis. Results: Our study revealed that higher preclinical technical knowledge predicted superior clinical competence and a higher level of burnout during clerkships. By contrast, higher preclinical nontechnical attributes (i.e., higher preclinical moral, social, and physical performance) predicted lower level of burnout. However, no relationship was discovered between clerkship burnout and the clinical competence of the medical students. Conclusions: Our study verified the value of a holistic education that encompasses both technical knowledge and nontechnical attributes during the preclinical learning stage for medical students. Our findings can serve as a reference for medical educators designing preclinical educational programs for medical students.

Keywords:

• academic performance
• clerkship
• clinical competence
• workplace burnout
• holistic education

Acknowledgments

We thank the Taiwan Ministry of Science and Technology for funding (MOST 102-2511-S-039-001-MY3 & MOST 106-2511-S-039 -002 -MY2) and supporting the academic and administrative processes in this study. Many thanks also go to Wei-Hao Chang, Ph.D., CEO of TRI-STAR STATISTICS SERVICE COMPANY in Taiwan for the statistical consultation in this study.

Disclosure statement

All authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Ethical approval

This work was approved by the Institutional Review Board of China Medical University Hospital (CMUH102-REC3-088).