Association of Use of the NEJM Knowledge+ Product and Performance on the ABIM IM-MOC Exam

Abstract

Phenomenon: Internal medicine physicians in the United States must pass the American Board of Internal Medicine Internal Medicine Maintenance of Certification (ABIM IM-MOC) examination as part of their ABIM IM-MOC requirements. Many of these physicians use an examination product to help them prepare, such as e-Learning products, including the ACP’s MKSAP, UpToDate, and NEJM Knowledge+, yet their effectiveness remains largely unstudied. Approach: We compared ABIM IM-MOC examination performance among 177 physicians who attempted an ABIM IM-MOC examination between 2014-2017 and completed at least 75% of the NEJM Knowledge+ product prior to the ABIM IM-MOC examination and 177 very similar matched control physicians who did not use NEJM Knowledge+. Our measures of ABIM IM-MOC exam performance for NEJM Knowledge+ users were based on the results of the first attempt immediately following the NEJM Knowledge+ use and for non-users were based on the applicable matched examination performance. The three dichotomous examination performance outcomes measured on the first attempt at the ABIM IM-MOC examination included pass rate, scoring in the upper quartile, and scoring in the lower quartile. Findings: Use of NEJM Knowledge+ was associated with a regression adjusted 10.6% (5.37% to 15.8%) greater likelihood of passing the MOC examination (p < .001), 10.7% (2.61% to 18.7%) greater likelihood of having an examination score in the top quartile (p = .009), and −10.8% (–16.8% to −4.86%) lower likelihood of being in the bottom quartile of the MOC examination (p < .001) as compared to similar physicians who did not use NEJM Knowledge+. Insight: Physicians who used NEJM Knowledge+ had better ABIM IM-MOC exam performance. Further research is needed to determine what aspects of e-Learning products best prepare physicians for MOC examinations.

Keywords:

• Adaptive e-learning
• maintenance of certification examination preparation
• NEJM Knowledge+
• physician education

Acknowledgments

The authors of this study would like to acknowledge Rebecca Lipner, Ph.D. and Michelle Hache for their thoughtful review of this manuscript.

Declaration of interest statement

Drs. Healy and Phitayakorn each receive partial stipends from the NEJM Group. Dr. Gray and Ms. Duhigg are employees of the American Board of Internal Medicine. Mr. O'Rourke, Mrs. Marchwinski, and Mrs. Elmore are employees of NEJM Group.