Abstract
The purpose of this study is to examine the effects of morphological instruction on language and literacy outcomes by synthesizing 92 standardized mean differences (d) from 30 independent studies. Findings show a moderate overall effect of morphological instruction ([dbar] = 0.32), suggesting that children receiving morphological instruction performed significantly better on measures of literacy achievement than comparison groups. Moderator analyses showed that intervention effect varied depending on the literacy outcome. There were significant and moderate intervention effects on morphological knowledge ([dbar] = 0.44), phonological awareness ([dbar] = 0.48), vocabulary ([dbar] = 0.34), decoding ([dbar] = 0.59), and spelling ([dbar] = 0.30) but not on reading comprehension or fluency. Results also suggested differences in effectiveness related to age and research design but not unit of intervention, scope, length, and learner type. Effect sizes decrease by school level (e.g., greater for younger students than middle school and upper elementary students). Also, there were larger effects for quasi-experimental than experimental studies and for researcher-designed measures than for standardized measures. Implications for educational settings and research agendas are discussed.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Dr. Terezinha Nunes, Dr. Michael Kieffer, and Dr. Nonie Lesaux for their prompt responses and feedback. Their data have improved this analysis. We also thank the anonymous reviewers and Joanne Carlisle for their helpful feedback
Notes
1Authors attended several educational and reading conferences such as the American Educational Research Association, Council for Exceptional Children Convention & Expo, Society for the Scientific Study of Reading, Institute for Educational Sciences Annual Conference, and the Literacy Research Association and polled experts to find any studies that were never published or upcoming unpublished studies related to morphological instruction.
2When studies reported incomplete data, the primary authors were contacted repeatedly via e-mail, via phone, and at conferences to obtain the information to calculate effect sizes. Researchers were sent requests for information on the intervention related to moderator variables as well.
3Time frame of studies published since 1980 was chosen based on the history of the study of morphological knowledge in relation to literacy. For example, in the 1970s, researchers seemed focused on examining the correlations between morphological knowledge and general reading measures (CitationBrittain, 1970), whereas by the 1980s, researchers determined the frequency of morphologically complex words in text (CitationNagy & Anderson, 1984) and began to study morphological interventions (CitationWhite, Sowell, & Yanagihara, 1989; CitationWysocki & Jenkins, 1987).
4Studies in which reading instruction did not occur in English were excluded, eliminating three studies with instruction in English and Spanish and seven studies with instruction in languages other than English (CitationArnbak & Elbro, 2000; CitationCañado, 2006; CitationCarlo et al., 2004; CitationCasalis & Cole, 2009; CitationChow, McBride-Chang, Cheung, & Chow, 2008; CitationElbro & Arnbak, 1996; CitationLyster, 2002; CitationMorin, 2003; CitationPackard et al., 2006; CitationTomesen & Aarnoutse, 1998). In addition, three single subject studies (i.e., CitationCarlisle, 2007; CitationEdwards, 1982; CitationKatz & Carlisle, 2009) and studies with no control group (CitationHesse, Robinson, & Rankin, 1983; CitationLong & Rule, 2004; CitationTsesmeli & Seymour, 2009; CitationWhite et al., 1989; CitationWysocki & Jenkins, 1987) were excluded.
Brittain
,
M.
1970
.
Inflectional performance and early reading achievement
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
6
:
34
–
38
.
Nagy
,
W.
and
Anderson
,
R.
1984
.
The number of words in printed school English
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
19
:
304
–
330
.
White
,
T. G.
,
Sowell
,
J.
and
Yanagihara
,
A.
1989
.
Teaching elementary students to use word-part clues
.
Reading Teacher
,
42
:
302
–
308
.
Wysocki
,
K.
and
Jenkins
,
J. R.
1987
.
Deriving word meanings through morphological generalization
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
22
:
66
–
81
.
Arnbak
,
E.
and
Elbro
,
C.
2000
.
The effects of morphological awareness training on the reading and spelling skills of young dyslexics
.
Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research
,
44
:
229
–
251
.
Cañado
,
M. L. P.
2006
.
The effects of explicit spelling instruction in the Spanish EFL classroom: Diagnosis, development and durability
.
Language Awareness
,
15–1
:
20
–
27
.
Carlo
,
M. S.
,
August
,
D.
,
McLaughlin
,
B.
,
Snow
,
C. E.
,
Dressler
,
C.
,
Lippman
,
D. N.
and
White
,
C. E.
2004
.
Closing the gap: Addressing the vocabulary needs of English-language learners in bilingual and mainstream classrooms
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
39
:
188
–
215
.
Casalis
,
S.
and
Cole
,
P.
2009
.
On the relationship between morphological and phonological awareness: Effects of training in kindergarten and in first grade reading
.
First Language
,
29
:
113
–
142
.
Chow
,
B. W.
,
McBride-Chang
,
C.
,
Cheung
,
H.
and
Chow
,
C. S.
2008
.
Dialogic reading and morphology training in Chinese children: Effects on language and literacy
.
Developmental Psychology
,
44
:
233
–
244
.
Elbro
,
C.
and
Arnbak
,
E.
1996
.
The role of morpheme recognition and morphological awareness in dyslexia
.
Annals of Dyslexia
,
46
:
209
–
240
.
Lyster
,
S. A. H.
2002
.
The effects of morphological versus phonological awareness training in kindergarten on reading development
.
Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal
,
15
:
261
–
294
.
Morin
,
R.
2003
.
Derivational morphological analysis as a strategy for vocabulary acquisition in Spanish
.
The Modern Language Journal
,
87
(
ii
)
:
200
–
221
.
Packard
,
J. L.
,
Chen
,
X.
,
Li
,
W.
,
Wu
,
X.
,
Gaffney
,
J. S.
,
Li
,
H.
and
Anderson
,
R. C.
2006
.
Explicit instruction in orthographic structure and word morphology helps Chinese children learn to write characters
.
Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal
,
19
:
457
–
487
.
Tomesen
,
M.
and
Aarnoutse
,
C.
1998
.
Effects of an instructional programme for deriving word meanings
.
Educational Studies
,
24
:
107
Carlisle
,
J. F.
2007
.
“
Fostering morphological processing, vocabulary development, and reading comprehension
”
. In
Vocabulary acquisition: Implications for reading comprehension
,
Edited by:
Wagner
,
R. K.
,
Muse
,
A. E.
and
Tannenbaum
,
K. R.
78
–
103
.
New York
,
NY
:
Guilford
.
Edwards
,
V. H.
1982
.
Effects of improved reading of verb and noun inflectional endings on the reading comprehension of learning disabled students
,
Nashville
,
TN
:
Peabody College for Teachers of Vanderbilt University
.
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation)
Katz
,
L. A.
and
Carlisle
,
J. F.
2009
.
Teaching students with reading difficulties to be close readers: A feasibility study
.
Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools
,
40
:
325
–
340
.
Hesse
,
K. D.
,
Robinson
,
J. W.
and
Rankin
,
R.
1983
.
Retention and transfer from a morphemically based direct instruction spelling program in junior high
.
Journal of Educational Research
,
76
:
276
–
279
.
Long
,
D.
and
Rule
,
A. C.
2004
.
Learning vocabulary through morpheme word family object boxes
.
Journal of Authentic Learning
,
1
:
40
–
50
.
Tsesmeli
,
S. N.
and
Seymour
,
P. H. K.
2009
.
The effects of training of morphological structure on spelling derived words by dyslexic adolescents
.
British Journal of Psychology
,
100
:
565
–
592
.
White
,
T. G.
,
Sowell
,
J.
and
Yanagihara
,
A.
1989
.
Teaching elementary students to use word-part clues
.
Reading Teacher
,
42
:
302
–
308
.
Wysocki
,
K.
and
Jenkins
,
J. R.
1987
.
Deriving word meanings through morphological generalization
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
22
:
66
–
81
.
Nunes
,
T.
,
Bryant
,
P.
and
Olsson
,
J.
2003
.
Learning morphological and phonological spelling rules: An intervention study
.
Scientific Studies of Reading
,
7
:
289
–
307
.
*Bryant
,
P.
,
Nunes
,
T.
,
Pretzlik
,
U.
,
Bell
,
D.
,
Evans
,
D.
and
Olsson
,
J.
2006
.
“
From the laboratory to the classroom
”
. In
Improving literacy by teaching morphemes
,
Edited by:
Nunes
,
T.
and
Bryant
,
P.
65
–
103
.
London
,
, UK
:
Routledge
.
Viechtbauer
,
W.
and
Cheung
,
M. W. L.
2010
.
Outlier and influence diagnostics for meta-analysis
.
Research Synthesis Methods
,
1
:
112
–
125
.