An exploratory mixed methods analysis of adherence predictors following acute coronary syndrome

Abstract

Adherence to cardiac health behaviors is a critical predictor of prognosis in the months following an acute coronary syndrome (ACS). However, there has been minimal concomitant study of multiple nonadherence risk factors, as assessed via record review, structured assessments, and qualitative interviews, among hospitalized ACS patients. Accordingly, we completed an exploratory mixed methods study with 22 individuals who were admitted for ACS and had suboptimal pre-ACS adherence to physical activity, heart-healthy diet, and/or medications, defined by a Medical Outcomes Study Specific Adherence Scale (MOS SAS) score <15/18. During hospitalization, participants underwent quantitative assessments of sociodemographic, medical, and psychological variables, followed by in-depth semi-structured interviews to explore intentions, plans, and perceived barriers related to post-discharge health behavior changes. The MOS SAS was readministered at 3 months and participants were designated as persistently nonadherent (MOS SAS <15; n = 9) or newly adherent (n = 13). Interviews were transcribed and coded by trained raters via content analysis, and quantitative variables were compared between groups using chi-square analysis and independent-samples t-tests. On our primary qualitative analysis, we found that participants with vaguely described intentions/plans regarding health behavior change, and those who focused on barriers to change that were perceived as static, were more likely to be persistently nonadherent. On exploratory quantitative analyses, greater medical burden, diabetes, depressive symptoms, and low optimism/positive affect at baseline were associated with subsequent post-ACS nonadherence (all p < .05). In conclusion, this appears to be the first study to prospectively examine all of these constructs in hospitalized ACS patients, and we found that specific factors were associated with nonadherence to key health behaviors 3 months later. Therefore it may be possible to predict future nonadherence in ACS patients, even during hospitalization, and specific interventions during admission may be indicated to prevent adverse outcomes among patients at highest risk for post-ACS nonadherence.

Keywords:

• acute coronary syndrome
• health behavior
• mixed methods
• optimism
• positive affect

Additional information

Funding

This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health – National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute [grant number R01HL113272].