Investigating the influence of continuous babble on auditory short-term memory performance

Abstract

A number of factors could explain the adverse effect that babble noise has on memory for spoken words (Murphy, Craik, Li, & Schneider, 2000). Babble could degrade the perceptual representation of words to such an extent that it compromises their subsequent processing, or the presence of speech noise in the period between word presentations could interfere with rehearsal. Thirdly, the top-down processes needed to extract the words from the babble could draw on resources that otherwise would be used for encoding. We tested all these hypotheses by presenting babble either only during word presentation or rehearsal, or by gating the babble on and off 500 ms before and after each word pair. Only the last condition led to a decline in memory. We propose that this decline in memory occurred because participants were focusing their attention on the auditory stream (to enable them to better segregate the words from the noise background) rather than on remembering the words they had heard. To further support our claim we show that a similar memory deficit results when participants perform the same memory task in quiet together with a nonauditory attention-demanding secondary task.

Acknowledgments

The research in this article was supported by grants from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada and Canadian Institutes of Health Research. The first author was supported, in part, by a Canadian Institutes of Health research training grant, and by the International Council for Canadian Studies. We thank Jane Carey and Neda and Alham Chelehmalzadeh for their assistance in data collection.

Notes

¹ Preliminary statistical analyses found no statistically significant effect of presentation rate, possibly because presentation rate was randomized within a list.