Aces High: My Control Trumps Your Care

Abstract

Drawing from my previous experiences as an Approved Social Worker and my current experiences as a social work educator, this paper will explore the issues that mental health professionals, and specifically social workers, will face when confronted with the requirement to make decisions that are contrary to the emancipatory values that may have been inculcated in them during their period of training. The controlling nature of statutory social work in particular will be investigated and an assessment of its impact will be offered. The legislative system in the United Kingdom dictates that one piece of legislation can override another in certain instances. In applying this phenomenon, the argument will be made that social workers are increasingly required to override certain values to accomplish the desired outcomes of their position. Ethical issues and the concept of care versus control will be assessed in an attempt to rationalize the problems faced by many of today's mental health social workers.

Keywords:

• Care versus control
• Mental Health
• Social work values

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Chris Yianni

Chris Yianni is a Senior Lecturer on the Social Work programmes at Manchester Metropolitan University. Before this he worked as an Approved Social Worker in Central Manchester. He has also worked in the Housing and Hostels Division at Greater Manchester Probation Service