Continuous Collaborative Reflection Sessions in a Professional Learning Community: The Development of Grade 8 Natural Sciences Teachers’ Reflective Practice

Abstract

Learners come to class with a wealth of knowledge. Working with learner prior knowledge (LPK) is the foundation upon which new concepts get their meaning. Yet some teachers find interacting with LPK complex. Reflecting on practice, particularly within a professional learning community (PLC), has resulted in improvements in teaching. The focus of this study was to explore how teacher participation and the level of reflection changed as teachers collaborated in a PLC. Four Grade 8 Natural Sciences teachers from a suburban high school in Gauteng were participants. Data was collected using a practical action research, research design. Results from the reflect-and-plan sessions are reported. Cycle 1 focused on how teachers work with LPK in their baseline practices, with the following cycles focused on the same content (effects of electric current), taught in successive years. Data collected from reflect-and-plan sessions was audio-recorded. From the transcripts reflective episodes were identified. Reflective episodes occurred where teachers reflected on an aspect of practice needing restructuring. Combining Zeichner and Liston’s levels of reflection with O’Sullivan’s basic level of reflection, teacher utterances were coded as indicating moral craftsperson, craftsperson, technician or basic technician. Results showed that, as teachers attended more sessions, so their participation and the level of their reflection increased. Teacher participation was dependent on a trusted environment. Inexperienced teachers were reliant on a leader with sound content and pedagogical knowledge guiding sessions. The importance of identifying motivated teachers to lead PLCs is highlighted.

Keywords:

• Collaboration
• Participation
• Level of Reflection
• Professional Learning Communities

ORCID

Jenny Woolway http://orcid.org/0000-0002-5451-6913

Audrey Msimanga http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7036-1181

Anthony Lelliott http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6424-5953

Notes

1 Natural Sciences is a subject taught in junior high school and includes chemistry, physics and biology.

Additional information

Funding

This work was supported by the National Research Foundation [grant number 90385].