A fairytale narrative for community sport? Exploring the politics of sport social enterprise

ABSTRACT

With voluntary sports clubs operating within competitive leisure markets and local governments responding to austerity by transferring sport facilities to community groups, such organisations are encouraged to become social enterprises. Driven by social entrepreneurs embracing ‘Robin Hood’ business models, they apparently deliver innovative solutions to social problems. Such fairytale narratives are increasingly popular in Scotland with its reputation as a ‘happening place’ for social policy innovation. Using case study material from an award-winning football social enterprise, I outline how time spent in their deprived community establishing needs and ownership aided success.  Also, recruiting local youth workers, developing authentic partnerships, and creating a non-judgemental environment delivered a positive ‘ripple effect’ beyond that possible from class-blind sport provision.  However, ‘win win’ rhetoric ignores stresses from meeting financial requirements and moral dilemmas from trade-offs between social and business goals. The organisation’s ‘non-establishment’ nature is partially undermined by emphasising local poverty of aspiration and the psychological thinking within Dweck’s ‘Growth Mindset’ and Duckworth’s ‘Grit’ research. The resulting focus on individual effort and learning from failure chimes with neoliberal thinking, ignoring how widening societal inequality and politics causes local problems and the need for structural changes for wider social impact.

KEYWORDS:

• Social enterprise
• football
• education
• politics
• youth work

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Gavin Reid

Gavin Reid lectures in sports development and the politics of sports policy at the University of Edinburgh. His main research interest is in the politics of sports policy in post devolution Scotland. His recent work has critically analysed the link between community sport and social enterprise, and the impact of austerity on local government sport and recreation services. He has also undertaken research on the politics of demonstrating a sporting legacy from Glasgow’s 2014 Commonwealth Games.