Terminal Feedback Outperforms Concurrent Visual, Auditory, and Haptic Feedback in Learning a Complex Rowing-Type Task

REFERENCES

• Blandin , Y. , Toussaint , L. and Shea , C. H. 2008 . Specificity of practice: Interaction between concurrent sensory information and terminal feedback . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition , 34 : 994 – 1000 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bluteau , J. , Coquillart , S. , Payan , Y. and Gentaz , E. 2008 . Haptic guidance improves the visuo-manual tracking of trajectories . PLoS ONE , 3 ( 3 ) : e1775
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chiviacowsky , S. and Wulf , G. 2002 . Self-controlled feedback: Does it enhance learning because performers get feedback when they need it? . Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport , 73 : 408 – 415 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chiviacowsky , S. and Wulf , G. 2005 . Self-controlled feedback is effective if it is based on the learner's performance . Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport , 76 : 42 – 48 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chollet , D. , Madani , M. and Micallef , J. P. 1992 . Biomechanics and medicine in swimming , London , England : E & FN Spon .
   Google Scholar
• Chollet , D. , Micallef , J. P. and Rabischong , P. 1988 . Swimming science V , Champaign , IL : Human Kinetics Books .
   Google Scholar
• Duschau-Wicke , A. , von Zitzewitz , J. , Caprez , A. , Lunenburger , L. and Riener , R. 2010 . Path control: A method for patient-cooperative robot-aided gait rehabilitation . IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering , 18 : 38 – 48 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Effenberg , A. O. and Mechling , H. 1998 . Bewegung hörbar machen—Warum? Zur Perspektive einer systematischen Umsetzung von Bewegung in Klänge [ . Psychologie und Sport , 5 : 28 – 38 . Make motion audible—Why? The perspective of a systematic transformation of movement into sounds].
   Google Scholar
• Eldridge , A. 2006 . Issues in auditory display . Artificial Life , 12 : 259 – 74 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Emken , J. L. , Benitez , R. and Reinkensmeyer , D. J. 2007 . Human-robot cooperative movement training: Learning a novel sensory motor transformation during walking with robotic assistance-as-needed . Journal of Neuroengineering and Rehabilitation , 4 : 8
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Feygin , D. , Keehner , M. and Tendick , R. 2002 . Haptic guidance: Experimental evaluation of a haptic training method for a perceptual motor skill . Proceedings of the 10th Symposium on Haptic Interfaces for Virtual Environment and Teleoperator Systems , : 40 – 47 .
   Google Scholar
• Freides , D. 1974 . Human information processing and sensory modality: Cross-modal functions, information complexity, memory, and deficit . Psychological Bulletin , 81 : 284 – 310 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Giese , M. A. and Poggio , T. 2000 . Morphable models for the analysis and synthesis of complex motion patterns . International Journal of Computer Vision , 38 : 59 – 73 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Godbout , A. and Boyd , J. 2010 . Corrective sonic feedback for speed skating: A case study . Proceedings of the 16th International Conference on Auditory Display , : 23 – 30 .
   Google Scholar
• Grond , F. , Hermann , T. , Verfaille , V. and Wanderley , M. 2010 . Gesture in embodied communication and human computer interaction, LNAI 5934 , New York , NY : Springer .
   Google Scholar
• Holden , M. K. 2005 . Virtual environments for motor rehabilitation: Review . Cyber Psychology & Behavior , 8 : 187 – 211 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Huegel , J. and O’Malley , M. K. 2010 . Progressive haptic and visual guidance for training in a virtual dynamic task . Haptics Symposium, 2010 IEEE , : 343 – 350 .
   Google Scholar
• Huet , M. , Camachon , C. , Fernandez , L. , Jacobs , D. M. and Montagne , G. 2009 . Self-controlled concurrent feedback and the education of attention toward perceptual invariants . Human Movement Science , 28 : 450 – 467 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hummel , J. , Hermann , T. , Frauenberger , C. and Stockman , T. 2010 . Interactive sonification of german wheel sports movement . Proceedings of ISon 2010, 3rd Interactive Sonification Workshop , : 17 – 22 .
   Google Scholar
• Ierusalimschy, R. (2013). Programming in Lua (3rd ed.). Available at http://www.lua.org
   Google Scholar
• Israel , J. , Campbell , D. , Kahn , J. and Hornby , T. 2006 . Metabolic costs and muscle activity patterns during robotic-and therapist-assisted treadmill walking in individuals with incomplete spinal cord injury . Physical Therapy , 86 : 1466 – 1478 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Janelle , C. M. , Barba , D. A. , Frehlich , S. G. , Tennant , L. K. and Cauraugh , H. 1997 . Maximizing performance feedback effectiveness through videotape replay and a self-controlled learning environment . Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport , 68 : 269 – 279 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Janelle , C. M. , Kim , J. and Singer , R. N. 1995 . Subject-controlled performance feedback and learning of a closed motor skill . Perceptual and Motor Skills , 81 : 627 – 634 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Khatib , O. 1986 . Real-time obstacle avoidance for manipulators and mobile robots . The International Journal of Robotics Research , 5 : 90
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Konttinen , N. , Mononen , K. , Viitasalo , J. and Mets , T. 2004 . The effects of augmented auditory feedback on psychomotor skill learning in precision shooting . Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology , 26 : 306 – 316 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kovacs , A. J. and Shea , C. H. 2011 . The learning of 90° continuous relative phase with and without lissajous feedback: External and internally generated bimanual coordination . Acta Psychologica , 136 : 311 – 320 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Krakauer , J. and Mazzoni , P. 2011 . Human sensorimotor learning: Adaptation, skill, and beyond . Current Opinion in Neurobiology , 21 : 636 – 644 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Liebermann , D. G. , Katz , L. , Hughes , M. D. , Bartlett , R. M. , McClements , J. and Franks , I. M. 2002 . Advances in the application of information technology to sport performance . Journal of Sports Sciences , 20 : 755 – 769 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Liu , D. and Todorov , E. 2007 . Evidence for the flexible sensorimotor strategies predicted by optimal feedback control . The Journal of Neuroscience , 27 : 9354 – 9368 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Liu , J. , Cramer , S. and Reinkensmeyer , D. 2006 . Learning to perform a new movement with robotic assistance: Comparison of haptic guidance and visual demonstration . Journal of Neuroengineering and Rehabilitation , 3 : 20
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Magill , R. and Anderson , D. 2012 . Skill acquisition in sports , 2nd ed. , New York , NY : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Marchal-Crespo , L. , Furumasu , J. and Reinkensmeyer , D. J. 2010 . A robotic wheelchair trainer: design overview and a feasibility study . Journal of Neuroengineering and Rehabilitation , 7 : 40 – 51 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Marchal-Crespo , L. , Rauter , G. , Wyss , D. , von Zitzewitz , J. and Riener , R. 2012 . Synthesis and control of a parallel tendon-based robotic tennis trainer . 4th IEEE RAS EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob) , : 355 – 360 .
   Google Scholar
• Marchal-Crespo , L. and Reinkensmeyer , D. 2008 . Haptic guidance can enhance motor learning of a steering task . Journal of Motor Behavior , 40 : 545 – 557 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Marchal-Crespo , L. and Reinkensmeyer , D. J. 2009 . Review of control strategies for robotic movement training after neurologic injury . Journal of Neuroengineering and Rehabilitation , 6 : 20
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Marschall , F. , Bund , A. and Wiemeyer , J. 2007 . Does frequent feedback really degrade learning? A meta analysis . E-Journal Bewegung und Training , 1 : 75 – 86 .
   Google Scholar
• Mononen , K. 2007 . The effect of augmented feedback on motor skill learning in shooting , Finland : University of Jyväskylä . PhD thesis
   Google Scholar
• Nesbitt , K. 2003 . Designing multi-sensory displays for abstract data , Australia : School of Information Technologies, University of Sydney . PhD thesis
   Google Scholar
• Park , J. H. , Shea , C. H. and Wright , D. L. 2000 . Reduced-frequency concurrent and terminal feedback: A test of the guidance hypothesis . Journal of Motor Behavior , 32 : 287 – 296 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Patoglu , V. , Li , Y. and O’Malley , M. 2009 . On the efficacy of haptic guidance schemes for human motor learning . World Congress on Medical Physics and Biomedical Engineering , : 203 – 206 .
   Google Scholar
• Patton , J. , Stoykov , M. , Kovic , M. and Mussa-Ivaldi , F. 2006 . Evaluation of robotic training forces that either enhance or reduce error in chronic hemiparetic stroke survivors . Experimental brain research , 168 : 368 – 383 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Proteau , L. 1992 . Vision and motor control (volume 85) , Amsterdam , the Netherlands : North-Holland .
   Google Scholar
• Proteau , L. 2005 . Visual afferent information dominates other sources of afferent information during mixed practice of a video-aiming task . Experimental Brain Research , 161 : 441 – 456 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Proteau , L. and Isabelle , G. 2002 . On the role of visual afferent information for the control of aiming movements toward targets of different sizes . Journal of Motor Behavior , 34 : 367 – 384 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ranganathan , R. and Newell , K. M. 2009 . Influence of augmented feedback on coordination strategies . Journal of Motor Behavior , 41 : 317 – 330 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rauter , G. , Sigrist , R. , Baur , K. , Baumgartner , L. , Wolf , P. and Riener , R. 2011 . “ A virtual trainer concept for robot-assisted human motor learning in rowing ” . In BIO Web of Conferences; The International Conference SKILLS (Vol. 1) Les Ulis , , France: EDP Sciences
   Google Scholar
• Rauter , G. , Sigrist , R. , Marchal-Crespo , L. , Vallery , H. , Riener , R. and Wolf , P. 2011 . Assistance or challenge? Filling a gap in user-cooperative control . IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS) , : 3068 – 3073 .
   Google Scholar
• Rauter , G. , von Zitzewitz , J. , Duschau-Wicke , A. , Vallery , H. and Riener , R. 2010 . A tendon based parallel robot applied to motor learning in sports . 3rd IEEE RAS and EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob), , : 82 – 87 .
   Google Scholar
• Reinkensmeyer , D. , Akoner , O. , Ferris , D. and Gordon , K. 2009 . Slacking by the human motor system: Computational models and implications for robotic orthoses . : 2129 – 2132 . Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2009. EMBC 2009. Annual International Conference of the IEEE
   Google Scholar
• Robin , C. , Toussaint , L. , Blandin , Y. and Proteau , L. 2005 . Specificity of learning in a video-aiming task: Modifying the salience of dynamic visual cues . Journal of Motor Behavior , 37 : 367 – 376 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , J. , Edwards , N. , Villanueva , D. , Krishna , S. , McDaniel , T. and Panchanathan , S. 2011 . Design, implementation, and case study of a pragmatic vibrotactile belt . IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement , 60 : 114 – 125 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Salmoni , S. 1984 . Knowledge of results and motor learning. A review and critical reappraisal . Psychological Bulletin , 95 : 355 – 386 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schmidt , R. A. 1991 . Frequent augmented feedback can degrade learning: Evidence and interpretations . Tutorials in Motor Neuroscience , 62 : 59 – 75 .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , R. A. and Wrisberg , C. 2008 . Motor learning and performance: A situation-based learning approach , Champaign , IL : Human Kinetics .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , R. A. and Wulf , G. 1997 . Continuous concurrent feedback degrades skill learning: Implications for training and simulation . Human Factors , 39 : 509 – 525 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schmidt , R. A. , Young , D. E. , Swinnen , S. and Shapiro , D. C. 1989 . Summary knowledge of results for skill acquisition: support for the guidance hypothesis . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition , 15 : 352 – 359 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Secoli , R. , Milot , M. , Rosati , G. and Reinkensmeyer , D. 2011 . Effect of visual distraction and auditory feedback on patient effort during robot-assisted movement training after stroke . Journal of Neuroengineering and Rehabilitation , 8 : 1 – 10 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Shadmehr , R. and Mussa-Ivaldi , F. 1994 . Adaptive representation of dynamics during learning of a motor task . Journal of Neuroscience , 14 : 3208 – 3224 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sigrist , R. , Rauter , G. , Riener , R. and Wolf , P. 2011 . “ Self-controlled feedback for a complex motor task ” . In BIO Web of Conferences; The International Conference SKILLS (Vol. 1) Les Ulis , , France: EDP Sciences
   Google Scholar
• Sigrist , R. , Rauter , G. , Riener , R. and Wolf , P. 2013 . Augmented visual, auditory, haptic, and multimodal feedback in motor learning: A review . Psychonomic Bulletin & Review , 20 : 21 – 53 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sigrist , R. , Schellenberg , J. , Rauter , G. , Broggi , S. , Riener , R. and Wolf , P. 2011 . Visual and auditory augmented concurrent feedback in a complex motor task . Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments , 20 : 15 – 32 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Snodgrass , S. J. , Rivett , D. A. , Robertson , V. J. and Stojanovski , E. 2010 . Real-time feedback improves accuracy of manually applied forces during cervical spine mobilisation . Manual Therapy , 15 : 19 – 25 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Swinnen , S. P. , Lee , T. D. , Verschueren , S. , Serrien , D. J. and Bogaerds , H. 1997 . Interlimb coordination: Learning and transfer under different feedback conditions . Human Movement Science , 16 : 749 – 785 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Swinnen , S. P. , Schmidt , R. A. , Nicholson , D. E. and Shapiro , D. C. 1990 . Information feedback for skill acquisition: Instantaneous knowledge of results degrades learning . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition , 16 : 706 – 716 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Todorov , E. 2004 . Optimality principles in sensorimotor control . Nature Neuroscience , 7 : 907 – 915 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Todorov , E. and Jordan , M. I. 2002 . Optimal feedback control as a theory of motor coordination . Nature Neuroscience , 5 : 1226 – 1235 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Todorov , E. , Shadmehr , R. and Bizzi , E. 1997 . Augmented feedback presented in a virtual environment accelerates learning of a difficult motor task . Journal of Motor Behavior , 29 : 147 – 158 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Vallery , H. , Guidali , M. , Duschau-Wicke , A. and Riener , R. 2009 . Patient-cooperative control: Providing safe support without restricting movement . World Congress on Medical Physics and Biomedical Engineering , : 166 – 169 .
   Google Scholar
• Van Beers , R. J. 2009 . Motor learning is optimally tuned to the properties of motor noise . Neuron , 63 : 406 – 417 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Van der Linden , D. W. , Cauraugh , J. H. and Greene , T. A. 1993 . The effect of frequency of kinetic feedback on learning an isometric force production task in nondisabled subjects . Physical Therapy , 73 : 79 – 87 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Van Erp , J. B. F. , Saturday , I. and Jansen , C. 2006 . Application of tactile displays in sports: Where to, how and when to move . Proceedings of the Eurohaptics International Conference , : 1 – 5 .
   Google Scholar
• Vlachos , M. , Hadjieleftheriou , M. , Gunopulos , D. and Keogh , E. 2003 . Indexing multi-dimensional time-series with support for multiple distance measures . Proceedings of the Ninth ACM SIGKDD International Conference on Knowledge discovery and Data Mining, KDD ‘03 , : 216 – 225 .
   Google Scholar
• Von Zitzewitz , J. , Wolf , P. , Novakovic , V. , Wellner , M. , Rauter , G. , Brunschweiler , A. and Riener , R. 2008 . Real-time rowing simulator with multimodal feedback . Sports Technology , 1 : 257 – 266 .
   Google Scholar
• Wei , K. and Körding , K. 2009 . Relevance of error: What drives motor adaptation? . Journal of Neurophysiology , 101 : 655 – 664 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Welch , R. B. and Warren , D. H. 1980 . Immediate perceptual response to intersensory discrepancy . Psychological Bulletin , 88 : 638 – 667 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Winstein , C. J. 1991 . Knowledge of results and motor learning—implications for physical therapy . Physical Therapy , 71 : 140 – 149 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Winstein , C. J. , Pohl , P. S. , Cardinale , C. , Green , A. , Scholtz , L. and Waters , C. S. 1996 . Learning a partial-weight-bearing skill: Effectiveness of two forms of feedback . Physical Therapy , 76 : 985 – 993 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wishart , L. R. , Lee , T. D. , Cunningham , S. J. and Murdoch , J. E. 2002 . Age-related differences and the role of augmented visual feedback in learning a bimanual coordination pattern . Acta Psychologica , 110 : 247 – 263 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wolpert , D. M. , Diedrichsen , J. and Flanagan , J. R. 2011 . Principles of sensorimotor learning . Nature Reviews Neuroscience , 12 : 739 – 749 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wulf , G. 2007 . Self-controlled practice enhances motor learning: Implications for physiotherapy . Physiotherapy , 93 : 96 – 101 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wulf , G. , Hörger , M. and Shea , C. H. 1999 . Benefits of blocked over serial feedback on complex motor skill learning . Journal of Motor Behavior , 31 : 95 – 103 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wulf , G. and Shea , C. H. 2002 . Principles derived from the study of simple skills do not generalize to complex skill learning . Psychonomic Bulletin & Review , 9 : 185 – 211 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wulf , G. , Shea , C. and Lewthwaite , R. 2010 . Motor skill learning and performance: A review of influential factors . Medical Education , 44 : 75 – 84 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wulf , G. , Shea , C. H. and Matschiner , S. 1998 . Frequent feedback enhances complex motor skill learning . Journal of Motor Behavior , 30 : 180 – 192 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar