3,134
Views
25
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original papers

Unconscious influences in sentencing decisions: a research review of psychological sources of disparity

&
Pages 19-36 | Published online: 09 Dec 2009

References

  • Findlay , M , Odgers , S and Yeo , S . 2003 . Australian criminal justice , New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Freiberg A Gelb K Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy Hawkins Press Sydney 2008
  • Gelb , K . 2006 . Myths and misconceptions: public opinion versus public judgment about sentencing , Melbourne : Sentencing Advisory Council .
  • Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 1982 . “ The criminal justice system: A social-psychological analysis ” . In An analysis of the sentencing system , Edited by: Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 293 – 332 . San Francisco : WH Freeman & Company .
  • Roberts , J V . 2008 . “ The evolving role of public opinion ” . In Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy , Edited by: Freiberg , A and Gelb , K . 15 – 30 . Sydney : Hawkins Press .
  • Keyzer , P and Blay , S . 2006 . Double punishment? Preventive detention schemes under Australian legislation and their consistency with international law: the Fardon communication . Melbourne Journal of International Law , 7 : 407 – 424 .
  • McSherry , B . 2008 . “ Dangerous legislation ” . In Forensic psychology and criminology: An Australian perspective , Edited by: Fritzon , K and Wilson , P . 227 – 236 . McGraw-Hill .
  • Sherman , L , Gottfredson , D , MacKenzie , D , Eck , J , Reuter , P and Bushway , S . Preventing crime: What works, what doesn't, what's promising Report to the US Congress, Washington, DC; 1997
  • Payne , J . 2007 . Recidivism in Australia: Findings and future research . Research and Public Policy Series , 80 : 1 – 139 .
  • Villettaz , P , Killias , M and Zoder , I . The effects of custodial vs. non-custodial sentences on re-offending: A systematic review of the state of knowledge Report to the Campbell Collaboration Crime and Justice Group; 2006. http://www.campbellcollaboration.org/doc-pdf/Campbell-report-30.09.06.pdf
  • Lovegrove , A . 2007 . Public opinion, sentencing and lenience: An empirical study involving judges consulting the community . Criminal Law Review , : 769 – 781 .
  • Warner , K , Davis , J , Walter , M , Bradfield , R and Vermey , R . 2009 . Gauging public opinion on sentencing: can asking jurors help? . Trends & Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice , 371 : 1 – 5 .
  • Jones , C , Weatherburn , D and McFarlane , K . 2008 . Public confidence in the New South Wales criminal justice system . Crime and Justice Bulletin , 118 : 1 – 18 .
  • Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 1982 . “ The criminal justice system: A social-psychological analysis ” . In An analysis of the sentencing system , Edited by: Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 293 – 332 . San Francisco : WH Freeman & Company .
  • Diamond , S and Zeisel , H . 1995 . Sentencing councils: A study of sentence disparity and its reduction . University of Chicago Law Review , 43 : 109 – 149 .
  • Lovegrove , A . 2008 . The framework of judicial sentencing: A study in legal decision making , UK : Cambridge University Press .
  • Oswald , M E . 1994 . Psychology of judicial sentencing , Stuttgart, , Germany : Enke .
  • Sporer , S L and Goodman-Delahunty , J . 2009 . “ Disparities in sentencing decisions ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 379 – 401 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Bruschke , J and Loges , W E . 2004 . Free press vs. Fair trials: Examining publicity's role in trial outcomes , Mahwah, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum Associate .
  • Vidmar , N . 2002 . Case studies of pre- and midtrial prejudice in criminal and civil litigation . Law and Human Behaviour , 26 : 76 – 105 .
  • Thompson , C M and Dennison , S . 2004 . Graphic evidence of violence: The impact on juror's decision-making, the influence of judicial instructions and the effect of juror biases . Psychiatry, Psychology and Law , 11 : 323 – 337 .
  • Bright , D A and Goodman-Delahunty , J . 2006 . Gruesome evidence and emotion: Anger, blame and jury decision making . Law and Human Behavior , 30 : 183 – 202 .
  • Nadler , J and Rose , M R . 2003 . Victim impact testimony and the psychology of punishment . Cornell Law Review , 88 : 419 – 438 .
  • Sporer , S L and Goodman-Delahunty , J . Breaking the chain of causation: The influence of extra-legal factors on judicial sentencing and victim compensation Unpublished manuscript. University of Giessen, Germany, 2007
  • Ebbesen , E E and Konecni , V J . 1982 . “ The process of sentencing adult felons: A causal analysis of sentencing decisions ” . In The trial process , Edited by: Sales , B D . 413 – 458 . NY : Plenum .
  • Ebbesen , E E and Konecni , V J . 1985 . Criticisms of the criminal justice system: A decision making analysis . Behavioural Science & the Law , 3 : 177 – 194 .
  • Spigelman , J J . 1999 . Sentencing guideline judgments Address to the National Conference of District and County Court Judges. http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/lawlink/supreme_court/ll_sc.nsf/pages/SCO_speech_spigelman_240699
  • New South Wales Sentencing Council . Guideline judgments http://www.lawlink.nsw. gov.au/Lawlink/scouncil/ll_scouncil.nsf/pages/scouncil_guidelinejudgments
  • New South Wales Sentencing Council . Factors in Sentencing http://www.lawlink.nsw. gov.au/Lawlink/scouncil/ll_scouncil.nsf/pages/scouncil_factors_sentencing
  • New South Wales Judicial Commission . Sentencing Benchbook http://www.judcom. nsw.gov.au/publications/benchbks/sentencing/index.html
  • Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 1984 . The mythology of legal decision making . International Journal of Psychiatry and Law , 7 : 5 – 18 .
  • Sporer , S L and Goodman-Delahunty , J . 2009 . “ Disparities in sentencing decisions ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 379 – 401 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Sporer , S L . 1982 . “ Reducing disparity in judicial sentencing: A social–psychological approach ” . Frankfurt : Peter Lang Verlag .
  • Sporer , S L . 1984 . Sentencing councils: A social-psychological analysis . International Review of Applied Psychology , 33 : 121 – 136 .
  • Wrightsman , L . 1999 . Judicial decision making: Is psychology relevant? , Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers .
  • Danelski , D J . 1966 . Values as variables in judicial decision making: Notes towards a theory . Vanderbilt Law Review , 19 : 721 – 740 .
  • Engel C Gigerenzer G Heuristics and the law Dahlem Workshop Report 94. Cambridge (MA): The MIT Press; 2006
  • Guthrie , C , Rachlinski , J and Wistrich , A . 2001 . Inside the judicial mind . Cornell Law Review , 86 : 777 – 830 .
  • Englich , B . 2009 . “ Heuristic strategies and persistent biases in sentencing decisions ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 295 – 314 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Englich , B . 2006 . Blind or biased? Justitia's susceptibility to anchoring effects in the courtroom based on given numerical representations . Law and Policy , 28 : 497 – 514 .
  • Oswald , M E and Stucki , I . 2009 . “ A two-process model of punishment ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 173 – 191 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Lovegrove , A . 2006 . The framework of judicial sentencing: A study in legal decision making , UK : Cambridge University Press .
  • Wayne , V . Judicial fact-finding: trial by judge alone in serious criminal cases Melbourne University Law Review; 2003. Retrieved July 7 2009 from http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/MULR/2003/16.html
  • Englich , B , Mussweiler , T and Strack , F . 2006 . Playing dice with criminal sentences: The influence of irrelevant anchors on experts' judicial decision making . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 32 : 188 – 200 .
  • Rosenblatt , A , Greenberg , J , Solomon , S , Pyzczynski , T and Lyon , D . 1989 . Evidence for terror management theory I: The effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who violate or uphold cultural values . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 57 : 681 – 690 .
  • Bieneck , S . 2009 . “ How adequate is the vignette technique as a research tool or psycho-legal research? ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 255 – 271 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Sporer , S L . 1982 . Reducing disparity in judicial sentencing: A social-psychological approach , Frankfurt/Main, , Germany : Peter Lang .
  • Rennig , C . 1991 . “ Zur Analyse von Urteilsberatungen im Schöffengericht: Wahrnehmung und Verarbeitung unterschiedlicher Fallauffassungen [Analysis of deliberations in mixed tribunals: Perception and interpretation of the differing case views] ” . In Brennpunkte der Rechtpsychologie: Polizei, Justiz, Drogen , Edited by: Egg , R . 311 – 328 . Bonn, , Germany : Forum .
  • Englich , B , Mussweiler , T and Strack , F . 2006 . Playing dice with criminal sentences: The influence of irrelevant anchors on experts' judicial decision making . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 32 : 188 – 200 .
  • Guthrie , C , Rachlinski , J and Wistrich , A . 2001 . Inside the judicial mind . Cornell Law Review , 86 : 777 – 830 .
  • Douglas , K S , Lyon , D R and Ogloff , J RP . 1997 . The impact of graphic photographic evidence on mock jurors' decisions in a murder trial: Probative or prejudicial? . Law and Human Behavior , 21 : 485 – 500 .
  • Eisenberg , T , Hannaford-Agor , P L , Hans , V P , Mott , N L , Munsterman , G T , Schwab , S J and Wells , M T . 2006 . Judge-jury agreement in criminal cases: A partial replication of Kalven and Zeisel's The American Jury . Journal of Empirical Legal Studies , 2 : 171 – 207 .
  • Ebbesen , E E and Konecni , V J . 1982 . “ The process of sentencing adult felons; 1981. Konecni VJ, Ebbesen EE. The criminal justice system: A social-psychological analysis ” . In An analysis of the sentencing system , Edited by: Konecni , V J and Ebbesen , E E . 293 – 332 . San Francisco : WH Freeman & Company .
  • Ebbesen , EB and Konečni , VJ . 1975 . Decision making and information integration in the courts: The setting of bail . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 32 : 805 – 821 .
  • Dhami , M . 2003 . From discretion to disagreement: Explaining disparities in judges' pretrial decisions . Behavioral Sciences and the Law , 23 : 367 – 386 .
  • Raine , J W and Willson , M J . 1994 . Conditional bail or bail with conditions? The use and effectiveness of bail conditions , Birmingham : Birmingham University School of Public Policy .
  • Oswald , M E and Stucki , I . 2009 . “ A two-process model of punishment ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 173 – 191 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Myers , M A and Talarico , S M . 1987 . The social context of criminal sentencing , New York : Springer .
  • Kritzer , H M and Uhlmann , T M . 1977 . Sisterhood in the courtroom: Sex of judge and defendant in criminal case disposition . Social Science Journal , 14 : 366 – 379 .
  • Hogarth , J . 1971 . Sentencing as a human process , Toronto : University Press .
  • Narby , D J , Cutler , B L and Moran , G . 1993 . A meta-analysis of the association between authoritarianism and jurors' perceptions of defendant culpability . Journal of Applied Psychology , 78 : 34 – 42 .
  • Sporer , S L and Goodman-Delahunty , J . 2009 . “ Disparities in sentencing decisions ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 379 – 401 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Duckitt , J . 2009 . “ Punishment and attitudes: their social and psychological bases ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 75 – 92 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Lerner , M J . 1970 . “ The desire for justice and reactions to victims ” . In Altruism and helping behaviour , Edited by: Macaulay , J and Berkowitz , L . 205 – 229 . Orlando, FL : Academic .
  • Davis , J. 2009 . Judicial reasoning and the ‘Just world delusion’: Using the psychology of justice to evaluate legal judgments . Paper presented at the Conference ‘Judicial Reasoning: Art or Science?’ . February 2009 , Canberra, ACT. http://njca.anu.edu.au/Professional%20 Development/programs%20by%20year/2009/Judic%20Reas%20papers/Davis%20.pdf
  • Haidt , J and Graham , J . 2007 . When morality opposes justice: Conservatives have moral intuitions that liberals may not recognize . Social Justice Research , 20 : 98 – 116 .
  • Findlay , M , Odgers , S and Yeo , S . 2003 . Australian criminal justice , New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Hogarth , J . 1971 . Sentencing as a human process , Toronto : University Press .
  • Tyler , T R . 2009 . “ New approaches to justice in the light of virtues and problems of the penal system ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 19 – 37 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • King , M , Freiberg , A , Batagol , B and Hyams , R . 2009 . Non-adversarial justice , Annandale, NSW : The Federation Press .
  • Wenzel , M , Okimoto , T G , Feather , N T and Platow , M J . 2008 . Retributive and restorative justice . Law and Human Behaviour , 32 : 375 – 389 .
  • Gromet , D N and Darley , J . 2009 . Punishment and beyond: Achieving justice through the satisfaction of multiple goals . Law & Society Review , 43 : 1 – 38 .
  • Steffensmeier , D and Demuth , S . 2006 . Does gender modify the effects of race- ethnicity on criminal sanctioning? Sentences for male and female white, black and Hispanic defendants . Journal of Quantitative Criminology , 22 : 241 – 261 .
  • Myers , M A and Talarico , S M . 1987 . The social context of criminal sentencing , New York : Springer .
  • Viki , G T , Massey , K and Masser , B . 2005 . When chivalry backfires: Benevolent sexism and attitudes towards Myra Hindley . Legal and Criminological Psychology , 10 : 109 – 120 .
  • Langlois , J H , Kalakanis , L , Rubenstein , A J , Larson , A , Hallam , M and Smoot , M . 2000 . Maxims or myths of beauty. A meta-analytic and theoretical review . Psychological Bulletin , 126 : 390 – 423 .
  • McArthur , L Z and Berry , D S . 1987 . Cross-cultural agreement in perceptions of babyfaced adults . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology , 18 : 165 – 192 .
  • Zebrowitz , L A and McDonald , S . 1991 . The impact of litigants' babyfacedness and attractiveness on adjudications in small claims courts . Law and Human Behavior , 15 : 603 – 623 .
  • Zebrowitz , L A . 1998 . Reading faces: Window to the soul , Westview Press .
  • Downs , A C and Lyons , P M . 1991 . Natural observations of the links between attractiveness and initial legal judgments . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 17 : 541 – 547 .
  • Sigall , H and Ostrove , N . 1975 . Beautiful but dangerous: effects of offender attractiveness and nature of the crime on juridic judgment . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 31 : 410 – 414 .
  • Mazella , R and Feingold , A . 1994 . The effects of physical attractiveness, race, socioeconomic status and gender of defendants and victims on judgments of mock-jurors: A meta-analysis . Journal of Applied Social Psychology , 24 : 1315 – 1344 .
  • Izzett , R and Fishman , L . 1976 . Defendant sentences as a function of attractiveness and justification for action . Journal of Social Psychology , 100 : 285 – 290 .
  • Heath , W P , Grannemann , B D and Peacock , M A . 2004 . How the defendant's emotion level affects mock jurors' decisions when presentation mode and evidence strength are varied . Journal of Applied Social Psychology , 34 : 624 – 664 .
  • Robbennolt , J K . 2000 . Outcome severity and judgments of ‘responsibility’: A meta-analytic review . Journal of Applied Social Psychology , 30 : 2575 – 2609 .
  • Hills , A and Thompson , D . 1000 . Should victim impact influence sentences? Understanding the community's justice reasoning . Behavioural Sciences & the Law , 117 : 661 – 671 .
  • Nadler , J and Rose , M R . 2003 . Victim impact testimony and the psychology of punishment . Cornell Law Review , 88 : 419 – 438 .
  • Myers , B and Greene , E L . 2004 . The prejudicial nature of victim impact statements: Implications for capital sentencing policy . Psychology, Public Policy and Law , 10 : 492 – 515 .
  • Sporer , S L and Goodman-Delahunty , J . 2009 . “ Disparities in sentencing decisions ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 379 – 401 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • Arndt , J , Cook , A , Lieberman , J D and Solomon , S . 2005 . Terror management in the courtroom: Exploring the effects of mortality salience on legal decision making. Psychology . Public Policy and Law , 11 : 407 – 438 .
  • Wisman , A and Koole , S L . 2003 . Hiding in the crowd: Can mortality salience promote affiliation with others who oppose one's worldviews? . Journal of Personality and Social Personality and Social Psychology , 84 : 511 – 526 .
  • Landau , M J , Solomon , S , Greenberg , J , Cohen , F , Pyszczynski , T , Arndt , J , Miller , C H , Ogilvie , D M and Cook , A . 2004 . Deliver us from evil: The effects of mortality salience and reminders of 9/11 on support for President George W. Bush . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 30 : 1136 – 1150 .
  • Pickel , K L and Brown , J R . Mortality salience and jurors' evaluations of criminal defendants: The effects of thinking about one's own or another person's death . Paper presented at the 75th Annual Conference of the Midwestern Psychological Association . Chicago, IL.
  • Arndt , J , Cook , A , Lieberman , J D and Solomon , S . 2005 . Terror management in the courtroom: Exploring the effects of mortality salience on legal decision making . Psychology, Public Policy and Law , 11 : 407 – 438 .
  • Nelson , L J , Moore , D L , Olivetti , J and Scott , T . 1997 . General and personal mortality salience and nationalistic bias . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 23 : 884 – 892 .
  • Fredrickson , B L , Tugade , M , Waugh , C and Larkin , G . 2003 . A prospective study of resilience and emotions following the terrorist attacks on the United States on September 11th, 2001 . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 84 : 365 – 376 .
  • Pyszczynski , T , Solomon , S and Greenberg , J . 2003 . In the wake of 9/11: The psychology of terror , Washington, DC : American Psychological Association .
  • Yum , Y-O and Schenck-Hamlin , W . 2005 . Reactions to 9/11 as a function of terror management and perspective taking . The Journal of Social Psychology , 145 : 265 – 286 .
  • Landau , M J , Solomon , S , Greenberg , J , Cohen , F , Pyszczynski , T , Arndt , J , Miller , C H , Ogilvie , D M and Cook , A . 2004 . Deliver us from evil: The effects of mortality salience and reminders of 9/11 on support for President George W. Bush . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin , 30 : 1136 – 1150 .
  • Niesta , D , Fritsche , I and Jonas , E . 2008 . Mortality salience and its effects on peace processes . A review. Social Psychology , 39 : 48 – 58 .
  • Schimel , J , Simon , L , Greenberg , J , Pyszczynski , T , Solomon , S , Wazmonsky , J and Arndt , J . 1999 . Stereotypes and terror management: Evidence that mortality salience enhances stereotypic thinking and preferences . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 77 : 905 – 926 .
  • McGregor , H A , Lieberman , J D , Greenberg , J , Solomon , S , Arndt , J , Simon , L and Pyszczynski , T . 1998 . Terror management and aggression: Evidence that mortality salience motivates aggression against worldview threatening others . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 74 : 590 – 605 .
  • Kugler , M B and Cooper , J . 2008 . Still an American? Mortality salience and treatment of suspected terrorist threats . Social Science Research , Retrieved July 5, 2008, from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1120946
  • Fischer , P , Greitemeyer , T , Kastenmüller , A , Frey , D and Oβwald , S . 2007 . Terror salience and punishment: Does terror salience induce threat to social order? . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology , 43 : 964 – 971 .
  • Kugler , M B and Cooper , J . 2008 . Still an American? Mortality salience and treatment of suspected terrorist threats . Social Science Research , Retrieved July 5, 2008, from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1120946
  • Lieberman , J D , Arndt , J , Personius , J and Cook , A . 2001 . Vicarious annihilation: The effect of mortality salience on perceptions of hate crimes . Law and Human Behavior , 25 : 547 – 566 .
  • Meeker , J W , Jesilow , P and Aranda , J . 1992 . Bias in sentencing: A preliminary analysis of community service sentences . Behavioural Sciences & the Law , 10 : 197 – 206 .
  • Douglas , K S , Lyon , D R and Ogloff , J RP . 1997 . The impact of graphic photographic evidence on mock jurors' decisions in a murder trial: Probative or prejudicial? . Law and Human Behavior , 21 : 485 – 500 .
  • Bornstein , B H and Weiner , R L . 2006 . Introduction to the special issue on emotion in legal. judgment and decision making . Law and Human Behaviour , 30 : 115 – 118 .
  • Oswald , M E and Stucki , I . 2009 . “ A two-process model of punishment ” . In Social psychology of punishment of crime , Edited by: Oswald , M E , Bienbeck , S and Hupfeld-Heinemann , J . 173 – 191 . Chichester, , UK : Wiley-Blackwell .
  • New South Wales Law Reform Commission Report 118, Role of juries in sentencing. Sydney: Author; 2007

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.