Scaffolding and Achievement in Problem-Based and Inquiry Learning: A Response to Kirschner, Sweller, and CitationClark (2006)

REFERENCES

• Albanese , M. A. and Mitchell , S. 1993 . Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues . Academic Medicine. , 68 : 52 – 81 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Amati , K. , Singer , J. and Carrillo , R. 1999 . What affects the quality of air in my community? . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association . April 1999 , Montreal, Canada.
   Google Scholar
• American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) . 1993 . Benchmarks for science literacy , New York : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Barrows , H. S. 2000 . Problem-based learning applied to medical education , Springfield, IL : Southern Illinois University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Barrows , H. S. and Tamblyn , R. 1980 . Problem-based learning: An approach to medical education. , New York : Springer .
   Google Scholar
• Bell , P. 2002 . “ Using argument representations to make thinking visible for individuals and groups ” . In CSCL II: Carrying forward the conversation , Edited by: Koschmann , T. , Hall , R. and Miyake , N. 449 – 455 . Mahwah, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates .
   Google Scholar
• Bereiter , C. and Scardamalia , M. 2006 . “ Education for the knowledge age: Design-centered models of teaching and instruction ” . In Handbook of educational psychology, , 2nd ed. , Edited by: Alexander , P. A. and Winne , P. H. 695 – 713 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Berkson , L. 1993 . Problem-based learning: Have the expectations been met? . Academic Medicine , 68 : S79 – S88 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bransford , J. D. , Brown , A. L. and Cocking , R. 2000 . How people learn , Washington DC : National Academy Press .
   Google Scholar
• Capon , N. and Kuhn , D. 2004 . What's so good about problem-based learning? . Cognition and Instruction , 22 : 61 – 79 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chinn , C. A. 2006 . “ Learning to argue ” . In Collaborative learning, reasoning, and technology , Edited by: O'Donnell , A. M. , Hmelo-Silver , C. and Erkens , G. 355 – 383 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Chinn , C. A. and Hung , C.-C. 2007 . Learning to reason about the methodology of scientific studies: A classroom experiment in the middle school . Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association . April 2007 , Chicago, IL.
   Google Scholar
• Chinn , C. A. , O'Donnell , A. M. and Jinks , T. S. 2000 . The structure of discourse in collaborative learning . Journal of Experimental Education. , 69 : 77 – 97 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cognition and Technology Group at Vanderbilt . 1992 . The Jasper series as an example of anchored instruction: Theory, program description and assessment data . Educational Psychologist. , 27 : 291 – 315 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Collins , A. , Brown , J. S. and Newman , S. E. 1989 . “ Cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching the crafts of reading, writing, and mathematics ” . In Knowing, learning, and instruction: Essays in honor of Robert Glaser , Edited by: Resnick , L. B. 453 – 494 . Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Davis , E. A. 2003 . Prompting middle school science students for productive reflection: Generic and directed prompts . Journal of the Learning Sciences. , 12 : 91 – 142 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Davis , E. A. and Linn , M. C. 2000 . Scaffolding students' knowledge integration: Prompts for reflection in KIE . International Journal of Science Education. , 22 : 819 – 837 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• DeBoer , G. E. 1991 . A history of ideas in science education , New York : Teachers College Press .
   Google Scholar
• Department for Education /Welsh Office (DFE/WO) . 1995 . Science in the national curriculum (1995) , London : HMSO .
   Google Scholar
• Derry , S. J. , Hmelo-Silver , C. E. , Nagarajan , A. , Chernobilsky , E. and Beitzel , B. 2006 . Cognitive transfer revisited: Can we exploit new media to solve old problems on a large scale? . Journal of Educational Computing Research , 35 : 145 – 162 .
   Google Scholar
• Dochy , F. , Segers , M. , Van den Bossche , P. and Gijbels , D. 2003 . Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis . Learning and Instruction. , 13 : 533 – 568 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Driver , R. , Leach , J. , Millar , R. and Scott , P. 1996 . Young people's images of science , Buckingham, , England : Open University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Duncan , R. G. 2006 . “ The role of domain-specific knowledge in promoting generative reasoning in genetics ” . In Proceedings of the seventh international conference for the learning sciences: Making a difference , Edited by: Barab , S. A. , Hay , K. E. and Hickey , D. T. 147 – 154 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Duschl , R. 1990 . Restructuring science education: The importance of theories and their development , New York : Teachers College Press .
   Google Scholar
• Edelson , D. C. 2001 . Learning-for-use: A framework for integrating content and process learning in the design of inquiry activities . Journal of Research in Science Teaching. , 38 : 355 – 385 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gallagher , S. A. , Stepien , W. J. and Rosenthal , H. 1992 . The effects of problem-based learning on problem solving . Gifted Child Quarterly. , 36 : 195 – 200 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Geier , R. , Blumenfeld , P. , Marx , R. , Krajcik , J. , Fishman , B. and Soloway , E. Standardized test outcomes for students engaged in inquiry-based science curriculum in the context of urban reform . Journal of Research in Science Teaching , in press
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Golan , R. , Kyza , E. A. , Reiser , B. J. and Edelson , D. C. . Scaffolding the task of analyzing animal behavior with the Animal Landlord software . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association . New Orleans, LA. April ,
   Google Scholar
• Greeno , J. G. 2006 . “ Learning in activity ” . In The Cambridge handbook of the learning sciences , Edited by: Sawyer , R. K. 79 – 96 . New York : Cambridge .
   Google Scholar
• Guthrie , J. T. , Wigfield , A. , Barbosa , P. , Perencevich , K. C. , Taboada , A. Davis , M. H. 2004 . Increasing reading comprehension and engagement through concept-oriented reading instruction . Journal of Educational Psychology. , 96 : 403 – 423 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Guzdial , M. 1994 . Software-realized scaffolding to facilitate programming for science learning . Interactive Learning Environments. , 4 : 1 – 44 .
   Google Scholar
• Hickey , D. T. , Kindfeld , A. C. H. , Horwitz , P. and Christie , M. A. 1999 . Advancing educational theory by enhancing practice in a technology-supported genetics learning environment . Journal of Education. , 181 : 25 – 55 .
   Google Scholar
• Hickey , D. T. , Wolfe , E. W. and Kindfield , A. C. H. 2000 . Assessing learning in a technology-supported genetics environment: Evidential and consequential validity issues . Educational Assessment. , 6 : 155 – 196 .
   Google Scholar
• Hmelo , C. E. 1998 . Problem-based learning: Effects on the early acquisition of cognitive skill in medicine . Journal of the Learning Sciences. , 7 : 173 – 208 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hmelo , C. E. and Guzdial , M. 1996 . “ Of black and glass boxes: Scaffolding for learning and doing ” . In Proceedings of ICLS 96 , Edited by: Edelson , D. C. and Domeshek , E. A. 128 – 134 . Charlottesville, VA : AACE .
   Google Scholar
• Hmelo , C. E. and Lin , X. 2000 . “ Becoming self-directed learners: Strategy development in problem-based learning ” . In Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions , Edited by: Evensen , D. and Hmelo , C. E. 227 – 250 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Hmelo-Silver , C. E. 2003 . Analyzing collaborative knowledge construction: Multiple methods for integrated understanding . Computers and Education. , 41 : 397 – 420 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hmelo-Silver , C. E. 2004 . Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn? . Educational Psychology Review , 16 : 235 – 266 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hmelo-Silver , C. E. 2006 . “ Design principles for scaffolding technology-based inquiry ” . In Collaborative reasoning, learning and technology , Edited by: O'Donnell , A. M. , Hmelo-Silver , C. E. and Erkens , G. 147 – 170 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Hmelo-Silver , C. E. and Barrows , H. S. 2006 . Goals and strategies of a problem-based learning facilitator . Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based Learning. , 1 : 21 – 39 .
   Google Scholar
• Hmelo-Silver , C. E. , Derry , S. J. , Woods , D. , DelMarcelle , M. and Chernobilsky , E. 2005 . “ From parallel play to meshed interaction: The evolution of the EStep system ” . In Proceedings of CSCL 2005 , Edited by: Suthers , D. and Koschmann , T. Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Horwitz , P. , Neumann , E. and Schwartz , J. 1996 . Teaching science at multiple levels: The GenScope program . Communications of the ACM , 39 : 100 – 102 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jackson , S. , Stratford , S. J. , Krajcik , J. S. and Soloway , E. 1996 . Making system dynamics modeling accessible to pre-college science students . Interactive Learning Environments. , 4 : 233 – 257 .
   Google Scholar
• Kirschner , P. A. and Erkens , G. 2006 . Cognitive tools and mindtools for collaborative learning . Journal of Educational Computing Research , 35 : 199 – 209 .
   Google Scholar
• Kirschner , P. A. , Sweller , J. and Clark , R. E. 2006 . Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching . Educational Psychologist. , 41 : 75 – 86 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kolodner , J. L. 1993 . Case-based reasoning , San Mateo, CA : Morgan Kaufmann .
   Google Scholar
• Krajcik , J. S. and Blumenfeld , P. 2006 . “ Project-based learning ” . In The Cambridge handbook of the learning sciences , Edited by: Sawyer , R. K. 317 – 334 . New York : Cambridge .
   Google Scholar
• Krajcik , J. S. , Czerniak , C. and Berger , C. 1999 . Teaching children science: A project-based approach , Boston, MA : McGraw-Hill .
   Google Scholar
• Kuhn , D. , Black , J. , Keselman , A. and Kaplan , D. 2000 . The development of cognitive skills to support inquiry learning . Cognition and Instruction , 18 : 495 – 523 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Langer , J. A. 2001 . Beating the odds: Teaching middle and high school students to read and write well . American Educational Research Journal. , 38 : 837 – 880 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lederman , N. G. 1998 . The state of science education: Subject matter without context . Electronic Journal of Science Education , : 41
   Google Scholar
• Leinhardt , G. and Steele , M. D. 2005 . Seeing the complexity of standing to the side: Instructional dialogues . Cognition and Instruction. , 23 : 87 – 163 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Linn , M. C. , Bell , P. and Hsi , S. 1999 . Lifelong science learning on the Internet: The knowledge integration environment . Interactive Learning Environments. , 6 : 4 – 38 .
   Google Scholar
• Linn , M. C. , Davis , E. A. and Bell , P. 2004 . Internet environments for science education , Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Linn , M. C. and Slotta , J. D. 2006 . “ Enabling participants in online forums to learn from each other ” . In Collaborative learning, reasoning, and technology , Edited by: O'Donnell , A. M. , Hmelo-Silver , C. E. and Erkens , G. 61 – 98 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Loh , B. , Reiser , B. J. , Radinsky , J. , Edelson , D. C. , Gomez , L. M. and Marshall , S. 2001 . “ Developing reflective inquiry practices: A case study of software, the teacher, and students ” . In Designing for science: Implications from everyday, classroom, and professional settings , Edited by: Crowley , K. , Schunn , C. and Okada , T. 279 – 324 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Lynch , S. , Kuipers , J. , Pyke , C. and Szesze , M. 2005 . Examining the effects of a highly rated science curriculum unit on diverse students: Results from a planning grant . Journal of Research in Science Teaching. , 42 : 921 – 946 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mayer , R. E. 2004 . Should there be a three-strikes rule against pure discovery learning? . American Psychologist , 59 : 14 – 19 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McComas , W. F. , Clough , M. P. and Almazroa , H. 1998 . The role and character of the nature of science in science education . Science and Education. , 7 : 511 – 532 .
   Google Scholar
• Mergendoller , J. R. , Maxwell , N. L. and Bellisimo , Y. 2006 . The effectiveness of problem-based instruction: A comparative study of instructional method and student characteristics . Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based Learning , 1 : 49 – 69 .
   Google Scholar
• Ministry of Education . 2001 . Standards for nine-year continuous curriculum at elementary and junior high level in Taiwan , Taipei : Ministry of Education, R.O.C .
   Google Scholar
• Minstrell , J. and Stimpson , V. 1996 . “ A classroom environment for learning: Guiding students' reconstruction of understanding and reasoning ” . In Innovations in learning: New environments for education , Edited by: Schauble , L. and Glaser , R. 175 – 202 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) . 2000 . Principles and standards for school mathematics , Reston, VA : NCTM .
   Google Scholar
• National Research Council (NRC) . 1996 . National science education standards , Washington DC : National Academy Press .
   Google Scholar
• Norman , G. R. , Brooks , L. R. , Colle , C. L. and Hatala , R. M. 2000 . The benefit of diagnostic hypotheses in clinical reasoning: Experimental study of an instructional intervention for forward and backward reasoning . Cognition and Instruction , 17 : 433 – 448 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Norman , G. R. , Trott , A. D. , Brooks , L. R. and Smith , E. K. 1994 . Cognitive differences in clinical reasoning related to postgraduate training . Teaching and Learning in Medicine. , 6 : 114 – 120 .
   Google Scholar
• Palincsar , A. S. 1998 . Social constructivist perspectives on teaching and learning . Annual Review of Psychology. , 45 : 345 – 375 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Patel , V. L. , Groen , G. J. and Norman , G. R. 1993 . Reasoning and instruction in medical curricula . Cognition and Instruction. , 10 : 335 – 378 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Puntambekar , S. and Kolodner , J. L. 2005 . Toward implementing distributed scaffolding: Helping students learn from design . Journal of Research in Science Teaching. , 42 : 185 – 217 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Quintana , C. , Reiser , B. J. , Davis , E. A. , Krajcik , J. , Fretz , E. Duncan , R. G. 2004 . A scaffolding design framework for software to support science inquiry . Journal of the Learning Sciences , 13 : 337 – 386 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Reiser , B. J. , Tabak , I. , Sandoval , W. A. , Smith , B. K. , Steinmuller , F. and Leone , A. J. 2001 . “ BGuILE: Strategic and conceptual scaffolds for scientific inquiry in biology classrooms ” . In Cognition and instruction: Twenty-five years of progress , Edited by: Carver , S. M. and Klahr , D. 263 – 305 . Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Reiser , B. J. 2004 . Scaffolding complex learning: The mechanisms of structuring and problematizing student work . Journal of the Learning Sciences , 13 : 273 – 304 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rogoff , B. 1990 . Apprenticeship in thinking: Cognitive development in social context , New York : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Salomon , G. , Perkins , D. N. and Globerson , T. 1991 . Partners in cognition: Extending human intelligences with intelligent technologies . Educational Researcher. , 20 : 2 – 9 .
   Google Scholar
• Sandoval , W. A. and Reiser , B. J. 2004 . Explanation-driven inquiry: Integrating conceptual and epistemic supports for science inquiry . Science Education. , 88 : 345 – 372 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schank , R. C. 1982 . Dynamic Memory: A theory of reminding and learning in computers and people , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Schank , R. and Cleary , C. 1995 . Engines for education , Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , H. G. 1983 . Problem-based learning: rationale and description . Medical Education. , 17 : 11 – 16 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schneider , R. M. and Krajcik , J. 2002 . Supporting science teacher learning: The role of educative curriculum materials . Journal of Science Teacher Education. , 13 : 221 – 245 .
   Google Scholar
• Schwartz , D. L. and Bransford , J. D. 1998 . A time for telling . Cognition and Instruction. , 16 : 475 – 522 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schwartz , D. L. and Martin , T. 2004 . Inventing to prepare for future learning: The hidden efficiency of encouraging original student production in statistics instruction . Cognition and Instruction. , 22 : 129 – 184 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Shymansky , J. A. 1984 . BSCS programs: Just how effective were they? . The American Biology Teacher , 46 : 54 – 57 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Singer , J. , Rivet , A. , Schneider , R. M. , Krajcik , J. S. , Amati , K. and Marx , R. W. . Setting the stage: Engaging students in water quality . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association . New Orleans, LA. April ,
   Google Scholar
• Smith , B. K. and Reiser , B. J. 1998 . “ National Geographic unplugged: Designing interactive nature films for classrooms ” . In Proceedings of CHI 98: Human factors in computing systems , Edited by: Karat , C.-M. , Lund , A. , Coutaz , J. and Karat , J. 424 – 431 . New York : ACM Press .
   Google Scholar
• Toth , E. E. , Suthers , D. D. and Lesgold , A. M. 2002 . “Mapping to know”: The effects of representational guidance and reflective assessment on scientific inquiry . Science Education. , 86 : 244 – 263 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Vernon , D. T. and Blake , R. L. 1993 . Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research . Academic Medicine. , 68 : 550 – 563 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Von Secker , C. and Lissitz , R. W. 1999 . Estimating the impact of instructional practices on student achievement in science . Journal of Research in Science Teaching. , 36 : 110 – 1126 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Vygotsky , L. S. 1978 . Mind in society , Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• White , B. Y. and Frederiksen , J. R. 1998 . Inquiry, modeling, and metacognition: Making science accessible to all students . Cognition and Instruction. , 16 : 3 – 118 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wise , K. C. and Okey , J. R. 1983 . A meta-analysis of the effects of various science teaching strategies on achievement . Journal of Research in Science Teaching , 20 : 419 – 435 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wu , Y.-T. and Tsai , C.-C. 2005 . Effects of constructivist-oriented instruction on elementary school students' cognitive structures . Journal of Biological Education , 39 : 113 – 119 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar