Political and Religious Constraints on Educational Policy in the Weimar Republic

References

• Führ , C. 1970 . Zur Schulpolitik der Weimarer Republik , Weinheim : Verlag Julius Beltz . The work of Gay and of Führ has stimulated interest once again in the cultural achievements of Weimar as opposed to the usual emphasis on its political and economic failures. Both authors have contributed considerably by their writings to my own modest efforts in this field. I have tried, however, notwithstanding this debt to base the present paper on contemporary documentation from the 1920s as much as possible, though clearly obtaining such documentation in England is extremely difficult. I hope that one service of the present paper may be to indicate some of the more readily available material to English students of the field. See P. Gay, Weimar Culture (London: Secker and Warburg, 1969), and
   Google Scholar
• Neumann , S. 1956 . Modern Political Parties—Approaches to Comparative Politics , 354 Chicago : University of Chicago Press . Certainly the ideological social and cultural foundations for action had been set down before the Republic came into being. See R. König, ‘Zur Soziologie der Zwanziger Jahre’ in L. Rhemisch, Die Zeit ohne Eigenschaften (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer Verlag, 1961), 82–118
   Google Scholar
• Neumann , S. 1965 . Die Parteien der Weimarer Republik , 30 – 31 . Stuttgart : W. Kohlhammer Verlag . Sontheimer has traced through this dissatisfaction into the anti‐democratic facets of the predominant ideological groupings in Weimar. See K. Sontheimer, Antidemokratisches Denken in der Weimarer Republik (Munich: Nymphenburger Verlagshandlung, 1962)
   Google Scholar
• Grebing , H. 1962 . Geschichte der deutschen Parteien , 149 – 151 . Wiesbaden : Franz Steiner Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Saupe , E. 1932 . Die Politischen Parteien und die Schule , 27 Osterwieck, Harz : A. W. Zickfeldt Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Wulff , H. 1962 . “ ‘Heinrich Schulz 1872–1932’ ” . In Bremisches Jahrbuch 319 – 374 . See
   Google Scholar
• Neumann , S. 1965 . 44ff op. cit.
   Google Scholar
• Details of the Party Programme are given in E. Saupe, op. cit., 17–20
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., 19
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., 20
   Google Scholar
• Hohfeld , J. 1954 . Dokumente der deutschen Politik und Geschichte von 1848 bis zur Gegenwart , Vol. iii , Berlin : Dokumenten‐Verlag Dr. Herbert Wendler and Co. . “Die Weimarer Republik”, 1919–33, Iff
   Google Scholar
• Saupe . 21 – 26 . op. cit
   Google Scholar
• Rosin , H. 1926 . “ ‘Das Verhaltnis des Staates zur Kirche und Erziehung in den Programmen der politischen Parteien’ ” . In Schulpolitisches Jahrbuch 99 – 104 . Ibid., 99. See also
   Google Scholar
• Eyck , E. 1962 . A History of the Weimar Republic , Vol. i , 55 – 56 . Cambridge, Mass : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Landé” , W. 1929 . Die Schule in der Reichsverfassung , 28 – 30 . Berlin : Verlag von Reimar Hobbing .
   Google Scholar
• Rosin , H. 1920 . Das Schulkompromiss (Schulfragen in der Reichsverfassung—Schriftenreihe des deutschen Lehrervereins) , 5 – 6 . Berlin : Verlag von Leonhard Simion .
   Google Scholar
• Menzel , G. 1920 . “ ‘Die gegenwärtige Lage des Volksschulwesens in Deutschland’, in Zentralinstitut für Erziehung und Unterricht ” . In Jahrbuch 1920 , 149 – 170 . Berlin : Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn . Antagonisms were particularly acute in Lower Saxony where Catholic schools were closed by the provincial government and where teachers in general tended to be labelled socialist See W. Offenstein, Die Schulpolitik der Sozialdemokratie (Heft 26 der Reihe: Schulpolitik und Erziehung—Zeitfragen) (Düsseldorf: Zentralstelle der Katholischen Schulorganization, no date), 93–94. A helpful resume1 of these and other early measures up to November 1919 is contained in the report of the Central Institute for Education and Instruction for 1920. See
   Google Scholar
• Schwarz , A. 1958 . Die Weimarer Republik , 52 Konstanz : Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft Athenaion .
   Google Scholar
• Giesecke , H. 1965 . ‘Zur Schulpolitik der Sozialdemokraten in Preussen und im Reich 1918/19’ . Vierteliahreshefte für Zeitgeschichte , XIII : 163
   Google Scholar
• Tews , J. 1919 . Sozialdemokratie und öffentliches Bildungswesen , 68ff Langensalza : Hermann Beyer & Söhne [Beyer und Mann] . The more important ordinances are reproduced in G. Giese, Quellen zur deutschen Schulgeschichte seit 1800 (Gottingen: Musterschmidt—Verlag., 1961), 231–240. A contemporary report on them is to be found in
   Google Scholar
• The questions and replies were published as:— Evangelischer Presseverband . 1919 . Die Stellung der Parteien zu den Kirchen—und Schulfragen , Berlin Steglitz : Verlag des Evangelischen Presseverbandes .
   Google Scholar
• Mehnert , G. 1959 . Evangelische Kirche und Politik 1917–1919 , 177 – 178 . DUsseldorf : Droste Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Tews , J. 1913 . Grundzüge der deutschen Schulgesetzebung , 158 – 159 . Leipzig : R. Voigtländers Verlag . This right of clerics had been set down in the Prussian Law of 28 July 1906. See
   Google Scholar
• Wende , F. 1959 . C. H. Becker, Mensch and Politiker: Ein biographischer Beitrag zur Kulturgeschichte der Weimarer Republik , Stuttgart : Deutsche Verlagsanstalt . I am grateful to Rolf Gardiner of Springhead, Fontmell Magna, who was a personal friend of Becker up to the time of the latter's death for access to personal correspondence and invaluable personal recollections of this very great Prussian. An extensive biography of Becker has been written by Erich Wende, a former colleague of his in the Prussian Ministry. See
   Google Scholar
• Gardiner , R. Midwinter 1946 . “ ‘Carl Henrich Becker’ ” . In Wessex—Letters from Springhead , Second Series, No. 2 This was later expanded into a pamphlet See C. H. Becker, Kulturpolitische Aufgaben des Reiches (Leipzig: Quelle und Meyer, 1930). An excellent ‘thumb‐nail’ sketch of Becker is contained in
   Google Scholar
• Kittel , H. 1957 . Die Entwicklung der padagogis‐chen Hochschulen 1926–32 , Hanover : Hermann Schroedel Verlag . A contemporary account of the measures taken up to November 1923 is contained in a book by Otto Boelitz, Minister of Education in Prussia from November 1921 to January 1925 in the Prussian Government of Braun. He confirms the central importance which was given to this reform by both himself and Becker. See O. Boeltiz, Preussisches Bildungswesen (Leipzig: Verlag Quelle und Meyer, 1924), 53ff and especially, 54. An up‐to‐date account of the reforms is contained in
   Google Scholar
• Preller , L. 1949 . Sozialpolitik der Weimarer Republik , 529ff Stuttgart : Franz Mittelbach Verlag . Details taken from
   Google Scholar
• Epstein , K. 1959 . Matthias Erzberger and the Dilemma of German Democracy , 287 Princeton : University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Eyck , E. 1964 . A History of the Weimar Republik , Vol. ii , 150 Cambridge, Mass : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hoffmann , J. 1921 . Schule und Lehrer in der Reichsverfassung , 16 – 17 . Stuttgart : Dietz .
   Google Scholar
• Tews , J. 1926 . Zum deutschen Schulkampf , 77 Frankfurt am Main : Neuer Frankfurter Verlag . Tews considers that there were three compromises. See
   Google Scholar
• Landé , W. 44 op. tit
   Google Scholar
• Führ , C. 1970 . op. cit
   Google Scholar
• Bracher , K. D. 1963 . Die Entstehung der Weimarer Verfassung , Hanover : Niedersachsische Landeszentrale für Politische Bildung . Details of The Articles are taken from
   Google Scholar
• Bäumer , G. 1928 . Deutsche Schulpolitik , 54 Karlsruhe : Verlag G. Braun . The latter interpretation is of very doubtful legality. See
   Google Scholar
• Dr Mausbach . 1922 . Religionsunterricht und Kirche (Heft 3 der Schriften zur deutschen Politik) , 32ff Freiburg : Herder and Co. . See
   Google Scholar
• Wolf , G. 1923 . Grundschulfragen und Grundschulgegner (Heft 9 Schulpolitik und Volksbilding‐Schriftenreihe des Preussischen Lehrervereins) , 13 – 25 . Osterwieck—Harz : Verlag von A. W. Zickfeldt .
   Google Scholar
• Kandel , I. L. and Alexander , T. 1927 . The Reorganization of Education in Prussia , 22ff. New York : Teachers College, Columbia University . This led to some strange and complex compromises. See O. Boelitz, (1924), op. cit., 22ff and the English translation of this, contained in
   Google Scholar
• Tormin , W. 1963 . Geschichte der deutschen Parteien , 286 Stuttgart : W. Kohlhammer Verlag . The number of seats which they gained fell from 91 to 64, 75 to 39 and 163 to 102 for the Centre, Democratic and Socialist Parties respectively. See
   Google Scholar
• Heckel , H. and Seipp , P. 1960 . Schulrechtskunde , 47 48 282 Berlin : Hermann Luchterhand Verlag . For the legal position with regard to religious education in West Germany and the continuing effect of the 1921 Law, see Part of this Law is reproduced in Kandel and Alexander, op. cit, 185–86
   Google Scholar
• Helmreich , E. C. 1959X . Religions Education in German Schools: An Historical Approach , 122 Cambridge, Mass : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Schorb , A. O. and Fritzsche , V. 1966 . Schulerneuerung in der Demokratie , Stuttgart : Emst Klett Verlag . An interesting view of the Conference from a present day East German point of view is to be found in G. Hohendorf, Die pädagogische Bewegung in den ersten Jahren der Weimarer Republik (Berlin: VEB Volk und Wissen, 1954). A comparison with the German Committee of 1953–65 is contained in
   Google Scholar
• the recommendations of the National School Conference on teacher training. 1920 . “ Zentralinstitut für Erziehung und Unterricht ” . In Die Reichsschulkonferenz in ihren Ergebnissen , 164 165 Leipzig : Verlag von Quelle und Meyer . See for example
   Google Scholar
• Tews , J. 1926 . Zum deutschen Schulkampf , 37 Frankfurt am Main : Neuer Frankfurter Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Offenstein , W. 1925 . Der Kampf um das Reichsschulgesetz , especially 86ff. Düsseldorf : Verlag der Katholischen Schulorganization . For a detailed account by a member of the Catholic clergy of this first phase of the negotiations, but one which is strongly biased in its presentation towards the Catholic point of view. See
   Google Scholar
• Preller , L. 1949 . Sozialpolitik in der Weimarer Republik , 189 Stuttgart : Franz Mittelbach Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Tews . 1926 . 16 op. cit
   Google Scholar
• Schwarz . 114 op. cit.
   Google Scholar
• Offenstein , W. 1928 . Der Kampf um das Reichsschulgesetz , especially 14ff. Diisseldorf : Verlag der Katholischen Schulorganization . Details of this second phase are taken from
   Google Scholar
• Schulz , H. 1926 . Der Leidensweg des Reichsschulgesetzes , See 136ff. Berlin : Verlag von J. H. W. Dietz Nachf. . An extensive account, though one written from a Social Democratic point of view, of the negotiations and progress of these first two drafts for a National School Law is contained in, He describes the fate of the Schiele draft as a tragic‐comedy
   Google Scholar
• Eyck , E. op. cit 336 See
   Google Scholar
• Offenstein . 1928 . op. cit 30 (But see also Hohlfeld, op. cit, 169.)
   Google Scholar
• Rosin , H. 1927 . Das Reichschulgesetz , For the final draft see especially 82ff. Berlin : Selbstverlag des deutschen Lehrervereins . The texts of all three drafts with details of the development and an extensive commentary from the point of view of the German Teachers’ Association culminating in a vigorous uncompromising and outright call for the rejection of the Law are contained in
   Google Scholar
• Führ . op. cit 72
   Google Scholar
• XI , Pius . 1963 . Die Christliche Erziehung der Jugend: Enzyklika ‘Divini illius magistri’ , Freiburg : Herder . The text of this Encyclical with a German translation and introduction can be found in (Annotated text with an introduction by Rudolf Pfeil)
   Google Scholar