The Albanians of Kosovo and Macedonia: Ethnic identity superseding religion

References

• Skendi , Stavro . 1967 . The Albanian National Awakening 1878-1912 , 469 Princeton : Princeton University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Jelavich , Barbara . 1994 . History of the Balkans. Twentieth Century , 86 New York : Cambridge University Press . They tried to create an Albanian state composed of the vilayets of Jarrina, Kosovo, Bitola, and Skhode'r with full administrative autonomy. Albanian was to be the language of education and administration
   Google Scholar
• Skendi . National Awakening 470 There are two principal Albanian dialects: Geg and Tosk. Geg is spoken by about two-thirds of Albanians, including almost all the Albanians in Kosovo. Despite the subdialects within each dialect and the variations that have developed in isolated communities, Albanians generally communicate well with each other
   Google Scholar
• Zickel , Raymond and Iwaskiw , Walter R. , eds. 1994 . Albania: A Country Study , 71 Washington : Library of Congress .
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . Mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der österreichischungarischen Periode , Frankfurt : Peter Lang . On the national development of the Bosnian Muslims see Aydin Babuna, Die nationale Entwicklung der bosnischen Muslims
   Google Scholar
• Friedman , Francine . 1996 . The Bosnian Muslims. Denial of a Nation , Boulder : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Babuna , Aydin . 1996 . "The Emergence of the First Muslim Party in Bosma-Hercegovina" . East European Quarterly , 2 : 131 – 151 .
   Google Scholar
• Biberaj , Elez . 1990 . Albania. A Socialist Maverick , 10 Boulder : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Norris , H. T. 1993 . Islam in the Balkans , 166 London : Hurst .
   Google Scholar
• Biberaj . Albania 9
   Google Scholar
• Skendi . National Awakening 470 There were instances in which one of the brothers was a Muslim and the other a Christian and they celebrated together the main holidays of their respective religions
   Google Scholar
• Lampe , John R. 1996 . Yugoslavia as History. Twice There Was a Country , 114 New York : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Beljo , Ante , ed. 1992 . Greater Serbia. From Ideology to Aggression , 37 – 50 . Zagreb : Croatian Information Centre . Even the total expulsion of the Albanians was planned in a memorandum submitted to the Stoyadinovic government in 1937 by Vaso Èubrilovic
   Google Scholar
• Banac , Ivo . 1995 . Nacionalno Pitanje u Yugoslaviji , 310 – 311 . Zagreb : Durieux . On the cemiyet see
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm , Noel . 1998 . Kosovo. A Short History , 269 London : Macmillan . They had agreed at the conference in Skopje on demands for rights, such as full religious autonomy, protection of the beys' estates, preservation of the vakifs and sheriat courts, and the free and official use of the respective mother tongues, where non-Serb, in the schools
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Vickers , Miranda . 1998 . Between Serb and Albanian. A History of Kosovo , 101 – 102 . London : Hurst .
   Google Scholar
• Poulton , Hugh and Vickers , Miranda . 1997 . "The Kosovo Albanians: Ethnic Confrontation with the Slav State" ” . In Muslim Identity and the Balkan State , Edited by: Poulton , Hugh and Farouki , Suha Taji . 145 London : Hurst .
   Google Scholar
• Banac . Nacionalno pitanje 241
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm . Kosovo 268
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Banac . Nacionalno pitanje 244
   Google Scholar
• Poulton and Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 146 – 147 .
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm . Kosovo 292
   Google Scholar
• Biberaj . Albania 116 – 117 .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 117-118.
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm . Kosovo 322
   Google Scholar
• Poulton , Hugh . 1993 . The Balkans. Minorities and States in Conflict , 92 London : Minority Rights Group . Some 80,000 according to Yugoslavia's statistical yearbooks and over 150,000 according to Turkish sources
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 92.
   Google Scholar
• Biberaj . Albania 118
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 195 The number of Kosovars declaring themselves "Yugoslav" in the census of 1981 was 0.2, the lowest in all of Yugoslavia
   Google Scholar
• Horvat , Branko . 1988 . Kosovsko pitanje , 121 Zagreb : Globus .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 123.
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm . Kosovo 324
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 170
   Google Scholar
• Horvat . Kosovsko pitanje 66
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 100-101.
   Google Scholar
• Lampe . Yugoslavia 297 The demonstrators in Tetovo demanded that the Albanian-inhabited areas of Macedonia should join Kosovo in a seventh republic
   Google Scholar
• Poulton , Hugh . 1995 . Who Are the Macedonians? , 126 London : Hurst .
   Google Scholar
• Lampe . Yugoslavia 297
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 180
   Google Scholar
• Poulton and Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 152
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 182
   Google Scholar
• Vickers , Miranda and Pettifer , James . 1997 . Albania. From Anarchy to a Balkan Identity , 144 New York : New York University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 110 – 111 . In contrast to the tribal structure in northern Albania the Kosovar Albanians lived in zadrugas (large families) like their Serbian and Montenegrin neighbours. This way of life, which largely disappeared after World War II, was still evident in many Kosovo Albanian villages in the 1990s. Life in these zadrugas was shaped by Islam
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 186.
   Google Scholar
• Horvat . Kosovsko pitanje 99 In 1985 it would be 3.33 times higher than the national average
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 191
   Google Scholar
• Lampe . Yugoslavia 332
   Google Scholar
• Horvat . Kosovsko pitanje 101 – 103 .
   Google Scholar
• Poulton . Balkans 78
   Google Scholar
• Poulton and Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 152
   Google Scholar
• Poulton . Balkans 72
   Google Scholar
• Poulton and Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 152
   Google Scholar
• The first pan-Albanian organization, "Revolutionary Movement for the Unification of the Albanians," was founded by Adem Demaci in the early 1960s. He was arrested in 1964.
   Google Scholar
• Poulton . Balkans 63
   Google Scholar
• Beljo , ed. "Serbian Academy of Arts and Sciences. Memorandum 1986" ” . In Greater Serbia 68
   Google Scholar
• Crnobrnja , Mihailo . 1996 . The Yugoslav Drama , 101 London : I. B. Tauris .
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , Lenard . 1993 . Broken Bonds. The Disintegration of Yugoslavia , 52 Boulder : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Crnobrnja . Yugoslav Drama 105
   Google Scholar
• Andrejevich , Milan . 1990 . "Some New Dimensions in the Kosovo Crisis" . Report on Eastern Europe , 2 March : 40
   Google Scholar
• PuIa , Gazmend . 1996 . "Modalities of Self-Determination-The Case of Kosovo as a Structural Issue for Lasting Stability in the Balkans" . Südosteuropa , 4-5 : 384
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Troebst , Stefan . 1999 . "The Kosovo War, Round One: 1998" . Südosteuropa , 3-4 : 156
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . "Kosovo Crisis. Making a Deal" . Time , 14 June : 24
   Google Scholar
• Andrejevich , Milan . 1990 . "Kosovo and Slovenia Declare Their Sovereignty" . Report on Eastern Europa , 27 July : 45
   Google Scholar
• Andrejevich , Milan . 1991 . "Kosovo: A Precarious Balance between Stability and Civil War" . Report on Eastern Europa , 18 October : 27
   Google Scholar
• Troebst . "Kosovo War" ” . 161
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . The Truth on Kosovo , 335 Tirana : Encyclopaedia Publishing House .
   Google Scholar
• Reuter , Jans . 1994 . "Die politische Entwicklung in Kosovo 1992/3" . Südosteuropa , 1-2 : 22 – 23 .
   Google Scholar
• Troebst . "Kosovo War" ” . 163
   Google Scholar
• Poulton and Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 169
   Google Scholar
• Reuter . "Kosovo 1992/3" ” . 24
   Google Scholar
• Vickers , Miranda . Between Serb and Albanian 299
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , Fabian and Moore , Patrick . 1995 . "Die Albaner im ehemaligen Jugoslawien als Sicherheitsfaktor" ” . In Minderheiten als Konfliktpotential in Ostmittel-und Südosteuropa , Edited by: Seewann , Gerhard . 81 – 82 . Munich : Südosteuropa Gesellschaft .
   Google Scholar
• Troebst . "Kosovo War" ” . 163 – 164 .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 83
   Google Scholar
• Maliqi , Shkelzen . 1996 . “ 'The Albanian Movement in Kosovo" ” . In Yugoslavia and After , Edited by: Dyker , David A. and Vejvoda , Ivan . 147 London : Longman .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 83
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 85.
   Google Scholar
• Maliqi . "Albanian Movement" ” . 148
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 151.
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . "MiloSevié poslije MiloSeviéa" . Svijet , 47 : 30 DraSkovié supported a high level of autonomy while Djindjié was in favour of regionalism
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 296
   Google Scholar
• Reuter . "Kosovo 1992/3" ” . 29
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "The Memorandum of the Association of Albanian Historians, Prishtine, Kosova 18.08. 1992" . Academy of Albanian Intellectuals of Sciences and Arts , : 149 – 150 .
   Google Scholar
• Stavileci , Esat . 1992 . Kosova and Albanians. Its Past, Present and Future , 196 Pristina : Independent Association of Lawyers of Kosova .
   Google Scholar
• Repishti , Sami . 1993 . "Self-Determination and the Present Status of Kosova" . Kosova , 2 : 37
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . "Sad Serbs" . The Economist , 31 July : 25 The percentage of Albanians in the total population of Kosovo must have increased, since a large number of the local Serbs left the province after the withdrawal of the Serbian forces. About two-thirds of the Serbian minority had already left Kosovo before the beginning of August 1999
   Google Scholar
• Maliqi . "Albanian Movement" ” . 145
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 294
   Google Scholar
• PuIa . "Modalities" ” . 387 – 390 .
   Google Scholar
• PuIa . "Modalities" ” . 398 – 404 . For the calls of the Albanian leaders for a reformulation of political objectives in Kosovo
   Google Scholar
• Vickers . Between Serb and Albanian 292
   Google Scholar
• Troebst . "Kosovo War" ” . 156 – 190 . For the details of the fighting between the KLA and the Serbian forces in 1998 in Kosovo, see
   Google Scholar
• Lipsius , Stephan . 1998 . "Kommunistische Parteien in Albanien und Kosovo-Vorbild Enver Hoxhar . Südosteuropa , 10-11 : 545
   Google Scholar
• Reuter , Jans . 1998 . "Die internationale Gemeinschaft und der Krieg in Kosovo" . Südosteuropa , 7-8 : 289 – 290 .
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , Chris . 1999 . "Kosovo's Next Masters?" . Foreign Affairs , 3 : 26 – 28 .
   Google Scholar
• Reuter . "Krieg in Kosovo" ” . 289
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , Chris . "Kosovo's Next Masters?" ” . 28
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 40.
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . Svijet , : 20 – 21 . On the other hand the quality of its military equipment and the number of experienced and professional officers among the commanders of the KLA also increased
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . "Patriarch und Partisan" . Der Spiegel , 21/24 : 170
   Google Scholar
• Hedges . "Kosovo's Next Masters?" ” . 39 Even though some ties between the KLA and the Islamist organizations have been detected and there is suspicion that some money has been forwarded by these organizations to the KLA, it seems that there are practical rather than ideological reasons behind this. It is estimated that only in the case of disenchantment with the West might the KLA turn to the Islamic radicals
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . "Hvala Islamskoj Zajednici u Sarajevo" . Prepared , 2 ( 489 ) : 8
   Google Scholar
• Silajdzié , Haris . 1990 . "Islamski fundamentalizam na Kosovu izmedu Cinjenica i motiva" . Glasnik , 3 : 7 – 11 .
   Google Scholar
• SillajxWq , Haris . 1994 . "Fundamentalizm! islamik ne Kosovë ndërmjet fakteve e motiveve" . Dituria Marne , 60 : 38 – 39 .
   Google Scholar
• Bata , Josef . 1997 . "Das Verhältnis von Christentum und Islam bei den Albanern in Geschichte und Gegenwart" ” . In Religion und Gesellschaft in Südostueropa , Edited by: Döpmann , Hans-Dieter . 162 Munich : Südosteuropa-Gesellschaft .
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm . "Kosovo" ” . 351
   Google Scholar
• Clayer , Nathalie . 1997 . "National and Religious Identity among Albanian Muslims" . Islamic Studies , 2 ( 3 ) : 408
   Google Scholar
• Boya , Recep . 1998 . "Tek hedef bagimsizlik" . Zaman (Istanbul) , 19 March : 5
   Google Scholar
• Clayer . "National and Religious Identity" ” . 409
   Google Scholar
• Poulton , Vickers . "Kosovo Albanians" ” . 168
   Google Scholar
• Andrejevich , Milan . 1991 . "Republican Leaders Reach Compromise Accord on Country's Future" . Report on Eastern Europe , 28 June : 34 – 35 .
   Google Scholar
• BUschenfeld , Herbert . 1995 . "Die Volkszählung 1994 in Makedonien. Erste Ergebnisse" . Osteuropa , 45 : 773 The Albanians had boycotted the previous census of 1991
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 116 – 117 . For example the number of Albanian refugees who fled from Kosovo into Macedonia during NATO's military campaign against Yugoslavia had reached a proportion (248,400 in June 1999) that could have changed the whole ethnic balance in Macedonia, but most of the refugees were to return to Kosovo after the end of the war
   Google Scholar
• Andrejevich , Milan . 1990 . "The Yugoslav Army in Kosovo: Unrest Spreads to Macedonia" . Report on Eastern Europa , 23 February : 39
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 123
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 121-122.
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 123
   Google Scholar
• Mickey , Robert W. 1996 . "Citizenship, Status, and Minority Political Participation: The Evidence from the Republic of Macedonia" ” . In Muslim Communities in the New Europe , Edited by: Nonneman , Gerd , Niblock , Tim and Szajkowski , Bogdan . 62 Lebanon : Ithaca Press . The Macedonians opposed the project on the grounds that there is no law regulating the establishment of such a university, but the Macedonian leaders pointed out that such a university would not be allowed even if there were regulations for it in force
   Google Scholar
• Wieland , Garsten . 1997 . "Ein Makedonien mit drei Gesichtern. Innenpolitische Debatten und Nationskonzepte" . Südosteuropa , 12 : 703
   Google Scholar
• Vickers and Pettifer . Albania 162
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 67 Many members of the political elite of the Macedonian Albanians, such as Arben Xhaferi and Fadil Sulejmani, are from Kosovo
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt . "Albaner" ” . 132
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 68
   Google Scholar
• Shoup , Paul . 1968 . Communism and the Yugoslav National Question , 144 – 183 . New York : Columbia University Press . On the national question in Macedonia following World War II see
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Makedonskiot narod medu najstarite" . VeCer , 1 October : 17
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Makedonski-Bugarski jaziCen spor" . Nova Makedonija , 12 August : 7
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Interview with Boro Mokrov. An Expression of National and Spiritual Independence" . Macedonian Times, February , : 24 – 26 .
   Google Scholar
• Pop-Atanasov , Gjorgi . 1998 . "Macedonia and Macedonians in the Holy Bible" . Macedonian Times , March : 16 – 18 .
   Google Scholar
• Wieland . "Makedonien" ” . 703 709
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Ustav na Republika Makedonija , 3 Skopje : Nip Magazin 21 .
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 59
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . Macedonian Times , April : 20 For example, after the imprisonment of Rufi Osmani (ex-mayor of Gostivar), vice-president of the DPA, Memduh Thachi declared that the Albanians who had been living for centuries together with the Macedonians had no intention of creating a parallel institution in Gostivar
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 58 – 60 .
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 61 According to Arben Xhaferi, with this status the Albanians would be able to prevent Macedonia from sliding into Orthodox alliances
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 61-62.
   Google Scholar
• Mickey . "Citizenship" ” . 65 – 66 . The Albanians, by contrast, complain that they are always outvoted by a coalition of Macedonian parties on issues relating to their rights and that the ministries given to them are less influential than the others
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 63.
   Google Scholar
• Atanasovski , Todor . 1998 . "Kosovo-A New Phase in the Regional Crisis" . Macedonian Times , June : 9 – 11 . Though Adem Demaci had declared that the KLA was not following a greater Albanian policy, some KLA officials like Krasniqi and Salihu stressed that the aim of the KLA was the unification of the Albanians in the Balkans. According to the Krasniqi, the KLA was already active in Macedonia
   Google Scholar
• Neke , Michael Schmidt . 1999 . "Makedoniens Albaner: Konfliktpotential oder Stabilisierungsfaktor" . Südosteuropa , 3-4 : 210
   Google Scholar
• Vickers and Pettifer . Albania 178
   Google Scholar
• Clayer . "National and Religious Identity" ” . 405 Simply because it is a multinational and multi-religious state
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 407.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 409.
   Google Scholar
• Poulton . Balkans 55
   Google Scholar
• Poulton . "Changing Notions of National Identity among Muslims in Thrace and Macedonia: Turks, Pomaks and Roma" ” . In Muslim Identity Edited by: Poulton and Farouki . 94 – 96 . The Slavic Muslims tended to support the PDP in the elections of November 1990. Ibid
   Google Scholar
• Clayer . "National and Religious Identity" ” . 407 – 408 .
   Google Scholar
• Najcevska , Mirjana , Simoska , Emilija and Gaber , Natasha . "Muslims, State and Society in the Republic of Macedonia: The View from Within" ” . In Muslim Communities Edited by: Nonneman , Niblock and Szajkowski . 91 – 96 . According to the results of this survey made in the two population groups, some 30 of the Orthodox population was devout while the proportion among the Muslims was thought to be somewhat higher, but the negative attitudes of the two communities towards members of the other faith appeared to have increased. More than 70 of both communities were against marriages with persons of different confessions while just over 45 favoured ethnically homogeneous marriages. Similar trends could be observed in the choice of neighbours, colleagues, and friends. As far as attitudes towards religious institutions are concerned, 64 of the Orthodox thought that the Islamic religious community had played a negative role in relations between the two communities, while 91 of the Muslims thought that its role was a positive one. In contrast, 67 of Orthodox Macedonians found the role of their church in relations between the two communities positive while 63 of the Muslims regarded it as negative. For the detailed results of this survey
   Google Scholar
• Gaber , Natasha . "The Muslim Population in FYROM (Macedonia): Public Perceptions" ” . In Muslim Identity Edited by: Poulton and Farouki . 110 In the survey of 1994 there was no change in the attitudes of the two communities to the religious institutions
   Google Scholar
• Najcevska , Simoska and Gaber . "Muslims" ” . 89
   Google Scholar
• Najcevska , Simoska and Gaber . "Muslims" ” . 92 – 93 . Ibid., p. 86. There are also some positive results of this study. More than 80 of both populations would never start an ethnic or religious war, and over 70 of both groups harboured no emotional hatred against the other group. More than 60 of both groups believed that inter-confessional problems were the result of political manipulation mainly by other countries and in part by the political parties and the extremists on both sides. The two populations were more or less in agreement about the factors that worsened inter-ethnic relations: the main reason was the social and economic crisis, followed by extreme nationalism, the non-recognition of the Republic of Macedonia, the political parties, interference by neighbouring countries, the primitive political culture, and the role of the religious communities
   Google Scholar
• Gaber . "Muslim Population" ” . 110 – 111 . The opinions of both communities on the negative factors in the inter-ethnic relations were more or less the same in the survey of 1994
   Google Scholar
• Willemsen , Heinz . 1999 . "Machtwechsel in der EIR Makedonien" . Südosteuropa , 1-2 : 26
   Google Scholar
• Neke . "Makedoniens Albaner" ” . 203 – 204 . For the programs of the Albanian parties see
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 204.
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Per shiptaret e RM-së te formohet universitet" . Flaka , 12 nëntor : 11
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Universitetin e ri duhet ta miratojè Qeveria" . Flaka , 13 nëntor : 11
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Universitetit te Tetovës" . Flaka , 21-22 nëntor : 7
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Intervju Abdurahman Aliti Definitivno odime vo opozicija" . Puls , 19 November : 16 – 19 .
   Google Scholar
• Najcevska , Simoska and Gaber . "Muslims" ” . 81 In 1993 86 of Albanians polled considered themselves second-class citizens. This number fell sharply to 42 in the survey of 1994. Among the Roma this figure was 35 while the Turks did not consider it an issue
   Google Scholar
• Gaber . "Muslim population" ” . 111
   Google Scholar
• Milosavlevski , Slavko and Tomovski , Mirce . 1997 . Albancite vo Republika Makedonija 1945-1995 , 315 – 438 . Skopje : Studentski zbor . For statistics about the participation of the Albanians in the social, economic, and cultural life in Macedonia see
   Google Scholar
• Najcevska , Simoska and Gaber . "Muslims" ” . 81
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Kolika Kosovo ja zagrozuva Makedonija?" . Nova Makedonija , 15 September : 2
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . "Intervju so Arben Caferi, pretsedatel na PDPA-NDP. Albancite se cuvstvuvaat nezaStiteni" . Nova Makedonija , 29 September : 5
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . RFE/RL Balkan Report , 3 ( 30 ) 3 August http:// www.rferl.org/balkan-report/
   Google Scholar