A Nonparametric “Trim and Fill” Method of Accounting for Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis

References

• Begg , C. B. 1994 . “Publication Bias,” . In The Handbook of Research Synthesis , Edited by: Cooper , H. and Hedges , L. V. 399 – 409 . New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Begg , C. B. and Mazumdar , M. 1994 . “Operating Characteristics of a Rank Correlation Test for Publication Bias,” . Biometrics , 50 : 1088 – 1101 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Biggerstaff , B. J. and Tweedie , R. L. 1997 . “Incorporating Variability in Estimates of Heterogeneity in the Random-Effects Model in Meta-Analysis,” . Statistics in Medicine , 16 : 753 – 768 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• British Medical Journal Editorial Staff . 1983 . “The Editor Regrets …” . British Medical Journal , 280 : 508 (editorial)
   Google Scholar
• Casella , G. and Berger , R. L. 1990 . Statistical Inference , Belmont , CA : Duxbury .
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , H. 1998 . Synthesizing Research , Thousand Oaks , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , H. and Hedges , L. V. , eds. 1994 . The Handbook of Research Synthesis , New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Dear , K. and Begg , C. 1992 . “An Approach for Assessing Publication Bias Prior to Performing a Meta-Analysis,” . Statistical Science , 7 : 237 – 245 .
   Google Scholar
• Dear , K. and Dobson , A. 1997 . Comment on “Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis: A Bayesian Data-Augmentation Approach to Account for Issues Exemplified in the Passive Smoking Debate” . Statistical Science , 12 : 245 – 246 . by G. H. Givens, D. D. Smith, and R. L. Tweedie
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• DerSimonian , R. and Laird , N. M. 1986 . “Meta-Analysis in Clinical Trials,” . Controlled Clinical Trials , 7 : 177 – 188 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Dickersin , K. , Min , Y. and Meinert , C. 1992 . “Factors Influencing Publication of Research Results,” . Journal of the American Medical Association , 267 : 374 – 378 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• DuMouchel , W. and Harris , J. 1997 . Comment on “Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis: A Bayesian Data-Augmentation Approach to Account for Issues Exemplified in the Passive Smoking Debate” . Statistical Science , 12 : 244 – 245 . by G. H. Givens, D. D. Smith, and R. L. Tweedie
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Duval , S. J. 1999 . “Effects of Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis,” , doctoral dissertation University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, Dept. of Preventive Medicine and Biometrics .
   Google Scholar
• Duval , S. J. and Tweedie , R. L. 2000 . “Trim and Fill: A Simple Funnel Plot-Based Method of Testing and Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis,” . Biometrics , 56 : 276 – 284 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Duval , S. J. and Tweedie , R. L. “Robustness of the ‘Trim and Fill’ publication bias approach to different mechanisms for study suppression,” (in preparation)
   Google Scholar
• Easterbrook , P. , Berlin , J. , Gopalan , R. and Matthews , D. 1991 . “Publication Bias in Clinical Research,” . Lancet , 337 : 867 – 872 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Eberly , L. E. and Casella , G. 1999 . “Estimating the Number of Unseen Studies in a Meta-Analysis,” . Journal of Official Statistics , 15 (in press)
   Google Scholar
• Egger , M. , Smith , G. D. , Schneider , M. and Minder , C. 1997 . “Bias in Meta-Analysis Detected by a Simple Graphical Test,” . British Medical Journal , 315 : 629 – 634 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Galbraith , R. 1988 . “A Note on the Graphical Presentation of Estimated Odds Ratios From Several Clinical Trials,” . Statistics in Medicine , 7 : 889 – 894 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Givens , G. H. , Smith , D. D. and Tweedie , R. L. 1997 . “Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis: A Bayesian Data-Augmentation Approach to Account for Issues Exemplified in the Passive Smoking Debate” . Statistical Science , 12 : 221 – 250 . (with discussion)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gleser , L. J. and Olkin , I. 1996 . “Models for Estimating the Number of Unpublished Studies,” . Statistics in Medicine , 15 : 2493 – 2507 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. 1992 . “Modeling Publication Selection Effects in Meta-Analysis,” . Statistical Science , 7 : 227 – 236 .
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. and Olkin , I. 1985 . Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis , New York : Academic Press .
   Google Scholar
• Iyengar , S. and Greenhouse , J. B. 1988 . “Selection Models and the File Drawer Problem” . Statistical Science , 3 : 109 – 135 . (with discussion)
   Google Scholar
• Lee , P. N. 1992 . Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Mortality , Basel : Karger .
   Google Scholar
• Light , R. and Pillemer , D. 1984 . Summing Up: the Science of Reviewing Research , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Marascuilo , L. A. and McSweeney , M. 1977 . Nonparametric and Distribution-Free Methods for the Social Sciences , Monterey , CA : Brooks/Cole .
   Google Scholar
• Mengersen , K. , Tweedie , R. and Biggerstaff , B. 1995 . “The Impact of Method Choice in Meta-Analysis,” . Australian Journal of Statistics , 37 : 19 – 44 .
   Google Scholar
• Misakian , A. L. and Bero , L. A. 1998 . “Publication Bias and Research on Passive Smoking: Comparison of Published and Unpublished Studies,” . Journal of the American Medical Association , 280 : 250 – 253 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• NRC Committee on Applied and Theoretical Statistics . 1992 . Combining Information: Statistical Issues and Opportunities for Research , Washington , DC : National Academy Press .
   Google Scholar
• Olkin , I. 1992 . “Meta-Analysis: Methods for Combining Independent Studies,” . Statistical Science , 7 : 226
   Google Scholar
• Smith , D. J. , Givens , G. H. and Tweedie , R. L. 1999 . “Adjusting for Publication and Quality Bias in Bayesian Meta-Analysis,” . In Meta-Analysis in Medicine and Health Policy , Edited by: Berry , D. A. and Stangl , D. K. New York : Marcel Dekker .
   Google Scholar
• Sugita , M. , Kanamori , M. , Izuno , T. and Miyakawa , M. 1992 . “Estimating a Summarized Odds Ratio Whilst Eliminating Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis,” . Japanese Journal of Clinical Oncology , 22 : 354 – 358 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sugita , M. , Yamaguchi , N. , Izuno , T. , Kanamori , M. and Kasuga , H. 1994 . “Publication Probability of a Study on Odds Ratio Value: Circumstantial Evidence for Publication Bias in Medical Study Areas,” . Tokai Journal of Experimental and Clinical Medicine , 19 : 29 – 37 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Sutton , A. J. , Duval , S. J. , Tweedie , R. L. , Abrams , K. R. and Jones , D. R. 1999 . “The Impact of Publication Bias on Meta-Analyses Within the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,” (submitted for publication)
   Google Scholar
• Tweedie , R. L. , Scott , D. S. , Biggerstaff , B. J. and Mengersen , K. L. 1996 . “Bayesian Meta-Analysis, With Application to Studies of ETS and Lung Cancer,” . Lung Cancer , 14 : S171 – S194 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar