The New Great Game and the new great gamers: Disciples of Kipling and Mackinder

References

• Weisbrode , K. 2001 . “ 'Central Eurasia: prize or quicksand? Contending views of instability in Karabakh, Ferghana and Afghanistan' ” . Adelphi Paper 338 11 – 14 . Oxford : International Institute of Strategic Studies/Oxford University Press . The labelling of geographical regions is one that has been the subject of debate. For the purposes of this paper 'Central Asia' is used to refer to the five republics to the east of the Caspian Sea--Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. The Transcaucasus' (or 'South Caucasus') refers to Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. Some current literature, however, stretches these definitions and there is no solid consensus on the means of the terms. For example, a further regional distinction of 'Central Eurasia' has emerged and is used to cover the area spreading from the Bosphorus in the West to Xinjiang province in China, and from the Kazak steppe and Russian border in the north to the Indian Ocean in the south. See
   Google Scholar
• Jaffe , A.M. and Olcott , MB. 2000 . Euro-Asia: A Period of Transition , Edited by: Lynch , D. and Kalyuzhnova , Y. 68 London : Palgrave Macmillan .
   Google Scholar
• Erickson , J. 1999 . 'Russia will not be trifled with: geopolitical facts and fantasies' . Journal of Strategic Studies , 22 ( 2/3 )
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gray , C.S. and Sloan , G. 1999 . Geopolitics: Geography and Strategy , 257 – 258 . London: Frank : Cass .
   Google Scholar
• Hopkirk , P. 1994 . The Great Game: The Struggle for Empire in Central Asia , New York : Kodansha International . The term 'the Great Game' was coined by Captain Arthur Conolly (1807-1842), a 'player' of the original Great Game. It is not the intention of this paper to recount the events of the Great Game; for a full examination see
   Google Scholar
• Meyer , K. and Brysac , S. 2001 . Tournament of Shadows: The Great Game and the Race for Empire in Asia , London : Abacus Books .
   Google Scholar
• Hopkirk , P. 2002 . The Great Game revisited?' . Asian Affairs , 33 : 59 – 63 .
   Google Scholar
• Fromkin , D. 1980 . "The Great Game in Asia' . Foreign Affairs , 58 ( 4 ) : 936 – 952 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Palace , W. 2002 . 'Afghanistan and the Great Game' . Asian Affairs , 33 : 64 – 67 . Part 1
   Google Scholar
• Verrier , A. 1992 . 'Francis Younghusband and the Great Game' . Asian Affairs , 23 : 34 – 43 . Part 1 (Old Series Vol 79),
   Google Scholar
• Hopkirk , P. 1984 . Setting the East Ablaze: Lenin's Dream of an Empire in Asia , London : John Murray . Hopkirk, op cit, Ref 5, p 61. For an examination of this period see
   Google Scholar
• Starr , F.S. 1996 . 'Making Eurasia stable' . Foreign Affairs , 75 ( 1 ) : 80
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Tsepkalo , V.V. 1998 . The remaking of Eurasia' . Foreign Affairs , 72 ( 2 ) : 107
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sariahmetoglu , N. 2000 . 'A look at the matters of route and security of the Caspian petroleum pipeline' . Eurasian Studies , 17 Spring-Summer : 68
   Google Scholar
• Brezinski , Z. 1997 . The Grand Chessboard: American Primacy and its Geostrategic Imperatives , 125 New York : Basic Books .
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , A. 1996 . 'The "New Great Game": pipeline politics in Eurasia' . Caspian Crossroads , 2 ( 1 ) Spring-Summer http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/usazerb/213.htm) [Accessed 19 July 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Karimov , I. 1997 . Uzbekistan on the Threshold of the Twenty-First Century , 29 Curzon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , A. 2001 . 'Is Russian New Caucasus policy threat to Turkish interests?' . Eurasian Studies , 20 ( Special Issue, ) Summer : 115
   Google Scholar
• Shammas , P. 1993 . 'Energy cooperation in Central Asia and the global perspective' . The Iranian Journal of International Affairs , 5 ( 1 ) : 25
   Google Scholar
• Ghorban , N. 1993 . 'The role of multinational oil companies in the development of oil and gas resources in Central Asia and the Caucasus' . The Iranian Journal of International Affairs , 5 ( 1 ) : 1 – 15 .
   Google Scholar
• Carver , J.P. and Englefield , G. 1994 . Oil and gas pipelines from Central Asia: a new approach' . The World Today , 50 ( 6 ) : 119 – 121 . Many articles have been written on the routes, problems, solutions and potential of Transcaucasian and Caspian pipelines. See, for example,
   Google Scholar
• Maley , W. 1998 . 'The perils of pipelines' . The World Today , 54 ( 8-9 ) : 231 – 232 .
   Google Scholar
• Rashid , A. 1997 . 'This way out' . Far Eastern Economic Review , 18 September : 60 – 61 . Sariahmetoglu, op cit, Ref 11, pp 67-80
   Google Scholar
• Stainslaw , J. and Yergin , D. 1993 . 'Oil: reopening the door' . Foreign Affairs , 72 ( 4 ) : 81
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Klare , M.T. 2002 . 'Global petro-politics: the foreign policy implications of the Bush administration's energy plan' . Current History , March : 100 United States Department of Energy and The White House, National Energy Report, 17 May 2001. Cited in
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ibid, p 100.
   Google Scholar
• Odom , W.E. 1998 . 'The Caspian Sea littoral states: the object of a New Great Game?' . Caspian Crossroads , 3 ( 3 ) http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/usazerb/332.htm) [Accessed 31 July 2002].
   Google Scholar
• Blank , S. 1999 . 'Every shark east of Suez: great power interests, policies and tactics in the Transcaspian energy wars' . Central Asian Survey , 18 ( 2 ) : 150
   Google Scholar
• Wendlant , A. 2001 . 'High politics help grease the wheels of trade' . The Financial Times , 9 April For an article on energy as a Russian political tool, see
   Google Scholar
• Miles , C. 1999 . 'The Caspian pipeline debate continues: why not Iran?' . Journal of International Affairs , 53 ( 1 ) : 327
   Google Scholar
• Tass , Prime . 2002 . 'BP eyes Caspian stake' . The Moscow Times , 25 November (http:// www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2002/11/25/061.html) [Accessed 25 November 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Tanmisever , OF. 2001 . 'Russia and the independent Turkic states: discovering the meaning of independence' . Eurasian Studies , 20 ( Special Issue, ) Summer : 101
   Google Scholar
• Adams , T. 1999 . Oil and geopolitical strategy in the Caucasus' . Asian Affairs , 33 : 14 (Old Series Vol 86),
   Google Scholar
• Reuters . 2002 . 'China pipeline terms agreed' . The Moscow Times , 26 July (http://www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2002/07/26/045.html) [Accessed 26 July 2002]. A strategic partnership between Russia and China was formed in 1996, though it has been argued that this is rather more limited in scope than the title suggests due to pragmatic concerns and economic limitations.
   Google Scholar
• Anderson , J. 1997 . “ 'The limits of Sino-Russian strategic partnership' ” . Adelphi Paper 315 Oxford : International Institute for Strategic Studies/Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Allison , R. 2001 . “ 'Structures and frameworks for security policy cooperation in Central Asia' ” . In Central Asian Security: The New International Context , Edited by: Allison , R. and Jonson , E. 219 – 245 . London Washington D.C. : The Royal Institute of International Affairs The Brooking Institution .
   Google Scholar
• Berry , N. “ 'Preventing another 'Great Game' in Central Asia: the Shanghai Five plus Six' ” . http:// www.cdi.org/asia/fa011201.html) [Accessed 30 May 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Mamadshoyev , M. 2000 . The Shanghai G-5 becomes the Shanghai Forum' . Eurasia Insight , 7 July (http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/ insight/aiticles/eav070700.shtml) [Accessed 7 August 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Strausz-Hupé , R. 1942 . Geopolitics: The Struggle for Power , 155 New York : G.P. Putnam's Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Harada , C. 1997 . “ 'Russia and North-east Asia' ” . Adelphi Paper 310 37 Oxford : International Institute for Strategic Studies/Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Maass , C.D. 1999 . 'The Afghanistan conflict: external involvement' . Central Asian Survey , 18 ( 1 ) : 77
   Google Scholar
• Valencia , M.J. 1995 . “ 'China and the South China Sea dispute' ” . Adelphi Paper 298 Oxford : International Institute for Strategic Studies/Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Tarock , A. 1997 . 'Iran's policy in Central Asia' . Central Asian Survey , 16 ( 2 ) : 185 – 200 .
   Google Scholar
• Pasha , S.A.H. 1997 . 'Turkey and the republics of Central Asia: emerging relations and dilemmas' . International Studies , 34 ( 3 ) : 343 – 357 .
   Google Scholar
• Ozey , R. 2001 . 'The geopolitical importance and the main problems of the Turkic world' . Eurasian Studies , 20 ( Special Issue, ) Summer : 83 – 94 .
   Google Scholar
• Foreign and Commonwealth Office . August 1998 . 'Iran's relations with the states of Central Asia and Transcaucasia', Background Brief , August , London : FCO .
   Google Scholar
• Lansford , T. 2002 . The Great Game renewed? US-Russian rivalry in the arms trade of South Asia' . Security Dialogue , 33 ( 2 )
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Beeman , W.O. 15 November 2001 . “ 'Op-Ed: "The Great Game" continues' ” . 15 November , For example the Royal Society for Asian Affairs ran an edition of Asian Affairs that looked at the ramifications of the American intervention. Several of the articles made reference to 'The New Great Game' either explicitly or by implication. See Asian Affairs, Vol 33, Part 1, 2002. One commentator said that the US victory in Afghanistan as part of the war on terrorism was 'no such thing. It is another move in the 150-year "Great Game", pitting colonial powers against each other for control of Central Asia.' See (http://www.brown.edu/ Administration/News_Bureau/2001-02/01-057.html) [Accessed 30 May 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Nougayrede , N. 2002 . 'Moscou veut étendre sa guerre «antiterroriste» à la Géorgie' and 'Un pays acculé entre le jeu de Moscou et les ambitions de Washington' . Le Monde , February : 24 – 25 .
   Google Scholar
• Prins , G. 2001 . 'Winners and losers in the oil war' . The Guardian , 26 November
   Google Scholar
• Page , J. 2001 . 'Analysis--China and Russia kick of new Great Game' . Afghan Info Center , 15 June Such as the Shanghai Forum, consisting of Russia, China and all the Central Asian states (except Turkmenistan)(http://www.afghan-info.com/Research_Articles/Analysis_china_Russia.htm) [Accessed 30 May 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Steen , M. 2001 . 'Kalashnikov-toting Russians bewilder Kabul' . The Moscow Times , 28 November Many NGOs have operated in Afghanistan during 2001 and 2002, especially since the fall of the Taleban, including Médecins sans Frontière, Aide Medicale Internationale, CARE International, Oxfam, Global Relief Foundation, DACAAR and SGAA in addition to UN agencies; (http://www.afghana.com/ Reconstruction/AfghanistanRehabilitation.htm) [Accessed 30 July 2002] and (http://www.careusa.org/ newsroom/specialreports/afghanistan/statement2.doc) [Accessed 30 July 2002]. They have, however, often operated alongside official state government organisations such as the Russian Emergency Situations Ministry. See (http://www.themoscowtimes.ru/stories/2001/11/28/003.html) [Accessed 28 November 2001]
   Google Scholar
• Pahlevan , T. 1998 . “ 'Iran and Central Asia' ” . In Post-Soviet Central Asia , Edited by: Akabaki , T. and O'Kane , J. 79 London Leiden : Tauris Academic Studies The International Institute for Asia Studies .
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . The Economist , 17 June : 64
   Google Scholar
• Tuomi , O. 1998 . "The new geopolitics--the world system and Northern Europe seen from a modern geopolitical perspective' , Finnish Defence Studies 11 28 Helsinki : National Defence College .
   Google Scholar
• Ferrari , B. “ 'Some considerations about the methods and the nature of political geography and geopolitics' ” . (http://www.ciari.org/investigacao/bruno_ferrari.htm) [Accessed 8 August 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Retaillé , D. 1998 . 'La geopolitique dans l'historié' . Espaces Temps , 68-70 : 187 – 201 .
   Google Scholar
• Retaillé , D. 2001 . “ 'Geopolitics in history' ” . In From Geopolitics to Global Politics: A French Connection , Edited by: Levy , J. 35 – 51 . London : Frank Cass . According to Retaillé the first geopolitical formula is grouped under the term imperialist as 'it is the basic principle of colonial conquest and also shows hegemony taken to extremes in arkhe (sovereignty and its expansion)' (p 37) using space and area as the basis of positions. The state model takes territory as its basis with linear frontiers identifying it; 'These may emerge from ethnic or political bases from original cores and centres, or be enclosed within limits inherited from the colonial episode or from different international settlements and treaties. In any event, national identity is sought and asserted' (p39), with the model allowing for zonal centre-perhipery regional units. The universalist models are not immediately geopolitical; 'they only become so by virtue of the paradox on which they are based and the context that they provide both for the imperialist and state models. The paradox results from the assertion of values of a universal nature… stemming from local philosophical and political traditions that are in conflict' (p 40), allowing for the formation of 'culture areas'
   Google Scholar
• Gilbert , E.W. 1951 . “ 'Introduction' ” . In The Scope and Methods of Geography and The Geographical Pivot of History , Edited by: Mackinder , H.J. 12 London : The Royal Geographical Society .
   Google Scholar
• Thompson , S. 1999 . 'A lexicon of "Brezezinski-isms" ' . Executive Intelligence Review , 9 April (http:// www.larouchepub.com/other/1999/thompson_brzezinski_2615.html) [Accessed 8 August 2002].
   Google Scholar
• Sloan , G. 1999 . “ 'Sir Harold Mackinder: the heartland theory then and now' ” . In Geopolitics: Geography and Strategy , Edited by: Gray , C.S. and Sloan , G. 32 London : Frank Cass .
   Google Scholar
• Hauner , M. , ed. 1992 . What is Asia to Us? , London : Taylor Francis . The heartland-rimland theories were proposed, respectively, by Mackinder and Spykman. Mackinder argued the heartland would dominate world politics; Spykman argued that the rimland--the circle of land surrounding the heartland--could be used to contain the heartland and nullify its influence. In reality this geopolitical theory turned in to the containment policy that was followed by the USA during the Cold War. For maps of the heartland/rimland concepts in comparison, see
   Google Scholar
• Fettweis , C.J. 2000 . 'Sir Halford Mackinder, geopolitics and policymaking in the 21st century' . Parameters , Summer : 58 – 71 . (http://carlisle-www.army.mil/usawc/Parameters/00summer/fettweis.htm) [Accessed 8 August 2002]
   Google Scholar
• Evans , G. and Newham , J. 1998 . The Penguin Dictionary of International Relations , London : Penguin . Following the article by Harold Sprout, 'Geopolitical hypotheses in technological perspective', World Politics, Vol 15, No 2, 1963, pp 187-212, geopolitics came to be identified with exploitation of knowledge to serve the aims of a national regime--associated through the works of Karl Haushofer with the aggressive actions of Nazi Germany. The term 'geopolitics' became value-laden, and despite the discipline having a heritage that could be traced back to Hippocrates and Aristotle, it became a concept that was frowned upon. Since the end of the Cold War geopolitics has experienced a revival in defence and military analysis. However, in contemporary analysis, the realist preoccupation with territorial defence has given way to neoliberal concerns over interdependence and world politics based on economic considerations. 'Geoeconomics' is said to have replaced geopolitics as the guiding motivation for foreign policy formulation and conduct. Summary taken from
   Google Scholar
• Weiser , D. 1994 . " 'Geopolitics"--renaissance of a controversial concept' . Aussenpolitik , 45 ( 4 ) : 402 – 411 . For a further explanation of geopolitics, see
   Google Scholar
• Mackinder , H.J. 1904 . 'The geographical pivot of history' . Geographical Journal , 23 : 421 – 437 . Mackinder proposed his ideas in
   Google Scholar
• Mackinder , H.J. 1919 . Democratic Ideals and Reality: A Study in the Politics of Reconstruction , London : Constable Co. . His argument that the Central Eurasian pivot area was key to the control of world politics was summed up in his famous phrase: 'Who rules East Europe commands the Heartland; Who rules the Heartland commands the World Island; Who rules the World Island commands the World.'
   Google Scholar
• Reuters . 2002 . 'China pipeline terms agreed' . The Moscow Times , 26 July BBC World Service News Report, 4 July 2002. See also, (http://www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2002/07/26/045.html) [Accessed 26 July 2002] and Reuters, 'Source: $1.7bln China pipe deal close', The Moscow Times, 21 November 2002 (http://www.themoscowtimes.eom/stories/2002/11/21/046.html) [Accessed 21 November 2002]. For further indications of Chinese involvement in the Eurasian area see
   Google Scholar
• Munro , R.H. 1994 . “ 'Central Asia and China' ” . In Central Asia and the World: Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan and Turkmenistan , Edited by: Mandelbaum , M. 225 – 238 . New York : Council on Foreign Relations Press .
   Google Scholar
• Rashid , A. and Saywell , T. 1998 . 'Beijing gusher' . Far Eastern Economic Review , 26 February
   Google Scholar
• Israeli , R. 1994 . 'Return to the source: the republics of Central Asia and the Middle East' . Central Asian Survey , 13 ( 1 ) : 22
   Google Scholar
• Diet , G. 1997 . Quest for influence in Central Asia: India and Pakistan' . International Studies , 34 ( 2 ) : 143
   Google Scholar
• Singh , K.R. 2001 . 'Changing geopolitical environment and new South-West Asia' . International Studies , 38 ( 4 ) : 363 – 364 .
   Google Scholar
• Burke , J. and Beaumont , P. 2002 . 'West pays warlords to stay in line' . The Observer , 21 July In post-Taleban Afghanistan, for example, it was reported that the US administration allegedly paid for certain key warlords to stay On side'(http://www.guardian.co.uk/afghanistan/story/0,1284,759203,00.html) [Accessed 8 August 2002].
   Google Scholar
• Hoffman , S. 1978 . Primacy or World Order , 175 New York : McGraw-Hill .
   Google Scholar
• Shams-Ud-Din . 1997 . "The New Great Game in Central Asia' . International Studies , 34 ( 3 ) : 339 – 340 .
   Google Scholar
• Rumer , B.Z. 1993 . "The gathering storm in Central Asia' . Orbis , 37 ( 1 ) : 89
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Doyle , M.W. 1986 . Empires , Ithaca , NY : Cornell University Press . For a discussion of the full meaning and range of the terms 'Imperialism' and 'Empire', see
   Google Scholar
• Hardt , M. and Negri , A. 2000 . Empire , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press . For a view of decolonization in Central Asia, see
   Google Scholar
• Grant , J. 1994 . 'Decolonization by default: independence in Soviet Central Asia' . Central Asian Survey , 13 ( 1 ) : 51 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• Ingram , E. 1979 . The Beginning of the Great Game in Asia, 1828-1834 , 339 Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar