‘Unhealthy areas’: Town planning, eugenics and the slums, 1890–1945

References

• Marwick , A. 1964 . Middle Opinion in the 1930s: Planning, Progress and Political Agreement . English Historical Review , : 285 – 298 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Freeden , M. 1979 . Eugenics and Progressive Thought: A study in Ideological Affinity . History Journal , 22 (30) : 645 – 671 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• M'Gonigle , G. C. M. and Kirby , J. 1937 . Poverty and Public Health , 76 London : Gollancz .
   Google Scholar
• Barnes , H. 1926–7 . The Slum Problem . Journal of Town Planning Institute , : 147 (J.T.P.I.)
   Google Scholar
• For a general discussion of sanitary reform, see
   Google Scholar
• Wohl , A. 1984 . Endangered Lives: Public Health in Victorian Britain , London : Methuen .
   Google Scholar
• For the effect of the 1880s on public health reformers’ aspirations, see Chapter 11, ‘Home Sweet Home’ and especially pp. 324–8.
   Google Scholar
• Titmuss , R. 1943 . Birth, Poverty and Wealth. A study of Infant Mortality , 14 London : Hamish Hamilton Medical Books .
   Google Scholar
• Wohl , A. Endangered Lives , 324
   Google Scholar
• ibid: p. 326. On the significance of the East End in terms of housing policy, see
   Google Scholar
• Stedman Jones , G. 1976 . Outcast London, A Study in the Relationship between Classes in Victorian Society , Peregrine Books .
   Google Scholar
• Wohl , A. 1977 . The Eternal Slum: Housing and Social Policy in Victorian London , 318 – 321 . London : Edward Arnold .
   Google Scholar
• Housing of the Working Classes Act 1890. Section 4. These terms repeat those used in the 1875 Housing Act.
   Google Scholar
• Evans , L. C. 1922–3 . (Town Clerk, Salford) . Acquiring and Replanning Congested Areas J.T.P.I. , : 84
   Google Scholar
• Bell , G. 1849–50 . Day and Night in The Wynds of Edinburgh and Blackfriars Wynd Analyzed reprinted Wakefield, 1983.
   Google Scholar
• From 1900 onwards, the WNHC supported the idea of local authority housebuilding in the suburbs, advocating not merely the provision of cottages with gardens, baths and hot and cold water, but estates ‘pleasant to the eye’ and equipped with communal facilities [Public Record Office CAB 27/42 DC 29. Memorandum by Addison, 3 December 1918].
   Google Scholar
• Hennock , E. P. 1976 . Poverty and Social Theory in England: The Experience of the 1880s . Social History , : 67 – 91 .
   Google Scholar
• The membership of social hygiene groups is discussed in
   Google Scholar
• Jones , G. 1986 . Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain , London : Croom Helm .
   Google Scholar
• Mazumdar , P. M. H. 1980 . The Eugenists and the Residuum: The Problem of the Urban Poor . Bulletin of History of Medicine , : 212 – 3 . LN
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jones , G. Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain , 19 43 – 7 . 50 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• Freeden , M. “ Eugenics and Social Thought ” . 654 – 7 .
   Google Scholar
• National Service Medical Boards . November 1917 ‐ October 1918 1920 . Physical examination of Men of Military Age: Report Vol. 1 , November 1917 ‐ October 1918 ,
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/129 Housing Act 1923 ‘Average Increase in Numbers of Houses since 1900–1914’. The Tudor Walters Committee reckoned a shortfall of 500,000. On unfitness, PRO HLG 47/699 Memorandum to Ministry of Health, signed 1. G. Gibbon, dated 29.7.20 ‘Unfit Houses and Unhealthy Areas’. For the viewpoint of the then Minister of Health see
   Google Scholar
• Addison , C. 1922 . The Betrayal of the Slums , London : Herbert Jenkin .
   Google Scholar
• This view has been argued by
   Google Scholar
• Swenarton , M. 1981 . Homes Fit for Heroes , London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar
• Ritchie , A. W. 1924–5 . The Housing Shortage and its Baneful Effects . Journal of The Royal Sanitary Institute (J.R.S.I.) , : 388
   Google Scholar
• Barnes , H. 1926 . Housing: The Fact and the Future , London : Ernest Benn .
   Google Scholar
• Carrott , E. 1920–21 . (Sanitary Inspector, Bristol), ‘The Duties of the Sanitary Inspector in Relation to the Housing Acts’ . J.R.S.I. , : 336
   Google Scholar
• Ministry of Health. Unhealthy Areas Committee . 1921 . Final Report 16 – 17 .
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/700 Unhealthy Areas Report. Minute. Signed I. G. Gibbon. Dated 24.6.1921.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/700 Unhealthy Areas. Ms. Note, Arthur Robinson, Minister of Health. Dated 23.5.1921.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/699 (1) I. G. Gibbon Minute ‘Designation of Unhealthy Areas’ dated 22.12.1919. Local Authorities were given only 6 months to carry out the survey and submit a programme to the Minister. (2) I. G. Gibbon Minute to Minister. Dated 12.2.1920. ‘Unhealthy Areas Town Planning’. (3) I. G. Gibbon Minute to Sir Arthur Robinson. Dated 8.12.1920. ‘Slum Areas’.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/699. Draft Minute. I. G. Gibbon to Minister of Health. Dated 29.7.1920.
   Google Scholar
• ibid.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/699. I. G. Gibbon to Sir Arthur Robinson. Dated 8.12.1920. ‘Slum Areas’.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/699. Minute prepared for I. G. Gibbon. Dated 13.6.1921. ‘Suggested “Rationing Arrangement” ‘.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 68/29. Sir Alfred Mond, Minister of Health. Cabinet Memorandum. Dated 22.6.21.
   Google Scholar
• Jones , G. Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain , 50 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• Laws , G. 1932–3 . Housing Act, 1930. Slum Ending or Slum Mending . J.R.S.I. , : 432 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• Hanks , Louis . 1927–8 . Improved Houses for Poor Families . J.R.S.I , : 178 – 9 .
   Google Scholar
• Sutherland , Joan . The Prevention of Slums . ibid , 259 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Hodson , C. B. S. 1923–4 . Eugenics and Public Health . J.R.S.I. , : 248
   Google Scholar
• Tredgold , A. F. 1926–7 . The Place of Inheritance in Preventative Medicine . J.R.S.I. , : 182
   Google Scholar
• For Tredgold's support for the detention and sterilisation of the feeble minded (including the senile, those referred by parents as in need of detention, those ‘defectives’ found wandering, neglected or cruelly treated plus any others in ‘special circumstances’ as defined by the Secretary of State), see
   Google Scholar
• Jones , G. Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain , 31 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• Bowley , A. L. 1923 . Death Rates, Density, Population and Housing . Journal of Royal Statistical Society , : 516 – 46 .
   Google Scholar
• Ward , S. 1974 . The Town and Country Planning Act, 1932 . The Planner ,
   Google Scholar
• Platt , F. 1928–9 . A Brief Review of the Present Condition of National Housing . J.R.S.I. , : 169
   Google Scholar
• Frazer , W. M. 1933–4 . Housing and Slum Clearance . J.R.S.I. , : 376 – 87 .
   Google Scholar
• Robertson , Professor Sir John . 1930–1 . The Slum Problem . J.R.S.I. , : 279 – 84 .
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Housing. Dated 13.12.1933. ‘Slum Clearance deals with the worst ... picks out the eyes’.
   Google Scholar
• Hanks, Improved Houses for Poor Families.
   Google Scholar
• Odlum , Doris . 1928–9 . The Influence of the Environment on the Mental Health and Development of the Child: with Special Reference to Housing and Sanitary Conditions Generally . J.R.S.I. , : 245
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 47/11. Statements showing the position of clearance and improvement’ areas at 31 December, 1932.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Notes of Departmental Conference. Dated 12.3.1934.
   Google Scholar
• ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Crothers , Hamilton . 1930–1 . Housing: with Special Reference to the Housing Act 1930, from the Point of view of a Town Councillor . J.R.S.I. , : 625 – 31 .
   Google Scholar
• Jefford , F. R. 1933–4 . Reconditioning in Relation to Urban Housing . J.R.S.I. , : 451 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Cresswell , W. T. Town and Country Planning . J.R.S.I. , 659 – 69 .
   Google Scholar
• Sutherland , Joan . 1927–8 . (Manager of Working Class Property in London) . The Prevention of the Slums J.R.S.I. , : 259 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Galton , M. 1926–7 . Housing of the Very Poor . J.R.S.I. , : 386 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Speake , T. 1929–30 . Housing of the Poor and slum Clearance . J.R.S.I. , : 571 – 5 .
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213 Housing. Dated 13.12.33.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Memorandum. Signed Sir Arthur Lowry. Revised 7.1.34.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Draft of a proposed Housing Bill. Dated 18.1.34.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Sir E. Hilton Young, Cabinet Memorandum, Housing Policy, Dated January 1934.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Conference Hilton Young and Miles Mitchell. Conference with Representatives of Local Authorities. February (?). 1934. Dated 28.2.34.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/214. Letter addressed to the National Housing Council. Signed E. Hilton Young. Dated 13.2.35.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Notes of Conference. Minister and Representatives of the Association of Municipal Corporations. Dated 13.4.34.
   Google Scholar
• ibid.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Note on Memorandum of Sir Arthur Lowry. Dated 4.1.34.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Memorandum. Dated 1.1.34.
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Memorandum. Revised 7.1.34. (Sir Arthur Lowry).
   Google Scholar
• PRO HLG 29/213. Note on Memorandum of Sir Arthur Lowry. Dated 4.1.34. PRO HLG 29/214. Housing Bill — Notes for Second Reading. A review of the new standard applied by Ministry officials to the Borough of Camberwell in London gave an increase in overcrowding of 50% compared with the 1931 Census.
   Google Scholar
• In relation to the overcrowding standard, it was held that ‘more important almost than the abatement of overcrowding was the prevention of new overcrowding’. PRO HLG 29/214. The Objects and Methods of the New Housing Bill. Dated Spring 1934.
   Google Scholar
• M'Gonigle , G. C. M. and Kirby , J. 1937 . Poverty and Public Health , 10 – 1 . Gollancz .
   Google Scholar
• ibid. pp. 102–3.
   Google Scholar
• ibid. p. 104.
   Google Scholar
• ibid. p. 11.
   Google Scholar
• ibid. p. 263.
   Google Scholar
• ibid. p. 275.
   Google Scholar
• A. Marwick, Middle Opinion in the 1930s.
   Google Scholar
• G. Jones, Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain, Ch. 6.
   Google Scholar
• M. Freeden, Eugenics and Progressive Thought.
   Google Scholar
• Odium , D. “ Influence of Environment on Mental Health ” . 246
   Google Scholar
• Jeffries , L. M. 1932–3 . Practical Aspects of Conception Control from a Medical Woman's Point of View . J.R.S.I. , : 201
   Google Scholar
• ibid. Discussion, p. 206 (Dr A. G. Thompson).
   Google Scholar
• Titmuss , R. 1943 . Birth, Poverty and Wealth. A study of Infant Mortality , London : Hamish Hamilton Medical Books .
   Google Scholar
• ibid, p. 59.
   Google Scholar
• ibid, p. 83
   Google Scholar
• ibid, p. 95.
   Google Scholar
• ibid, p. 100.
   Google Scholar
• Wilkinson , R. , ed. 1986 . Class and Health: Research and Longitudinal Data , London : Longman .
   Google Scholar
• For an evaluation of the current status of eugenics, see
   Google Scholar
• Kevles , Daniel L. 1985 . In the Name of Eugenics: Genetics and the Uses of Human Heredity , New York : Knopf .
   Google Scholar
• Lockwood , M. 1985 . Nature , 317 10 October : 481 – 2 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dr Patrica L. Garside is Senior Lecturer in Environmental Health and Housing at the University of Salford; her chief research interest is the history of planning and housing policy, and its relationship with urban development. Previous publications include Metropolitan London: Politics and Urban Change 1837–1981 (with Ken Young, 1982).
   Google Scholar