Researching grant‐maintained schoolsFootnote¹

1. This paper was first presented at an Education Reform Act Research Network Seminar held in the Faculty of Education, Bristol Polytechnic, on Thursday 30 November 1989. Parts of the paper draw on the authors’ research proposal to the Economic and Social Research Council, J. Fitz and D. Halpin (1989), and work subsequently supported by one of its grants (Award No. R0000231899). A number of colleagues, including Geoff Whitty, Len Barton, Gill Crozier, Paul Croll, Ian Menter, Peter Aggleton and Andrew Pollard (all from the Bristol Polytechnic) and Mike Flude and Merrill Hammer (both from the Open University) read and commented on earlier versions of the paper, as did James Wetz, Headteacher, St Laurence School, Bradford on Avon. We are grateful for their time, encouragement and advice. None of them, however, should be held responsible for the arguments we put forward

References

• Anon . 1987a . ‘The Thatcher Plan for an alternative system’ . Education , 18 September : 225
   Google Scholar
• Anon . 1987b . ‘Baker scotches rumours of rift with Mrs Thatcher’ . Times Educational Supplement , 25 September : 14
   Google Scholar
• Anon . 1988a . ‘Baker still opting out of Thatcher camp’ . Education , 1 April : 272
   Google Scholar
• Anon . 1988b . ‘NUT opts for Gould advice’ . Education , 12 February : 117
   Google Scholar
• Audit Commission . 1989 . Losing an Empire, Finding a Role: The LEA of the Future , London : Her Majesty's Stationery Office .
   Google Scholar
• Ball , S. and Bowe , R. 1989 . ‘When the garment gapes: policy and ethnography as practices’ , London : Education Reform Act Project, Centre for Educational Studies, King's College, London . unpublished paper
   Google Scholar
• Bash , L. and Coulby , D. 1989 . The Reform Act: Competition and Control , London : Cassell .
   Google Scholar
• Brighouse , T. 1989 . ‘Dodgy cocktails’ . Times Educational Supplement , 23 June : 15
   Google Scholar
• Chanan , G. 1987 . ‘No option’ . Times Educational Supplement , 24 July : 14
   Google Scholar
• Chitty , C. 1989 . Towards a New Educational System: The Victory of the New Right? , Lewes : The Falmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Conservative Central Office . 1987 . The Next Moves Forward , London : Conservative Central Office .
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , B.S. 1989 . “ ‘The politics of privatization: policy‐making and private schools in the USA and Great Britain’ ” . In Private Schools and Public Policy: International Perspectives , Edited by: Boyd , W. L. and Cibulka , J. G. Lewes : The Falmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Coulby , D. 1989 . “ ‘The ideological contradictions of educational reform’ ” . In The Reform Act: Competition and Control , Edited by: Bash , L. and Coulby , D. London : Cassell .
   Google Scholar
• Cox , C.B. and Boyson , R. 1977 . Black Paper 5 , London : Temple Smith .
   Google Scholar
• Crequer , N. 1989 . ‘Schools vote for opt‐out to escape selection’ . Independent , 5 October
   Google Scholar
• Dean , C. and Blackburn , L. 1989 . ‘Protests over extra cash for opt‐out schools’ . Times Educational Supplement , 13 October : 1
   Google Scholar
• Dennison , W. 1988 . ‘The rewards of opting out’ . Education , 18 November : 481 – 482 .
   Google Scholar
• Des . 1987 . Grant‐Maintained Schools: Consultative Paper , London : Department of Education and Science .
   Google Scholar
• Dexter , L. A. 1970 . Elite and Specialised Interviewing , Illinois : Northwestern University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Fisher , A. 1987 . ‘Fears for the future of the “forgotten” children’ . Times Educational Supplement , 6 November : 15
   Google Scholar
• Fitz , J. and Halpin , D. 1989 . ‘Opting for Grant‐Maintained Status: A Study of Policy Making in Education’ , Bristol : Faculty of Education, Bristol Polytechnic . unpublished paper
   Google Scholar
• Fitz , J. , Edwards , T. and Whitty , G. 1986 . ‘Beneficiaries, benefits and costs: an investigation of the Assisted Places Scheme” . Research Papers in Education , 1 (3)
   Google Scholar
• Flude , M. and Hammer , M. 1990 . “ ‘Opting into an uncertain future: Grant‐Maintained Schools’ ” . In The Education Reform Act 1988: its origins and implications , Edited by: Flude , M. and Hammer , M. Lewes : The Falmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Garner , R. 1987 . ‘Mrs Thatcher enthuses over opting out proposals’ . Times Educational Supplement , 18 September : 7
   Google Scholar
• Griggs , C. 1989 . “ ‘The New Right and English secondary education’ ” . In The Changing Secondary School , Edited by: Lowe , R. Lewes : The Falmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hammer , M. and Flude , M. 1989 . ‘ “Grant‐maintained schools are nothing to do with party politics”: an interview with Andrew Turner, Director of the Grant‐Maintained Schools Trust’ . Journal of Education Policy , 4 (4)
   Google Scholar
• Harding , R. 1987 . ‘Careering off down the wrong road’ . Times Educational Supplement , 3 July : 4
   Google Scholar
• Hargreaves , A. and Reynolds , D. 1989 . “ ‘Decomprehensivization’ ” . In Education Policies: Controversies and Critiques , Edited by: Hargreaves , A. and Reynolds , D. Lewes : The Falmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Haviland , J. 1988 . Take Care, Mr Baker! , London : Fourth Estate .
   Google Scholar
• Heald , D. 1983 . Public Expenditure , Oxford : Basil Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Horn , J. 1987 . ‘Diving into dangerous waters’ . Times Educational Supplement , 18 December
   Google Scholar
• Houlden , R. and Tipple , C. 1988 . ‘A warning for fortune hunters’ . Education , 9 December : 533
   Google Scholar
• Hugill , B. 1987a . ‘Opted‐out schools face HMI policing’ . Times Educational Supplement , 5 June : 1
   Google Scholar
• Hugill , B. 1987b . ‘Bishop's move ‐‐ but which way?’ . Times Educational Supplement , 27 November : 6
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , P. 1987 . ‘The false premises behind the Conservative proposals on opting‐out’ . Education , 19 June : 533
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , R. 1989 . ‘Thatcherism and English education: breaking the mould or confirming the pattern?’ . History of Education , 18 (2)
   Google Scholar
• Kogan , M. 1975 . Educational Policy‐Making , London : George, Allen & Unwin .
   Google Scholar
• Kogan , M. 1978 . The Politics of Educational Change , Mancheste : University of Manchester Press .
   Google Scholar
• Last , E. H. 1987 . ‘Small schools will suffer if opt‐out plans go through’ . Times Educational Supplement , 11 December : 20
   Google Scholar
• Lodge , B. 1987 . ‘Clergy fears opting out will close its schools’ . Times Educational Supplement , 20 November : 3
   Google Scholar
• McPherson , A. and Raab , C. 1988 . Governing Education: A Sociology of Policy Since 1945 , Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Meickle , J. 1987 . ‘Opt‐out plan casts doubt on maintained sector’ . Times Educational Supplement , 29 May : 5
   Google Scholar
• Moyser , G. and Wagstaffe , M. , eds. 1987 . Research Methods for Elite Studies , London : George Allen & Unwin .
   Google Scholar
• Nash , I. and Garner , R. 1987 . ‘Baker quiets Tory fears of a mass opt‐out’ . Times Educational Supplement , 18 September : 1
   Google Scholar
• O'Connor , M. 1989 . ‘Opting‐out finds favour in the Tory heartlands’ . Observer , 15 October : 60
   Google Scholar
• Parkes , S. 1987a . ‘Baker finds Thatcher hard to follow’ . Times Educational Supplement , 29 May : 7
   Google Scholar
• Parkes , S. 1978b . ‘Opting‐out may hurt special needs pupils’ . Times Educational Supplement , 23 November : 1
   Google Scholar
• Quicke , J. 1988 . ‘The ‘New Right’ and education’ . British Journal of Educational Studies , 36 (1)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rogers , R. 1989 . Considering the Options: A Guide on Opting Out , London : Advisory Centre for Education .
   Google Scholar
• Salter , B. and Tapper , E. 1981 . Education, Politics and the State: The Theory and Practice of Educational Change , London : Grant‐MacIntyre .
   Google Scholar
• Salter , B. and Tapper , E. 1988 . ‘The politics of reversing the rachet in secondary education, 1969‐1986’ . Journal of Educational Administration and History , 20 (2)
   Google Scholar
• Seldon , A. and Pappworth , J. 1983 . By Word of Mouth: ‘Elite’ Oral History , London : Methuen .
   Google Scholar
• Sexton , S. 1989 . Opting to Grant‐Maintained Schools , London : Institute of Economic Affairs .
   Google Scholar
• Simon , B. 1988 . Bending the Rules: The Baker ‘Reform’ of Education , London : Lawrence & Wishart .
   Google Scholar
• Sutcliffe , J. 1987 . ‘Tory shires worried by opting‐out threat’ . Times Educational Supplement , 4 December : 1
   Google Scholar
• Thomas , G. 1987 . ‘Opting out? No thanks’ . Times Educational Supplement , 11 December : 20
   Google Scholar
• Whitty , G. and Edwards , T. 1984 . “ ‘Evaluating policy change: the Assisted Places Scheme’ ” . In British Public Schools: Policy and Practice , Edited by: Walford , G. Lewes : The Palmer Press .
   Google Scholar
• Whitty , G. and Menter , I. 1989 . ‘Lessons of Thatcherism: education policy in England and Wales 1979‐88’ . Journal of Law and Society , 16 (1)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Young , K. and Mills , L. 1978 . Understanding the ‘Assumptive Worlds’ of Governmental Actors: Issues and Approaches , Bristol : Report to the SSRC Panel on Centre/Local Government Relations, University of Bristol .
   Google Scholar