92
Views
3
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Unconcern at dawn, surprise at sunset: Egyptian intelligence appreciation before the Sinai campaign, 1956

Pages 7-56 | Published online: 02 Jan 2008

Notes

  • Bar‐On , Mordechai . 1988 . Mediniut Hachutz Vehabitachon Shel Israel Bashanim 1955–1957 [Israel's Foreign and Security Policy in the Years 1955–1957] , Jerusalem : Hebrew University . doctoral dissertation,
  • Jackson , Robert . 1990 . Suez 1956: Operation ‘Musketeer’ London
  • Troen , Ilan and Shemesh , Moshe , eds. 1990 . The Suez‐Sinai Crisis. A Retrospective London
  • Louis , W.R. and Owen , R. , eds. 1989 . Suez 1956: The Crisis and its Consequences Oxford
  • Heikal , Mohamed . 1988 . Cutting the Lion's Tail. Suez Through Egyptian Eyes 193 London
  • Heikal , Mohamed . 1972 . Nasser. The Cairo Documents 107 London
  • Nasser , Gamal Abdel . 6 December 1956 . Egyptian Gazette 6 December , (hereafter Nasser).
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 91
  • Fawzi , Mahmoud . 1985 . Suez 1956. An Egyptian Perspective London
  • 1989 . Wathaiq Nadwah al‐Suways al‐Dawliyya, Ma'raka al‐Suways ‐ Thalathown ‘Ama [Arabic: Proceedings of Suez International Conference, Suez Campaign — 30 years] Cairo
  • Tharwat . 1986 . ‘Ukasha, Mudhakirati fi Siasa wal‐Thaqafa [Arabic: Reminiscence of Politics and Culture] Cairo
  • Hewedy , Amin . “ ‘Nasser and the Crisis of 1956’ ” . Edited by: Louis and Owen . 161 – 72 .
  • Heikal , Mohamed . 1986 . Milaffat al‐Suways [Arabic: Suez Files] Cairo
  • Al‐Quwat al‐musalaha liljumhuria al‐arabia Al‐mutahida . Summer 1956 . Harb al‐Udwan al‐Thulathi ‘ala misr. Harif sana 1956 , Summer , Arabic : United Arab Republic Armed Forces, The Triple Aggression against Egypt .
  • Wheelcock , Keith . 1960 . Nasser's New Egypt 238 – 9 . New York
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 89 – 91 .
  • Official History , I 42
  • Heikal . Suez Files 462 – 4 .
  • 1978 . The Sphinx and the Commissar 68 London
  • Moncrieff , Anthony , ed. 1967 . Suez Ten Years After 44 London
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 133
  • Oren , Michael . 1989 . ‘Escalation to Suez: The Egypt‐Israel Border War, 1949–1956’ . Journal of Contemporary History , 24 ( 2 ) April : 347 – 72 .
  • Shamir , Shimon . “ ‘The Collapse of Project Alpha’ ” . Edited by: Louis and Owen . 73 – 100 .
  • Green , Stephan . ‘Hukuma al‐Ra'is Eisenhower wal‐'Udwan ‘ala Misr’ [Arabic: The Eisenhower Government and the Aggression Against Egypt] . Cairo Proceedings , 91 – 121 .
  • Jackson , Elmore . 1982 . Middle East Mission New York
  • Harel , Isser . 1989 . Modi'in Vedemokratya [Hebrew: Intelligence and Democracy] 394 – 400 . Tel Aviv
  • Shamir . “The Collapse of Project Alpha’ ” . 80
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 98
  • Heikal . Suez Files 435 – 6 .
  • Servan‐Schreiber , Jean Jacques . 1980 . The World Challenge 180 New York
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 136
  • Jackson . Middle East Mission 95
  • Shamir , Shimon . 1987 . ‘Im Hipatach Hatikim’ [Hebrew; With the Opening of the Files] . Ha'aretz , 8 October
  • Bandman , Yonah . 1987 . “ ‘Hatzi Ha'i Sinai: Hatfisa Ha'estrategit Shel Mitzraim, 1949–1967’ [Hebrew: The Sinai Peninsula: Egypt's Strategic Concept, 1949–1967] ” . In Sinai Edited by: Gvirtsman , Gedalyahu . Vol. B , 941 – 60 . Tel Aviv
  • Fahrmbacher , Wilhelm . 1959 . ‘Giluyav Shel Yoetz Latsava Hamitsri’, [Hebrew: The Disclosures of an Adviser to the Egyptian Army] . Cyclon , August : 3 – 14 .
  • January 1957 . “ ‘Planning of Attacks on Israeli Settlements’, September 1956 ” . In The Egyptian Army, Selected Captured Documents , January , 32 – 3 . IDF/DMI .
  • July 1957 . The Egyptian Army ‐3rd Infantry Division Plan , July , IDF/DMI . [Hebrew].
  • Teveth , Shabtai . 1957 . Masa Tsahal Besinai [Hebrew: The IDF Campaign in Sinai] 11 – 14 . Tel Aviv (hereafter Teveth).
  • CCD: Military Security Directorate . 8 November 1956 . “ ‘Security Publication No. 2’ ” . 8 November , ref. 41/4884,
  • Mahr , Hamid Abdel . 1977 . Mismachei Hamid. Sipuro Ha'otenti shel Ktzin Modi'in Mitsri [Hebrew: The Hamid Documents. The Authentic Story of an Egyptian Intelligence Officer] 20 Tel Aviv
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 119
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 118
  • Ya'ari , Ehud . 1975 . Mitsraim Vehafedayeen 1953–1956 [Hebrew: Egypt and the Fedayeen 1953–1956] 27 – 31 . Givat Haviva
  • Argeman , Yosef . 1987 . ‘Ketsad Husal Mustafa Hafiz’ [Hebrew: How Mustafa Hafiz Was Eliminated] . Bamahane, IDF weekly , 4 November : 38 – 41 .
  • CCD . January 1957 . “ ‘Intelligence Report on the IDF, 1956’ ” . In Egyptian Army ‐ Selected Documents January , 70 – 75 .
  • Steigman , Yitzhak . 1986 . Mivtsa Kadesh. Hail Ha'avir Bashanim 1950–1956 [Hebrew: The ‘Kadesh’ Campaign. The Israeli Air Force in the Years 1950–1956] 46 Tel Aviv (hereafter Steigman).
  • Dayan , Moshe . 1976 . Avnay Derech [Hebrew: Milestones) 162 – 3 . Tel Aviv
  • Cohen , Stuart . 1988 . ‘A Still Stranger Aspect of Suez; British Operational Plan to Attack Israel, 1955–1956’ . The International History Review , May : 261 – 81 .
  • Glubb , John . 1957 . A Soldier with the Arabs 261 – 3 . London
  • Heikal . Suez Files , Document No. 120 785
  • Oren , Michael . The Origins of the Second Arab‐Israeli War: Egypt, Israel and the Great Powers 280 – 313 . (forthcoming),
  • Cohen , Raymond . 1988 . ‘Israeli Military Intelligence Before 1956’ . Intelligence and National Security , 3 ( 1 ) January : 131
  • Heikal . Suez Files 401
  • CCD . “ ‘Protocol of the First Meeting of the Joint Egyptian‐Syrian Intelligence Conference, April 30‐May 7 1956’ ” . 4
  • CCD . June 1957 . “ ‘Military Training Policy for 1956–1957’, 15 April ” . In Egyptian Army ‐ Selected Documents June , 32
  • Official History , 182
  • CCD: Eastern Command, Operations Branch . 25 July 1956 . “ ‘Marching Orders of the Eastern Command No. 33’ ” . 25 July , ref. 120/36/1027, of
  • Official History , 188
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 91
  • Official History , 193 – 5 .
  • CCD: 3rd Infantry Division . 5–10 October 1956 . “ ‘Orders to 4th, 5th & 6th Brigades’ ” . 5–10 October , probably distributed between
  • CCD: 3rd Infantry Division Intelligence . 19 August 1956 . “ ‘Special Security Orders’ ” . 19 August , ref. Security/31/ Secret/56,
  • CCD: General Staff of the Armed Forces . 28 August 1956 . “ ‘General Orders for the Defence of Egypt’ ” . 28 August ,
  • ‘An Appreciation of the Military Situation in the Eastern Mediterranean, September 1956’ . Official History , 298 – 307 . Appendix B,
  • CCD . 1 September 1956 . “ ‘Military Operational Orders No. 50 for the Strategic Defence of the Republic of Egypt’ ” . 1 September ,
  • Official History , 308 – 20 . Appendix C,
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 192
  • Rouleau , Eric . 1970 . Le Monde , 8 April
  • Caroz , Ya'acov . 1976 . Hamodi'in Ha'wavi [Hebrew: Arab Intelligence Services] 46 – 9 . Tel Aviv
  • CCD: Eastern Command to the 8th Palestinian Division and the Sinai Sector . 11 August 1956 . “ ‘Operational Order’ ” . 11 August , ref. 50/'A/102,
  • Official History , 71
  • Thomas , Hugh . 1967 . The Suez Affair 55 ff London
  • Barker , A.J. 1964 . Suez. The Seven Days War 37 – 40 . London
  • Beaufre , Andre . 1969 . The Suez Expedition, 1956 23 – 60 . London
  • Gorst , Anthony and Lucas , Scott . 1988 . ‘Suez 1956: Strategy and the Diplomatic Process’ . Journal of Strategic Studies , 11 ( 4 ) November : 391 – 436 .
  • Dooley , Howard . 1989 . ‘Great Britain's “Last Battle” in the Middle East Notes on Cabinet Planning during the Suez Crisis of 1956’ . The International History Review , August : 486 – 513 .
  • Thomas . Suez Affair 65
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 154 – 5 .
  • Official History , 309
  • Montague House Annexe, War Office . 20 August 1956 . “ ‘Operation in Conjunction with Musketeer’ ” . 20 August ,
  • ‘Eastern Command Planning Order No. 30’ . Official History , 196 – 98 .
  • Barker . Suez 35 – 37 .
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 158
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 113
  • Thomas . Suez Affair 83 – 4 .
  • Barker . Suez 56 – 7 .
  • Heikal . Suez Files , Document No. 143 825
  • Suez Files , Document No. 147 828
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 104
  • Heikal . Suez Files , Document No. 164 844
  • General Staff/DMI . February 1957 . Hapeiloot Bagvulot. Doh Mesakem Lishnat 1956. Mispar 3 [Hebrew: Activity Along the Borders, Concluding Report for 1956, No. 3] February ,
  • Dayan . Milestones 249
  • Dayan . Milestones 220
  • Ne'eman , Yuval . 1987 . ‘Kesher Im Hatsarfatim Vehabritim Bema'arechet Sinai’ [Hebrew: Co‐operation with the British and French in the Sinai Campaign] . Ma'arachot , January : 31 – 6 .
  • Official History , 105
  • Lucas , W. Scott . 1990 . ‘Redefining the Suez “Collusion"’ . Middle Eastern Studies , 26 ( 1 ) January : 100 – 103 .
  • Bar‐Zohar , Michael . 1977 . Ben Gurion: Biographia Politit [Hebrew: Ben Gurion, A Political Biography] Vol. III , 1230 Tel Aviv
  • Heikal . Suez Files 514
  • Gorst and Lucas . “ ‘Suez 1956’ ” . 419 – 21 .
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 108
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 190
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 107
  • CCD . June 1956 . “ ‘Minutes of the Eastern Command's Training Conference’, October 1956 ” . In Egyptian Army — Selected Documents June , 39
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 105
  • Handel , Michael . 1984 . “ ‘Crisis and Surprise in Three Arab Israeli Wars’ ” . In Strategic Military Surprise Edited by: Knorr , Klaus and Morgan , Patrick . 111 – 22 . New York
  • Dayan's , Moshe . 1966 . Milestones and Diary of the Sinai Campaign London
  • General Staff/Operations Branch . October 21 1956 . “ ‘Esau Planning’ ” . In Study of the Sinai Campaign File October 21 ,
  • Handel . “ ‘Crisis and Surprise’ ” . 117
  • Artzieli , Mordechai . 1985 . ‘Kenes Shloshim Shana Lemivtsa Kadesh’ [Hebrew: 30th Anniversary Conference of the ‘Kadesh’ Operation] . Ha'aretz , 30 October
  • Kochva , Moshe Bar . 1988 . Merkavot Haplada [Hebrew: Chariots of Steel] 455 Tel Aviv
  • Ze'ev , Yosef Ben . 1987 . ‘Hamodi'in Bema'arechet Sinai’ [Hebrew: Military Intelligence in the Sinai Campaign] . Ma'arachot , January : 20
  • Granot , Oded . 1981 . Chail Hamodi'in [Hebrew: The Intelligence Corps] 54 Tel Aviv
  • Dayan . Diary of the Sinai Campaign 210
  • Dayan . Milestones 269
  • Yanouka , Moshe . 1967 . Mekibia Ad Hamitle [Hebrew: From Kibiya to the Mitla] 157 – 9 . Tel Aviv
  • Dayan . Milestones 271
  • Official History , II 91
  • CCD: 5th Infantry Brigade . January 1957 . “ ‘Military Operational Orders No. 8, Plan for en Attack on Kerem Shalom’, 25 October 1956 ” . In Egyptian Army ‐ Selected Documents January , 28
  • Official History , I 222
  • Bar‐Zohar , Michael . 1964 . Gesher Me'al Hayam Hatichon [Hebrew: A Bridge Over the Mediterranean] 140 Tel Aviv
  • IDF General Staff/DMI . April 1957 . Hatsava Hamitsri Bema'arechet Sinai ‐ Shihzur April ,
  • Peschloss , Michael . 1986 . Mayday. The U‐2 Affair 137 New York
  • Dulles , Allen . 1963 . The Craft of Intelligence 168 New York
  • Handel . “ ‘Crisis and Surprise’ ” . 118 – 19 .
  • Eisenhower , Dwight . 1965 . Waging Peace 56 Washington
  • Official History , I 98 – 9 . 260
  • Heikal . Cairo Documents 106
  • Official History , II 5 – 6 .
  • Heikal . Cutting the Lion's Tail 195
  • Official History , II 7 – 8 .
  • Heweydi , Amin . 1987 . ‘Numuzat Harb al‐Suways’ [Arabic: Paragon of the Suez Campaign] . Al‐Mustaqbal al‐Arabi , April : 40
  • Heikal . Suez Files 533
  • Evron , Yosef . 1986 . Suez 1956 ‐ Mabat Hadash [Hebrew: Suez 1956 ‐ A New View] 186 Tel Aviv
  • Cohen , R. “ ‘Israeli Military Intelligence’ ” . 130 – 33 .
  • Amidror , Binyamin . 1974 . ‘Kadesh. Hakishalon Shehitsliach’ [Hebrew: Kadesh, the Successful Failure] . Ha'olam Ha'ze , 25 September
  • Ilan , Y. 1966 . ‘Nitsul Ha'aphta'a Bemivtsa Kadesh’ [Hebrew: The Exploitation of Surprise in the Kadesh Operation] . Ma'arachot , October : 178 – 179 . 27 – 35 .
  • Gafni , Shraga . 1986 . ‘Hachra'at Ma'arach Rafiah Bekadesh’ [Hebrew: The Defeat of the Rafah Defences in Kadesh] . Skira Hodshit , October‐November : 46 – 7 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.