Preludes to the NCAA: Early Failures of Faculty Intercollegiate Athletic Control

References

• 22 June 1874 . Princeton Trustees Minutes , 22 June , 351 Princeton University Archives (Hereafter called P.U.A.) .
   Google Scholar
• The NCAA claims that it was created in 1906, but the organization was set in motion in December, 1905, when it met in New York City
   Google Scholar
• Meiklejohn , Alexander . 1905 . “The Evils of College Athletics,” . Harper's Weekly , XLIX 2 December : 1752
   Google Scholar
• John Lucas , A. and Ronald Smith , A. 1978 . Saga of American Sport , 221 – 224 . Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger .
   Google Scholar
• Walter Camp , C. 1884 . “College Athletics,” . New Englander , XLIV January : 139 A. M. F. Davis in “College Athletics,” Atlantic Monthly, LI (1883), p. 676, states that college athletics were “almost exclusively under the charge of students.”
   Google Scholar
• Hart , A. B. 1890 . “The Status of Athletics in American Colleges,” . Atlantic Monthly , XLVI July : 69
   Google Scholar
• 1881 . Princeton Faculty Minutes , 29 April : 67 P.U.A. and Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes, 15 June 1882, p. 1, Harvard University Archives (Hereafter called H.U.A.)
   Google Scholar
• 1873 . Princeton Faculty Minutes , 15 October : 395 13 November 1873, p. 397; 8 May 1874, p. 417; 20 November 1875, p. 480; 1 June 1877, pp. 540–541; 4 June 1877, p. 541; 11 June 1877, p. 548; 15 June 1877, pp. 548–551; 28 January 1878, p. 576; 26 January 1880, p. 19; 11 October 1880, p. 46; and 7 March 1881, p. 62, P.U.A., and the Committee of Physical Training, Athletic Sports, and Sanitary Conditions of Buildings, “Important Suggestions in Athletics,” Harvard Graduates' Magazine, VI (December 1897), pp. 193–194, indicates that the Harvard Athletic Committee was orginally organized to control (1) the number and place of games, (2) brutality and professionalism, and (3) interschool negotiations
   Google Scholar
• 1882 . Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes , 6 November : 17 H.U.A. One of Harvard's pre-athletic committee rules limited games to Saturdays and after 4:00 p.m. on weekdays. Princeton Faculty Minutes, 13 October 1882, pp. 151–152, P.U.A., contains a report of the athletic committee regulations. The regulations forbade leaves of absence of more than eight days during any term for either the baseball or football teams, and no leaves during exams; parental permission for the leaves and a list of athletes to be filed at the registrar's office; and home matches during the week only between 12:10 p.m. and 2:45 p.m.
   Google Scholar
• 1882 . Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes , 15 June : 1 and 7 October 1882, p. 10, H.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• Henry Sheldon , D. 1901 . Student Life and Customs , 246 New York : D. Appleton & Co. .
   Google Scholar
• Eliot , C. W. 1934 . “The Charles W. Eliot Centennial,” . Journal of Physical Education , V March : 24 letter to other college presidents, 11 September 1882, as quoted in Luther W. Warren, Dartmouth Faculty Records, 18 September 1882, Dartmouth College Archives; and Yale University Faculty Minutes, 4 October 1882, Yale University Archives. The concern over professionalism had evidently followed Harvard's hiring of a professional baseball coach in 1881 and the participation against professionals and thus contact with what were considered the lower elements of the major league teams. The Harvard athletic committee forbade coach Robinson's employment following the 1882 season. See Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes, 17 June 1882, p. 4, and 27 September 1882, p. 5, H.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• 1882 . Yale University Faculty Minutes , 11 October Yale University Archives
   Google Scholar
• 1882 . Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes , 4 October : 7 14 October 1882, p. 13; and 17 October 1882, H.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• 1883 . Ibid , 10 December : 27 – 30 .
   Google Scholar
• John White , W. , Chaplin , W. S. and Hart , A. B. 12 June 1888 . “Athletic Report,” 12 June , 13 – 14 . HUD 8388.3B, H.U.A.; Edward M. Hartwell, “Physical Training in American Colleges and Universities,” Bureau of Education Circular of Information No. 5, 1885 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1886, pp. 125–128; and Dudley A. Sargent, “History of the Administration of Intercollegiate Athletics in the United States,” American Physical Education Review, XV (1910), pp. 252–253
   Google Scholar
• 1884 . Harvard Crimson , 14 February : 1 White and others, Ibid, 22 February 1884, p. 1; and 23 February 1884, p. 1
   Google Scholar
• White and others . Ibid , 14
   Google Scholar
• 7 March 1884 . Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes , 7 March , 35 H.U.A. .
   Google Scholar
• 1884 . Harvard Crimson , 26 February : 1
   Google Scholar
• 1884 . Ibid , 22 February : 1
   Google Scholar
• 1884 . Ibid , 6 March : 1 and 12 March 1884, p. 1
   Google Scholar
• Richards , E. L. 18 February 1884 . 18 February , 1 Letter to W. M. Sloan, as quoted in the Harvard Crimson, 21 February 1884
   Google Scholar
• 24 January 1884 . 24 January , 1 As quoted in the Harvard Crimson
   Google Scholar
• 1886 . The [Brown College] Brunonian , 18 December : 114 125 and Bruce Leslie, “The Responses of Four Colleges to the Rise of Intercollegiate Athletics,” Journal of Sport History, III (Winter 1976), p. 216
   Google Scholar
• Camp , Walter . 1 March 1884 . 1 March , 2 letter to the New York Times, as quoted in the Harvard Crimson
   Google Scholar
• Hart , A. B. 27 November 1888 . 27 November , 190 – 191 . H.U.A . Reviewed the history of inter-institutional attempts to control athletics in the Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes
   Google Scholar
• 1897-1904 . Newspaper clipping, 17 February 1898, Brown University College Scrapbook, Brown University Archives (Hereafter called B.U.A.)
   Google Scholar
• 8 February 1898 . Brown University Faculty Minutes , 8 February , B.U.A. .
   Google Scholar
• 1898 . Brown Daily Herald , 18 February : 1 Cornell sent no student representative. Professor William H. Munro, Brown, was elected Chairman, with Harvard alumnus F. W. Moore chosen as secretary
   Google Scholar
• 19 February 1898 . 19 February , 1 Ibid., and newspaper clipping, 19 February 1898, Brown University College Scrapbook, 1897–1904, B.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• “Conference on Intercollegiate Athletics, 1898,” early draft, B.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid. Compare the early draft to the published document
   Google Scholar
• Wilfred Munro , H. April 1898 . April , 5 B.U.A. . (Brown University), Benjamin I. Wheeler (University of California representing Cornell University), James F. Kemp (Columbia University), Louis M. Dennis (Cornell University), Ira N. Hollis (Harvard University), George S. Patterson (University of Pennsylvania), and Henry B. Fine (Princeton University), “Report on Intercollegiate Sports,” ca
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• 9 Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• John Lucas , A. and Ronald Smith , A. 1978 . Saga of American Sport , 197 – 199 . Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger .
   Google Scholar
• Guy Lewis , M. 1967 . “America's First Intercollegiate Sport: Regattas from 1852–1875,” . Research Quarterly , XXXVIII December : 642
   Google Scholar
• Charles Eliot , W. 19 October 1869 . “Inaugural Address,” , 19 October , 22 H.U.A. .
   Google Scholar
• 10 December 1883 . 10 December , 27 H.U.A. . Quoting Yale Professor Thatcher, Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes
   Google Scholar
• Santayana , George . 1894 . “Philosophy on the Bleachers,” . Harvard Monthly , XVIII July : 181 – 190 .
   Google Scholar
• “Conference on Intercollegiate Athletics, 1898,” early draft, B.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• Ronald Smith , A. 1980 . “Winning and a Theory of Competitive Athletics,” . In Sport and the Humanities: A Collection of Original Essays , Edited by: William Morgan , J. 44 – 50 . Knoxville : The Bureau of Education Research, University of Tennessee .
   Google Scholar
• April 1898 . April , 10 – 14 . B.U.A. . “Report on Intercollegiate Sports,” ca.
   Google Scholar
• James Kemp , F. 1901 . “History of Faculty Control at Columbia,” . Columbia University Quarterly , IV December : 39 – 40 . C. W. Eliot, “President Eliot's Report,” Harvard Graduates' Magazine, IX (March 1901), p. 452; and Francis A. March, Jr., Athletics at Lafayette College (Easton, PA: Lafayette College, 1923), p. 152
   Google Scholar
• April 1898 . April , 10 B.U.A. . “Report on Intercollegiate Sports,” ca.
   Google Scholar
• Augustus Hemenway, Robert Bacon, and Theodore Roosevelt (The Committee on Physical Training, Athletic Sports, and Sanitary Condition of Buildings) . 1897 . “Important Suggestions in Athletics,” . Harvard Graduates' Maagazine , VI December : 195 – 196 . Emphasis added
   Google Scholar
• Ira Hollis , N. 19 November 1900 . 19 November , letter to Charles W. Eliot, Eliot Papers, Box 110, Folder 143, “Hollis,” H.U.A.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• George Kirchwey , W. 14 July 1902 . 14 July , letter to President Nicholas Murray Butler, Columbia, “Athletics” Folder, Columbia University Central Files
   Google Scholar
• Whitney , Caspar . 1902 . “The Guiding Hand of Faculty in College Sports,” . Outing , XL July : 497 As quoted in
   Google Scholar
• Lewis , Guy . 1969 . “Theodore Roosevelt's Role in the 1905 Football Controversy,” . Research Quarterly , XL December : 717 – 724 . and Ronald A. Smith, “Harvard and Columbia and a Reconsideration of the 1905–06 Football Crisis,” Journal of Sport History, VIII (Winter 1981), pp. 5–19
   Google Scholar
• 10 January 1906 . 10 January , 548 H.U.A. . As quoted in the Harvard Athletic Committee Minutes
   Google Scholar