261
Views
3
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Bukharin's alternative to Stalin: Industrialisation without forced collectivisation

Pages 97-159 | Published online: 05 Jun 2010

References

  • Ahmed , R. and Bernard , A. Feb. 1989 . Rice Price Fluctuation and an Approach to Price Stabilisation in Bangladesh , Feb. , Washington : Institute of Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) . Research Report No.72,
  • 1981 . Area: Area and Production of Principal Crops in India 1979–80 , New Delhi : Ministry of Agriculture .
  • Arkhipov , V.A. and Morozon , L.A. 1978 . Bor'ba protiv kapitalisticheskikh elementov v promyshlennosti i torgovle: 20e‐nachalo 30kh godov Moscow
  • Babynin , B. 1940 . ‘Trudovye resursy kolkhozov i ikh ispol'zovanie’ . Problemy Ekonomiki ,
  • Ball , A.M. 1987 . Russia's Last Capitalists: The Nepmen, 1921–29 , Berkeley , CA : University of California Press .
  • Barsov , A.A. 1969 . Balans stoimostnykh obmenov mezhdu gorodom i derevnei Moscow
  • Barsov , A.A. 1974 . “ ‘NEP i vyravnivanie ekonomicheskikh otnoshenii mezhdu gorodom i derevnei’ ” . In Novaya ekonomicheskaya politika: voprosy teorii i istorii , Moscow : AN SSSR .
  • Bergson , A. 1961 . The Real National Income of Soviet Russia since 1928 , Cambridge MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Birman , I. 1988 . Ekonomika nedostachii , New York : Chalidze Publications .
  • Broadbridge , S. 1966 . Industrial Dualism in Japan , London : Frank Cass .
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1924 . “ ‘Novoe otkovrenie o sovetskoi ekonomike ili kak mozhno pogubit’ raboche‐krest'yanskii blok,’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1925a . “ ‘O novoi ekonomicheskoi politike i nashikh zadachakh’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1925b . “ ‘Put’ k sotsializmu i raboche‐krest'yanskii soyuz’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1926a . Kritika ekonomicheskoi platformy oppozitsii Leningrad
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1926b . “ ‘Doklad na XXIII chrezvychainoi leningradskoi gubernskoi konferentsii VKP(B)’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1927 . “ ‘Partiya i oppozitsiya na poroge XV parts'ezda’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1928a . “ ‘Uroki khlebozagotovok, shakhtinskogo dela i zadachi partii’ ” . In Izbrannye proizvedeniya: Put'k sotsializmu Novosibirsk 1990
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1928b . “ ‘Zametki ekonomista’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1929a . “ ‘Politicheskoe zaveshchanie Lenina’ ” . Edited by: Bukharin . [1988].
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1929b . “ ‘Vstuplenie na ob'edinennom plenume TsK i TsKK VKP(B): 18 aprelya 1929 g’ ” . In Problemy teorii i praktiki sotsializma Moscow 1991.
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1983 . Transition to Socialism , Edited by: Day , R.B. London : Spokesman .
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1988 . Izbrannye proizvedeniya Moscow
  • Bulletin: Bulletin of Food Statistics , New Delhi : Ministry of Agriculture . various issues.
  • Carr , E.H. 1970 . Socialism in One Country, 1924–1926 , Vol.1 , Harmondsworth : Penguin Books .
  • Carr , E.H. and Davies , R.W. 1974 . Foundations of a Planned Economy, 1926–1929 , Vol.1 , Harmondsworth : Penguin Books .
  • Chandra , N.K. Sept. 1984 . “ ‘Soviet Industrialisation in the 1930s: Some Tentative Notes on Trends in National Income, Wages and Living Standards and on the Initial Conditions’ ” . Sept. , Calcutta : Indian Institute of Management . Working Paper No.86,
  • Chandra , N.K. 1988 . The Retarded Economies: Foreign Domination and Class Relations in India and Other Emerging Nations , Bombay : Sameeksha Trust . Oxford: Oxford University Press
  • Chapman , J.G. 1963 . Real Wages in Soviet Russia since 1928 , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Chayanov , A.V. 1925 . “ ‘Peasant Farm Organisation’ ” . In The Theory of the Peasant Economy , Delhi : Oxford University Press . 1987.
  • Clark , M.G. 1956 . The Economics of Soviet Steel , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Cohen , S.F. 1973 . Bukharin and the Bolshevik Revolution: A Political Biography, 1888–1938 (paperback) , Oxford : Oxford University Press . 1980.
  • Conquest , R. 1968 . The Great Terror: Stalin's Purges of the Thirties , London : Macmillan .
  • Conquest , R. 1978 . The Harvest of Sorrow , London : Arrow Books .
  • Danilov , V.P. 1979 . Sovetskaya dokolkhoznaya derevnya: sotsial'naya struktura, sotsial'nye otnosheniya Moscow
  • Davies , R.W. 1976 . “ ‘The Soviet Economic Crisis of 1931–33’ ” . University of Birmingham . SIPS No.4, CREES,
  • Davies , R.W. 1978 . “ ‘Soviet Industrial Production 1928–1937: The Rival Estimates’ ” . University of Birmingham . SIPS No.18, CREES,
  • Davies , R.W. 1980 . The Socialist Offensive: The Collectivisation of Soviet Agriculture, 1929–30 , London : Macmillan .
  • Davies , R.W. 1984 . ‘The Socialist Market: A Debate on Soviet Industry’ . The Slavic Review , Summer
  • Davies , R.W. 1989 . The Soviet Economy in Turmoil, 1929–30 , London : Macmillan .
  • Davies , R.W. , ed. 1990 . From Tsarism to the NEP: Continuity and Change in the Economy of the USSR , London : Macmillan .
  • Davies , R.W. 1991 . ‘Sovetskaya ekonomika v period krizisa 1930–1933 gody’ . Istoriya SSSR ,
  • Dobb , M.H. 1960 . Soviet Economic Development Since 1917 , 5th ed. , London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
  • Dore , R.P. 1959 . Land Reform in Japan , London : Oxford University Press .
  • ES: Economic Survey , New Delhi : Ministry of Finance . various issues.
  • Ellman , M. 1975 . ‘Did Agricultural Surplus Provide the Resources for the Increase in Investment in the USSR During the First Five Year Plan?’ . The Economic Journal , Dec.
  • Erlich , A. 1959 . The Soviet Industrialisation Debate , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
  • FAO: Production Yearbook , Rome : Food and Agricultural Organisation . various issues.
  • Gosplan . 1930a . Zhivodnovodstvo SSSR Moscow
  • Gosplan . 1930b . Trud v SSSR: Spravochnik 1926–30 Moscow
  • Gosplan . 1930c . Pyatiletnyi plan narodnogo stroitel'stva SSSR Moscow torn 2, chast’ 2,
  • Gosplan . 1933 . Summary of the Fulfilment of the First Five Year Plan for the Development of the National Economy of the USSR Moscow
  • Gosplan . 1939 . Itogi vypolneniya vtorogo pyatiletnogo plana narodnogo khozyaistva SSSR Moscow
  • Granick , D. 1967 . Soviet Metal‐Fabricating and Economic Development: Practice versus Policy , Madison , WI : University of Wisconsin Press .
  • Grosskopf , S. 1976 . L'alliance ouvrière et paysanne en URSS (1921–1928): Le problème du blé , Paris : Maspero .
  • Harrison , M. 1984 . “ ‘Why Was NEP Abandoned?’ ” . Edited by: Stuart , R.C.
  • Harrison , M. 1990 . “ ‘The Peasantry and Industrialisation’ ” . Edited by: Davies .
  • Heitman , S. , ed. 1967 . Bukharin: Put’ k sotsializmu v Rossii , New York : Omicron Books .
  • Hunter , H. 1973 . ‘The Overambitious First Soviet Five‐Year Plan’ . The Slavic Review , Summer
  • Hunter , H. 1988 . ‘Soviet Agriculture with and without Collectivisation’ . The Slavic Review , Summer
  • IFS: International Financial Statistics Yearbook 1989 , Washington : International Monetary Fund .
  • Jasny , N. 1949 . The Socialised Agriculture of the USSR: Plans and Performance , Stanford , CA : Stanford University Press .
  • Jasny , N. 1951 . ‘Labour and Output in Soviet Concentration Camps’ . The Journal of Political Economy , Oct.
  • Johnson , C. 1982 . MITI and the Japanese Miracle: The Growth of Industrial Policy , Stanford , CA : Stanford University Press .
  • Kalecki , M. 1959 . “ ‘Z zagadnień teorii dynamiki gospodarki socjalistycnej’ ” . In Zagadnienia ekonomii politycznej socjalizmu , 2nd ed. Edited by: Lange , O. Warsaw
  • Kats , V. 1932 . Narodnyi dokhod SSSR i ego raspredelenie Moscow
  • Kaufman , A. 1962 . Small‐scale Industry in the Soviet Union , New York : National Bureau of Economic Research .
  • Kheinman , S. 1933 . K voprosu o proizvoditel'nosti truda v SSSR Moscow
  • Komiya , R. 1988 . “ ‘Introduction’ ” . In Industrial Policy of Japan , Edited by: Komiya , R. , Okuna , M. and Suzumra , K. Tokyo : Academic Press .
  • Kornai , J. 1982 . Growth, Shortage and Efficiency: A Macrodynamic Model of the Socialist Economy , Oxford : Basil Blackwell .
  • Krest'yanskie . 1977 . Krest'yanskie khozyaistva, kolkhozy i sovkhozy SSSR v 1924/25–1927/28 gg , Moscow : Institut Istorii, Akademiya Nauk . compiled by V.P. Danilov and T.I. Slavko,
  • Lee , E. 1979 . “ ‘Egalitarian Peasant Farming and Rural Development: The Case of South Korea’ ” . In Agrarian Systems and Rural Development , Edited by: Ghai , D. London : Macmillan .
  • Lee , T.H. , Chen , H.H. and Chen , Y.E. 1980 . “ ‘Labour Absorption in Taiwan Agriculture’ ” . In Labour Absorption in Agriculture: The East Asian Experience , Bangkok : ILO‐ARTEP .
  • Lenin , V.I. Collected Works Vol.3 , Moscow no date.
  • Lewin , M. 1973 . ‘Disappearance of Planning in the Plan’ . The Slavic Review , June
  • Lewin , M. 1974 . Political Undercurrents in the Soviet Debate on Economic Reforms: From Bukharin to Modern Reformers , Princeton , N.J : Princeton University Press .
  • Libkind , A. 1939 . ‘Voprosy ratsional'nogo ispol'zovaniya trudovykh resursov’ . Problemy Ekonomiki ,
  • Lockwood , W.W. 1954 . Economic Development of Japan: Growth and Structural Change 1868–1938 , Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Lorimer , F. 1946 . The Population of the Soviet Union , Geneva : League of Nations .
  • Maimin , A. 1930 . ‘Gorod i derevnya na putyakh k sotsializmu’ . Na Planovom Fronte ,
  • Malafeyev , A.N. 1964 . Istoriya tsenoobrazovaniya v SSSR, 1917–1963 Moscow
  • Materials . 1932 . Materials for a Balance of the Soviet National Economy 1928–1930 , Edited by: Wheatcroft , S.G. and Davies , R.W. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . 1985.
  • Millar , J.R. 1976 . ‘Was Stalin Really Necessary? A Debate on Collectivisation’ . Problems of Communism , Aug. also in Millar [1990].
  • Millar , J.R. 1984 . “ ‘Views on Soviet Collectivisation of Agriculture: The State of the Revisionist Debate’ ” . Edited by: Stuart .
  • Millar , J.R. 1990 . The Soviet Economic Experiment , Urbana , IL : University of Illinois Press .
  • Moorsteen , R. 1962 . Prices and Production of Machinery in the Soviet Union, 1928–1955 , Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Moorsteen , R. and Powell , R.P. 1966 . The Soviet Capital Stock, 1928–1962 , Homewood , IL : Richard D. Irwin .
  • Morishima , M. 1982 . Why Has Japan ‘Succeeded'? Western Technology and Japanese Ethos , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Morrison , D.J. 1989 . ‘The Soviet Peasantry's Real Expenditure in Socialised Trade, 1928–1934’ . Soviet Studies , April
  • Narkhoz: Narodnoe khozyaistvo SSSR, Moscow, various issues.
  • Nove , A. 1962 . ‘Was Stalin Really Necessary?’ . Encounter , April reprinted in his Was
  • 1964 . Stalin Really Necesary? Some Problems in Soviet Political Economy , London : G. Allen & Unwin .
  • Nove , A. 1972 . An Economic History of the USSR , Harmondsworth : Penguin Books .
  • Nove , A. 1976 . ‘The “Logic” and Cost of Collectivisation’ . Problems of Communism , Aug. also in Millar [1990].
  • Nove , A. 1989 . Stalinism and After: The Road to Gorbachev , 3rd ed. , London : Unwin & Hyman .
  • Ohkawa , K. and Rosovsky , H. 1973 . Economic Growth: Trend Acceleration in the Twentieth Century , Standford , CA : Stanford University Press .
  • Pinckney , T.C. Dec. 1989 . The Demand for Public Storage of Foodgrains in Pakistan , Dec. , Washington : International Food Policy Research Institute . Report No.77,
  • Pollyak , G. 1931 . ‘K voprosu ob urovne zhizni rabochego klassa SSSR’ . Planovoe Khozyaistvo ,
  • Polyakov , Yu. A. , Zhiromskaya , V.B. and Kiselev , I.N. 1990a . ‘Polveka molchaniya [vsesoyuznaya perepis'naseleniy 1937g.]’ . Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya ,
  • Polyakov , Yu. A. , Zhiromskaya , V.B. and Kiselev , I.N. 1990b . ‘Polveka molchaniya [vsesoyuznaya perepis'naseleniya 1937g.]’ . Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya ,
  • Preobrazhensky , E. 1965 . The New Economics , Oxford : Clarendon Press .
  • Reddy , V.N. Dec. 1987 . “ ‘On Estimating Gompertz Curve’ ” . Dec. , Calcutta : Indian Institute of Management . Working Paper No.105,
  • Sivasubramonian , S. 1965 . “ ‘National Income of India: 1900–01 to 1946–47’ ” . University of Delhi . unpublished Ph.D. dissertation,
  • Stalin , J.V. 1954 . Works Vol.11 , Moscow
  • Stalin , J.V. 1976 . Problems of Leninism Peking
  • Stuart , R.C. 1984 . The Soviet Rural Economy , Totowa , NJ : Rowman & Allanheld .
  • Swianiewicz , S. 1965 . Forced Labour and Economic Development , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Tomskii , M. , Bukharin , N. and Rykov , A. 1929 . “'Schitaem svoim politicheskim dolgom”: Zayavlenie N.I. Bukharina, A.I. Rykova i M.P. Tomskogo na Plenume TsK VKP(B) 12 noyabrya 1929 g’ . Sovetskaya Rossiya , 10 Feb. 1989.
  • TsSU . 1929a . Sel'skoe khozyaistvo SSSR 1925–1928 Moscow
  • TsSU . 1929b . Byudzhet rabochikh i sluzhashchikh Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1932a . Sotsialisticheskoe pereustroistvo sel'skogo khozyaistva SSSR mezhdu XV i XVI s'ezdami VKP (B) , 2nd ed. Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1932b . Trud v SSSR: ekonomiko‐statisticheskii spravochnik Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1935 . Sotsialisticheskoe stroitel'stvo SSSR Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1936a . Kolkhoznaya i individual'no‐krest'yanskaya torgovlya Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1936b . SSSR: Strana sotsializma Moscow
  • TsUNKhU . 1936c . Trud v SSSR: statisticheskii spravochnik Moscow
  • Vainshtein , A.L. 1969 . Narodnyi dokhod Rossii i SSSR Moscow
  • 1960 . Vneshtorg: Vneshnyaya torgovlya SSSR za 1918–1940 gg.: statisticheskii obzor Moscow
  • Vyas , A. 1978 . Consumption in a Socialist Economy: The Soviet Industrialisation Experience, 1929–37 , New Delhi : People's Publishing House .
  • Wheatcroft , S.G. , Davies , R.W. and Cooper , J.M. 1986 . ‘Soviet Industrialisation Reconsidered: Some Preliminary Conclusions about Economic Development between 1926 and 1941’ . Economic History Review , May
  • Yasuba , Y. 1976 . “ ‘The Evolution of Dualistic Wage Structure’ ” . In Japanese Industrialisation and Its Social Consequences , Edited by: Patrick , H. Berkeley , CA : University of California Press .
  • Zaleski , E. 1962 . Planification de la croissance et fluctuations économiques en URSS, tome 1, 1918–1932 , Paris : SEDES .
  • Zemskov , V.N. 1990–91 . Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya 1990/11, 1991/1–2.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.