A COMPARISON OF THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS WITH MULTIATTRIBUTE UTILITY THEORY: A CASE STUDY

REFERENCES

• Arbel , A. , and Seidmann , A. , “ Selecting a Microcomputer for Process Control and Data Acquisition ,” Iie Transactions . 16 ( 1 ) 73 – 80 ( 1984 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Aczel , J. , and Alsina , C. , “ Synthesizing Judgements A Functional Equation Approach ,” Mathematical Modelling , 9 311 – 320 ( 1987 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bard , J. F. , “ Evaluating Space Station Applications of Automation and Robotics ,” IEEE Trans. Engineering Management , EM-33 ( 2 ) 102 – 111 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bard , J. F. , and Feinberg , A. , “ A Two-Phase Methodology for Technology Selection and System Design ,” IEEE Trans. Engineering Management , EM-36 ( 1 ) 28 – 36 ( 1989 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bard , J. F. , and Sousk , S. F. , “ A Tradeoff Analysis for Rough Terrain Cargo Handlers Using the AHP An Example of Group Decision Making ,” IEEE Trans. Engineering Management , EM-37 ( 3 ) 222 – 228 ( 1990 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Belton , V. , “ A Comparison of the Analytic Hierarchy Process and a Simple Multi-Attribute Value function ,” European Journal of Operational Research , 26 7 – 21 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Belton , V. , and Gear , T. , “ On a Shortcoming of Saaty's Method of Analytic Hierarchies ,” OMEGA , 11 228 – 230 ( 1984 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Belvoir RD&E Center , Test and Evaluation Master Plan for the Variable Reach Rough Terrain Forklifi . U.S. Army Troop Support Command , Logistics Equipment Directorate , Fort Belvoir , VA ( 1987 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Dyer , J. S. , and Miles , R. F. , Jr. , “ An Actual Application of Collective Choice Theory to the Selection of Trajectories for the Mariner Jupiter/Saturn 1977 Project ,” Operations Research . 24 220 – 244 ( 1976 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hobbs , B. F. , “ A Comparison of Weighting Methods in Power Plant Siting ,” Decision Science , 11 ( 4 ) 725 – 737 ( 1980 ).
   Google Scholar
• Iyer , R. , “ Universal Self Deployable Cargo Handler System Integration Plan ,” Technical Report E-3212, prepared for die US Army Belvoir RD&E Center by FMC Corp. , Minneapolis . MN ( March 18 , 1988 ).
   Google Scholar
• KamenentzKy , R. D. , “ The Relationship between the AHP and the Additive Value function ,” Decision Science , 13 702 – 713 ( 1982 ).
   Google Scholar
• Keeney , R. L. , and Raiffa , H. , Decisions with Multiple Objectives Preference and Value Tradeoffs , John Wiley & Sons , NY ( 1976 ) .
   Google Scholar
• McCord , M. , de Neufville , R. , “ Utility Dependence on Probability An Empirical Demonstration ,” Journal of Large Scale Systems , 6 91 – 103 ( 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Mehrez , A. , and Sinuary-Stern , Z. , “ Resource Allocation to the Interrelated Risky Projects Using Multiattribute Utility function ,” Management Science . 29 ( 4 ) 430 – 439 ( 1983 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• NASA , “ Advancing Automation and Robotics Technology for the Space Station and the U.S. Economy ,” TM-87566, Advanced Technology Advisory Committee (ATAQ, Artificial Intelligence Office , Johnson Space Center , Houston , TX ( March 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Saaty , T. L. , The Analytic Hierarchy Process , McGraw-Hill , NY ( 1980 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Saaty , T. L. , “ Axiomatic Foundations of the Analytic Hierarchy Process ,” Management Science , 32 841 – 855 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Shaw , M. E. , Group Dynamics The Psychology of Small Croup behavior , Third Edition , McGraw-Hill , NY ( 1981 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Shoemaker , P. J. H. , and Waid , C. C. , “ An Experimental Comparison of Different Approaches to Determining Weights in Additive Utility Models ,” Management Science , 28 182 – 196 ( 1982 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Smith , J. H. , Feinberg , A. , and Lee , T. , Smart Edgent A Decision Support System for Expert Knowledge Acquisition and Evaluation , Haviland-Lee, Inc. , Northridge , CA ( 1987 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Souder , W. E. , and Mandakovic , T. , “ R&D Project Selection Models ,” Research Management , 29 ( 4 ) 36 – 42 ( July-Aug. 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sousk , S. F. , Keller , H. L. , and Locke , M. C. , “ Science and Technology for Cargo Handling in the Unstructured Field Environment ,” US Army Belvoir RD&E Center , Logistics Equipment Directorate , Fort Belvoir , VA ( 1988 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Handled by the Department of Management. This work was conducted while die author was an ASEE-U.S. Army Summer Faculty Fellow.
   Google Scholar