Rivers as living beings: rights in law, but no rights to water?

Primary legal sources

Cases

• Centro de Estudios para la Justicia Social ‘Tierra Digna’ and Others v the President of the Republic and Others [2016] Corte Constituciónal [Constitutional Court], Sala Sexta de Revision [Sixth Chamber] (Colombia) No T-622 of 2016 (10 November 2016), translations as per Macpherson and Clavijo Ospina (2018).
   Google Scholar
• Drewes Farm Partnership v. City of Toledo Ohio 441 F. Supp. 3d 551 (N.D. Ohio 2020).
   Google Scholar
• Human Rights and Peace for Bangladesh v Government of Bangladesh and others [2016] HCD (Writ Petition No. 13989 of 2016, judgement declared on 3 February 2019; translations from Bangla as per Islam and O’Donnell (2020).
   Google Scholar
• Lalit Miglani v State of Uttarakhand & others, WPPIL 140/2015 (High Court of Uttarakhand) 2017 (India).
   Google Scholar
• Mohd. Salim v State of Uttarakhand & others WPPIL 126/2014 (High Court of Uttarakhand) 2017 (India).
   Google Scholar
• Nishat Jute Mills Limited v Human Rights and Peace for Bangladesh (HRPB) and others [2019] Appellate Division (Civil Petition No. 3039 of 2019) judgment declared on 17 February 2020.
   Google Scholar
• Sierra Club v. Morton, 405 U.S. 727, 743 (1972).
   Google Scholar
• State of Uttarakhand & others v Mohd Salim & others, Petition for Special Leave to Appeal 016879/2017 (Supreme Court of India) 7 July 2017.
   Google Scholar
• Wheeler v Director de la Procuraduria General Del Estado de Loja, Juicio No. 11121-2011-0010, translations from Spanish as per Daly (2012).
   Google Scholar

Legislation

• Constitution of the Republic of Ecuador 2008 (Ecuador).
   Google Scholar
• Endangered Species Act 1973 (USA), 16 U.S.C. ch. 35 § 1531 et seq.
   Google Scholar
• Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth).
   Google Scholar
• Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 (WA).
   Google Scholar
• Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River Claims Settlement) Act 2017 (New Zealand).
   Google Scholar
• Toledo Municipal Code, Charter of the City of Toledo, Ohio, Chapter XVII, ‘Lake Erie Bill of Rights’.
   Google Scholar
• Water Act 1989 (Vic).
   Google Scholar
• Water Law, 5719-1959, § 6 (1959-1960) (as amended) (Isr.).
   Google Scholar
• Yarra River Protection (Wilip-gin Birrarung Murron) Act 2017 (Vic).
   Google Scholar

International Agreements

• Garma International Indigenous Water Declaration (2008), https://www.afn.ca/uploads/files/env/garma-international.pdf
   Google Scholar
• Brisbane Declaration, Environmental Flows are Essential for Freshwater Ecosystem Health and Human Well-Being (10th International River Symposium and International Environmental Flows Conference, 3–6 September 2007, Brisbane, Australia, 2007)
   Google Scholar

Secondary sources

• Rachelle Adam (2019) ‘The Saga of Jerusalem’s Ein Lavan Spring: How the Human Right to Development Trumps the Rights of Nature’ 20 Vermont Journal of Environmental Law 290–304.
   Google Scholar
• Afshin Akhtar-Khavari (2020) ‘Restoration and Cooperation for Flourishing Socio-Ecological Landscapes’ 11 Transnational Legal Theory 62–74.
   Google Scholar
• Anna Arstein-Kerslake (2017) Restoring Voice to People with Cognitive Disabilities: Realizing the Right to Equal Representation Before the Law, Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Angela H Arthington (2012) Environmental Flows: Saving Rivers in the Third Millennium, University of California Press.
   Google Scholar
• Angela H Arthington, Anik Bhaduri, Stuart E Bunn, Sue E Jackson, Rebecca E Tharme, Dave Tickner, Bill Young, et al. (2018) ‘The Brisbane Declaration and Global Action Agenda on Environmental Flows’ 6 Frontiers in Environmental Science.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosalind H Bark, Catherine J Robinson, and Karl W Flessa (2016) ‘Tracking Cultural Ecosystem Services: Water Chasing the Colorado River Restoration Pulse Flow’ 127 Ecological Economics, 165–72.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Thomas Berry (1999) The Great Work: Our Way Into the Future. Harmony/Bell Tower.
   Google Scholar
• David R Boyd (2017) The Rights of Nature: A Legal Revolution That Could Save the World, ECW Press.
   Google Scholar
• ES Brondizio, J Settele, S Díaz, and HT Ngo (eds) (2019) Global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (DRAFT), IPBES Secretariat.
   Google Scholar
• Rina Chandran (2019) ‘Fears of evictions as Bangladesh gives rivers legal rights’, Reuters Asia, 5 July 2019.
   Google Scholar
• NT Chowdhury (2010) ‘Water management in Bangladesh: an analytical review’ 12 Water Policy 32–51.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• C Clark, N Emmanouil, J Page, and A Pelizzon (2018) ‘Can You Hear the Rivers Sing? Legal Personhood, Ontology, and the Nitty-Gritty of Governance’ 45 Ecology Law Quarterly 787–844.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Alice Cohen (2015) ‘Water as a Governance Opportunity’ in Seanna L Davidson, Jamie Linton and Warren E Mabee (eds) Water as a Social Opportunity, McGill-Queen's University Press.
   Google Scholar
• J Connor, C Regan and T Nicol (2019) ‘Environmental, Cultural and Social Capital as a Core Asset for the Martuwarra (Fitzroy River) and Its People.’ Alice Springs: Ninti One; UniSA.
   Google Scholar
• Erin Daly (2012) ‘The Ecuadorian Exemplar: The First Ever Vindication of Constitutional Rights of Nature’ 21 Review of European Community and International Environmental Law 63–66.
   Google Scholar
• GT Davies, CM Finlayson, DE Pritchard, NC Davidson, RC Gardner, WR Moomaw, E Okuno, JC Whitacre (2020). Towards a Universal Declaration of the Rights of Wetlands. Marine and Freshwater Research (in press). doi:10.1071/MF20219.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nopera Dennis-McCarthy (2019) ‘Incorporating Indigenous Worldviews on the Environment into Non-Indigenous Legal Systems: Has the Te Awa Tupua Act Led to Reconciliation and Self-Determination?’, Maori Law Review, (online): http://maorilawreview.co.nz/2019/02/incorporating-indigenous-worldviews-on-the-environment-into-non-indigenous-legal-systems-has-the-te-awa-tupua-act-led-to-reconciliation-and-self-determination/.
   Google Scholar
• Álvaro Fernández-Llamazares, Julien Terraube, Michael C Gavin, Aili Pyhälä, Sacha MO Siani, Mar Cabeza, and Eduardo S Brondizio (2020). ‘Reframing the Wilderness Concept Can Bolster Collaborative Conservation’ 35 Trends in Ecology & Evolution 750–53.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Martina Flörke, Christof Schneider and Robert I McDonald (2018) ‘Water Competition between Cities and Agriculture Driven by Climate Change and Urban Growth’ 1 Nature Sustainability 51–58.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Robert A Francis, Simon P G Hoggart, Angela M Gurnell, and Chris Coode (2008) ‘Meeting the Challenges of Urban River Habitat Restoration: Developing a Methodology for the River Thames through Central London’ 40 Area 435–45.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dustin E Garrick, Jim W Hall, Andrew Dobson, Richard Damania, R Quentin Grafton, Cameron Hepburn, Robert Hope, et al. (2017) ‘Valuing Water for Sustainable Development’, 358 Science 1003–05.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lee Godden (1998) ‘Preserving Natural Heritage: Nature as Other’ 22 Melbourne University Law Review 719–42.
   Google Scholar
• Tom B K Goldtooth (2015) ‘Indigenous Peoples Cosmovision, Conflicts of Conquest and Need For Humanity to Come Back to Mother Earth’ in Shannon Biggs, Osprey Orielle Lake and Tom BK Goldtooth (eds), Rights of Nature & Mother Earth: Rights-based law for Systemic Change (Indigenous Environmental Network: online).
   Google Scholar
• Andrew Harwood, Susan Johnson, Brian Richter, Allan Locke, Xuezhong Yu, and David Tickner (2017) Listen to the River: Lessons from a Global Review of Environmental Flow Success Stories, WWF-UK.
   Google Scholar
• Avril C Horne, Erin L O'Donnell and Rebecca E Tharme (2017) ‘Mechanisms for Allocating Environmental Water’ in Avril Horne, Michael Stewardson, Angus Webb, Mike Acreman and Brian Richter (eds) Water for the Environment: From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Academic Press.
   Google Scholar
• Mohammad Sohidul Islam and Erin O'Donnell (2020) ‘Legal Rights for the Turag: Rivers as Living Entities in Bangladesh’ 23 Asia Pacific Journal of Environmental Law 160–77.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Joshua Jowitt (2020) ‘Legal Rights for Animals: Aspiration or Logical Necessity?’ 11(2) Journal of Human Rights and the Environment 173–198
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Craig M Kauffman and Pamela L Martin (2019) ‘How Courts Are Developing River Rights Jurisprudence: Comparing Guardianship in New Zealand, Colombia, and India’ 20 Vermont Journal of Environmental Law 260–89.
   Google Scholar
• Eloise Kendy, Karl W Flessa, Karen J Schlatter, Carlos A de la Parra, Osvel M Hinojosa Huerta, Yamilett K Carrillo-Guerrero, and Enrique Guillen (2017) ‘Leveraging Environmental Flows to reform Water Management Policy: Lessons Learned from the 2014 Colorado River Delta Pulse Flow’ 106 Ecological Engineering 683–94.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Louis Kotzé (2014) ‘Rethinking Global Environmental Law and Governance in the Anthropocene’ 32 Journal of Energy and Natural Resources Law 121–56.
   Google Scholar
• Visa A J Kurki (2019) A Theory of Legal Personhood, Oxford University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Tom Le Quesne, Eloise Kendy and Derek Weston (2010) The Implementation Challenge: Taking Stock of Government Policies to Protect and Restore Environmental Flows, World Wildlife Fund UK.
   Google Scholar
• C Levis, FRC Costa, F Bongers, M Peña-Claros, CR Clement, AB Junqueira, EG Neves, et al. (2017) ‘Persistent Effects of Pre-Columbian Plant Domestication on Amazonian Forest Composition’ 355 Science 925–31.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Michelle Lim, Anne Poelina, and Donna Bagnall (2017) ‘Can the Fitzroy River Realisation of the First Declaration Ensure the Laws of the River and Secure Sustainable and Equitable Futures for the West Kimberley?’ 32 Australian Environment Review 18–24.
   Google Scholar
• Susanna Lindroos-Hovinheimo (2017) 'Private Selves – An Analysis of Legal Individualism' in Visa A.J. Kurki and Tomasz Pietrzykowski (eds.), Legal Personhood: Animals, Artificial Intelligence and the Unborn, Springer.
   Google Scholar
• Chicu Lokgariwar, Ravi Chopra, Vladimir Smakhtin, Luna Bharati, and Jay O’Keeffe (2014) ‘Including Cultural Water Requirements in Environmental Flow Assessment: An Example from the Upper Ganga River, India’ 39 Water International 81–96.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• EJ Macpherson (2019) Indigenous Water Rights in Law and Regulation: Lessons from Comparative Experience, Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Elizabeth Macpherson and Felipe Clavijo Ospina (2018) ‘The Pluralism of River Rights in Aotearoa New Zealand and Colombia’ 25 Journal of Water Law 283–93.
   Google Scholar
• Elizabeth Macpherson, Julia Torres Ventura, and Felipe Clavijo Ospina (2020) ‘Constitutional Law, Ecosystems and Indigenous Peoples in Colombia: Biocultural Rights and Legal Subjects’ 9 Transnational Environmental Law 521–40.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Virginia Marshall (2020) ‘Removing the Veil from the ‘Rights of Nature’: The Dichotomy between First Nations Customary Rights and Environmental Legal Personhood’, Australian Feminist Law Journal (online). doi:10.1080/13200968.2019.1802154.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bill McKibben (1989) The End of Nature, Random House.
   Google Scholar
• Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (2005) Ecosystems and Human Well-Being: Wetlands and Water Synthesis, World Resources Institute.
   Google Scholar
• Hafsa Ahmed Munia, JHA Guillaume, Yoshihide Wada, Ted Veldkamp, Vili Virkki, and Matti Kummu (2020) ‘Future Transboundary Water Stress and Its Drivers under Climate Change: A Global Study’ 8 Earth's Future (online) e2019EF001321.
   Google Scholar
• Ngaire Naffine (2009) Law's Meaning of Life: Philosophy, Religion, Darwin and the Legal Person, Hart Publishing.
   Google Scholar
• Ngaire Naffine (2017) ‘Legal Persons as Abstractions: The Extrapolation of Persons from the Male Case’ in Visa AJ Kurki and Tomasz Pietrzykowski (eds) Legal Personhood: Animals, Artificial Intelligence and the Unborn, Springer, E-book, pp. 15–28.
   Google Scholar
• Richard H Norris and Martin C Thoms (1999) ‘What Is River Health?’, Freshwater Biology, 41: 197–209.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Thomas S O'Connor (1994) ‘We Are Part of Nature: Indigenous Peoples’ Rights as a Basis for Environmental Protection in the Amazon Basin’ 5 Colorado Journal of International Environmental Law and Policy 193–212.
   Google Scholar
• Erin O'Donnell (2018a) Legal Rights for Rivers: Competition, Collaboration and Water Governance, Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Erin O'Donnell (2018b) ‘At the Intersection of the Sacred and the Legal: Rights for Nature in Uttarakhand, India’ 30 Journal of Environmental Law 135–44.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• E O'Donnell, A Poelina, A Pelizzon, and C Clark (2020) ‘Stop Burying the Lede: The Essential Role of Indigenous Law(s) in Creating Rights for Nature’, Transnational Environmental Law, forthcoming.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Erin L O'Donnell and Dustin E Garrick (2017) ‘Environmental Water Organizations and Institutional Settings.’ in Avril Horne, Angus Webb, Michael Stewardson, Brian Richter and Mike Acreman (eds), Water for the Environment: From policy and science to implementation and management, Academic Press, 421–452.
   Google Scholar
• Erin O'Donnell and Julia Talbot-Jones (2018) ‘Creating Legal Rights for Rivers: Lessons from Australia, New Zealand, and India’ 23 Ecology and Society 7.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lisa Palmer (2006) ‘‘Nature’, Place and the Recognition of Indigenous Polities’ 37 Australian Geographer 33–43.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pooja Parmar (2015) Indigeneity and Legal Pluralism in India: Claims, Histories, Meanings, Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Bruce Pascoe (2018) Dark Emu, Magabala Books.
   Google Scholar
• Alessandro Pelizzon (2014) ‘Earth Laws, Rights of Nature and Legal Pluralism’ in Michelle Maloney and Peter Burdon (eds) Wild Law - In Practice, Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Zygmunt JB Plater (1994) ‘From the Beginning, a Fundamental Shift of Paradigms: A Theory and Short History of Environmental Law’ 27 Loyola of Los Angeles Law Revew 981–1008.
   Google Scholar
• Anne Poelina, Kathrine S Taylor, and Ian Perdrisat (2019) ‘Martuwarra Fitzroy River Council: An Indigenous Cultural Approach to Collaborative Water Governance’ 26 Australasian Journal of Environmental Management 236–54.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• N LeRoy Poff, J David Allan, Mark B Bain, James R Karr, Karen L Prestegaard, Brian D Richter, Richard E Sparks, and Julie C Stromberg (1997) ‘The Natural Flow Regime’ 47 BioScience 769–84.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• J Rockström, W Steffen, K Noone, Å Persson, FS Chapin III, E Lambin, TM Lenton, et al. (2009) ‘Planetary Boundaries: Exploring the Safe Operating Space for Humanity’ 14 Ecology and Society (online) 1–33.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Holmes Rolston III (1993) ‘Rights and Responsibilities on the Home Planet’ 18 Yale Journal of International Law 251.
   Google Scholar
• Jacinta Ruru (2019) ‘Who are your waters?’, E-Flux Architecture Liquid Utility, Accessed 19 July 2019 <https://www.e-flux.com/architecture/liquid-utility/259674/who-are-your-waters/>.
   Google Scholar
• Anne Salmond (2014) ‘Tears of Rangi: Water, Power, and People in New Zealand’ 4 HAU Journal of Ethnographic Theory 285–309.
   Google Scholar
• Margaret Shanafield, Sarah Godsey, Thibault Datry, Rebecca Hale, Samuel C Zipper, Katie Costigan, Corey A Krabbenhoft, et al. (2020) ‘Science Gets Up to Speed on Dry Rivers’ 101 Eos.
   Google Scholar
• Linda Sheehan (2019) ‘Implementing Nature’s Rights through Regulatory Standards’ 20 Vermont Journal of Environmental Law 227–42.
   Google Scholar
• Will Steffen (2015) Thirsty Country: Climate Change and Drought in Australia. Climate Council of Australia.
   Google Scholar
• Christopher D Stone (1972) ‘Should Trees Have Standing? Towards Legal Rights for Natural Objects’ 45 Southern California Law Review 450–501.
   Google Scholar
• David Takacs (2020) ‘We Are the River’, University of Illinois Law Review, forthcoming.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Julia Talbot-Jones (2017) ‘The Institutional Economics of Granting a River Legal Standing’, Australian National University.
   Google Scholar
• Mihnea Tănăsescu, (2020) ‘Rights of Nature, Legal Personality, and Indigenous Philosophies’ 9(3) Transnational Environmental Law 429–453.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Linda Te Aho (2009) ‘Indigenous Challenges to Enhance Freshwater Governance and Management in Aotearoa New Zealand - the Waikato River Settlement’ 20 Journal of Water Law 285–92.
   Google Scholar
• Laurence H Tribe (1974) ‘Ways Not to Think About Plastic Trees: New Foundations for Environmental Law’ 83 Yale Law Journal 1315–46.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• United Nations Secretary-General (2019) Harmony With Nature. Seventy-Fourth Session General Assembly, Item 19(i) of the Provisional Agenda, ‘Sustainable Development.’ (26 July 2019), A/74/236.
   Google Scholar
• CJ Vörösmarty, PB McIntyre, MO Gessner, D Dudgeon, A Prusevich, P Green, S Glidden, et al. (2010) ‘Global Threats to Human Water Security and River Biodiversity’ 467 Nature 555–61.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Yoshihide Wada and Marc FP Bierkens (2014) ‘Sustainability of Global Water Use: Past Reconstruction and Future Projections’ 9 Environmental Research Letters 104003.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Waitangi Tribunal (2015) He Whiritaunoka: The Whanganui Land Report (Wai 903), Waitangi Tribunal.
   Google Scholar
• Irene Watson (2018) ‘Aboriginal Relationships to the Natural World: Colonial ‘Protection’ of Human Rights and the Environment’ 9 Journal of Human Rights and the Environment 119–40.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mary Elizabeth Whittemore (2011) ‘The Problem of Enforcing Nature's Rights under Ecuador's Constitution: Why the 2008 Environmental Amendments Have No Bite’ 20 Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 659–91.
   Google Scholar
• World Economic Forum (2020) The Global Risks Report 2020 (World Economic Forum: Geneva) <http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Global_Risk_Report_2020.pdf>.
   Google Scholar
• Susanne Wuijts, Jappe Beekman, Bas van der Wal, Cathy Suykens, Peter PJ Driessen, and Helena FMW Van Rijswick (2019) ‘An Ecological Perspective on a River’s Rights: A Recipe for More Effective Water Quality Governance?’ 44 Water International 647–66.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar