Advanced search
Publication Cover
Central States Speech Journal Volume 30, 1979 - Issue 1
Journal homepage
36
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Criticism of communication theory and research: A critical celebration

David R. Seibold Assistant Professor in the Department of Speech Communication, University of Illinois, Urbana, 61801
Pages 25-39 | Published online: 22 May 2009

  • Black , Edwin . 1965 . Rhetorical Criticism: A Study in Method , New York : Macmillan .
  • Rosenfield , Lawrence W. 1968 . “The Anatomy of Critical Discourse,” . Speech Monographs , 25 : 50 – 59 .
  • Scott , Robert L. 1973 . “On Not Defining Rhetoric,” . Philosophy if Rhetoric , 6 : 81 – 96 .
  • Hill‐bruner , Anthony . 1960 . “Creativity and Contemporary Criticism,” . Western Speech , 24 : 5 – 12 .
  • Windt , Theodore Otto Jr. 1972 . “The Diatribe: Last Resort for Protest,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 58 : 1 – 14 .
  • Rosenthal , Paul I. 1972 . “The Concept of the Paramessage in Persuasive Communication,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 58 : 15 – 30 .
  • Campbell , Karlyn Kohrs . 1974 . “Carroll C. Arnold: Two Views of Criticism,” . Today's Speech , 22 : 39 – 41 .
  • Jamieson , Kathleen . 1976 . “The Rhetorical Manifestations of Weltanschauung,” . Central States Speech Journal , 27 : 4 – 14 .
  • Chesebro , James W. and Hamsher , Caroline D. 1973 . “Rhetorical Criticism: A Message‐Centered Procedure,” . Speech Teacher , 22 : 282 – 290 .
  • Griffin , Leland M. 1964 . “The Rhetorical Structure of the ‘New Left’ Movement: Part I,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 50 : 113 – 135 .
  • Simons , Herbert W. 1970 . “Requirements, Problems, and Strategies: A Theory of Persuasion for Social Movements,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 56 : 1 – 11 .
  • Cathcart , Robert S. 1972 . “New Approaches to the Study of Movements: Defining Movements Rhetorically,” . Western Speech , 36 : 82 – 88 .
  • Seibold , David . 1973 . “Jewish Defense League: The Rhetoric of Resistance,” . Today's Speech , 21 : 39 – 48 .
  • Fisher , Jeanne Y. 1974 . “A Burkean Analysis of the Rhetorical Dimensions of a Multiple Murder and Sucide,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 60 : 175 – 189 .
  • Burgess , Parke C. “Murder Will Out‐But As Rhetoric?” . 225 – 231 .
  • Fisher . “Rhetoric as More than Just a Well Man Speaking: A Rejoinder,” . 231 – 234 .
  • Nichols , Marie Hochmuth . 1963 . Rhetoric and Criticism , Baton Rouge : Louisiana State University Press .
  • Scott , Robert L. and Brock , Bernard L. 1972 . Methods of Rhetorical Criticism: A Twentieth Century Perspective , vii New York : Harper & Row .
  • Bryant , Donald C. 1973 . Rhetorical Dimensions in Criticism , Baton Rouge : Louisiana State University Press .
  • Chesebro , James W. and Hamsher , Caroline D. 1975 . “Contemporary Rhetorical Theory and Criticism: Dimensions of the New Rhetoric,” . Speech Monographs , 42 : 312
  • Hillbruner , Anthony . 1975 . “The Moral Imperative of Criticism,” . Southern Speech Communication Journal , 10 : 228
  • Swanson , David L. 1977 . “A Reflective View of the Epistemology of Critical Inquiry,” . Communication Monographs , 44 : 219
  • Bowers , John Waite . 1968 . “The Pre‐Scientific Function of Rhetorical Criticism” . In Essays on Rhetorical Criticism , Edited by: Nilsen , Thomas R. 126 – 145 . New York : Random House .
  • Hart , Roderick P. 1976 . “Theory‐Building and Rhetorical Criticism: An Informal Statement of Opinion,” . Central States Speech Journal , 27 : 70 – 77 .
  • Wander , Philip and Jenkins , Steven . 1972 . “Rhetoric, Society, and the Critical Response,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 58 : 441 – 450 .
  • Arnold , Carroll C. 1974 . Criticism of Oral Rhetoric , Columbus, Ohio : Charles E. Merrill .
  • Walter , Otis M. “On the Varieties of Rhetorical Criticism,” . In Essays on Rhetorical Criticism Edited by: Nilsen . 168
  • Thons‐sen , Lester , Baird , A. Craig and Braden , Waldo W. 1970 . Speech Criticism, , 2nd Ed. , 23 New York : Ronald Press .
  • 1975 . “A Synoptic View of Systems of Western Rhetoric,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 61 : 440
  • 1977 . “Communication as an Intentional, Social System,” . Human Communication Research , 3 : 258 – 268 .
  • 1972 . “Rhetorical and Communication Studies: Two Worlds or One?” . Western Speech , 36 : 75 – 81 .
  • Deetz , Stanley . 1973 . “An Understanding of Science and a Hermeneutic Science of Understanding,” . Journal of Communication , 23 : 139 – 157 .
  • Williams , Kenneth R. 1973 . “Reflections on a Human Science of Communication,” . Journal of Communication , 23 : 239 – 250 .
  • Williams , Raymond . 1974 . “Communications as Cultural Science,” . Journal of Communication , 24 ( 3 ) : 17 – 25 .
  • Campbell , Paul Newell . 1975 . “The Personae of Scientific Discourse,” . Quarerly Journal of Speech , 61 : 391 – 405 .
  • O'Keefe , Daniel J. 1975 . “Logical Empiricism and the Study of Human Communication,” . Speech Monographs , 42 : 169 – 183 .
  • Wander , Philip C. 1976 . “The Rhetoric of Science,” . Western Speech , 40 : 226 – 235 .
  • Barnland , Dean C. 1962 . “Toward a Meaning‐Centered Philosophy of Communication,” . JoC , 12 : 197 – 211 .
  • Miller , Gerald R. 1966 . “On Defining Communication: Another Stab,” . JoC , 16 : 88 – 98 .
  • Gerbner , George . 1966 . “On Defining Communication: Still Another View,” . JoC , 16 : 99 – 103 .
  • Dance , Frank E. K. 1970 . “The Concept of Communication,” . JoC , 20 : 201 – 210 .
  • Miller , Gerald R. 1976 . “The Goals of the Association: Three Views,” . Annual Convention of the Speech Communication Association . December 1976 , San Francisco. Untitled Paper Presented at Program on
  • Merton , Robert K. 1968 . “Science and Democratic Social Structure,” . In Social Theory and Social Structure, , 1968 Enlarged Edition , Edited by: Merton , Robert K. 605 New York : The Free Press .
  • Storer , Norman W. 1966 . The Social System of Science , 4 New York : Holt, Rinehart and Winston .
  • Ben‐David , Joseph . 1971 . The Scientist's Role in Society , 3 – 4 . Englewood Cliffs, N.J. : Prentice Hall .
  • Storer . The Social System of Science 6
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure , 591 – 627 .
  • Barber , Bernard . 1952 . Science and the Social Order , New York : The Free Press .
  • Shils , Edward . 1972 . “Scientific Community: Thoughts After Hamburg,” . In The Intellectuals and the Powers, Selected Papers , Edited by: Edward Shils . Vol. 1 , 204 – 212 . Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Kuhn , Thomas S. 1962 . The Structure of Scientific Revolutions , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Kaplan , Norman . 1964 . “The Sociology of Science,” . In Handbook of Modern Sociology , Edited by: Faris , Robert E. Chicago : Rand McNally .
  • Barber , Bernard and Hirch , Walter , eds. 1962 . The Sociology of Science , New York : The Free Press .
  • Hagstrom , Warren O. 1965 . The Scientific Community , New York : Basic Books .
  • Merton , Robert K. , ed. 1973 . The Sociology of Science: Theoretical and Empirical Investigations , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Cole , Jonathan and Cole , Stephen . 1973 . Social Stratification in Science , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Zuckerman , Harriet A. 1968 . “Patterns of Name Ordering Among Authors of Scientific Papers: A Study of Symbolism and Its Ambiquity,” . American Journal of Sociology , 74 : 276 – 291 .
  • Crane , Diana . 1972 . Invisible Colleges: Diffusion of Knowledge in Scientific Communities , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Mullins , Nicholas C. 1968 . “The Distribution of Social and Cultural Properties in Informal Communication Networks among Biological Scientists,” . American Sociological Review , 33 : 768 – 797 .
  • Menzel , Herbert . 1966 . “Scientific Communication: Five Themes from Social Research,” . American Psychologist , 21 : 999 – 1004 .
  • Storer . The Social System of Science 75
  • Parsons , Talcott . 1951 . The Social System , New York : The Free Press .
  • Smelser , Neil J. 1959 . “A Comparative View of Exchange Systems,” . Economic Development and Cultural Change , 7 : 173 – 182 .
  • Stein , Morris I. “Creativity and the Scientist,” . In The Sociology of Science Edited by: Barber and Hirsch . 329 – 343 .
  • De Solía Price , Derek J. 1963 . Little Science, Big Science , 107 – 108 . New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Hagstrom . The Scientific Community 13
  • Storer . The Social System of Science 76
  • Gouldner , Alvin W. 1960 . “The Norm of Reciprocity,” . American Sociological Review , 25 : 161 – 178 .
  • Hagstrom . The Scientific Community 13
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure 604 – 615 .
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure 607
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure 610
  • Storer . The Social System of Science 79
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure 611
  • Huxley . “Our admiration of his genius is tampered by a certain disapproval; we feel such a man is selfish and anti‐social,” . 611 analysis of Henry Cavendish
  • Merton . Social Theory and Social Structure 614
  • Wenzel , Joseph W. 1974 . “Rhetoric and Anti‐Rhetoric in Early American Scientific Societies,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 60 : 328 – 336 .
  • Mills , C. Wright . 1974 . The Sociological Imagination , 197 New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Etzioni , Amitai . 1977 . “Public Affairs: A Science Court,” . Human Behavior , 6 ( 11 ) : 18 – 19 .
  • Crane , Diana . 1972 . Invisible Colleges; Diffusion of Knowledge in Scientific Communities , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • 1977 . “The Future of Communication Theory” . at the conveniton of the Southern Speech Communication Association in Knoxville . April 1977 , Tennessee.
  • Ruben , Brent D. , ed. 1977 . Communication Yearbook I , New Brunswick, N.J. : Transaction Books .
  • 1977 . “Naturalistic Study of Communication,” . 25 Summer
  • 1977 . “Alternative Theoretical Bases for the Study of Human Communication,” . 25 Winter
  • 1977 . “Symposium: What Criteria Should Be Used to Judge the Admis‐sibility of Evidence to Support Theoretical Propositions in Communication Research?” . Western Journal of Speech Communication , 41 Winter
  • 1975 . “Colloquy” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , February department of inaugurated in the
  • Grossberg , Lawrence and O'Keefe , Daniel J. 1975 . “Presuppositions, Conceptual Foundations, and Communication Theory: On Hawes’ Approach to Communication,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 61 : 195 – 208 .
  • Hawes , Leonard C. “A Response to Grossberg and O'Keefe: Building a Human Science of Communication,” . 209 – 219 .
  • 1975 . "Forum” . QJS , 61 Oct. section
  • O'Keefe and Grossberg . “Theoretical Clarity and Interpretive Social Science,” . 320 – 322 .
  • Hawes . “Theoretical Pragmatics and Scholastic Exe‐getics, or Will the ‘Real’ Schutz and Brodbeck Please Sit Down,” . 319 – 320 .
  • Seibold , David R. 1977 . “ (Top Three Plus Two) + (One Critic) = A Critique of ISGC's Finest,” . Paper presented to the Interpersonal and Small Group Communication Division of the Speech Communication Association . December 1977 , Washington, D.C..
  • 1972 . Spectra , 8 Decemeber : 2 – 3 .
  • Pearce , W. Barnett . 1973 . “Consensual Rules in Interpersonal Communication: A Reply to Cushman and Whiting,” . Journal of Communication , 23 : 160 – 168 .
  • Delia , Jesse G. 1976 . “A Constructivist Analysis of the Concept of Credibility,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 62 : 361 – 375 .
  • Clement , Donald A. and Frandsen , Kenneth D. 1976 . “On Conceptual and Empirical Treatments of Feedback in Human Communication,” . Communication Monographs , 43 : 11 – 28 .
  • Gouran , Dennis S. 1974 . “Perspectives on the Study of Leadership: Its Present and Its Future,” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 60 : 376 – 381 .
  • Miller , Gerald R. 1973 . “Counterattitudinal Advocacy: A Current Appraisal,” . In Advances In Communication Research , Edited by: Mortensen , C. David and Sereno , Kenneth K. 105 – 152 . New York : Harper & Row .
  • Seibold , David R. 1975 . Communication Research and the Attitude‐Verbal Report‐Overt Behavior Relationship: A Critique and Theoretic Reformulation,” . Human Communication Research , 2 : 3 – 32 .
  • Chase , Lawrence J. and Tucker , Raymond K. 1975 . “A Power‐Analytic Examination of Contemporary Communication Research,” . Speech Monographs , 42 : 29 – 41 .
  • Cronkhite , Gary and Liska , Jo . 1976 . “A Critique of Factor Analytic Approaches to the Study of Credibility,” . Communication Monographs , 43 : 91 – 107 .
  • Cappella , Joseph N. 1977 . “Research Methodology in Communication: Review and Commentary,” . In Communication Yearbook I , Edited by: Ruben , Brent D. 37 – 54 . New Brunswick, N.J. : Transaction Books .
  • 1976 . “Colloquy,” . Journal of Communication , 26 : 218 – 220 .
  • Price . Little Science, Big Science , 1 – 32 . interesing discussion of the growth rate of science in
  • Swanson . “A Reflective View . . .,” . 209 – 210 .
  • Schutz , Alfred . 1970 . Alfred Schutz on Phenomenology and Social Relations: Selected Writings , Edited by: Wagner , Helmut R. 275 – 278 . Chicago : U. of Chicago Press .
  • Schutz , Alfred . 1967 . The Phenomenology of the Social World , Edited by: Walsh , George and Lehnert , Frederick . 10 Evanston, Ill. : Northwestern University Press .
  • Lindsey , Duncan . 1976 . “Distinction, Achievement, and Editorial Board Membership,” . American Psychologist , 31 : 799 – 804 .
  • Zuckerman , Harriet . 1970 . “Stratification in American Science,” . Sociological Inquiry , 40 : 235 – 257 .
  • Gustin , Bernard H. 1973 . “Charisma, Recognition, and the Motivation of Scientists,” . American Journal of Sociology , 78 : 1119 – 1134 .
  • Myers , C. Rogers . 1970 . “Journal Citations and Scientific Eminence in Contemporary Psychology,” . American Psychologist , 25 : 1041 – 1048 .
  • Cole , Stephen and Cole , Jonathan R. 1967 . “Scientific Output and Recognition: A Study in the Operation of the Reward System in Science,” . American Sociological Review , 32 : 377 – 390 .
  • 1978 . “A Note From the Editor,” . Communication Research , 4 : 195
  • Wolff , Wirt M. 1973 . “Publication Problems in Psychology and an Explicit Evaluation Schema for Manuscripts,” . American Psychologist , 28 : 257 – 261 .
  • Wolff , Wirt M. 1970 . “A Study of Criteria for Journal Manuscripts,” . American Psychologist , 25 : 636 – 639 .
  • Chase , Janet M. 1970 . “Normative Criteria for Scientific Publication,” . American Sociologist , 5 : 262 – 265 .
  • McReynoIds , Paul . 1971 . “Reliability of Ratings of Research Papers,” . American Psychologist , 26 : 400 – 401 .
  • Scott , William A. 1974 . “Inter‐referee Agreement on Some Characteristics of Manuscripts Submitted to the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,” . American Psychologist , 29 : 689 – 702 .
  • Bowen , Donald D. , Perloff , Robert and Jacoby , Jacob . 1972 . “Improving Manuscript Evaluation Procedures,” . American Psychologist , 27 : 221 – 225 .
  • Kinkade , R. G. 1970 . “The Experimental Publication System: An Aid to Information System Planning,” . American Psychologist , 25 : 925 – 936 .
  • Schaeffer , Dirk L. 1970 . “Do APA Journals Play Professional Favorites?” . American Psychologist , 25 : 362 – 365 .
  • Tasto , D. , Dinges , G. , Weigel , R. and Hulse , H. K. 1971 . “Institutional Ties of Authors and Editors of the Journal of Counseling Psychology.” . Paper presented at the meetings of the Rocky Mountain Psychological Association . May 1971 , Denver.
  • Crane , Diana . 1967 . “The Gatekeepers of Science: Some Factors Affecting the Selection of Articles for Scientific Journals,” . American Sociologist , 32 : 195 – 201 .
  • Brackbill , Yvonne and Korten , Frances . 1970 . “Journal Reviewing Practices: Authors’ and APA Members’ Suggestions for Revision,” . American Psychologist , 25 : 937 – 940 .
  • Newman , S. H. 1966 . “Improving the Evaluation of Submitted Manuscripts,” . American Psychologist , 21 : 980 – 981 .
  • Yoels , William C. 1974 . “The Structure of Scientific Fields and the Allocation of Editorships on Scientific Journals: Some Observations on the Politics of Knowledge,” . Sociological Quarterly , 15 : 264 – 276 .
  • Beyer , Janice M. 1978 . “Editorial Policies and Practices Among Leading Journals in Four Scientific Fields,” . Sociological Quarterly , 19 : 68 – 88 .
  • Pfeffer , Jeffrey , Leong , Anthony and Strehl , Katherine . 1977 . “Paradigm Development and Particularism: Journal Publication in Three Scientific Disciplines,” . Social Forces , 51 : 938 – 951 .
  • Zuckerman , Harriet and Merton , Robert K. 1971 . “Patterns of Evaluation in Science: In‐stitutionalism, Structure and Functions of the Referee System,” . Minerva , 9 : 66 – 100 .
  • 1965 . “Publication in APA Journals: Some Advice from the Editors,” . American Psychologist , 20 : 711 – 720 .
  • Rodman , Hyman . 1970 . “Notes to an Incoming Journal Editor,” . American Psychologist , 25 : 269 – 273 .
  • Miller , Gerald R. and Berger , Charles R. 1978 . “On Keeping the Faith in Matters Scientific,” . Western Journal of Speech Communication , 42 : 44 – 57 .
  • 1976 . “Presidential Address: Sociology for Whom?” . American Sociological Review , 41 : 925 – 936 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.