Meta‐analysis comparing the persuasiveness of one‐sided and two‐sided messages

References

• Abelson , R. P. 1985 . A variance explanation paradox: When a little is a lot . Psychological Bulletin , 97 : 129 – 133 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Alexander , R. A. , Scozzaro , M. J. and Borodkin , L. J. 1989 . Statistical and empirical examination of the chi‐square test for homogeneity of correlations in meta‐analysis . Psychological Bulletin , 106 : 329 – 331 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Allen , M. , Hale , J. , Mongeau , P. , Berkowitz‐Stafford , S. , Stafford , S. , Shanahan , W. , Agee , P. , Dillon , K. , Jackson , R. and Ray , C. 1990 . Testing a model of message sidedness: Three replications . Communication Monographs , 57 : 275 – 291 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Allen , M. and Reynolds , R. The Elaboration Likelihood Model and the sleeper effect: Time after time after time . Paper presented at the International Communication Association . San Francisco , CA .
   Google Scholar
• Allen , M. and Stiff , J. B. 1989 . Testing three models for the sleeper effect . Western Journal of Speech Communication , 53 : 411 – 426 .
   Google Scholar
• Aristotle . 1932 . The rhetoric of Aristotle , Edited by: Cooper , L. New York : Appelton‐Century Crofts .
   Google Scholar
• Bangert‐Drowns , R. 1986 . Review of developments in meta‐analytic method . Psychological Bulletin , 99 : 388 – 399 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Belch , G. E. 1981 . An examination of comparative and noncomparative television commercials: The effects of claim variation and repetition on cognitive response and message acceptance . Journal of Marketing Research , 18 : 333 – 349 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Benoit , P. J. and Benoit , W. J. 1986 . Consciousness: The mindless/mindfulness and verbal report controversies . Western Journal of Speech Communication , 50 : 41 – 63 .
   Google Scholar
• Bettinghaus , E. P. and Baseheart , R. J. 1969 . Some specific factors affecting attitude change . Journal of Communication , 19 : 227 – 238 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Burgoon , M. 1989 . “ Messages and persuasive effects ” . In Message effects in communication science , Edited by: Bradac , J. J. 129 – 164 . Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Burrell , N. and Koper , R. “ The efficacy of powerful/powerless language on persuasiveness/credibility: A meta‐analytic review ” . In Persuasion: Advances through meta‐analysis , Edited by: Allen , M. and Preiss , R. Newbury Park , CA : Sage . (in press)
   Google Scholar
• Chu , G. C. 1967 . Prior familiarity, perceived bias, and one‐sided versus two‐sided communications . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology , 3 : 243 – 254 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cook , T. D. and Leviton , L. C. 1980 . Reviewing the literature: A comparison of traditional methods with meta‐analysis . Journal of Personality , 48 : 449 – 472 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cooper , H. M. and Rosenthal , R. 1980 . Statistical versus traditional procedures for summarizing research findings . Psychological Bulletin , 87 : 442 – 449 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dillard , J. P. , Hunter , J. E. and Burgoon , M. 1984 . Sequential‐request persuasive strategies: Meta‐analysis of foot‐in‐the‐door and door‐in‐the‐face . Human Communication Research , 10 : 461 – 488 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dipboye , R. L. 1977 . The effectiveness of one‐sided and two sided appeals as a function of familiarization and context . Journal of Social Psychology , 102 : 125 – 131 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dycus , R. D. 1976 . Relative efficacy of a one‐sided vs. two‐sided communication in a simulated government evaluation of proposals . Psychological Reports , 38 : 787 – 790 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Etgar , M. and Goodwin , S. A. 1982 . One‐sided versus two‐sided comparative message appeals for new brand introductions . Journal of Consumer Research , 8 : 460 – 465 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fort , L. and Smith , S. 1991 . Organ donation message strategies . American Behavioral Scientist , 34 : 695 – 711 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hample , D. 1984 . On the use of self‐reports . Journal of the American Forensic Association , 20 : 140 – 153 .
   Google Scholar
• Hass , R. G. and Linder , D. E. 1972 . Counterargument availability and the effect of message structure on persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 23 : 219 – 233 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. V. and Olkin , I. 1985 . Statistical methods for meta‐analysis , Orlando , FL : Academic Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hilyard , D. 1966 . One‐sided vs. two sided messages: An experiment in counterconditioning , East Lansing , MI : Michigan State University . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Hovland , C. , Lumsdaine , A. and Sheffield , F. 1949 . Experiments on mass communication , Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , Hamilton , M. A. and Allen , M. 1989 . The design and analysis of language experiments in communication . Communication Monographs , 56 : 341 – 363 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. and Schmidt , F. L. 1990 . Methods of meta‐analysis , Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , Schmidt , F. L. and Jackson , G. B. 1982 . Meta‐analysis: Cumulating research findings across studies , Beverly Hills , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Insko , C. A. 1962 . One‐sided versus two‐sided communications and countercommunications . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 65 : 203 – 206 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jackson , S. , O'Keefe , D. J. , Jacobs , S. and Brashers , D. E. 1989 . Messages as replications toward a message‐centered strategy . Communication Monographs , 56 : 364 – 384 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jaksa , J. 1963 . An experimental study of one‐sided and two‐sided argument with emphasis on three two‐sided speeches , Detroit , Michigan : Wayne State University . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Janis , I. L. and Feierabend , R. L. 1957 . “ Effect of alternative ways of ordering pro and con arguments in persuasive communications ” . In The order of presentation in persuasion , Edited by: Hovland , C. J. 115 – 128 . New Haven , CT : Yale University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Jones , R. A. and Brehm , J. W. 1970 . Persuasiveness of one and two‐sided communications as a function of awareness there are two sides . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology , 6 : 47 – 56 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kanungo , R. N. and Johar , J. S. 1975 . Effects of slogans and human model characteristics in product advertisements . Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science , 7 : 127 – 138 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kaplowitz , S. and Fisher , B. 1985 . Revealing the logic of freeriding and contributions to the nuclear freeze movement . Research in Social Movements, Conflicts, and Change , 8 : 47 – 64 .
   Google Scholar
• Keppel , G. 1982 . Design and analysis: A researcher's handbook , (2nd ed.) , Englewood Cliffs , NJ : Prentice‐Hall .
   Google Scholar
• Kim , M. and Hunter , J. Attitude‐behavior relations: A meta‐analysis of past research focusing on attitudinal relevance and topic . Paper presented at the International Communication Association Convention . Chicago .
   Google Scholar
• Koballa , T. 1984 . Changing attitudes toward energy conservation: The effect of development advancements on the salience of one‐sided and two‐sided persuasive communications . Journal of Research in Science Teaching , 21 : 659 – 668 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Koehler , J. 1968 . Effects on audience opinion of one‐sided and two‐sided speeches supporting and opposing a proposition, examining opinions on speaker's ethos, the topic, and the “open mindedness”; of the listeners , State College , PA : Pennsylvania State University . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Koyama , S. 1981 . Effects of television camera angle, locus of control, and two‐sided/onesided persuasive messages upon attitudes toward disabled people , Seattle , WA : University of Washington . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• LaPiere , R. T. 1934 . Attitudes vs. actions . Social Forces , 13 : 230 – 237 .
   Google Scholar
• Ley , P. , Whitworth , M. , Woodward , R. and Yorke , R. 1977 . The effect of sidedness and fear arousal on willingness to participate in a slimming scheme . Health Education Journal , 36 : 67 – 69 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lumsdaine , A. A. and Janis , I. L. 1953 . Resistance to “counterpropaganda”; produced by one‐sided and two‐sided “propaganda”; presentations . Public Opinion Quarterly , 17 : 311 – 318 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McCroskey , J. C. , Yount , T. J. and Scott , M. D. 1972 . The effects of message sidedness and evidence on inoculation against counterpersuasion in small group communication . Speech Monographs , 29 : 267 – 271 .
   Google Scholar
• McGinnies , E. 1966 . Studies in persuasion: III. Reactions of Japanese students to onesided and two‐sided communications . Journal of Social Psychology , 70 : 87 – 93 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. 1961a . Persistence of the resistance to persuasion induced by various types of prior belief defenses . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 64 : 241 – 248 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. 1961b . The effectiveness of supportive and refutational defenses in immunizing and restoring beliefs against persuasion . Sociometry , 24 : 184 – 197 .
   Google Scholar
• Mintz , J. 1983 . Integrating research evidence: A commentary on meta‐analysis . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology , 51 : 71 – 75 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Misra , S. and Jain , S. 1977 . Effect of fittingness, type of goods, and type of slogan on brand awareness . Journal of Applied Psychology , 55 : 580 – 585 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mongeau , P. “ Fear‐arousing persuasive appeals ” . In Persuasion: Advances through meta‐analysis , Edited by: Allen , M. and Preiss , R. Newbury Park , CA : Sage . (in press)
   Google Scholar
• Paulson , S. 1952 . Experimental study of spoken communications: The effects of prestige of the speaker and acknowledgment of opposing arguments on audience retention and shift of opinion , St. Paul , MN : University of Minnesota . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Paulson , S. F. 1954 . The effects of the prestige of the speaker and acknowledgment of opposing arguments on audience retention and shift of opinion . Speech Monographs , 21 : 267 – 271 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Petty , R. and Cacioppo , J. 1981 . Attitudes and persuasion: Classic and contemporary approaches , Dubuque , IA : Wm. C. Brown .
   Google Scholar
• Petty , R. E. and Cacioppo , J. T. 1986 . Communication and persuasion: Central and peripheral routes to attitude change , New York : Springer‐Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Preiss , R. and Allen , M. “ Precautions and prospects for meta‐analysis ” . In Persuasion: Advances through meta‐analysis , Edited by: Allen , M. and Preiss , R. Newbury Park , CA : Sage . (in press)
   Google Scholar
• Reinhard , J. “ The persuasive effects of evidence ” . In Persuasion: Advances through meta‐analysis , Edited by: Allen , M. and Preiss , R. Newbury Park , CA : Sage . (in press)
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. 1983 . Assessing the statistical and social importance of the effects of psychotherapy . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology , 51 : 4 – 13 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. 1984 . Meta‐analytic procedures for social research , Beverly Hills , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. 1987 . Judgment studies: Design, analysis, and meta‐analysis , New York : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. and Rubin , D. B. 1979 . A note on percent variance explained as a measure of the importance of effects . Journal of Applied Social Psychology , 9 : 395 – 396 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. and Rubin , D. B. 1982 . A simple, general purpose display of magnitude of experimental effect . Journal of Educational Psychology , 74 : 166 – 169 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. and Rubin , D. B. 1985 . Statistical analysis: Summarizing evidence versus establishing facts . Psychological Bulletin , 97 : 527 – 529 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosnow , R. L. 1968 . One‐sided versus two‐sided communication under indirect awareness of persuasive intent . Public Opinion Quarterly , 32 : 95 – 101 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schmidt , F. L. , Hunter , J. E. and Raju , N. S. 1988 . Validity generalization and situational specificity: A second look at the 75% rule and Fisher's z transformation . Journal of Applied Psychology , 73 : 665 – 672 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sawyer , A. G. 1973 . The effects of repetition of refutational and supportive advertising appeals . Journal of Marketing Research , 10 : 23 – 33 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Settle , R. B. and Golden , L. L. 1974 . Attribution theory and advertiser credibility . Journal of Marketing Research , 11 : 181 – 185 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sinha , D. and Dhawan , N. 1971 . Nature of communication, intelligence, suggestibility, and attitude change . Journal Indian Academy of Applied Psychology , 8 : 53 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• Skilbeck , C. , Tulips , J. and Ley , P. 1977 . The effects of fear arousal, fear position, fear exposure, and sidedness on compliance with dietary instructions . European Journal of Social Psychology , 7 : 221 – 239 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Smith , M. 1984 . Persuasion and human action , Belmont , CA : Wadsworth .
   Google Scholar
• Smith , R. E. and Hunt , S. D. 1978 . Attributional processes and effects in promotional situations . Journal of Consumer Research , 5 : 149 – 158 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Spector , P. E. and Levine , E. L. 1987 . Meta‐analysis for integrating study outcomes: A Monte Carlo study of its susceptibility to Type I and Type II errors . Journal of Applied Psychology , 72 : 3 – 9 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Stainback , R. D. and Rogers , R. W. 1983 . Identifying effective components of alcohol abuse prevention programs: Effects of fear appeals, message style, and source expertise . International Journal of the Addictions , 18 : 393 – 405 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Strube , M. J. 1988 . Averaging correlation coefficients: Influence of heterogeneity and set size . Journal of Applied Psychology , 73 : 559 – 568 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Thistlethwaite , D. J. and Kamenetzky , J. 1955 . Attitude change through refutation and elaboration of audience counterarguments . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 51 : 3 – 12 .
   Google Scholar
• Weston , J. 1967 . Argumentative message structure and prior familiarity as predictions of source credibility and attitude change , East Lansing , MI : Michigan State University . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Winer , B. J. 1971 . Statistical principles in experimental design , (2nd ed.) , New York : McGraw‐Hill .
   Google Scholar
• Winkel , F. W. 1984 . Public communication on donorcards: A comparison of persuasive styles . Social Science and Medicine , 19 : 957 – 963 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar