The ‘counter‐terrorist operation’ in Chechnya: ‘Information warfare’ aspects

Notes

• Thomas , Timothy L. July 1996 . “ ‘Russian Views on Information‐Based Warfare’ ” . July , 1 – 12 . Fort Leavenworth, KS : Foreign Military Studies Office .
   Google Scholar
• Tsygichko , V.N. , Smolian , G.L. and Chereshkin , D.S. 1997 . “ ‘Informatsionnoe oruzhie kak geopolticheskiy factor i instrument silovoy politiki’ ” . 16 – 17 .
   Google Scholar
• Krutskikh , A. 1999 . ‘Information Challenges to Security’ . International Affairs: A Russian Journal of World Politics, Diplomacy and International Relations , 45 ( 2 ) : 29 – 36 .
   Google Scholar
• Hockstader , Lee . 1995 . ‘Russians Get Their First Dose of Televised War’ . Moscow Times , 5 Jan. : 2
   Google Scholar
• Babakian , Genine . 1996 . ‘Propaganda Struggles to Survive Onslaught’ . Moscow Times , 5 Jan. : 3
   Google Scholar
• 24 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Russian Soldiers’ Mothers organization complies data on Chechnya dead’ ” . 24 Jan. , BBC Monitoring Service, Summary of World Broadcasts, Part I, Former Soviet Union (hereafter SWB), SU/3745 B/4
   Google Scholar
• Thomas , Timothy L. 1998 . ‘Russia's Information Warfare Structure: Understanding the Roles of the Security Council, FAPSI, the State Technical Commission and the Military’ . European Security , 7 ( 1 ) Spring : 156 – 72 .
   Google Scholar
• Main , S. J. June 2000 . “Counter‐Terrorist Operation’ in Chechnya: On the Legality of the Current Conflict’ ” . In The Second Chechen War , Edited by: Aldis , Mrs A.C. June , 31 29 – 37 . Camberley : CSRC, RMA Sandhurst .
   Google Scholar
• www.ppc.pims.org/rojects/csrc. (www.ppc.pims.org/rojects/csrc.)
   Google Scholar
• 1 May 2000 . “ ‘War ‘conspiracy of the Yeltsin administration’ ‐ President Maskhadov’ ” . 1 May , SWB, SU/3828 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Novaya Gazela (Internet version), Moscow , 27 April
   Google Scholar
• 17 July 2000 . “ ‘Basayev says West is bankrolling war in Chechnya’ ” . 17 July , SWB, SU/3894 B/8
   Google Scholar
• Hoffman , David . 1999 . ‘War Reports Limited on Russian TV . Washington Post , 10 Oct.
   Google Scholar
• 17 July 2000 . “ ‘Basayev says West is bankrolling war in Chechnya’ ” . 17 July , SWB, SU/3894 B/8
   Google Scholar
• Zolotov , Andrei . 1999 . ‘Kremlin Scores Strategic Victory in Chechnya over the Media’ . CRS , 4 Nov.
   Google Scholar
• Lurie , Lev . 2000 . ‘The Russian Media Turns’ . CRS , 14 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• Batuev , Erik . 28 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen Information War Escalates’ ” . 28 Jan. , Institute for War and Peace Reporting .
   Google Scholar
• Kozin , Vladimir . 2000 . ‘West's Media Aids Rebels’ . Moscow Times , 11 Feb.
   Google Scholar
• Traynor , Ian . 1999 . ‘No News is Good News’ . The Guardian , 17 Dec. : 20
   Google Scholar
• 10 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Foreign Ministry slams Russian ‘fabrications’ about support for Chechens’ ” . 10 Jan. , SWB, SU/3733 F/5
   Google Scholar
• 20 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Russian Defence Ministry denies report of use of chemical weapons’ ” . 20 Jan. , SWB, SU/3742 B5
   Google Scholar
• Herd , Graeme P. March 2000 . “ ‘Information Warfare during the Second Chechen Campaign, 1999–2000’ ” . In Post‐Soviet Security and Identity , Edited by: Cummings , Sally . March , 31 – 42 . Sandhurst : CSRC Occasional Paper, RMA . G81
   Google Scholar
• Thomas , Timothy L. “ ‘Manipulating Mass Consciousness: Russian & Chechen “Information War” Tactics in the Second Chechen‐Russian Conflict’ ” . In The Second Chechen War Edited by: Aldis . 31 112 – 29 . (note 6)
   Google Scholar
• 17 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Regional data suggests 3,000 Russian soldiers killed in Chechnya’ ” . 17 Jan. , SWB, SU/3739 B/9
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . ‘Death and inglory in Chechnya’ . The Economist , 15–20 Jan. : 40
   Google Scholar
• 4 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Soldiers’ mothers say 3,000 servicemen killed, 5,000 wounded in Chechnya’ ” . 4 Feb. , SWB, SU/3755 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Nezavisimaya Gazeta , 2 Feb.
   Google Scholar
• 25 March 2000 . “ ‘More than 4,000 Russian servicemen died in Chechnya ‐ soldiers’ mothers’ ” . 25 March , SWB, SU/3798 B/10
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Nezavisimaya Gazeta , 23 March
   Google Scholar
• 3 April 2000 . “ ‘Russian losses top 2000’ ” . 3 April , SWB, SU/3805 B/6
   Google Scholar
• 13 May 2000 . “ ‘Russia general reports federal losses in Chechen war’ ” . 13 May , SWB, SU/3839 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 25 May 2000 . “ ‘Chechen detail losses of both sides since hostilities broke out’ ” . 25 May , SWB, SU/3849 B/5
   Google Scholar
• 28 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechens say Russia lost 11,000 troops since the start of the invasion’ ” . 28 Jan. , SWB, SU/3749 B/6
   Google Scholar
• 28 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Russians says civilian casualties counted in the hundreds’ ” . 28 Jan. , SWB, SU/3749 B/9
   Google Scholar
• 20 July 2000 . “ ‘Putin aide denies reports that Chechen Kavkaz TV is back on air’ ” . 20 July , SWB, SU/3897 B/17
   Google Scholar
• 25 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Putin dismisses talk of impending dictatorship, says Chechen offensive not political’ ” . 25 Jan. , SWB, SU/3746 B/1
   Google Scholar
• 28 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Two official spokesmen to handle all Chechnya briefings from now on’ ” . 28 Jan. , SWB, SU/3749 B/3
   Google Scholar
• 26 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Putin to rid media coverage of Chechnya of “rough edges'” . 26 Jan. , SWB, SU/3747 B/6
   Google Scholar
• Batuev , Erik . 28 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen Information War Escalates’ ” . 28 Jan. , Institute for War and Peace Reporting .
   Google Scholar
• Koreneva , Marina . 31 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘The Internet Battlefield In War Between Russia, Chechnya’ ” . 31 Jan. , Agence France Press .
   Google Scholar
• Eichrodt , Joan Beecher . 1999 . ‘Internet Insurrection’ . Transitions Online , 1 ( 1 ) 13 Oct. : 1 – 4 .
   Google Scholar
• Gigorian , Mark . 2000 . ‘Azeri Cyber Forces’ . CRS , 4 Feb.
   Google Scholar
• 10 March 2000 . “ ‘Federal authorities take steps to restore broadcasting’ ” . 10 March , SWB, SU/3785 B/5
   Google Scholar
• 3 July 2000 . “ ‘New plan prepared on information support for Russian army ‐ newspaper’ ” . 3 July , SWB, SU/3882 S1/2
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Nezavisimaya Gazeta, Moscow , 29 June
   Google Scholar
• 1 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Radio Liberty reporter in Chechnya to be held for 10 days’ ” . 1 Feb. , SWB, SU/3752 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 8 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Russian justice minister insists Radio Liberty journalist treated fairly’ ” . 8 Feb. , SWB, SU/3758 B/3
   Google Scholar
• 9 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Russian special services set up journalist's kidnapping, Chechens say’ ” . 9 Feb. , SWB, SU/3759
   Google Scholar
• 23 June 2000 . “ ‘Chechen website accuses pro‐Moscow leader of involvement in kidnappings’ ” . 23 June , SWB, SU/3874 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 5 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Radio Liberty journalist's lawyer condemns his handover to Chechens’ ” . 5 Feb. , SWB, SU/3756 B/6
   Google Scholar
• Lurie , Lev . 2000 . ‘The Russian Media Turns’ . CRS , 14 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• 18 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Putin's first appointments show Kremlin old guard still in place, says TV’ ” . 18 Jan. , SWB, SU/3740 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 13 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Newspaper questions motives and conduct of war in Chechnya’ ” . 13 Jan. , SWB, SU/3736 B/10
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Novaya Gazeta ‐ ponedelnik , 10 Jan. : 6 Moscow
   Google Scholar
• 15 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Putin faces election campaign setbacks ‐ paper’ ” . 15 Jan. , SWB, SU/3738 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Izvestiya, Moscow , 11 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• 13 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen war seen as risk to Putin's presidential ambition’ ” . 13 Jan. , SWB, SU/3736 B/3
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Segodnya, Moscow , 11 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• 25 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Russian casualty figures could be 10 times higher than officially stated ‐ TV’ ” . 25 Jan. , SWB, SU/3746 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . NTV, Moscow , 23 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• 15 May 2000 . “ ‘Putin's Chechnya optimism questioned’ ” . 15 May , SWB, SU/3789 B/4
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Moskovskiy Komsomolels, Moscow , 11 May
   Google Scholar
• 18 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Russians are ‘not concealing losses’ in Chechnya ‐ journalist’ ” . 18 Jan. , SWB, SU/3740 B/6
   Google Scholar
• 18 Jar. 2000 . “ ‘Ingush head warns of protracted war, calls for talks’ ” . 18 Jar. , SWB, SU/3740 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Sueddeutsche Zeitung website, Munich , 15 Jan.
   Google Scholar
• 26 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Moscow Mayor says sending troops to Chechnya was a mistake’ ” . 26 Jan. , SWB, SUI/3747 B/7
   Google Scholar
• Thomas . “ ‘Russia's Information Warfare Structure’ ” . 168 (note 5)
   Google Scholar
• 7 July 2000 . “ ‘Website to publish extensive ‘Russiagate’ database’ ” . 7 July , SWB, SU/3886 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Nezavisimaya Gazeta, Moscow , 4 July
   Google Scholar
• 26 June 2000 . “ ‘Media tycoon Gusinsky questioned, says authorities want to muzzle NTV’ ” . 26 June , SWB, SU/3876 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 20 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Media mogul suggests he's being set up again’ ” . 20 Sept. , SWB, SU/3950 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 12 July 2000 . “ ‘Influential journalist launches attack on Putin’ ” . 12 July , SWB, SU/3890 B/5
   Google Scholar
• 4 Aug. 2000 . “ ‘Radio commentator savages Putin's version of North Caucasus events’ ” . 4 Aug. , SWB, SU/3910 B/1
   Google Scholar
• 26 July 2000 . “ ‘Council approves information security doctrine’ ” . 26 July , SWB, SU/3876 B/1
   Google Scholar
• 14 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Putin endorses doctrine on information security ‐ outline of contents’ ” . 14 Sept. , SWB, SU/3945 B/1
   Google Scholar
• 18 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Public figures criticise new information security doctrine’ ” . 18 Sept. , SWB, SU/3948 B/1
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Segodnya, Moscow , 14 Sept.
   Google Scholar
• 16 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Union of Journalists condemns information security doctrine’ ” . 16 Sept. , SWB, SU/3947 B/3
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty , 15 Sept. Newsline, 4/179, Part I
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Jamestown Foundation , 15 Sept. Monitor 6/171, Friday
   Google Scholar
• 29 Aug. 2000 . “ ‘Communications Ministry bugging order takes legal effect’ ” . 29 Aug. , SWB, SU/3931 B/4
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Segodnya, Moscow , 22 Aug.
   Google Scholar
• 9 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Government classifies 7m dollars ‘to oppose mass media’ ” . 9 Sept. , SWB, SU/3941 B/4
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Kommersant, Moscow , 6 Sept.
   Google Scholar
• 19 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘NTV accuses military of forcing broadcast off air at gunpoint, hitting cameraman’ ” . 19 Sept. , SWB, SU/3949 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 14 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Russian troops seize rebel TV centre, destroy ammunition depots’ ” . 14 Feb. , SWB, SU/3763 B/10
   Google Scholar
• 19 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Foreign minister Ivanov accuses Western media of biased Chechen coverage’ ” . 19 Jan. , SWB, SU/3741 B/10
   Google Scholar
• Krutskikh , A. and Fedorov , A. 2000 . ‘International Information Security’ . International Affairs: A Russian Journal of World Politics, Diplomacy and International Relations , 46 ( 2 ) : 170 – 82 .
   Google Scholar
• 20 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Pro‐Chechen website over 300 killed in the capital’ ” . 20 Jan. , SWB, SU/3742 B/7
   Google Scholar
• 22‐July 2000 . “ ‘Rebel activity intensifying ‐ Russian deputy chief of the General Staff ” . 22‐July , SWB, SU/3899 B/2
   Google Scholar
• 27 July 2000 . “ ‘Russian forces seize mobile TV station used by Chechen rebels’ ” . 27 July , SWB, SU/3903 B/6
   Google Scholar
• 1878 . Nezavisimaya Gazeta , 7 April 1999
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . NG Religii‐dayazhest , 3 (3) April : 12
   Google Scholar
• www.amina.com (www.amina.com)
   Google Scholar
• www.chechentimes.com. (www.chechentimes.com.)
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . Serkalo Baku , 19 Jan. : 1 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• 2 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen website reports two Chechen generals perish in fighting’ ” . 2 Feb. , SWB, SU/3754 B/10
   Google Scholar
• Krushelnycky , Askhold . 2000 . ‘Chechnya: Rebels use Internet in Propaganda War with Russians’ . RFE/RL , 11 May
   Google Scholar
• 22 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechens seen stepping up “Internet war” against Russia’ ” . 22 Feb. , SWB, SU/3770 B/4
   Google Scholar
• 26 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen commanders reportedly say they are holding Grozny to humiliate Russia’ ” . 26 Jan. , SWB, SU/3747 B/9
   Google Scholar
• 7 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Pro‐Chechen website reports commander in good spirits after light injury’ ” . 7 Feb. , SWB, SU/3757 B/11
   Google Scholar
• 1 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Authorities do not recognize Chechen mission in Georgia’ ” . 1 Feb. , SWB, SU/3752 F/2
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . ‘There is only one representative of Russia ‐ the Russian embassy in Georgia’ . Svobodnaya Geuzia , 1 Feb. : 2
   Google Scholar
• 6 March 2000 . “ ‘Foreign Ministry tells Georgia to close Chechen mission’ ” . 6 March , SWB, SU/3781 B/10
   Google Scholar
• 26 July 2000 . “ ‘Russia calls on Georgia to close Chechen offices in Tblisi’ ” . 26 July , SWB, SU/3876 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 3 July 2000 . “ ‘Chechen parliament appeals to the world to stop Russia's ‘genocide” . 3 July , SWB. SU/3882 B/14
   Google Scholar
• 20 June 2000 . “ ‘Foreign Ministry accuses Russia of waging anti‐Georgian propaganda’ ” . 20 June , SWB, SU/3871 F/6
   Google Scholar
• Hasanli , Gorkhmaz . 2000 . ‘Pro‐Chechen Information Centre Set up in Baku’ . Azer‐News , 11 (141) 15–22 March
   Google Scholar
• 2 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen foreign minister reports Chechen forces withdrawal from Grozny’ ” . 2 Feb. , SWB, SU/3754 B/9
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . ‘Representative Office of the Chechen Republic of Ichkeria in Azerbaijan’ . Baku , 1 Feb.
   Google Scholar
• 4 May 2000 . “ ‘Chechen minister calls on USA to save Chechen people from the Russians’ ” . 4 May , SWB, SU/3831 B/5
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . ‘Representative Office of the Chechen Republic of Ichkeria in Azerbaijan’ . Baku , 1 Feb.
   Google Scholar
• 17 July 2000 . “ ‘Basayev says West is bankrolling war in Chechnya’ ” . 17 July , SWB, SU/3894 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 18 July 2000 . “ ‘Head of presidential staff promises Russians probe into Basayev interview’ ” . 18 July , SWB, SU/3895 F/2
   Google Scholar
• 20 July 2000 . “ ‘Azeri TV broadcasts interview with field commander Basayev’ ” . 20 July , SWB, SU/3899 B/5
   Google Scholar
• 2 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechnya mission closed down’ ” . 2 Feb. , SWB, SU/3753 B/18
   Google Scholar
• Gurgendize , Paata . 1999 . ‘The Issue of a Chechen Information Centre in Georgia’ . The Army and Society in Georgia , 7/11 (41) Nov. : 10
   Google Scholar
• 15 April 2000 . “ ‘Foreign support for Chechen militants aimed at weakening Russia ‐ general’ ” . 15 April , SWB, SU/3816 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 24 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechnya‐Taleban axis set up ‐ agency’ ” . 24 Jan. , SWB, SU/3745 B/4
   Google Scholar
• 15 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen ex‐president said to have met Pakistani military ruler’ ” . 15 Feb. , SWB, SU/3764 B/9
   Google Scholar
• 28 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Chechen envoy in United Arab Emirates’ ” . 28 Feb. , SWB, SU/3755 B/11
   Google Scholar
• 23 March 2000 . “ ‘Foreign Minister protests against reception of Chechen envoy in Qatar’ ” . 23 March , SWB, SU/3796 B/8
   Google Scholar
• 20 Jan. 2000 . “ ‘Chechens talk up the importance of recognition from Afghanistan’ ” . 20 Jan. , SWB, SU/3742 B/10
   Google Scholar
• 14 Feb. 2000 . “ ‘Maskhadov promises to fight Russian troops with dignity’ ” . 14 Feb. , SWB, SU/3763 B/9
   Google Scholar
• Krushelnycky , Askhold . 2000 . ‘Chechnya: Rebels use Internet in Propaganda War with Russians’ . RFE/RL , 11 May
   Google Scholar
• 17 April 2000 . “ ‘President Maskhadov ready for talks without preconditions’ ” . 17 April , SWB, SU/3817 B/8
   Google Scholar
• www.dwelle.de (www.dwelle.de)
   Google Scholar
• 14 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Chechens announce two‐million‐dollar reward for Putin's head’ ” . 14 Sept. , SWB, SU/3945 B/6
   Google Scholar
• 7 July 2000 . “ ‘Putin ready to talk to Chechen commander who has given up armed struggle’ ” . 7 July , SWB, SU/3886 B/5
   Google Scholar
• Libicki , Martin . 1996 . ‘The Emerging Primacy of Information’ . Orbis , 40 ( 2 ) Spring : 261 – 76 .
   Google Scholar
• Wriston , Walter B. 1997 . ‘Bits, Bytes, and Diplomacy’ . Foreign Affairs , 76 ( 5 ) Sept./Oct. : 172 – 82 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Vlahos , Michael . 1997 . ‘The War after Byte City’ . Washington Quarterly , 30 ( 2 ) Spring : 39 – 72 .
   Google Scholar
• Mathews , Jessica T. 1997 . ‘Power Shift’ . Foreign Affairs , 76 ( 1 ) Jan./Feb. : 50 – 66 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Keohane , Robert O. and Nye , Joseph S. Jr . 1998 . ‘Power and Interdependence in the Information Age’ . Foreign Affairs , 77 ( 5 ) Sept./Oct. : 81 – 94 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nye , Joseph S. Jr . 1999 . ‘Redefining NATO's Mission in the Information Age’ . NATO Review , Winter : 12 – 15 .
   Google Scholar
• Lonsdale , David J. 1999 . “ ‘Information Power: Strategy, Geopolitics, and the Fifth Dimension’ ” . In Geopolitics, Geography and Strategy , Edited by: Gray , Colin S. and Sloan , Geoffrey . 137 – 60 . London and Portland, OR : Frank Cass .
   Google Scholar
• 10 March 2000 . “ ‘Industries show “spectacular” 10‐year decline’ ” . 10 March , SWB, SUW/0630 WA/3
   Google Scholar
• 15 Sept. 2000 . “ ‘Worse‐case scenario’ ” . 15 Sept. , SUW/0657 WA/17
   Google Scholar
• Masoud , Bahram Director . Iranian Journal of International Affairs , Islamic Republic of Iran : MFA official .
   Google Scholar
• 2000 . ‘Mass Media ‐ Cyberwarfare and Public Opinion Conference’ . Jan. 21–22 2000 , Athens. Greek MoD and Scottish Centre for International Security, University of Aberdeen . hosted by the
   Google Scholar
• Nye , Joseph S. Jr and Owens , William A. 1996 . ‘America's Information Edge’ . Foreign Affairs , 75 ( 2 ) March/April : 30 – 6 .
   Google Scholar
• Nye , Joseph S. Jr . 1999 . ‘Redefining NATO's mission in the Information Age’ . NATO Review , Winter : 12
   Google Scholar