4,762
Views
5
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

American racism and the lost legacy of Sir Jagadis Chandra Bose, the father of plant neurobiology

ORCID Icon
Article: 1818030 | Received 29 Jun 2020, Accepted 28 Aug 2020, Published online: 04 Dec 2020

References

  • Bose JC. Plant and animal response. Proc R Soc Med. 1920;13(Gen_Rep):1–17. doi:10.1177/003591572001300505.
  • Bose S. Professor Jagadis Chandra Bose in America. Mod Rev (Calcutta). 1915;17:559–564.
  • Das RK. Sir J. C. Bose in Europe. Mod Rev (Calcutta). 1926;40:409–410.
  • Engineer MH. The millimeter wave researches of J. C. Bose. In: Gupta DPS, Engineer MH, Shepherd VA, editors. Remembering Sir JC Bose. Hackensack (New Jersey): World Scientific Publishing Co.; 2009. p. 63–99.
  • Siegel PH. Sir Jagadis Chunder Bose: traversing the interdisciplinary gap between physics and biology. IEEE Microwave Mag. 2009;10:119–121. doi:10.1109/MMM.2009.932241.
  • Bose JC. Response in the living and non-living. London: Longmans Green; 1902.
  • De Luccia TPDB. Mimosa pudica, Dionaea muscipula and anesthetics. Plant Signaling Behav. 2012;7:1163–1167.
  • Matthus E, Wilkins KA, Swarbreck SM, Doddrell NH, Doccula F, Costa A, Davies JM. Phosphate starvation alters abiotic-stress-induced cytosolic free calcium increases in roots. Plant Physiol. 2019;179:1754–1767. doi:10.1104/pp.18.01469.
  • Bünning E. Die Reizbewegungen der Staubblatter von Sparmannia africana. Protoplasma. 1930;11:49–84. doi:10.1007/BF01614318.
  • Dixon HH. The transpiration stream. London: University of London Press; 1924. 35–38.
  • Bose JC. The unvoiced life. Mod Rev (Calcutta). 1925;38:712–722.
  • Shepherd VA. Reflections on the many-in-one: J. C. Bose and the roots of plant neurobiology. In: Gupta DPS, Engineer MH, Shepherd VA, editors. Remembering Sir JC Bose. Hackensack (New Jersey): World Scientific Publishing Co.; 2009. p. 101–160.
  • Brenner ED, Stahlberg R, Mancuso S, Vivanco J, Baluška F, Van Volkenburgh E. Plant neurobiology: an integrated view of plant signaling. Trends Plant Sci. 2006;11:413–419.
  • Bose JC. Researches on the growth of plants. Nature. 1920;105:615–617.
  • Bose JC. Electrical response in ordinary plants under mechanical stimulation. J Linn Soc London Bot. 1902;35:275–304.
  • Fromm J, Lautner S. Electrical signals and their physiological significance in plants. Plant Cell Environ. 2007;30:249–257.
  • Bose JC. Researches on irritability of plants. London: Longmans Green; 1913.
  • Minorsky PV. Temperature sensing by plants: a review and hypothesis. Plant Cell Environ. 1989;12:119–135. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3040.1989.tb01924.x.
  • Bose JC. Plant response as a means of physiological investigation. London: Longmans Green; 1905.
  • Zawadzki T. Electrical properties of Lupinus augustifolius L. stem. I. Subthreshold potentials. Acta Soc Bot Pol. 1979;48(1):99–107. doi:10.5586/asbp.1979.009.
  • Shimmen T. Involvement of receptor potentials and action potentials in mechano-perception in plants. Aust J Plant Physiol. 2001;28:567–576.
  • Bose JC III. An automatic method for the investigation of velocity of transmission of excitation in Mimosa. Proc R Soc Ser B. 1914;204:63–97.
  • Bose JC, Das GP. The high magnification crescograph for researches on growth. Trans Bose Res Inst. 1919;1:151–172.
  • Kôketsu R. Über die Wirkungen der Elektrischen Reizung an den Pflanzlichen Zellgebilden. J Depart Agric Kyushu Imperial Univ. 1923;1:1–133.
  • Abe T. The shortening and action potential of the cortex in the main pulvinus of Mimosa pudica. Bot Mag. 1980;93:247–251. doi:10.1007/BF02489326.
  • Shiina T, Tazawa M. Action potential in Luffa cylindrica and its effects on elongation growth. Plant Cell Physiol. 1986;27:1081–1089.
  • Okamoto H. On the excitation phenomena in embryonic plants of Vigna sesquipedalis caused by electrical stimuli, and presence of polarities concerning the excitability. Bot Mag. 1955;68:141–149. doi:10.15281/jplantres1887.68.141.
  • Bose JC, Das GP. Physiological and anatomical investigations on Mimosa pudica. Proc R S London Ser B. 1925;98:290–312.
  • Samejima M, Sibaoka T. Identification of excitable cells in the petiole of Mimosa pudica by intracellular injection of procion yellow. Plant Cell Physiol. 1983;24:33–39. doi:10.1093/oxfordjournals.pcp.a076511.
  • Bose JC. The action of drugs on plants. Proc R Soc Med. 1914;8:1–40.
  • Bose JC. On the electric pulsation accompanying automatic movements in Desmodium gyrans, DC. J Linn Soc London Bot. 1903;35:405–420. doi:10.1111/j.1095-8339.1903.tb00603.x.
  • Mitsuno T, Sibaoka T. Rhythmic electrical potential change of motor pulvinus in lateral leaflet of Codariocalyx motorius. Plant Cell Physiol. 1989;30(8):1123–1127. doi:10.1093/oxfordjournals.pcp.a077853.
  • Bose JC. The motor mechanism of plants. London: Longmans Green; 1928. p. 256.
  • Tretyn A, Kendrick RE. Acetylcholine in plants: presence, metabolism, and mechanism of action. Bot Rev. 1991;57:34–73. doi:10.1007/BF02858764.
  • Ramesh SA, Tyerman SD, Xu B, Bose J, Kaur S, Conn V, Domingos P, Ullah S, Wege S, Shabala S, et al. GABA signalling modulates plant growth by directly regulating the activity of plant-specific anion transporters. Nat Commun. 2015;6:7879. doi:10.1038/ncomms8879.
  • Choi J, Tanaka K, Cao Y, Qi Y, Qiu J, Liang Y, Lee SY, Stacey G. Identification of a plant receptor for extracellular ATP. Science. 2014;343:290–294. doi:10.1126/science.343.6168.290.
  • Bose JC. Physiology of the ascent of sap. London: Longmans Green; 1923.
  • Toko K, Souda M, Matsuno T, Yamafuji K. Oscillations of electrical potential along a root of a higher plant. Biophys J. 1990;57:269–279. doi:10.1016/S0006-3495(90)82529-7.
  • Burgerstein A. Über einige physiologische und pathologische Wirkungen des Kampfers auf die Pflanzen, insbesondere auf Laubsprosse. Verhandlung Kaiserlich Königlichen Zöol Bot Ges Wien. 1884;34:543–562.
  • James WO. Review of Life Movements in Plants by J. C. Bose. New Phytol. 1931;30:142–144.
  • Wessler I, Kilbinger H, Bittinger F, Kirkpatrick CJ. The non-neuronal cholinergic system: the biological role of non-neuronal acetylcholine in plants and animals. Jpn J Pharmacol. 2001;85:2–10. doi:10.1254/jjp.85.2.
  • Zholkevich VN, Aniskin DN, Dustmamatov AH. On the stimulatory effect of neuromediators on the root pumping effect. Dokl Biol Sci. 2003;392(1/6):138–141. doi:10.1023/A:1026179905962.
  • Zholkevich VN, Emel’yanova IB, Suschenko SV. Self-oscillations of water transport in the plant root. Dokl Biol Sci. 2005;403(1–6):269–271. doi:10.1007/s10630-005-0108-8.
  • Mozhaeva LV, Pil’shchikova NV. Relationship between root pressure constituents and root water pumping rate. Dokl Akad Nauk SSSR. 1978;239:1005–1008. [ in Russian].
  • Benedict HM. Application of Bose’s theory of sap rise to ten species of trees. Am J Bot. 1927;14:623.
  • Choi W, Toyota M, Kim S, Hilleary R, Gilroy S. Salt stress-induced Ca2+ waves are associated with rapid, long-distance root-to-shoot signaling in plants. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 2014;111(17):6497–6502. doi:10.1073/pnas.1319955111.
  • Toyota M, Spencer D, Sawai-Toyota S, Jiaqui W, Zhang T, Koo AJ, Howe GA, Gilroy S. Glutamate triggers long-distance, calcium-based plant defense signaling. Science. 2018;361:1112–1115. doi:10.1126/science.aat7744.
  • Lin CC, Cao CH. Cell wall peroxidase activity, hydrogen peroxide level and NaCl-inhibited root growth of rice seedlings. Plant Soil. 2001;230:135–143. doi:10.1023/A:1004876712476.
  • Orozco-Cárdenas ML, Ryan C. Hydrogen peroxide is generated systemically in plant leaves by wounding and systemin via the octadecanoid pathway. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 1999;96:6553–6557. doi:10.1073/pnas.96.11.6553.
  • MacDougal DT. The reactions of plants to new habitats. Ecology. 1921;2:1–20. doi:10.2307/1929523.
  • D. T. MacDougal to E. E. Free, Records of the Desert Botanical Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution, University of Arizona Special Collections, Tucson, Arizona, 3 Apr. 1924, Box 13, Folder 4.
  • D. T. MacDougal to AAAS Membership, 9 Mar. 1922, UA AZ356, Box 20, Folder 2.
  • MacDougal DT. The influence of light and darkness upon growth and development. Mem N Y Bot Garden. 1903;2:1–319.
  • W. H. Ballou, “Growing Plants in Darkness.” 23 Mar. 1902, New York Times, SM13.
  • Dodging Hostile Yaquis. New York Times. 1902 Jun 8: SM8.
  • MacDougal DT. Heredity and environic forces. Science. 1908;27:121–128. doi:10.1126/science.27.682.121.
  • MacDougal DT. Alterations in heredity induced by ovarial treatments. Bot Gaz. 1911;51:241–257. doi:10.1086/330486.
  • Harding JW. Dr. MacDougal’s botanical feat threatens evolution theories. NYT; 1905 Dec 24. p. SM1–2.
  • Kingsland SE. The battling botanist: Daniel Trembly MacDougal, mutation theory, and the rise of experimental evolutionary biology in America, 1900–1912. Isis. 1991;82(3):479–501. doi:10.1086/355838.
  • Shreve F. Daniel Trembly MacDougal – pioneer plant physiologist. Plant Physiol. 1939;14:191–202.
  • Hornaday WT. Camp-fires on desert and lava. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1908. p. 4.
  • Bowers JE. A debt to the future: scientific achievements of the desert laboratory, Tumamoc Hill, Tucson, Arizona. Desert Plants. 1990;10:9–12; 35–47.
  • Klautke E. ‘The Germans are beating us at our own game’: American eugenics and the German Sterilization Law of 1933. Hist Hum Sci. 2016;29:25–43. doi:10.1177/0952695116631230.
  • Gould SJ. The mismeasure of man. New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 1981.
  • G. von Hoffman to H. H. Laughlin, 26 May 1914, Truman State University Special Collections, Harry H. Laughlin Papers, Box D-5-4, Folder 7.
  • Kühl S. The Nazi connection. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1994. 68–69.
  • Davenport CB. The racial element in national vitality. Popul Sci Mon. 1915;86:331–333.
  • D. T. MacDougal to H. H. Crampton, 1 Jun. 1914, Daniel Trembly MacDougal Papers, Arizona Historical Society, Tucson, Arizona, AHS MS 0452, Box 18, Folder 248.
  • W. A. Cannon to D. T. MacDougal, 21 May 1908, UA AZ356, Box 8, Folder 102.
  • B. E. Livingston to D. T. MacDougal, 15 Jul. 1925, UA AZ356, Box 15, Folder 1.
  • R. S. Woodward to D. T. MacDougal, 16 Nov. 1915, AHS MS 0452, Box 19, Folder 273.
  • Goodman S, Dawson C. Mary Austin and the American West. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2008. p. 30–31.
  • Stearns HE. The street I know. New York: Lee Furman, Inc.; 1935.
  • Edwards RW. Jennie V. Cannon: the untold history of the Carmel and Berkeley art colonies. Oakland: East Bay Heritage Project; 2012. Vol. 1. p. 489–490.
  • Newkirk P. Spectacle: the astonishing life of Ota Benga. New York: Amistad Press; 2015.
  • Yaqui Indians Were Driven to Many Crimes. The Philadelphia Times. 1902 Jun 8; p. 18.
  • D. T. MacDougal to W. T. Hornaday, 5 Dec. 1919, AHS MS 0452, Box 15, Folder 9.
  • D. T. MacDougal to W. E. Davis, 8 Apr. 1926, UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 8.
  • D. T. MacDougal to E. E. Free, 15 Jul. 1927; UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 4.
  • 5 Mexican States Cleared of Chinese. New York Times. 1931 Oct 18; p. 2.
  • D. T. MacDougal to S. L. Gulick, 24 Jan. 1921, UA AZ356, Box 27, Folder 10.
  • Protoplasmic Cell Seen as Odd Tangle. New York Times. 1922 Dec 13; p. 18.
  • Thorne VB. ’Brains,’ Ganglia and Nerves of the “bashful young potato”. NYT 1926 Jun 20. p. BR12.
  • MacDougal DT. Sensational. Sci Am. 1926;135:311–312.
  • D. T. MacDougal to A. G. Ingalls, 13 Jul. 1926, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • D. T. MacDougal to H. H. Dixon, 6 Jun. 1928, UA AZ356, Box 18, Folder 8.
  • Bose’s Claims Denied. The Science News-Letter. 1927 Jan 8;11: 23–24, p. 23.
  • Science News. Science 1927; 65:xxxvi-xxxviii.
  • Souls for Parsnips. New York Herald Tribune. 1926 May 4; p. 22.
  • The Alleged Heart Beats in Plants. New York Herald Tribune. 1926 Aug 8; p. B6.
  • The Bose Scandal Grows. New York Herald Tribune. 1926 Aug 27; p. 12.
  • Sir Jagadis and the Fairies. New York Herald Tribune. 1927 Feb 4; p. 16.
  • Taiz L, Alkon D, Draguhn A, Murphy A, Blatt M, et al. Plants neither possess nor require consciousness. Trends Plant Sci. 2019;24:677–687.
  • Thirty Years Added to the Life of Man. New York Times. 1926 Dec 29; p. 1.
  • MacDougall D. The soul: hypothesis concerning soul substance together with experimental evidence of the existence of such substance. Am Med. 1907;2:240–243.
  • Bose JC. The mechanism of life. Mod Rev. (Calcutta). 1926;40:667–672.
  • Raber O. Principles of plant physiology. New York: MacMillan; 1932. 353–354.
  • Molisch H. The movement of sap in plants. Nature. 1928;122:168–169.
  • Molisch H. The movement of sap in plants. Science. 1929;69:217–218. doi:10.1126/science.69.1782.217-a.
  • Molisch H. Nervous impulse in Mimosa pudica. Nature. 1929;123:562–563.
  • F. Thone to D. T. MacDougal, 27 Feb. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 8.
  • D. T. MacDougal to F. Thone, 8 Mar. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 8.
  • Oppenheimer HR. In memory of Hans Molisch. Palestine J Bot. 1938;1:98–102. Rehovot Series.
  • Molisch H. Der Einfluss einer Pflanze au die andere – allelopathie. Jena: Fischer; 1937.
  • Goldschmidt RB. In and out of the ivory tower. Seattle: University of Washington Press; 1960. p. 260–261.
  • Weindling P. Weimar eugenics: the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Anthropology, Human Heredity and Eugenics in social context. Ann Sci. 1985;42:303–318. doi:10.1080/00033798500200221.
  • Mukherje V. Jagadis Chandra Bose. New Delhi: Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India; 1983. 12.
  • Gupta M. Jagadischandra Bose: a biography. Bombay: Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan; 1964. p. 21.
  • Savishinsky J. The volunteer and the sannyasin: archetypes of retirement in America and India. Int J Aging Hum Dev. 2004;59:25–41.
  • Kaempffert W. What Plants Feel. McClure’s Mag. 1915 April;44:67–76.
  • Huxley A. Jesting Pilate: an intellectual holyday. New York: George H. Doran Company; 1926. p. 175.
  • Peirce GJ. Sir Jagadis Bose and his latest book. Science. 1927;66:621–622. doi:10.1126/science.66.1721.621.
  • Bringing the Type-Casting Plant Within the Reach of the Small Printer. Scientific American. 1917 Apr 28;116:426, 430, p. 430.
  • Burlingame LL, Heath H, Martin EG, Peirce GJ. General biology. New York: Henry Holt and Company; 1922. p. 526–528; 554.
  • American Philosophical Society, American Eugenics Society Records, Mss.575.06. Am3, folder: AES Membership Campaign, 1925.
  • G. J. Peirce to D. T. MacDougal, 23 Feb. 1928, UA AZ356, Box 16, Folder 13.
  • Raber O. Principles of plant physiology. New York: MacMillan Co.; 1928.
  • G. J. Peirce to D. T. MacDougal, 5 Jul. 1928, UA AZ356, Box 16, Folder 13.
  • Persson GA. Have plants a heart beat? Sci Am. 1929;140:393–396. doi:10.1038/scientificamerican0529-393.
  • Bose JC. Plant autographs and their revelations. New York: The MacMillan Company; 1927. p. 170–171.
  • Flexner A, Medical education in the United States and Canada: a report to the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.” New York: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching; 1910. p. 33.
  • Mt. Clemens Hotel Man Didn’t Like the Chicago Mayor’s Proposed Guests. Marshall Evening Chronicle (Marshall, Michigan) 1931 Mar 2.;p. 1.
  • Longstaff ND. The mineral bath era. In: Magee DM editor. Centennial history of Mount Clemens, Michigan. 1879–1979. Mount Clemens Public Library; 1980. p. 81–96.
  • Moore C. History of Michigan. Chicago: Lewis Publishing Company; 1915. Vol. II. p. 846–847.
  • Persson GA. Treatment of chronic diseases at spas, particularly with reference to the modern conception of radium emanation. N Y Med J. 1912;95:1038–1042.
  • A. G. Ingalls to D. T. MacDougal, 3 Jun. 1926, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • D. T. MacDougal to A. G. Ingalls, 8 Jun. 1926, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • A. G. Ingalls to D. T. MacDougal, 29 Jun. 1926, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • A. G. Ingalls to D. T. MacDougal, 16 Feb. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • D. T. MacDougal to A. G. Ingalls, 26 Mar. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • No Heartbeats in Plants. The Science News-Letter, 1929; 15:241.
  • D. T. MacDougal to A. G. Ingalls, Aug. 13, 1926, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • Bose JC. The “Praying” palm tree. Transactions of the Bose Research Institute 1918;1:5–30.
  • Puttonen E, Briese C, Mandlburger G, Wieser M, Pfennigbauer M, et al. Quantification of overnight movement of birch (Betula pendula) branches and foliage with short interval terrestrial laser scanning. Frontiers in Plant Science, 2016;7:222.
  • Hatcher BA. Remembering Rammohan: an essay on the (Re‐)emergence of modern Hinduism. Hist Religions. 2006;46:50–80. doi:10.1086/507928.
  • Kopf D. The Brahmo Samaj and the shaping of the modern Indian mind. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1979.
  • Gosling DL. Science and the Indian tradition: when Tagore met Einstein. Oxon: Routledge; 2007. 17.
  • Bose JC. Is the plant a sentient being[?]. Century Mag. 1929;117:385–393.
  • Chatterjee S. Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose: looking beyond the idiom. In: Paranjape M, editor. Science, spirituality and the modernization of India. New Delhi (London and New York): Anthem Press; 2008. p. 65–95.
  • Foxe B. Long journey home: a biography of Margaret Noble (Nivedita). London: Rider and Company; 1975. p. 168.
  • MacDougal DT, Overton JB. Sap flow and pressure in trees. Science, 1927;65:189–190.
  • D. T. MacDougal to E. E. Free, 15 Jul. 1926, UA AZ356 Box 13, Folder 5.
  • A. G. Ingalls to D. T. MacDougal, 16 Feb. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • D. T. MacDougal to A. G. Ingalls, 1 Apr. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 28, Folder 3.
  • E. E. Slosson to D. T. MacDougal, 18 Jan. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 8.
  • D. T. MacDougal to E. E. Slosson, 31 Jan. 1929, UA AZ356, Box 13, Folder 8.
  • Brimble LJF. Problems of Plant Physiology. Nature. 1930;125:438–441. doi:10.1038/125438a0.
  • Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Vegetable. http:// www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vegetable
  • Dasgupta S. Jagadis Chandra Bose and the Indian response to Western science. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1999.
  • MacDougal DT. The mechanism of movement and transmission of impulses in Mimosa and other “sensitive” plants: a review with some additional experiments. Bot Gaz. 1896;22:293–300. doi:10.1086/327415.
  • D. T. MacDougal to H. H. Dixon, 6 Jun. 1928, UA AZ356, Box 18, Folder 8.
  • Arthur JC, MacDougal DT. Living plants and their properties: a collection of essays. New York: Baker and Taylor; 1898.
  • Austin M. Experiences facing death. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merril; 1931. 241.
  • Cattell JM, Brimhall DR. American men of science. 3rd ed. Garrison: The Science Press; 1921.
  • Godlewski E. Zur Theorie der Wasserbewegung in den Pflanzen. Jahrb Wiss Bot. 1884;15:569–630.
  • Canny MJ. A new theory for the ascent of sap – cohesion supported by tissue tension. Ann Bot. 1995;75:343–357.
  • MacDougal DT. A half century of plant physiology. Ann Missouri Bot Garden. 1932;19:31–43. doi:10.2307/2394171.
  • Taiz L, Zeiger E. Plant physiology. Sunderland, Sinauer Associates, Inc.; 2010.