2,711
Views
148
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The impact of theory on the effectiveness of worksite physical activity interventions: a meta-analysis and meta-regression

, &
Pages 33-73 | Received 15 Jul 2010, Accepted 14 Oct 2010, Published online: 15 Feb 2011

References

  • Abraham , C. and Graham-Rowe , E. 2009 . Are worksite interventions effective in increasing physical activity? A systematic review and meta-analysis . Health Psychology Review , 3 : 108 – 144 .
  • Abraham , C. and Michie , S. 2008 . A taxonomy of behavior change techniques used in interventions . Health Psychology , 27 : 379 – 387 .
  • Ajzen , I. 1985 . From intentions to actions: A theory of planned behavior . In J. Kuhl & J. Beckman , Action control: From cognition to behaviour (pp. 11 – 39 ). Heidelberg : Springer .
  • Ajzen , I. and Fishbein , M. 1980 . Understanding attitudes and predicting social behaviour , Englewood Cliffs , NJ : Prentice-Hall .
  • Albarracin , D. , Gillette , J.C. , Earl , A.N. , Glasman , L.R. , Durantini , M.R. and Ho , M.H. 2005 . A test of major assumptions about behavior change: A comprehensive look at the effects of passive and active HIV-prevention interventions since the beginning of the epidemic . Psychological Bulletin , 131 : 856 – 897 .
  • Allender , S. , Foster , C. , Scarborough , P. and Rayner , M. 2007 . The burden of physical activity-related ill health in the UK . Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health , 61 : 344 – 348 .
  • APA-Task-Force . 1976 . Contributions of psychology to health research: Patterns, problems, and potentials . American Psychologist , 31 , 263 – 274 .
  • Atlantis , E. , Chow , C.M. , Kirby , A. and Singh , M.A.F. 2004 . Worksite intervention effects on physical health: An RCT . Health Promotion International , 21 : 191 – 200 .
  • Baron , R.M. and Kenny , D.A. 1986 . The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psycholofical research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 51 : 1173 – 1182 .
  • Bartholomew , L.K. , Parcel , G.S. , Kok , G. and Gottlieb , N. 2001 . Intervention mapping: Developing theory and evidence-based health education programs , Mountain View , CA : Mayfield .
  • Bartholomew , L.K. , Parcel , G.S. , Kok , G. and Gottlieb , N. 2006 . Planning health promotion programs: An intervention mapping approach , San Francisco , CA : Jossey-Bass .
  • Blissmer , B. and McAuley , E. 2002 . Testing the requirements of stages of physical activity amongst adults: The comparitive effectiveness of stage-matched, miss-matched, standard care, and control interventions . Annals of Behavioral Medicine , 24 : 181 – 189 .
  • Borenstein , M. , Hedges , L.V. , Higgins , J. and Rothstein , H. 2005 . Comprehensive meta-analysis version 2 , Englewood , NJ : Biostat .
  • Borenstein , M. , Hedges , L.V. , Higgins , J. and Rothstein , H. 2009 . Introduction to meta-analysis , Chichester : Wiley .
  • Brand , R. , Schlicht , W. , Grossmann , K. and Duhnsen , R. 2006 . Effects of a physical exercise intervention on employees’ perceptions of quality of life: A randomized controlled trial . Sozial-Und Praventivmedizin , 51 : 14 – 23 .
  • Brox , J.I. and Froystein , O. 2005 . Health-related quality of life and sickness absence in community nursing home employees: Randomized controlled trial of physical exercise . Occupational Medicine-Oxford , 55 : 558 – 563 .
  • Brug , J. , Oenema , A. and Ferreria , I. 2005 . Theory, evidence and intervention mapping to improve behavior nutrition and physical activity interventions . International Journal of Nutrition and Physical Activity , 2 : 1 – 7 .
  • Campbell , M.K. , Tessaro , I. , DeVellis , B. , Benedict , S. , Kelsey , K. , Belton , L. , & Sanhueza , A. , 2002 . Effects of a tailored health promotion program for female blue-collar workers: Health works for women . Preventive Medicine , 34 , 313 – 323 .
  • Cardinal , B.J. and Sachs , M.L. 1996 . Effects of mail-mediated, stage-matched exercise behavior change strategies on female adults’ leisure-time exercise behavior . Journal of Sports Medicine & Physical Fitness , 36 : 100 – 107 .
  • Chenoweth , D. and Leutzinger , J. 2006 . The economic cost of physical inactivity and excess weight in American adults . Journal of Physical Activity and Health , 3 : 148 – 163 .
  • Cochran , W.G. 1954 . The combination of estimates from different experiments . Biometrics , 10 : 101 – 129 .
  • Cohen , J. 1988 . Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences, () , 2nd ed. . New Jersey : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Cohen , J. 1992 . A power primer . Psychological Bulletin , 112 : 155 – 159 .
  • Conn , V.S. , Hafdahl , A.R. , Cooper , P.S. , Brown , L.M. and Lusk , S.L. 2009 . Meta-analysis of workplace physical activity interventions . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 37 : 330 – 339 .
  • Cooper , H. and Hedges , L.V. 1994 . The handbook of research synthesis , New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
  • DeCoster , J. ( 2009 ). Meta-analysis notes . Retrieved from http://www.stat-help.com/notes.html
  • Department of Culture, Media and Sport . 2002 . Game plan: A strategy for delivering government's sport and physical activity objectives . Retrieved from http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/media/cabinetoffice/strategy/assets/game_plan_report.pdf
  • DerSimonian , R. and Laird , N. 1986 . Meta-analysis in clinical trials . Controlled Clinical Trials , 7 : 177 – 188 .
  • Dishman , R.K. , DeJoy , D.M. , Wilson , M.G. and Vandenberg , R.J. 2009 . Move to improve: A randomized workplace trial to increase physical activity . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 36 : 133 – 141 .
  • Dishman , R.K. , Oldenburg , B. , O'Neal , H. and Shephard , R.J. 1998 . Worksite physical activity interventions . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 15 : 344 – 361 .
  • DoH . 2004 . At least five a week: Evidence on the impact of physical activity and its relationship to health: A report from the Chief Medical Officer . London. Retrieved from http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/DH_4080994
  • Dombrowski , S.U. , Sniehotta , F.F. , Avenel , A. and Coyne , J.C. 2007 . Towards a cumulative science of behaviour change: Do current conduct and reporting of behavioural interventions fall short of best practice? . Psychology and Health , 22 : 869 – 874 .
  • Dugdill , L. , Brettle , A. , Hulme , C. , McCluskey , S. and Long , A.F. 2008 . Workplace physical activity interventions: A systematic review . International Journal of Worlplace Health Management , 1 : 20 – 40 .
  • Duval , S. and Tweedie , R. 2000a . A non-parametric ‘trim and fill’ method of accounting for publication bias in meta-analysis . Journal of the American Statistical Association , 95 : 89 – 98 .
  • Duval , S. and Tweedie , R. 2000b . Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis . Biometrics , 56 : 455 – 463 .
  • Elbel , R. , Aldana , S. , Bloswick , D. and Lyon , J.L. 2003 . A pilot study evaluating a peer led and professional led physical activity intervention with blue-collar employees: Work . Journal of Prevention. Assessment & Rehabilitation , 21 : 199 – 210 .
  • Elliot , D.L. , Goldberg , L. , Kuehl , K.S. , Moe , E.L. , Breger , R.K. and Pickering , M.A. 2007 . The PHLAME (promoting healthy lifestyles: Alternative models’ effects) firefighter study: Outcomes of two models of behavior change . Journal of Occupational & Environmental Medicine , 49 : 204 – 213 .
  • Evans , L. and Hardy , L. 2002 . Injury rehabilitation: A goal setting study . Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport , 73 : 310 – 319 .
  • Evers , K.E. , Prochaska , J.M. , Driskell , M.M. , Cummins , C.O. , Prochaska , J.O. and Velicer , W.F. 2003 . Strengths and weaknesses of health behaviour change programs on the internet . Journal of Health Psychology , 13 : 531 – 543 .
  • Field , A. 2001 . Meta-analysis of correlation coefficients: A Monte Carlo comparison of fixed and random effects methods . Psychological Methods , 6 : 161 – 180 .
  • Fishbein , M. and Yzer , M.C. 2003 . Using theory to design effective health behaviour interventions . Communication Theory , 13 : 164 – 183 .
  • Freeman , G.H. and Halton , J.H. 1951 . Note on exact treatment of contingency, goodness of fit and other problems of significance . Biometrics , 38 : 141 – 149 .
  • Friedman , H.S. and Adler , N.E. 2007 . “ The history and background of health psychology ” . In Foundations of health psychology , Edited by: Friedman , H.S. and Silver , R.C. 3 – 18 . New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Gilson , N. , McKenna , J. , Cooke , C. and Brown , W. 2007 . Walking towards health in a university community: A feasibility study . Preventive Medicine , 44 : 167 – 169 .
  • Griffin , S. , Kinmonth , A.L. , Skinner , C.S. and Kelly , J. 1999 . Educational and psychosocial interventions for adults with diabetes , London : British Diabetic Association .
  • Grønningsäter , H. , Hytten , K. , Skauli , G. , Christiensen , C.C. and Ursin , H. 1992 . Improved health and coping by physical exercise or cognitive behavioural stress management traning in a work environment . Psychology and Health , 7 : 147 – 163 .
  • Gundewall , B. , Liljeqvist , M. and Hansson , T. 1993 . Primary prevention of back symptoms and absence from work: A prospective randomised controlled trial among hospital employees . Spine , 18 : 587 – 594 .
  • Hagger , M. , Wood , C. and Chatzisarantis , N. 2010 . Ego depletion and the strength model of self-control: A meta-analysis . Psychological Bulletin , 136 : 495 – 525 .
  • Hardeman , W. , Sutton , S. , Griffin , S. , Johnston , M. , White , A.J. , Wareham , N.J. , & Kinmonth , A.L. , 2005 . A causal modelling approach to the development of theory-based behaviour change programmes for trial evaluation . Health Education Research , 20 , 676 – 687 .
  • Hedges , L.V. and Olkin , I. 1985 . Statisical methods for meta-analysis , Orlando , FL : Academic Press .
  • Higgins , J. and Thompson , S. 2002 . Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis . Statistics in Medicine , 21 : 1539 – 1558 .
  • Higgins , J. , Thompson , S. , Deeks , J. and Altman , D. 2003 . Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysis . British Medical Journal , 327 : 557 – 560 .
  • Hunter , J.E. and Schmidt , F.L. 2004 . Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting for error and bias in research findings , 2nd ed. , London : Sage .
  • Ishii , A. , Nakiri , M. , Nagatomi , K. , Tsuji , Y. , Hoshiko , M. , Yamaguchi , Y. , … Ishitake , T. , 2007 . Effect of a physical activity improvement program using the transtheoretical model at a small-scale company . Kurume Medical Journal , 54 , 1 – 8 .
  • Kampenes , V.B. , Dyba , T. , Hannay , J.E. and Sjøberg , D.I.K. 2007 . A systematic review of effect size in software engineering experiments . Information and Software Technology , 49 : 1073 – 1086 .
  • Kok , G. , Schlaama , H. , Ruiter , R.A.C. and Van Empelen , P. 2004 . Intervention mapping: A protocol for applying health psychology theory to prevention programmes . Journal of Health Psychology , 9 : 85 – 98 .
  • Lawlor , D.A. , Ness , A.R. , Cope , A.M. , Davis , A. , Insall , P. and Riddoch , C. 2003 . The challenges of evaluating environmental interventions to increase the population levels of physical activity: The case of the UK cycle network . Journal of Epidemiological Community Health , 57 : 96 – 101 .
  • Lee , C. and White , S.W. 1997 . Controlled trial of a minimal-intervention exercise program for middle-aged working women . Psychology & Health , 12 : 361 – 374 .
  • Liberati , A. , Altman , D.G. , Tetzlaff , J. , Mulrow , C. , Gøtzsche , P.C. , Ioannidis , J.P.A. , … Moher , D. 2009 . The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: Explanation and elaboration . Research Methods and Reporting , 339 . Retrieved from http://www.bmj.com/content/339/bmj.b2700
  • Lippke , S. and Ziegelmann , J.P. 2008 . Theory-based health behaviour change: Developing, testing, and applying theories for evidence-based interventions . Applied Psychology: An International Review , 57 : 598 – 716 .
  • Lipsey , M.W. 2003 . Those confounded moderators in meta-analysis: Good, bad and ugly . The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences , 587 ( 69 ) : 69 – 81 .
  • Logan , P.A. , Gladman , J.R.F. , Avery , A. , Walker , M.F. , Dyas , J. and Groom , L. 2004 . Randomised controlled trial of an occupational therapy intervention to increase outdoor mobility after stroke . British Medical Journal , 11 : 1372 – 1375 .
  • Marcus , B.H. and Forsyth , L.H. 1999 . How are we doing with physical activity? . American Journal of Health Promotion , 14 : 118 – 124 .
  • Marteau , T. , Dieppe , P. , Foy , R. and Kinmonth , A.L. 2006 . Behavioural medicine: Changing our behaviour . British Medical Journal , 332 : 437 – 438 .
  • Michie , S. and Abraham , C. 2004 . Interventions to change health behaviours: Evidence based or evidence inspired? . Psychology and Health , 19 : 29 – 49 .
  • Michie , S. , Abraham , C. , Whittington , C. , McAteer , J. , & Gupta , S. 2009 . Effective techniques in health eating and physical activity interventions: a meta-regression . Health Psychology , 28 , 690 – 701 .
  • Michie , S. and Prestwich , A. 2010 . Are interventions theory-based? Development of a theory coding scheme . Health Psychology , 29 : 1 – 8 .
  • Michie , S. , Sheeran , P. and Rothman , A.J. 2007 . Advancing the science of behaviour change. Invited editorial . Psychology & Health , 22 : 249 – 253 .
  • Napolitano , M.A. , Fotheringham , M. , Tate , D. , Sciamanna , C. , Leslie , E. , Owen , N. , … Marcus , B. , 2003 . Evaluation of an internet-based physical activity intervention: A preliminary investigation . Annals of Behavioral Medicine , 25 , 92 – 99 .
  • Nichols , J.F. , Wellman , E. , Caparosa , S. , Sallis , J.F. , Calfas , K.J. and Rowe , R. 2000 . Impact of a worksite behavioral skills intervention . American Journal of Health Promotion , 14 : 218 – 221 .
  • Noar , S.M. , Benac , C. and Harris , M. 2007 . Does tailoring matter? Meta-analytic review of tailored print health behabiour change interventions . Psychological Bulletin , 133 : 673 – 693 .
  • Painter , J.E. , Borba , C.P.C. , Hynes , M. , Mays , D. and Glanz , K. 2008 . The use of theory in health behaviour research from 2000 to 2005: A systematic review . Annals of Behavioral Medicine , 35 : 358 – 362 .
  • Patall , E.A. , Cooper , H. and Robinson , J.C. 2008 . The effects of choice on intrinsic motivation and related outcomes: A meta-analysis of research findings . Psychological Bulletin , 2 : 270 – 300 .
  • Peterson , M. and Aldana , S. 1999 . Improving exercise behavior: An application of the stages of change model in a worksite setting . American Journal of Health Promotion , 13 : 229 – 232 .
  • Pinto , B.M. , Friedman , R. , Marcus , B.H. , Kelley , H. , Tennstedt , S. and Gillman , M.W. 2002 . Effects of a computer-based, telephone-counseling system on physical activity . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 23 : 113 – 120 .
  • Plotnikoff , R.C. , Brunet , S. , Courneya , K.S. , Spence , J.C. , Birkett , N.J. , Marcus , B. , & Whitely , J. , 2007 . The efficacy of stage-matched and standard public health materials for promoting physical activity in the workplace: The physical activity workplace study (PAWS) . American Journal of Health Promotion , 21 , 501 – 509 .
  • Plotnikoff , R.C. , McCargar , L.J. , Wilson , P.M. and Loucaides , C.A. 2005 . Efficacy of an e-mail intervention for the promotion of physical activity and nutrition behavior in the workplace context . American Journal of Health Promotion , 19 : 422 – 429 .
  • Pohjonen , T. and Ranta , R. 2001 . Effects of worksite physical exercise intervention on physical fitness, perceived health status, and work ability among home care workers: Five-year follow-up . Preventive Medicine , 32 : 465 – 475 .
  • Pratt , C.A. 2008 . Findings from the 2007 active living research conference implications for future research . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 34 : 366 – 368 .
  • Prochaska , J. , DiClemente , C.C. and Norcross , J.C. 1992 . In search of how people change: Applications to addictive behaviors . American Psychologist , 47 : 1102 – 1114 .
  • Proper , K.I. , Hildebrandt , V.H. , Van der Beek , A.J. , Twisk , J.W. and Van Mechelen , W. 2003 . Effect of individual counseling on physical activity fitness and health: A randomized controlled trial in a workplace setting . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 24 : 218 – 226 .
  • Proper , K.I. , Staal , J.B. , Hildebrandt , V.H. , Van der Beek , A.J. and Van Mechelen , W. 2002 . Effectiveness of physical activity programs at worksites with respect to work-related outcomes. Scandinavian Journal of Work . Environment & Health , 28 : 75 – 84 .
  • Proper , K.I. and Van Mechelen , W. 2007 . Effectiveness and economic impact of worksite interventions to promote physical activity and diet , Dalian , , China : World Health Organisation .
  • Purath , J. , Miller , A.M. , McCabe , G. and Wilbur , J. 2004 . A brief intervention to increase physical activity in sedentary working women . Canadian Journal of Nursing Research , 36 : 76 – 91 .
  • Rosenstock , I. 1966 . Why people use health services . Millbank Memorial Fund Quarterly , 44 ( Suppl ) : 94 – 127 .
  • Rothman , A.J. 2004 . Is there nothing more practical than a good theory?: Why innovations and advances in health behaviour change will arise if interventions are used to test and refine theory . International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition and Physical Activity , 1 . Retrieved from http://ijnpa.org/content/2011/2011/2011
  • Schwarzer , R. 1992 . “ Self-efficacy in the adoption and maintenance of health behaviors: Theoretcial approaches and a new model ” . In Self-efficacy: Thought control of action , Edited by: Schwarzer , R. 217 – 242 . Washington , DC : Hemisphere .
  • Shephard , R.J. 1996 . Worksite fitness and exercise programs: A review of methodology and health impact . American Journal of Health Promotion , 10 : 436 – 452 .
  • Shrout , P.E. and Bolger , N. 2002 . Mediation in experimental and non-experimental studies: New procedures and recommendations . Psychological Methods , 7 : 422 – 425 .
  • Speck , B.J. and Looney , S.W. 2001 . Effects of a minimal intervention to increase physical activity in women: Daily activity records . Nursing Research , 50 : 374 – 378 .
  • Spittaels , H. , De Bourdeaudhuij , I. , Brug , J. and Vandelanotte , C. 2007 . Effectiveness of an online computer-tailored physical activity intervention in a real-life setting . Health Education Research , 22 : 385 – 396 .
  • Spittaels , H. , De Bourdeaudhuij , I. and Vandelanotte , C. 2007 . Evaluation of a website-delivered computer-tailored intervention for increasing physical activity in the general population . Preventive Medicine: An International Journal Devoted to Practice and Theory , 44 : 209 – 217 .
  • Sternfeld , B. , Block , C. , Quesenberry , C.P. and Block , T.J. 2009 . Improving diet and physical activity with ALIVE: A worksite randomized trial . American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 36 : 475 – 483 .
  • Sutton , A.J. and Higgins , J. 2008 . Recent developments in meta-analysis . Statistics in Medicine , 27 : 625 – 650 .
  • Talvi , A.I. , Jarvisalo , J.O. and Knuts , L.R. 1999 . A health promotion programme for oil refinery employees: Changes of health promotion needs observed at three years . Occupational Medicine-Oxford , 49 : 93 – 101 .
  • Thompson , P.D. and Higgins , J. 2002 . How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted? . Statistics in Medicine , 21 : 1559 – 1573 .
  • Troiano , R.P. , Berrigan , D. and Dodd , K.W. 2008 . Physical activity in the United States as measured by accelerometer . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise , 40 : 181 – 188 .
  • van Wier , M.F. , Ariens , G.A. , Dekkers , J.C. , Hendriksen , I.J. , Smid , T. , & van Mechelen , W. 2009 . Phone and e-mail counselling are effective for weight management in an overweight working population: A randomized controlled trial . BMC Public Health , 9 (online) , 491 .
  • Warburton , D.E.R. , Nicol , C.H. and Bredin , S.S.D. 2006 . Health benefits of physical activity: The evidence . Canadian Medical Association Journal , 174 : 801 – 809 .
  • Webb , T.L. , Joseph , J. , Yardley , L. and Michie , S. 2010 . Using the internet to promote health behaviour change: A meta-analysis of the impact of theoretical basis, use of behavior change techniques, and mode of delivery on efficacy . Journal of Medical Internet Research , 12 : e1
  • Webb , T.L. and Sheeran , P. 2006 . Does changing behavioral intentions engender behaviour change? A meta-analysis of experimental evidence . Psychological Bulletin , 132 : 249 – 268 .
  • World Health Organisation . 2004 . Global strategy on diet, physical activity and health . Retrieved from http://who.int/hpr/global.strategy.shtml

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.