Advanced search
Publication Cover
Acta Orthopaedica Latest Articles
Journal homepage
5,806
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Article

Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy: did it ever work?

A narrative review from basic research to proposed disease framework and science of clinical practice

Aleksi Reitoa Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Tampere University Hospital, and Faculty of Medicine and Health Technology, Tampere University, Finland;Correspondence[email protected]
,
Ian A Harrisb Ingham Institute for Applied Medical Research, South Western Sydney Clinical School, UNSW Sydney, Australia;;
&
Teemu Karjalainenc Central Finland Hospital, Jyväskylä, Finland
Published online: 04 Oct 2021

  • Abram S G F, Judge A, Beard D J, Carr A J, Price A J. Long-term rates of knee arthroplasty in a cohort of 834 393 patients with a history of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Bone Joint J 2019a; 101-B(9): 1071–80.
  • Abram S G F, Judge A, Beard D J, Wilson H A, Price A J. Temporal trends and regional variation in the rate of arthroscopic knee surgery in England: analysis of over 1.7 million procedures between 1997 and 2017. Has practice changed in response to new evidence? Br J Sports Med 2019b; 53(24): 1533–8.
  • Abram S G F, Hopewell S, Monk A P, Bayliss L E, Beard D J, Price A J. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for meniscal tears of the knee: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med 2020; 54(11): 652–63.
  • Agusti A. The disease model: implications for clinical practice. Eur Respir J 2018; 51(4): 1800188. .
  • Annandale T. Excision of the internal semilunar cartilage, resulting in perfect restoration of the joint-movements. BMJ 1889; 1(1467): 291–2.
  • Ashraf S, Wibberley H, Mapp P I, Hill R, Wilson D, Walsh D A. Increased vascular penetration and nerve growth in the meniscus: a potential source of pain in osteoarthritis. Ann Rheum Dis 2011; 70(3): 523–9.
  • Assimakopoulos A P, Katonis P G, Agapitos M V, Exarchou E I. The innervation of the human meniscus. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1992; (275): 232–6.
  • Australian Knee Society. Position statement from the australian knee society on arthroscopic surgery of the knee, including reference to the presence of osteoarthritis or degenerative joint disease: updated october 2016. Orthop J Sports Med 2017; 5(9): 2325967117728677.
  • Ayral X, Pickering E H, Woodworth T G, Mackillop N, Dougados M. Synovitis: a potential predictive factor of structural progression of medial tibiofemoral knee osteoarthritis—results of a 1 year longitudinal arthroscopic study in 422 patients. Osteoarthr Cartil 2005; 13(5): 361–7.
  • Baratz M E, Fu F H, Mengato R. Meniscal tears: the effect of meniscectomy and of repair on intraarticular contact areas and stress in the human knee. A preliminary report. Am J Sports Med 1986; 14(4): 270–5.
  • Barnett A G, van der Pols J C, Dobson A J. Regression to the mean: what it is and how to deal with it. Int J Epidemiol 2005; 34(1): 215–20.
  • Beaufils P, Becker R, Kopf S, Englund M, Verdonk R, Ollivier M, et al. Surgical management of degenerative meniscus lesions: the 2016 ESSKA meniscus consensus. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2017a; 25(2): 335–46.
  • Beaufils P, Becker R, Kopf S, Matthieu O, Pujol N. The knee meniscus: management of traumatic tears and degenerative lesions. EFORT Open Reviews 2017b; 2(5): 195–203.
  • Bhattacharyya T, Gale D, Dewire P, Totterman S, Gale M E, McLaughlin S, et al. The clinical importance of meniscal tears demonstrated by magnetic resonance imaging in osteoarthritis of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2003; 85(1): 4–9.
  • Campbell J, Harte A, Kerr D P, Murray P. The location of knee pain and pathology in patients with a presumed meniscus tear: preoperative symptoms compared to arthroscopic findings. Ir J Med Sci 2014; 183(1): 23–31.
  • Chauffard A. Address in medicine, ON MEDICAL PROGNOSIS: ITS METHODS, ITS EVOLUTION, ITS LIMITATIONS: delivered at the seventeenth international congress of medicine. BMJ 1913; 2(2745): 286–90.
  • Croft P, Altman D G, Deeks J J, Dunn KM, Hay A D, Hemingway H, et al. The science of clinical practice: disease diagnosis or patient prognosis? Evidence about “what is likely to happen” should shape clinical practice. BMC Med 2015; 13: 20.
  • Day B, Mackenzie WG, Shim SS, Leung G. The vascular and nerve supply of the human meniscus. Arthroscopy 1985; 1(1): 58–62.
  • Décary S, Fallaha M, Frémont P, Martel-Pelletier J, Pelletier J-P, Feldman D E, et al. Diagnostic validity of combining history elements and physical examination tests for traumatic and degenerative symptomatic meniscal tears. PM R 2018; 10(5): 472–82.
  • Doherty M, Dieppe P. The “placebo” response in osteoarthritis and its implications for clinical practice. Osteoarthritis Cartilage 2009; 17(10): 1255–62.
  • Eitner A, Hofmann G O, Schaible H-G. Mechanisms of osteoarthritic pain: studies in humans and experimental models. Front Mol Neurosci 2017; 10: 349.
  • Englund M, Lohmander L S. Risk factors for symptomatic knee osteoarthritis fifteen to twenty-two years after meniscectomy. Arthritis Rheum 2004 ep; 50(9): 2811–19.
  • Englund M, Niu J, Guermazi A, Roemer F W, Hunter D J, Lynch J A, et al. Effect of meniscal damage on the development of frequent knee pain, aching, or stiffness. Arthritis Rheum 2007; 56(12): 4048–54.
  • Englund M, Guermazi A, Gale D, Hunter D J, Aliabadi P, Clancy M, et al. Incidental meniscal findings on knee MRI in middle-aged and elderly persons. N Engl J Med 2008; 359(11): 1108–15.
  • Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group. Evidence-based medicine: a new approach to teaching the practice of medicine. JAMA 1992; 268(17): 2420–5.
  • Fairbank T J. Knee joint changes after meniscectomy. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1948; 30B(4): 664–70.
  • Farina E M, Lowenstein N A, Chang Y, Arant K R, Katz J N, Matzkin E G. Meniscal and mechanical symptoms are associated with cartilage damage, not meniscal pathology. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2021; 103(5): 381–8.
  • Felson D T, Niu J, Guermazi A, Roemer F, Aliabadi P, Clancy M, et al. Correlation of the development of knee pain with enlarging bone marrow lesions on magnetic resonance imaging. Arthritis Rheum 2007; 56(9): 2986–92.
  • Fu K, Robbins S R, McDougall J J. Osteoarthritis: the genesis of pain. Rheumatology 2018; 57(Suppl_4): iv43–iv50.
  • Gauffin H, Tagesson S, Meunier A, Magnusson H, Kvist J. Knee arthroscopic surgery is beneficial to middle-aged patients with meniscal symptoms: a prospective, randomised, single-blinded study. Osteoarthritis Cartilage 2014; 22(11): 1808–16.
  • Gauffin H, Sonesson S, Meunier A, Magnusson H, Kvist J. Knee arthroscopic surgery in middle-aged patients with meniscal symptoms: a 3-year follow-up of a prospective, randomized study. Am J Sports Med 2017; 45(9): 2077–84.
  • Gear M W. The late results of meniscectomy. Br J Surg 1967; 54(4): 270–2.
  • Grönblad M, Korkala O, Liesi P, Karaharju E. Innervation of synovial membrane and meniscus. Acta Orthop Scand 1985; 56(6): 484–6.
  • Hall M J, Schwartzman A, Zhang J, Liu X. Ambulatory surgery data from hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers: united states, 2010. Natl Health Stat Report 2017; (102): 1–15.
  • Hare K B, Stefan Lohmander L, Kise N J, Risberg M A, Roos E M. Middle-aged patients with an MRI-verified medial meniscal tear report symptoms commonly associated with knee osteoarthritis. Acta Orthop 2017; 88(6): 664–9.
  • Harris I. When the placebo effect is not an effect. Acta Orthop 2021; 92 (5): 501–22.
  • Herrlin S, Hållander M, Wange P, Weidenhielm L, Werner S. Arthroscopic or conservative treatment of degenerative medial meniscal tears: a prospective randomised trial. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2007; 15(4): 393–401.
  • Hohmann E, Angelo R, Arciero R, Bach B R, Cole B, Cote M, et al. Degenerative meniscus lesions: an expert consensus statement using the modified delphi technique. Arthroscopy 2020; 36(2): 501–12.
  • Holtedahl R, Brox J I, Aune A K, Nguyen D, Risberg M A, Tjomsland O. Changes in the rate of publicly financed knee arthroscopies: an analysis of data from the Norwegian patient registry from 2012 to 2016. BMJ Open 2018; 8(6): e021199.
  • Horga L M, Hirschmann A C, Henckel J, Fotiadou A, Di Laura A, Torlasco C, et al. Prevalence of abnormal findings in 230 knees of asymptomatic adults using 3.0 T MRI. Skeletal Radiol 2020; 49(7): 1099–1107.
  • Howard D H. Trends in the use of knee arthroscopy in adults. JAMA Intern Med 2018; 178(11): 1557–8.
  • Howell R, Kumar N S, Patel N, Tom J. Degenerative meniscus: pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment options. World J Orthop 2014; 5(5): 597–602.
  • Hróbjartsson A, Gøtzsche P C. Is the placebo powerless? An analysis of clinical trials comparing placebo with no treatment. N Engl J Med 2001; 344(21): 1594–1602.
  • Hunter D J, McDougall J J, Keefe F J. The symptoms of osteoarthritis and the genesis of pain. Med Clin North Am 2009; 93(1): 83–100, xi.
  • Jackson J P. Degenerative changes in the knee after meniscectomy. BMJ 1968; 2(5604): 525–7.
  • Jackson R W. From the scalpel to the scope: the history of arthroscopy. Baylor University Medical Center Proceedings 1996; 9(4): 77–9.
  • Jackson R W, Abe I. The role of arthroscopy in the management of disorders of the knee: an analysis of 200 consecutive examinations. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1972; 54(2): 310–22.
  • Jayson M I, Dixon A S. Arthroscopy of the knee in rheumatic diseases. Ann Rheum Dis 1968; 27(6): 503–11.
  • Jones R. II. Derangements of the knee: based upon a personal experience of over five hundred operations. Ann Surg 1909; 50(6): 969–1001.
  • Karelson M C, Jokihaara J, Launonen A P, Huttunen T, Mattila V M. Lower nationwide rates of arthroscopic procedures in 2016 compared with 1997 (634925 total arthroscopic procedures): has the tide turned? Br J Sports Med 2021; 55(18): 1018–23.
  • Katz J N, Brophy R H, Chaisson C E, de Chaves L, Cole B J, Dahm D L, et al. Surgery versus physical therapy for a meniscal tear and osteoarthritis. N Engl J Med 2013; 368(18): 1675–84.
  • Kirkley A, Birmingham T B, Litchfield R B, Giffin J R, Willits K R, Wong C J, et al. A randomized trial of arthroscopic surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee. N Engl J Med 2008; 359(11): 1097–1107.
  • Kise N J, Aga C, Engebretsen L, Roos E M, Tariq R, Risberg M A. Complex tears, extrusion, and larger excision are prognostic factors for worse outcomes 1 and 2 years after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for degenerative meniscal tears: a secondary explorative study of the surgically treated group from the Odense-Oslo Meniscectomy Versus Exercise (OMEX) Trial. Am J Sports Med 2019; 47(10): 2402–11.
  • Kopf S, Beaufils P, Hirschmann MT, Rotigliano N, Ollivier M, Pereira H, et al. Management of traumatic meniscus tears: the 2019 ESSKA meniscus consensus. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2020; 28(4): 1177–94.
  • Krogsgaard M R, Lind M, Jørgensen U. A positive viewpoint regarding arthroscopy for degenerative knee conditions. Acta Orthop 2014; 85(6): 681–2.
  • Lee S M S, Awal W, Vertullo C. Changing practice: incidence of non-reconstructive arthroscopic knee surgery in people over 50 years of age, Australia, 2008–2018. Med J Aust 2020; 212(1): 29–30.
  • Liebensteiner M C, Khosravi I, Hirschmann M T, Heuberer P R, Board of the AGA-Society of Arthroscopy and Joint-Surgery, Thaler M. Massive cutback in orthopaedic healthcare services due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2020; 28(6): 1705–11.
  • Lin Y, Zhang K, Li Q, Li J, Xu B. Innervation of nociceptors in intact human menisci along the longitudinal axis: semi-quantitative histological evaluation and clinical implications. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2019; 20(1): 338.
  • Liu-Bryan R, Terkeltaub R. Emerging regulators of the inflammatory process in osteoarthritis. Nat Rev Rheumatol 2015; 11(1): 35–44.
  • Lubowitz J H, Provencher M T, Rossi M J. Could the New England Journal of Medicine be biased against arthroscopic knee surgery? Part 2. Arthroscopy 2014; 30(6): 654–5.
  • Lyman S, Oh L S, Reinhardt K R, Mandl L A, Katz J N, Levy B A, et al. Surgical decision making for arthroscopic partial meniscectomy in patients aged over 40 years. Arthroscopy 2012; 28(4): 492–501.e1.
  • MacFarlane L A, Yang H, Collins J E, Brophy R H, Cole B J, Spindler K P, et al. Association between baseline “meniscal symptoms” and outcomes of operative and non-operative treatment of meniscal tear in patients with osteoarthritis. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) 2021 Mar 1. Online ahead of print.
  • Macmull S, Gupte C M. (ii) Basic knee arthroscopy: a brief history, surgical techniques and potential complications. Orthop Trauma 2015; 29(1): 6–11.
  • Mapp P I. Innervation of the synovium. Ann Rheum Dis 1995; 54(5): 398–403.
  • Mattila V M, Sihvonen R, Paloneva J, Felländer-Tsai L. Changes in rates of arthroscopy due to degenerative knee disease and traumatic meniscal tears in Finland and Sweden. Acta Orthop 2016; 87(1): 5–11.
  • Merchan E C R, Galindo E. Arthroscope-guided surgery versus nonoperative treatment for limited degenerative osteoarthritis of the femorotibial joint in patients over 50 years of age: a prospective comparative study. Arthroscopy 1993; 9(6): 663–7.
  • Miller R E, Tran P B, Obeidat A M, Raghu P, Ishihara S, Miller R J, et al. The role of peripheral nociceptive neurons in the pathophysiology of osteoarthritis pain. Curr Osteoporos Rep 2015; 13(5): 318–26.
  • Mine T, Kimura M, Sakka A, Kawai S. Innervation of nociceptors in the menisci of the knee joint: an immunohistochemical study. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2000; 120(3-4): 201–4.
  • Moseley J B, O’Malley K, Petersen N J, Menke T J, Brody B A, Kuykendall D H, et al. A controlled trial of arthroscopic surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee. N Engl J Med 2002; 347(2): 81–8.
  • Northmore-Ball M D, Dandy D J, Jackson R W. Arthroscopic, open partial, and total meniscectomy: a comparative study. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1983; 65(4): 400–4.
  • Pihl K, Englund M, Lohmander L S, Jørgensen U, Nissen N, Schjerning J, et al. Signs of knee osteoarthritis common in 620 patients undergoing arthroscopic surgery for meniscal tear. Acta Orthop 2017; 88(1): 90–5.
  • Rockborn P, Gillquist J. Outcome of arthroscopic meniscectomy: a a 13-year physical and radiographic follow-up of 43 patients under 23 years of age. Acta Orthop Scand 1995; 66(2): 113–17.
  • Rongen J J, Rovers M M, van Tienen T G, Buma P, Hannink G. Increased risk for knee replacement surgery after arthroscopic surgery for degenerative meniscal tears: a multi-center longitudinal observational study using data from the osteoarthritis initiative. Osteoarthritis Cartilage 2017; 25(1): 23–9.
  • Rongen J J, van Tienen T G, Buma P, Hannink G. Meniscus surgery is still widely performed in the treatment of degenerative meniscus tears in The Netherlands. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2018; 26(4): 1123–9.
  • Rossi M J, D’Agostino R B, Provencher M T, Lubowitz J H. Could the New England Journal of Medicine be biased against arthroscopic knee surgery? Arthroscopy 2014; 30(5): 536–7.
  • Scanzello C R, McKeon B, Swaim B H, DiCarlo E, Asomugha E U, Kanda V, et al. Synovial inflammation in patients undergoing arthroscopic meniscectomy: molecular characterization and relationship to symptoms. Arthritis Rheum 2011; 63(2): 391–400.
  • Shahriaree H, ed. O’Connor’s textbook of arthroscopic surgery, 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins; 1992.
  • Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Malmivaara A, Itälä A, Joukainen A, Nurmi H, et al. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus sham surgery for a degenerative meniscal tear. N Engl J Med 2013; 369(26): 2515–24.
  • Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Malmivaara A, Itälä A, Joukainen A, Nurmi H, et al. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus placebo surgery for a degenerative meniscus tear: a 2-year follow-up of the randomised controlled trial. Ann Rheum Dis 2018; 77(2): 188–95.
  • Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Malmivaara A, Itälä A, Joukainen A, Kalske J, et al. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for a degenerative meniscus tear: a 5 year follow-up of the placebo-surgery controlled FIDELITY (Finnish Degenerative Meniscus Lesion Study) trial. Br J Sports Med 2020; 54(22): 1332–9.
  • Smith B E, Thacker D, Crewesmith A, Hall M. Special tests for assessing meniscal tears within the knee: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Evid Based Med 2015; 20(3): 88–97.
  • Smith L, Barratt A, Buchbinder R, Harris I A, Doust J, Bell K. Trends in knee magnetic resonance imaging, arthroscopies and joint replacements in older Australians: still too much low-value care? ANZ J Surg 2020; 90(5): 833–9.
  • Smoak J B, Matthews J R, Vinod A V, Kluczynski M A, Bisson L J. An up-to-date review of the meniscus literature: a systematic summary of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Orthop J Sports Med 2020; 8(9): 2325967120950306.
  • Sochacki K R, Mather R C, Nwachukwu B U, Dong D, Nho S J, Cote MP, et al. Sham surgery studies in orthopedic surgery may just be a sham: a systematic review of randomized placebo-controlled trials. Arthroscopy 2020. Epub May 14.
  • Sonesson S, Kvist J, Yakob J, Hedevik H, Gauffin H. Knee arthroscopic surgery in middle-aged patients with meniscal symptoms: a 5-year follow-up of a prospective, randomized study. Orthop J Sports Med 2020; 8(1): 2325967119893920.
  • Stone J A, Salzler M J, Parker D A, Becker R, Harner C D. Degenerative meniscus tears—assimilation of evidence and consensus statements across three continents: state of the art. J ISAKOS 2017a; 2(2): 108–19.
  • Stone O D, Duckworth A D, Curran D P, Ballantyne J A, Brenkel I J. Severe arthritis predicts greater improvements in function following total knee arthroplasty. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2017b; 25(8): 2573–9.
  • Sutherland A G, Cuthbertson B H, Campbell M. Sham surgery studies. Arthroscopy 2014; 30(11): 1389.
  • Tenney B. I. The anatomy and surgery of the internal derangements of the knee-joint. Based on a study of 150 dissected joints and the literature. Ann Surg 1904; 40(1): 1–34.
  • Thorlund J B, Pihl K, Nissen N, Jørgensen U, Fristed J V, Lohmander L S, et al. Conundrum of mechanical knee symptoms: signifying feature of a meniscal tear? Br J Sports Med 2019; 53(5): 299–303.
  • Tinetti M E, Fried T. The end of the disease era. Am J Med 2004; 116(3): 179–85.
  • Van Arkel E R A, Koëter S, Rijk P C, Van Tienen T G, Vincken P W J, Segers M J M, et al. Dutch Guideline on Knee Arthroscopy Part 1, the meniscus: a multidisciplinary review by the Dutch Orthopaedic Association. Acta Orthop 2021; 92(1): 74–80.
  • van de Graaf V A, Noorduyn J C A, Willigenburg N W, Butter I K, de Gast A, Mol B W, et al. Effect of early surgery vs physical therapy on knee function among patients with nonobstructive meniscal tears: the ESCAPE randomized clinical trial. JAMA 2018; 320(13): 1328–37.
  • van de Water R B, Leichtenberg C S, Nelissen R G H H, Kroon H M, Kaptijn H H, Onstenk R, et al. Preoperative radiographic osteoarthritis severity modifies the effect of preoperative pain on pain/function after total knee arthroplasty: results at 1 and 2 years postoperatively. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2019; 101(10): 879–87.
  • Wilson A S, Legg P G, McNeur J C. Studies on the innervation of the medial meniscus in the human knee joint. Anat Rec 1969; 165(4): 485–91.
  • Wynn Parry C B, Nichols P J, Lewis N R. Meniscectomy: a review of 1,723 cases. Ann Phys Med 1958; 4(6): 201–15.
  • Xiao M, Donahue J, Safran M R, Sherman S L, Abrams G D. Administrative databases utilized for sports medicine research demonstrate significant differences in underlying patient demographics and resulting surgical trends. Arthroscopy 2021; 37(1): 282–9.e1

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.