2,743
Views
3
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

What are the appropriate mapping units for ecosystem service assessments? A systematic review

, &
Article: 1888655 | Received 12 May 2020, Accepted 06 Feb 2021, Published online: 31 Mar 2021

References

  • Ala-Hulkko, T., O. Kotavaara, J. Alahuhta, and J. Hjort. 2019. “Mapping Supply and Demand of a Provisioning Ecosystem Service across Europe.” Ecological Indicators 103: 520–20. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2019.04.049.
  • Andrew, M. E., M. A. Wulder, T. A. Nelson, and N. C. Coops. 2015. “Spatial Data, Analysis Approaches, and Information Needs for Spatial Ecosystem Service Assessments: A Review.” Giscience & Remote Sensing 52 (3): 344–373. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/15481603.2015.1033809.
  • Arbuckle, J. L. 2012. IBM®sPSS®AmosTMuser’s Guide. Chicago: IBM Corp.
  • Babu, S. C., and P. Sanyal. 2009. “Chapter 4 - Effects of Technology Adoption and Gender of Household Head: The Issue, Its Importance in Food Security – Application of Cramer’s V and Phi Coefficient.” In Food Security, Poverty and Nutrition Policy Analysis, edited by S. C. Babu and P. Sanyal, 61–72. San Diego: Academic Press.
  • Balvanera, P. 2001. “Conserving Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services.” Science 291 (5511): 2047. doi:https://doi.org/10.1126/science.291.5511.2047.
  • Benis Egoh, E. G., M. B. Drakou, J. M. Dunbar, and L. Willemen. 2012. Indicators for Mapping Ecosystem Services a Review. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
  • Bicking, S., B. Burkhard, M. Kruse, and F. Müller. 2018. “Mapping of Nutrient Regulating Ecosystem Service Supply and Demand on Different Scales in Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.” One Ecosystem 3: e22509. doi:https://doi.org/10.3897/oneeco.3.e22509.
  • Brown, G., and N. Fagerholm. 2015. “Empirical PPGIS/PGIS Mapping of Ecosystem Services: A Review and Evaluation.” Ecosystem Services 13: 119–133.
  • Burkhard, B., F. Kroll, S. Nedkov, and F. Müller. 2012. “Mapping Ecosystem Service Supply, Demand and Budgets.” Ecological Indicators 21: 17–29.
  • Burnett, W. C., P. K. Aggarwal, A. Aureli, H. Bokuniewicz, J. E. Cable, M. A. Charette, E. Kontar, et al. 2006. “Quantifying Submarine Groundwater Discharge in the Coastal Zone via Multiple Methods.” Science of the Total Environment 367: 498–543.
  • Calderón-Contreras, R., and L. E. Quiroz-Rosas. 2017. “Analysing Scale, Quality and Diversity of Green Infrastructure and the Provision of Urban Ecosystem Services: A Case from Mexico City.” Ecosystem Services 23: 127–137.
  • Castillo-Eguskitza, N., B. Martín-López, and M. Onaindia. 2018. “A Comprehensive Assessment of Ecosystem Services: Integrating Supply, Demand and Interest in the Urdaibai Biosphere Reserve.” Ecological Indicators 93: 1176–1189.
  • Chen, C., Y. Wang, J. Jia, L. Mao, and C. D. Meurk. 2019. “Ecosystem Services Mapping in Practice: A Pasteur’s Quadrant Perspective.” Ecosystem Services 40: 101042.
  • Congalton, R. G. 1997. “Exploring and Evaluating the Consequences of Vector-to-Raster and Raster-to-Vector Conversion.” Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing 63: 425–434.
  • Costanza, R., R. D’Arge, S. Naeem, R. V. O’Neil, J. Paruelo, R. G. Raskin, P. Sutton, and D. B. Van. 1997. “The Value of the World’s Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital.” World Environment 25: 3–15. M
  • Crossman, N. D., B. Burkhard, S. Nedkov, L. Willemen, K. Petz, I. Palomo, E. G. Drakou, et al. 2013. “A Blueprint for Mapping and Modelling Ecosystem Services.” Ecosystem Services 4: 4–14.
  • Crouzat, E., M. Mouchet, F. Turkelboom, C. Byczek, J. Meersmans, F. Berger, P. J. Verkerk, and S. Lavorel. 2015. “Assessing Bundles of Ecosystem Services from Regional to Landscape Scale: Insights from the French Alps.” Journal of Applied Ecology 52: 1145–1155.
  • Cui, F., H. Tang, Q. Zhang, B. Wang, and L. Dai. 2019. “Integrating Ecosystem Services Supply and Demand into Optimized Management at Different Scales: A Case Study in Hulunbuir, China.” Ecosystem Services 39: 100984.
  • Czúcz, B., I. Arany, M. Potschin-Young, K. Bereczki, M. Kertész, M. Kiss, R. Aszalós, and R. Haines-Young. 2018. “Where Concepts Meet the Real World: A Systematic Review of Ecosystem Service Indicators and Their Classification Using CICES.” Ecosystem Services 29: 145–157.
  • Duinker, P., N. Steenberg, W. James, N. Robinson, and J. Pamela. 2015. “Neighbourhood-scale Urban Forest Ecosystem Classification.” Journal of Environmental Management 163: 134–145.
  • Englund, O., G. Berndes, and C. Cederberg. 2017. “How to Analyse Ecosystem Services in landscapes—A Systematic Review.” Ecological Indicators 73: 492–504.
  • Fagerholm, N., N. Käyhkö, F. Ndumbaro, and M. Khamis. 2012. “Community Stakeholders’ Knowledge in Landscape Assessments – Mapping Indicators for Landscape Services.” Ecological Indicators 18: 421–433.
  • Frueh-Mueller, A., S. Hotes, L. Breuer, V. Wolters, and T. Koellner. 2016. “Regional Patterns of Ecosystem Services in Cultural Landscapes.” Land 5 (2): 17.
  • Gilbert, G. E., and S. Prion. 2016. “Making Sense of Methods and Measurement: The Chi-Square Test.” Clinical Simulation in Nursing 12: 145–146.
  • Goldenberg, R., Z. Kalantari, V. Cvetkovic, U. Mörtberg, B. Deal, and G. Destouni. 2017. “Distinction, Quantification and Mapping of Potential and Realized Supply-demand of Flow-dependent Ecosystem Services.” Science of the Total Environment 593-594: 599–609.
  • Haines-Young, R., and M. Potschin, 2013. Common International Classification of Ecosystem Services (CICES), Version 4.3. Report to the European Environment Agency EEA/BSS/07/007.
  • Hamann, M., R. Biggs, and B. Reyers. 2015. “Mapping Social–ecological Systems: Identifying ‘Green-loop’ and ‘Red-loop’ Dynamics Based on Characteristic Bundles of Ecosystem Service Use.” Global Environmental Change 34: 218–226.
  • Holt, A. R., M. Mears, L. Maltby, and P. Warren. 2015. “Understanding Spatial Patterns in the Production of Multiple Urban Ecosystem Services.” Ecosystem Services 16: 33–46.
  • Jacobs, S., B. Burkhard, T. Van Daele, J. Staes, and A. Schneiders. 2015. “The Matrix Reloaded’: A Review of Expert Knowledge Use for Mapping Ecosystem Services.” Ecological Modelling 295: 21–30.
  • Jose Martinez-Harms, M., S. Quijas, A. M. Merenlender, and P. Balvanera. 2016. “Enhancing Ecosystem Services Maps Combining Field and Environmental Data.” Ecosystem Services 22: 32–40.
  • Kain, J.-H., N. Larondelle, D. Haase, and A. Kaczorowska. 2016. “Exploring Local Consequences of Two Land-use Alternatives for the Supply of Urban Ecosystem Services in Stockholm Year 2050.” Ecological Indicators 70: 615–629.
  • Katalin, P., and P. E. V. O. Alexander. 2012. “Modelling Land Management Effect on Ecosystem Functions and Services: A Study in the Netherlands.” International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services & Management 8: 135–155.
  • Koschke, L., C. Lorz, C. Fürst, T. Lehmann, and F. Makeschin. 2014. “Assessing Hydrological and Provisioning Ecosystem Services in a Case Study in Western Central Brazil.” Ecological Processes 3: 2.
  • Kreuter, U. P., H. G. Harris, M. D. Matlock, and R. E. Lacey. 2001. “Change in Ecosystem Service Values in the San Antonio Area, Texas.” Ecological Economics 39: 333–346.
  • Kruczkowska, B., J. Solon, and J. Wolski. 2017. “Mapping Ecosystem Services – A New Approach in Regional Scale.” Geographia Polonica 90: 503–520.
  • Li, B., D. Chen, S. Wu, S. Zhou, T. Wang, and H. Chen. 2016a. “Spatio-temporal Assessment of Urbanization Impacts on Ecosystem Services: Case Study of Nanjing City, China.” Ecological Indicators 71: 416–427.
  • Li, J., H. Jiang, Y. Bai, J. M. Alatalo, X. Li, H. Jiang, G. Liu, and J. Xu. 2016b. “Indicators for Spatial–temporal Comparisons of Ecosystem Service Status between Regions: A Case Study of the Taihu River Basin, China.” Ecological Indicators 60: 1008–1016.
  • Lin, S., R. Wu, F. Yang, J. Wang, and W. Wu. 2018. “Spatial Trade-offs and Synergies among Ecosystem Services within a Global Biodiversity Hotspot.” Ecological Indicators 84: 371–381.
  • Liquete, C., S. Kleeschulte, G. Dige, J. Maes, B. Grizzetti, B. Olah, and G. Zulian. 2015. “Mapping Green Infrastructure Based on Ecosystem Services and Ecological Networks: A Pan-European Case Study.” Environmental Science & Policy 54: 268–280.
  • Lorilla, R., K. Poirazidis, S. Kalogirou, V. Detsis, and A. Martinis. 2018. “Assessment of the Spatial Dynamics and Interactions among Multiple Ecosystem Services to Promote Effective Policy Making across Mediterranean Island Landscapes.” Sustainability 10: 3285.
  • Lorilla, R. S., S. Kalogirou, K. Poirazidis, and G. Kefalas. 2019. “Identifying Spatial Mismatches between the Supply and Demand of Ecosystem Services to Achieve a Sustainable Management Regime in the Ionian Islands (Western Greece).” Land Use Policy 88: 104171.
  • Luck, G. W., G. C. Daily, and P. R. Ehrlich. 2003. “Population Diversity and Ecosystem Services.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18: 331–336.
  • Luck, G. W., R. Harrington, P. A. Harrison, and C. Kremen. 2009. “Quantifying the Contribution of Organisms to the Provision of Ecosystem Services.” Bioscience 59: 223–235.
  • Luna-Romera, J. M., M. Martínez-Ballesteros, J. García-Gutiérrez, and J. C. Riquelme. 2019. “External Clustering Validity Index Based on Chi-squared Statistical Test.” Information Sciences 487: 1–17.
  • Lyu, R., K. C. Clarke, J. Zhang, J. Feng, X. Jia, and J. Li. 2019. “Spatial Correlations among Ecosystem Services and Their Socio-ecological Driving Factors: A Case Study in the City Belt along the Yellow River in Ningxia, China.” Applied Geography 108: 64–73.
  • Maes, J., B. Egoh, L. Willemen, C. Liquete, P. Vihervaara, J. P. Schägner, B. Grizzetti, et al. 2012. “Mapping Ecosystem Services for Policy Support and Decision Making in the European Union.” Ecosystem Services 1: 31–39.
  • Malinga, R., Gordon, L.J., Jewitt, G and Lindborg, R. 2015. “Mapping Ecosystem Services Across Scales and Continents – A review.“ Ecosystem Services 13: 57–63.
  • Martínez-Harms, M. J., and P. Balvanera. 2012. “Methods for Mapping Ecosystem Service Supply: A Review.” International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services & Management 8: 17–25.
  • Mendoza-González, G., M. L. Martínez, D. Lithgow, O. Pérez-Maqueo, and P. Simonin. 2012. “Land Use Change and Its Effects on the Value of Ecosystem Services along the Coast of the Gulf of Mexico.” Ecological Economics 82: 23–32.
  • Mexia, T., J. Vieira, A. Príncipe, A. Anjos, P. Silva, N. Lopes, C. Freitas, et al. 2018. “Ecosystem Services: Urban Parks under a Magnifying Glass.” Environmental Research 160: 469–478.
  • Moher, D., A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff, and D. G. Altman. 2010. “Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses: The PRISMA Statement.” International Journal of Surgery 8: 336–341.
  • Nahuelhual, L., F. Benra, P. Laterra, S. Marin, R. Arriagada, and C. Jullian. 2018. “Patterns of Ecosystem Services Supply across Farm Properties: Implications for Ecosystem Services-based Policy Incentives.” Science of the Total Environment 634: 941–950.
  • Paudyal, K., H. Baral, S. P. Bhandari, A. Bhandari, and R. J. Keenan. 2019. “Spatial Assessment of the Impact of Land Use and Land Cover Change on Supply of Ecosystem Services in Phewa Watershed, Nepal.” Ecosystem Services 36: 100895.
  • Peng, J., Y. Liu, Z. Liu, and Y. Yang. 2017. “Mapping Spatial Non-stationarity of Human-natural Factors Associated with Agricultural Landscape Multifunctionality in Beijing–Tianjin–Hebei Region, China.” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 246: 221–233.
  • Plummer, M. L. 2009. “Assessing Benefit Transfer for the Valuation of Ecosystem Services. Frontiers in Ecology & the Environment7: 38-45.
  • Quintas-Soriano, C., M. García-Llorente, A. Norström, M. Meacham, G. Peterson, and A. J. Castro. 2019. “Integrating Supply and Demand in Ecosystem Service Bundles Characterization across Mediterranean Transformed Landscapes.” Landscape Ecology 34: 1619–1633.
  • Ramyar, R. 2019. “Social–ecological Mapping of Urban Landscapes: Challenges and Perspectives on Ecosystem Services in Mashhad, Iran.” Habitat International 92: 102043.
  • Roces-Díaz, J. V., B. Burkhard, M. Kruse, F. Müller, E. R. Díaz-Varela, and P. Álvarez-Álvarez. 2017. “Use of Ecosystem Information Derived from Forest Thematic Maps for Spatial Analysis of Ecosystem Services in Northwestern Spain.” Landscape and Ecological Engineering 13: 45–57.
  • Roces-Diaz, J. V., J. Vayreda, M. Banque-Casanovas, E. Diaz-Varela, J. A. Bonet, L. Brotons, S. de-Miguel, S. Herrando, and J. Martinez-Vilalta. 2018a. “The Spatial Level of Analysis Affects the Patterns of Forest Ecosystem Services Supply and Their Relationships.” Science of the Total Environment 626: 1270–1283.
  • Roces-Díaz, J. V., J. Vayreda, M. Banqué-Casanovas, M. Cusó, M. Anton, J. A. Bonet, L. Brotons, et al. 2018b. “Assessing the Distribution of Forest Ecosystem Services in a Highly Populated Mediterranean Region.” Ecological Indicators 93: 986–997.
  • Ruiz‐Benito, P., L. Gómez‐Aparicio, A. Paquette, C. Messier, J. Kattge, and M. A. Zavala. 2014. “Diversity Increases Carbon Storage and Tree Productivity in Spanish Forests.” Global Ecology and Biogeography 23: 311–322.
  • Sahle, M., O. Saito, C. Fürst, and K. Yeshitela. 2019. “Quantifying and Mapping of Water-related Ecosystem Services for Enhancing the Security of the Food-water-energy Nexus in Tropical Data–sparse Catchment.” Science of the Total Environment 646: 573–586.
  • Sannigrahi, S., S. Chakraborti, P. K. Joshi, S. Keesstra, S. Sen, S. K. Paul, U. Kreuter, P. C. Sutton, S. Jha, and K. B. Dang. 2019. “Ecosystem Service Value Assessment of a Natural Reserve Region for Strengthening Protection and Conservation.” Journal of Environmental Management 244: 208–227.
  • Schägner, J. P., L. Brander, J. Maes, and V. Hartje. 2013. “Mapping Ecosystem Services’ Values: Current Practice and Future Prospects.” Ecosystem Services 4: 33–46.
  • Schirpke, U., S. Candiago, L. E. Vigl, H. Jager, A. Labadini, T. Marsoner, C. Meisch, E. Tasser, and U. Tappeiner. 2019. “Integrating Supply, Flow and Demand to Enhance the Understanding of Interactions among Multiple Ecosystem Services.” Science of the Total Environment 651: 928–941.
  • Schön, D. 2001. “The Crisis of Professional Knowledge and the Pursuit of an Epistemology of Practice.” In Competence in the Learning Society, edited by J. Raven and J. Stephenson, 185–207. New York: Peter Lang.
  • Seppelt, R., C. F. Dormann, F. V. Eppink, S. Lautenbach, and S. Schmidt. 2011. “A Quantitative Review of Ecosystem Service Studies: Approaches, Shortcomings and the Road Ahead.” Journal of Applied Ecology 48: 630–636.
  • Siegel, A. F. 2012. “Chapter 17 - Chi-Squared Analysis: Testing for Patterns in Qualitative Data.” In Practical Business Statistics, edited by A. F. Siegel, 507–522. Boston: Academic Press.
  • Sierra-Correa, P. C., and J. R. Cantera Kintz. 2015. “Ecosystem-based Adaptation for Improving Coastal Planning for Sea-level Rise: A Systematic Review for Mangrove Coasts.” Marine Policy 51: 385–393.
  • Spano, M., V. Leronni, R. Lafortezza, and F. Gentile. 2017. “Are Ecosystem Service Hotspots Located in Protected Areas? Results from a Study in Southern Italy.” Environmental Science & Policy 73: 52–60.
  • Su, C., B. Fu, Y. Wei, Y. Lü, G. Liu, D. Wang, K. Mao, and X. Feng. 2012. “Ecosystem Management Based on Ecosystem Services and Human Activities: A Case Study in the Yanhe Watershed.” Sustainability Science 7: 17–32.
  • Syrbe, R.-U., and U. Walz. 2012. “Spatial Indicators for the Assessment of Ecosystem Services: Providing, Benefiting and Connecting Areas and Landscape Metrics.” Ecological Indicators 21: 80–88.
  • Tallis, H., S. E. Lester, M. Ruckelshaus, M. Plummer, K. McLeod, A. Guerry, S. Andelman, M. R. Caldwell, M. Conte, and S. Copps. 2011. “New Metrics for Managing and Sustaining the Ocean’s Bounty.” Marine Policy 36: 1–4.
  • TerBraak, C. J. F., and P. Smilauer. 2012. CANOCO Reference Manual and User’S Guide: Software for Ordination (Version 5). New York: Microcomputer Power Ithaca.
  • Vallecillo, S., C. Polce, A. Barbosa, C. Perpiña Castillo, I. Vandecasteele, G. M. Rusch, and J. Maes. 2018. “Spatial Alternatives for Green Infrastructure Planning across the EU: An Ecosystem Service Perspective.” Landscape and Urban Planning 174: 41–54.
  • Vihervaara, P., T. Kumpula, A. Ruokolainen, A. Tanskanen, and B. Burkhard. 2012. “The Use of Detailed Biotope Data for Linking Biodiversity with Ecosystem Services in Finland.” International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services and Management 8: 169–185.
  • Vorstius, A. C., and C. J. Spray. 2015. “A Comparison of Ecosystem Services Mapping Tools for Their Potential to Support Planning and Decision-making on A Local Scale.” Ecosystem Services 15: 75–83.
  • Vrebos, D., J. Staes, T. Vandenbroucke, T. D׳Haeyer, R. Johnston, M. Muhumuza, C. Kasabeke, and P. Meire. 2015. “Mapping Ecosystem Service Flows with Land Cover Scoring Maps for Data-scarce Regions.” Ecosystem Services 13: 28–40.
  • Wei, H., H. Liu, Z. Xu, J. Ren, N. Lu, W. Fan, P. Zhang, and X. Dong. 2018. “Linking Ecosystem Services Supply, Social Demand and Human Well-being in a Typical Mountain–oasis–desert Area, Xinjiang, China.” Ecosystem Services 31: 44–57.
  • Wolff, S., C. J. E. Schulp, and P. H. Verburg. 2015. “Mapping Ecosystem Services Demand: A Review of Current Research and Future Perspectives.” Ecological Indicators 55: 159–171.
  • Woodley, S., B. Bertzky, and N. Crawhall, et al. 2012. “Meeting Aichi Target 11: What Does Success Look like for Protected Area Systems?” Parks 18:23–36.
  • Wu, X., S. Liu, S. Zhao, X. Hou, J. Xu, S. Dong, and G. Liu. 2019. “Quantification and Driving Force Analysis of Ecosystem Services Supply, Demand and Balance in China.” Science of the Total Environment 652: 1375–1386.
  • Wurster, D., and M. Artmann. 2014. “Development of a Concept for Non-monetary Assessment of Urban Ecosystem Services at the Site Level.” AMBIO 43: 454–465.
  • Xiang, W.-N. 2017. “Correction To: Pasteur’s Quadrant: An Appealing Ecophronetic Alternative to the Prevalent Bohr’s Quadrant in Ecosystem Services Research.” Landscape Ecology 33: 171.
  • Xu, S., Y. Liu, X. Wang, and G. Zhang. 2017. “Scale Effect on Spatial Patterns of Ecosystem Services and Associations among Them in Semi-arid Area: A Case Study in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, China.” Science of the Total Environment 598: 297–306.
  • Yaneva, R. 2016. “Mapping Ecosystem Services Supply: Challenges and Opportunities in the Geo-spatial Analysis.”6th International Conference on Cartography & Gis, Albena, Bulgaria.
  • Yin, R. K. 1993. “Applications of Case Study Research.” Bms Bulletin of Sociological Methodology34: 101.
  • Yushanjiang, A., Z. Fei, H. Yu, and H. T. Kung. 2018. “Quantifying the Spatial Correlations between Landscape Pattern and Ecosystem Service Value: A Case Study in Ebinur Lake Basin, Xinjiang, China.” Ecological Engineering 113: 94–104.
  • Zarandian, A., H. Baral, N. E. Stork, M. A. Ling, A. R. Yavari, H. R. Jafari, and H. Amirnejad. 2017. “Modeling of Ecosystem Services Informs Spatial Planning in Lands Adjacent to the Sarvelat and Javaherdasht Protected Area in Northern Iran.” Land Use Policy 61: 487–500.
  • Zhang, L., Y. Lü, B. Fu, Z. Dong, Y. Zeng, and B. Wu. 2017a. “Mapping Ecosystem Services for China’s Ecoregions with a Biophysical Surrogate Approach.” Landscape and Urban Planning 161: 22–31.
  • Zhang, Z., J. Gao, X. Fan, Y. Lan, and M. Zhao. 2017b. “Response of Ecosystem Services to Socioeconomic Development in the Yangtze River Basin, China.” Ecological Indicators 72: 481–493.
  • Zhao, M., J. Peng, Y. Liu, T. Li, and Y. Wang. 2018. “Mapping Watershed-Level Ecosystem Service Bundles in the Pearl River Delta, China.” Ecological Economics 152: 106–117.