Professional strategy and division: The Disciplinary Board of the Danish Bar and Law Society

References

• Carr-Saunders , A. M. and Wilson , P. A. 1964 . The Professions , 1st edn 1933 , 421 – 446 . Oxford : Oxford University Press . A well-known example of the obligation to serve was the English barrister who was obliged to take the cases presented to him in the order they appeared, the "cabrank rule"
   Google Scholar
• Parsons , Talcott . 1954 . “ A sociologist looks at the legal profession ” . In Essays in Sociological Theory , Edited by: Parsons , Talcott . 370 – 385 . 374 – 74 . 384 378 – 79 . New York : The Free Press . stressing service as opposed to commercial basis in the work of the professional
   Google Scholar
• Macdonald , Keith M. 1995 . The Sociology of Professions , 4 London : Sage . In general this perspective is labelled the functionalist approach, see
   Google Scholar
• Keith M. Macdonald, ibid., note 3.
   Google Scholar
• Zander , Michael . 1968 . “ Lawyers and the Public Interest ” . In A Study in Restrictive Practices , 5 – 7 . London : Weidenfeld and Nicholson .
   Google Scholar
• Zander , Michael . 1978 . Legal Services for the Community , 173 – 174 . 176 – 199 . London : Temple and Smith .
   Google Scholar
• Schultz , Ulrike . 1977 . Legal ethics in Germany . International Journal of the Legal Profession , 4 (1/2) : 55 – 87 . 79
   Google Scholar
• Abel . 1988 . “ The Legal Profession in England and Wales ” . 289 – 293 . note 5
   Google Scholar
• Abel , Richard L. American Lawyers , 27 – 28 . 28 – 30 . 48 – 51 .
   Google Scholar
• Abel . “ The Legal Profession in England and Wales ” . 285 – 289 . note 5
   Google Scholar
• Abel . “ The Legal Profession in England and Wales ” . 293 – 296 . note 5
   Google Scholar
• Abel , Richard L. American Lawyers , 25 – 27 .
   Google Scholar
• Abel , Richard L. American Lawyers , 112 – 126 .
   Google Scholar
• This term to be introduced by Magali Sarfatri Larson, The Rue of Professionalisation, note 5.
   Google Scholar
• Auerbach , Jerold . 1976 . “ Unequal Justice ” . In Lawyers and Social Change in Modern America , 101 – 129 . New York : Oxford University Press . on the American post-First World War experience
   Google Scholar
• Zander . Lawyers and the Public Interest , 21 – 23 . 30 – 31 . 128 – 139 . 132 on entrance to the higher levels of the English bar as in the appointment of the Queen's Counsel
   Google Scholar
• Zander . Lawyers and the Public Interest , 32 – 39 . on "keeping terms" for barristers
   Google Scholar
• Burrage , Jarausch and Siegrist . 1990 . “ An Actor-based Framework for Studying Professions ” . In Professions in Theory and History. Rethinking the Study of Professions , Edited by: Burrage , Michael and Torstendahl , Rolf . 207 London : Sage . to accommodate the different experiences of the Continental and the English-American experience, since the academics in continental countries have been the ones to train the professionals. This is opposed to England, but not the USA. They hereby exclude the fifth actor, the competing profession, as suggested by Andrew Abbott, ibid., note 5
   Google Scholar
• Zweigert , Konrad and Kotz , Heinz . 1987 . Introduction to Comparative Law, I , 128 – 130 . Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Siegrist , Hannes . “ Professionalisation as a process ” . In Burrage and Torstendahl, Professions in Theory and History 180 – 182 . note 19
   Google Scholar
• Conza , Werner and Kocka , Jürgen . 1985 . Bildungsbürgertum im 19. Jahrhundert, Teil I , 9 – 26 . Stuttgart : Qett-Kotta . More about this continental European criticism in Rolf Torstendahl, Three approaches to theories of professionalism, note 4, pp. 55 and 58 mentioning civil servants as a group where one can find many professional properties, some professional strategies, but rather more strategies for status quo or politicisation as a competing strategy to professionalisation
   Google Scholar
• Rolf Torstendahl, Three approaches to theories of professionalism, see Torstendahl and Burrage, The Formation of Professions. Knowledge, State and Strategy, note 4, pp. 48, 59, 54.
   Google Scholar
• Abel , Richard L. 1988 . “ Lawyers in the civil law world ” . In Lawyers in Society. Vol. 2. The Civil Law World , Edited by: Abel , Richard L. and Lewis , Philip S. C. Vol. 2 , 1 – 53 . 42 – 43 . Berkeley : University of California Press .
   Google Scholar
• Galanter , Marc and Paley , Thomas . 1991 . The Tournament of Lawyers , 121 – 138 . Chicago : University of Chicago Press . This conclusion is in accordance with the work of, of US firms pointing to five different styles of firms besides the large business firms, the specialised boutique, the lifestyle firm, the franchise
   Google Scholar
• Wiegend , Wolfgang . 1991 . The reception of American law in Europe . American Journal of Comparative Law , 39 : 229 – 248 . 229 – 243 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Watkins , Jeff , Drury , Lynn and Freddy , Don . 1992 . “ From Evolution to Revolution ” . In The Pressures on Professional Life in the 1990s , 52 Bristol : University of Bristol .
   Google Scholar
• This is suggested as a possibility by Jørgen Hannen, ibid., note 89, p. 157.
   Google Scholar
• Scandinavia . 1948 . Pound's theories were introduced by the Norwegian Ragnar Knoph, cf. Ragnar Knoph, Rettslige Standarder (Legal Standards') , Oslo : Grendahl & Son . Knoph based his analysis on some work of Roscoe Pound's, and his book presented the most extensive analysis of Pound's theories applied on Scandinavian law, cf. Knoph, pp. 3-4, 7-8. Knoph's use of sources reveals that he based his analysis on material from the years immediately after the First World War
   Google Scholar
• 1963 . The Danish Weekly Lato Report 59 This was a change back from the 1960s, when the Bar and Law Society conducted a court case barring the formation of a specific law firm as a company with limited liability, cf. UfR
   Google Scholar
• Betsenkning nr. 871 vedrerende revision afretsplejelovensafsnit om advokater, afgivetafdet afjustitsministerietden 4. april 1974 nedsatte udvalg (Report No. 871 concerning the Revision of the Administration of Justice Paragraph on Attorneys, published by the committee established by the Minister of Justice on April 4, 1974) Copenhagen, 1979, p. 59.
   Google Scholar
• 1984 . Advokaten , : 3 – 4 .
   Google Scholar
• Kruse , Anders Vinding . 1990 . Advokatansvaret (Lawyers' Liability) , 12 9 Copenhagen : Djöf . quotation marks are those of the author. Vinding Kruse's analysis concerns liability in torts, but the situations are related (op. cit., p. 7). Vinding Kruse argues that the professional liability is extended in tort law, compared to the professional standard and this extension is more likely to take place when the profession itself keeps the control
   Google Scholar
• J.M. Jr. Nr. LA 1979-40002-32 (file number referring to the files of the Ministry of Justice), see the minutes of the meeting between the Ministry and the Law Society, dated November 1981.
   Google Scholar
• Held , David . 1987 . Models of Democracy , 184 204 Cambridge : Polity Press .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, letter dated 26 March 1980 from the social democrat, Law Professor Ole Espersen to his party fellow, the Minister of Justice Henning Rasmussen asking when Rasmussen would forward a bill concerning the self regulation of lawyers. In 1981 Espersen was the Minister of Justice. From the attacks on the self-regulation during the debate over the bill it is clear that the prevailing attitude is against the self-regulation. The reports from the courts voiced a general satisfaction with the self regulation, cf. J.M. Jr. Nr. LA 1979-40002-32. This supports the evaluation that the change was a political one.
   Google Scholar
• Hansen , Jørgen . 1986 . Advokatgerningen som liberait erhverv (The Catting of the Attorney as a Free Enterprise) , 43 Copenhagen : Juraconsult . Figures produced by the Agency of Monopoly Control in 1980, cf. Monopoltilsynet, Advokaterhvervets Struktur, takster og indtiening (Attorneys, the Structure of the Profession, its Fees and Income), Copenhagen, 1982. Cited in
   Google Scholar
• Arnold , Bruce L and Kay , Fiona M. 1995 . Social capital, violations of trust and vulnerability of isolates: the social organisation of law practice and professional self regulation . International Journal of the Sociology of Law , 23 : 321 – 346 . concerning Canada
   Google Scholar
• Hanlon and Shapland, ibid., note 45, pp. 104-122;. Heinz and Lauman, ibid., note 39, passim.
   Google Scholar
• Jørgen Hansen, ibid., note 89, p. 157 advances the hypothesis that some people feel a discomfort simply at persons opposing them. I can sympathise with this. But would this feeling not motivate the person to avoid conflicts altogether?
   Google Scholar
• I have searched The Lawyer and The Law Society Gazette for articles on international relations from 1996 to spring 1998, and my impression is gathered on this background. For the reference to the Scandinavian market, see The Lawyer, April 1998, p. 5 referring to negotiations between Sweden's Vinge, Norway's Krefting, Greve, Lund and Denmark's Kromann and Munter.
   Google Scholar
• Schultz, ibid., note 9, pp. 55-87; Michael Burrage, Beyond a sub-set: the professional aspirations of manual workers in France, the US and Britain, in: Burrage and Torstendahl, ibid., note 19, pp. 65-73 talk of a move in the opposite direction, affecting groups not having a higher education. The result would be a levelling of the professionals.
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . The Lawyer , 5 May : 2
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . The Lota Society Gazette , 22 April : 1 4
   Google Scholar
• Merricks , Walter and Wallman , Russel . 1991 . The Court and Legal Services Act. A Solicitors Guide , 49 London : The Law Society .
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . The Lota Society Gazette , 16 April : 5 mentioning the appointment of the third solicitor QC and ibid., 4 February 1998, p. 4 discussing the abolition of silk. Demand of abolition of silk as a barrier for women
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . The Latoyer , 12 April : 2
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . The Lawyer , 12 November : 7 and ibid., 16 February 1997, pp. 5, 6
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . The Lawyer , 10 February : 5 about foreign lawyers in Budapest protesting against regulation proposed to protect domestic firms
   Google Scholar
• Magali Sarfatti Larson, ibid., note 5.
   Google Scholar
• Heinz , John P. and Lauman , Edward O. 1982 . Chicago Lawyers. The Social Structure of the Bar , NY/ Chicago : Russel Sage Foundation/American Bar Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Carlin , Jerome E. 1966 . Lawyers' Ethics. A Survey of the New York City Bar , New York : Russell Sage Foundation . This was done by asking a representative sample of attorneys of the existing norm, or of what they knew of the code of conduct
   Google Scholar
• Smigel , Erwin . 1973 . The Wall Street Lawyer. Professional Organisation Man? , 68 – 69 . 320 – 322 . 345 – 346 . Bloomington/London : Indiana University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Heinz and Lauman, ibid., note 39, pp. 319-320.
   Google Scholar
• van Hoy , Jerry . 1995 . Selling and processing law: legal work at franchise law firms . Law and Society Review , 29 : 703 – 729 . 721 Heinz and Lauman, aid., note 39, pp. 355-360 discussing the legal aid and criminal attorneys as opposed to corporate attorneys. Also labelling the successful attorney one who was able to convince clients to buy their services by offering a specific cause of action
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Heinz and Lauman, ibid., note 39, p. 360.
   Google Scholar
• 1970 . Advokaten , : 1 – 2 . See Tables 1-3 for an overview
   Google Scholar
• 1972 . Advokaten , : 1 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• 1970 . Advokaten , : 1 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• 1978 . Advokaten , : 1 – 3 . However divorce was not mentioned as growth in work, although the number of divorces exploded, see annex 1
   Google Scholar
• 1980 . Advokaten , : 1 ibid., 1981, p. 2; ibid., 1982, p. 2; ibid., 1983, p. 3; ibid., 1986, pp. 1-2; ibid., 1987, p. 3
   Google Scholar
• 1987 . Justitsministeriet (The Ministry of Justice), Betænkning om retshjælp , Report Na 1113 on Legal Aid 160 – 161 . Copenhagen
   Google Scholar
• 1976 . Advokaten , : 1 – 2 . ibid., 1975, pp. 1-3; ibid., 1973, pp. 1-2
   Google Scholar
• 1974 . Advokaten , : 1 – 2 . and ibid., 1977, pp. 1-3
   Google Scholar
• Jørgensen , Bent Nyløkke . 1983 . “ Fra faglig forening til fagforening, (From expert association to union) ” . In Festskrift til professor, dr. jur. W. E. von Eyben, (festschrift for Professor Dr. Juris. W. E. von Eyben) , 93 96 – 97 . Copenhagen : Djøf . The resistance against the grade system originated in 1953. In 1957 an attack was launched on the discretion in the advancement system. These initiatives are then not a result of the democratic moves of the 1970s but purely professional strategy
   Google Scholar
• Jørgensen, ibid., note 66, p. 99. Judges were then excluded from these collective rules.
   Google Scholar
• Jørgensen, ibid., note 66, pp. 112, 114,116-117.
   Google Scholar
• 1979 . Advokaten , : 1 – 2 . ibid., 1978,pp. 1-3
   Google Scholar