Advanced search
Publication Cover
Interdisciplinary Science Reviews Volume 7, 1982 - Issue 4
Journal homepage
26
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Humour The Interdisciplinary Denominator in Science

Alexander KohnIsrael Institute for Biological Research, Ness Ziona, Israel
Pages 309-324 | Published online: 20 Nov 2013

LITERATURE CITED

  • O. Foerster and O. Gagel, cited in J. P. Martin, Fits of Laughter (sham mirth) in organic cerebral disease. Brain, A Jour, of Neurology 73, 453 (1950).
  • C. Landis, Emotion: II, the expression of emotion, in A Handbook of General Experimental Psychology, edited by C. Morchison, Chapter 7, Clark University Press, Worcester, Massachusetts (1934).
  • L. Feieki, Keeping laughably up with science. Impact Sci. Soc. 19, 279–290 (1969).
  • L. Cazamian, The Development of English humour, Duke University Press, Durham, North Carolina (1952).
  • C. Morris, Essay toward fixing the true standards of wit, humour, raillery, satire and ridicule (1744).
  • J. B. Priestley, English Humour, Longmans Green Co., London and New York (1930).
  • M. Eastman, The Sense of Humour, Scribner, New York (1922).
  • J. Read, Humour and Humanism in Chemistry, G. Bell, London (1957).
  • G. Bateson, The role of humor in human communication, in Cybernetics, edited by H. von Foerster, Macy Foundation, New York (1953).
  • A. Rapp, The Origins of Wit and Humor, Dutton, New York (1951).
  • J. H. Goldstein and P. E. McGhee (Eds), The Psychology of HumoriTheoretical Perspectives and Empirical Issues, Academic Press, New York (1972).
  • A. J. Chapman and H. C. Foot, The development of English Humor, Duke University Press, Durham, North Carolina (1952).
  • A. J. Chapman and H. C. Foot (Eds), It’s a Funny Thing, Humor, Pergamon Press, Oxford (1977).
  • P. E. McGhee, Humor, Its Origin and Development, W. H. Freeman & Co., San Francisco, California (1979).
  • P. Daninos, Le Tour du Monde du Rire, Hachette, Paris (1952).
  • W. E. Fry, SweetiMadness, a Study of Humor, Pacific Books (1968).
  • H. B. Keller, D. A. Levine and G. B. Whitham, Motion of a bore on a sloping beach, J. Fluid Mech. 7, 302–316 (1960).
  • W. J. M. Douglas, Heat and mass transfer in a turbulent bed contactor, Chem, Eng. Progr. 60(7), 66–71 (1964).
  • J. B. Hamilton, Demonstrated ability of penile erection in castrate men with markedly low titers of urinary androgens. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 54, 309–312 (1946).
  • N. Vanserg, Mathmanship (or the fine art of appearing smarter than you are). Am. Sci. 46, 94A–98A (1958).
  • S. Harris, What’s So Funny About Science, W, Kaufman, Inc., Los Altos, California (1980).
  • Spin Off—A selection of cartoons from New Scientist, C. G. Harrap and Co., London (1965).
  • B. S. Old, On the mathematics of committees, boards and panels. Sci. Mon. 63, 129–134 (1946).
  • H. Petard, Contribution to the mathematical theory of big game hunting. Am. Math. Mon. 45, 446–447 (1938).
  • G. Albrecht, Science on the march. The Schuss-Yucca. Sci. Mon. 75, 260–252 (1952).
  • B. Scheer, Dental disease in Brunus edwardii. Brit. MediJ. 148, 193–194(1980),
  • D. K. Blackmore, D. G. Owen and C. M. Yound, Some observations on the disease of Brunus edwardii (species nova). Vet. Rec. 90, 382–385 (1972).
  • H. M. Shapiro, Fluorescent dyes for differential counts by flow cytometry. Does histochemistry tell us much more than cell geometry? J. Histochem. Cytochem. 25, 976–989 (1977).
  • D. Upper, The unsuccessful self-treatment of writer’s block. J. Appl. Behav. Anal. 7, 497 (1974).
  • E. Scott Barr, Concerning index of refraction and density. Am. J. Phys. 23, 623–624 (1955).
  • R. R. Wilcox, An unusual case of vaginal tumour. Sr. J. Vener. Dis. 37, 284 (1961).
  • T. P. Lowry, Initial coital experiences: where and with whom. Mil. Med. 129, 966–967 (1964).
  • R. D. Bryant, An unusual obstetrical case history. Obstet. Gynecol. 2, 187–200 (1953).
  • C. Dickens, Sketches by Boz: Mudfog and other sketches: Full report of the Second Meeting of the Mudfog Association for the Advancement of Everything, pp. 531–550. Chapman & Hall, London (1903).
  • I. Dubin, The case of the floating matzo balls. Perspectives Biol. Med. 21, 127–133 (1978).
  • Anon, An old fairy theorem. Eureka 13, 8–9 (1963).
  • Duscartes, Hence Eureka 28, 25–26 (1965).
  • C. Voit, Ode to the negative gaussian curvature of potato crisps. Eureka 36, 27–28 (1973).
  • D. R. Grey, The marriage problem. Eureka 33, 7–8 (1970).
  • Anon, The Malpighii 2(9), 3 (1960).
  • C. E. Siem, The stress and strain in maidenform strapless brassiere. Mad Engineer (Purdue Univ.) 55, 12–13, 53 (1960).
  • C. E. Siem, in A Stress Analysis of a Strapless Evening Gown, edited by R. A. Baker, pp. 106–111. Prentice Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey (1963).
  • R. L. Weber, A Bandom Walk in Science, Crane Russak & Co., New York (1973).
  • W. A. Walters, How free radicals work for industry. New Sci. 12, 434–435 (1961).
  • Anon, A new laboratory for research on creep. Nature (London) 191, 1049–1050 (1961).
  • Anon, Eruption of bearded tits during 1959–1965, Sr. Birds 59, 513 (1966).
  • K. Lindestrøm-Lang, The Thermodynamic Activity of the Male Housefly, Academic Press, New York (1956).
  • P. Weiss, Life on Earth, Rockefeller Inst. Rev. 12(6), 7–14 (1964).
  • C. M. Cipolla, The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity, The Mad Millers, Bologna, Italy (1976).
  • X. Perry Mental, No-Acetol. J. Irrepr. Res. 13, 62 (1965).
  • S. Haber, No-Acetol. JiIrrepr. Res. 14, 48 (1965).
  • C. Price, No-Acetol. J. Irrepr. Res. 18, 62 (1970).
  • A. Lepins, No-Acetol. J. Irrepr. Res. 14, 47 (1965).
  • J. S. Greenstein, Studies on a new, peerless contraceptive agent. Can, Med. Assoc. J. 93, 1351–1355 (1965).
  • O. H. Iversen, The significant correlation between the average annual age-specific incidence rates of malignant melanoma and the topography of the Norwegian west coast. J. Irrepr. Res. 24(3), 17–19 (1978).
  • G. Kaub, National Geographic: the doomsday machine. JiIrrepr. Res. 20(3), 22–23 (1974).
  • L. M. Jones, National Geographic: doomsday machine or benefactor? A vindication. J. Irrepr. Res. 20(4), 12–14 (1974).
  • A. D. Conger, A new unit of work for population genetics: The cock-foot. J. Irrepr. Res. 24(1), 25 (1978 ). (see also Playboy, Playboy Forum), July 1979).
  • Z. Pelah et al., New catenanes. J. Irrepr. Res. 14, 5–7 (1965).
  • S. Rudin, A psychoanalysis of US missile failures. J. Irrepr. Res. 10, 13–14 (1961).
  • M. V. King, X-ray crystallographic data on some proteins of the xenonase complex. J. Irrepr. Res. 12, 13–15 (1963).
  • C. L. Chemick, et al., Fluorine compounds of xenon and radon. Science 138, 136 (1962).
  • J. L. DeLucas, Definition of a dark bulb. J. Irrepr. Res, 22(3), 22–33 (1976).
  • A. T. Edison, An inexpensive dissipator of radiant energy. Electronics 42, 59–67 (1970).
  • B. Turchin, (Ed.); Fiziki prodoljayout shutit (Physicists continue to laugh), Mir. Moscow (1968).
  • E. Garfield, Humor in scientific journals and journals of scientific humor, Curr. Cont. 51, 5–12 (1976).
  • Ancn, Science of Humor and Humor of Science, UNESCO Impact Sc. Soc. 19(3) (1969).
  • A. Kohn, Onderzoekerskunst, Scheltema and Holkema, Amsterdam (1963).
  • J. Ertel (Ed.), Selected papers from the JIR, JIR Publishers, Chicago, 60411 (1978).
  • J. V. McConnell, TheiWorm Re-turns, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey (1965).
  • J. V. McConnell, Science, Sex and Sacred Cows. Harcourt, Brace, Janovich, New York (1971).
  • R. Armour, It all started with Hippocrates, McGraw Hill, New York (1966).
  • A. Bloch, Murphy’s Law and Other Reasons Why Things Go Wrong, Prince, Stern, Sloan Publ. Inc., Los Angeles (1977).
  • H. F. Ellis, Mediatrics, Geoffrey Blues, London (1961).
  • H. Stuempke, The Snouters (Form and Life of the Rhinogrades), Natural History Press, Garden City, New York (1967).
  • R. L. Weber, A Bandom Walk in Science, Crane, Russak and Co. (1973).
  • R. A. Baker, Psychology in the Wry, D. van Nostrand Co., Princeton, New Jersey (1963).
  • R. Sommer, Expertland, Doubleday and Co., Garden City, New York (1963).
  • M. Stultifer, The Case for Extinction (An Answer to Conservationists), The Dial Press, New York (1970).
  • J. D. Pauiett, Pilot study of old age pensioners. Br. Med. J. 1, 432–436 (1969).
  • A. Auliciems, Warmth and comfort in subtropical winter, A study in Brisbane schools. J. Hyg. (Camb.) 74, 339–343 (1975).
  • S. Potter, Supermanship, Hart-Davis, London (1958).
  • E. Garfield, Citations and games scientists play. Curr. Cont. 31, 5 (1974).
  • A. C. Leopold, Games scientists play. BioScience 23, 590–594(1973).
  • L. J. Peter and R. Hull, The Peter’s Principle. Why things always go wrong, Souvenir Press, London (1969).
  • L. J. Peter, The Peter’s Prescription, How to make things go right, W. Morrow and Co., New York (1972).
  • B. J. Ford, Nonscience, Wolfe Publishing Ltd., London (1971).
  • P. Dickson, The Official Rules, Arrow Books Ltd., London (1978).
  • C. N. Parkinson, Parkinson’s Law or the Pursuit of Progress, J. Murray, London (1958).
  • C. N. Parkinson, Mrs Parkinson’s Law, J. Murray, London (1968).
  • G. Orwell, Politics and the English Language, p. 9. Horizon, News of the World, London (1946).
  • E. Gower, The Complete Plain Words, p. 204. Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London (1973).
  • A. Kohn, Principles and methods of obscurantism. New Sci. 45, 212–213 (1970).
  • N. P. Christy, English is our second language. N. Engl. J. Med. 300, 979–981 (1979).
  • J. Roberts, The synapse as a cybernetic unit. A biochemist phantasy. Neuroscience Res, Program II, 42, 1–51 (1964).
  • E. S. Maccia and G. S. Maccia, Development of educational theory derived from three educational theory models. US Office Education Project # 5–0683, Contract OE 4-10-186 p. 100 (1966).
  • W. H. Hollinshead, Textbook of Anatomy, 2nd edn, p. 236. Harper, New York (1967).
  • D. Napley, Hazards of the road. Nature (Lond) 195, 1242–1245 (1962).
  • S. I. Ben-Abraham, On internal stresses due to a random distribution of dislocations. Scr. Metall. 2, 9 (1968).
  • S. Karlin and J. McGregor, A characterization of birth and death processes. Proe. Natl Acad, Sci. USA 45, 375 (1959).
  • H. Maier-Leibnitz, Chairman and cook, twice as spicy, Interdiscipl. Sci. Rev. 5, 33–36 (1980).
  • R. H. House and H. von Foerster, Introductory comments to Francisco Varella’s calculus for self reference. Int. J. Gen. Syst. 2, 1 (1975).
  • A. Burger, Book review on ‘Psychopharmacological Agents’ Vol. 1, edited by M. Gordon, Academic Press (1964); J. Med. Chem. 8, 556 (1965).
  • C. B. Goodhart, A biological view of toplessness. New Sci. 25, 558–560 (1964).
  • A. K. Swersie, Suggestions on adult circumcision, NY State Med. J. 50, 1101–1108 (1950).
  • W. K. Kerr, M. Barkin, J. Alosio and Z. Menczyk, Observations on the movement of ions and water across the wall of the human bladder and ureter, J, Urol. 89, 812–819(1963).
  • J. D. Battle, Credit carditis. A new clinical entity. N. Engl. J. Med. 274, 467 (1966).
  • H. Z. Sable, An editor writes to William Shakespeare. Trends in Biochem. Sci. 5, XIV (1980).
  • I. Goldiamond, A crucial experiment resubmitted, American Psychologist 669–671 (1977).
  • N. S. Haile, Preparing scientific papers. Nature (London) 268. 100(1977).
  • A. G. Foraker, If Koch had applied for a research grant. Science 142, 11 (1963).
  • J. E. Miller, How Newton discovered the law of gravitation. The Malpighii, 2, 128–136 (1960).
  • F. Shor, Lombardy’s Lakes, Blue jewels in Italy’s crown. Nat. Geogr. Mag. 78 (1968).
  • H. M. Merrill and M. Mills, Survey of medical care in a war industry area. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 126, 867–892 (1944).
  • J. B. Appel, The rat: an important subject. J. Exp. Analysis of Behavior 7, 355–366 (1964).
  • C. M. Garn and W. D. Block, Limited nutritional value of cannibalism. Am. Anthropol, 72, 106 (1970).
  • Anon, Communicable Disease Summary, Oregon State Health Division (30 March 1974).
  • H. M. Smith and C. H. Alfred, Recognizing and coping with the vertical patron. Spec. Libraries 66, 528 (1975).
  • L. Erlenmyer-Kimling and S. Stern, Heritability of IQ by social class, evidence inconclusive. Science 182, 1045 (1973).
  • B. S. Linn, S. E. Stephenson, and J. Smith, Evaluation of burn care in Florida. N. Engl. J. Med. 296, 311–315 (1977).
  • M. I. Kamien and N. Megiddo, An intergenerational cake eating game. Econ. Lett. 2, 5–7 (1979).
  • R. O, Gregg and E. D. Astwood (Eds), Female reproductive system in two parts, in Handbook of Physiology. Williams and Wilkins, New York (1973).
  • M. Bander and E. Gotsman, Dips at nonsense wrong signature points, Phys. Rev, D2, 224 (1970).
  • R. J. Myers, An instance of the pitfalls prevelant in graveyard research. Biometrics 19, 638–652 (1963).
  • F. Girling, The effect of breathing 15–21% and 100% oxygen on the shivering response of nude human subjects at 10°C. Can. J. Physiol, and Pharmacol. 44, 495–499 (1966).
  • R. K. Siegel, Stimulus selection and tracking during urination: autoshaping directed behavior with toilet targets. J. Appl. Behav. Anal. 10, 255 (1971).
  • C. Cox, How Women Can Make up to $1000 a Week, Van Nostrand, New York (1963).
  • J. O. Smith and O. M. Sidebottom, Elementary Mechanics of Deformable Bodies, MacMillan, New York (1969).
  • W. E. Dasent, Non-existent compounds, M. Dekker, New York (1965).
  • C. Leakey, Tit Watching in the British Isles, Southbridge Press, London (1965).
  • J. C. Maxwell, Are there real analogies in nature? edited by L. Campbell and W. Garnett, in The Life of James Clark Maxwell, pp. 235–255, Macmillan, London (1856).
  • C. Tickle and J. P. Trinkaus, Observations on nudging cells in culture, Nature (London) 261, 413 (1976).
  • R. Lord Brain and H. Head, The man and his ideas. Brain 84, 561 (1961).
  • R. N. Dull and R. Dull, Mathematics for Engineers, 3rd edn, McGraw Hill, New York (1951).
  • W. M. Fox, A sociosexual behavioral abnormality in the dog resembling Oedipus complex in man. J, Am. Vet. Med. Assoc. 144, 868 (1964).
  • C. Read, Lessons to be learned from the preschool orthographer, in: Foundations of Learning Development, edited by E. H. Lennenberg and E. Lennenberg, Academic Press, New York (1975).
  • I. Tiger and H. Fox, The zoological perspective in social science, Man 1, 75–81 (1966),
  • P. T. Mountjoy, Some early attempts to modify penile erections in horse and human. Psychol. Rec. 24, 291–308 (1974).
  • J. V. Chuba et at., Multiple specificities of mammalian blood group substance comparatively studied with human isoagglutinins and fractionated anti-H lectins. Immunol. 29, 17–30 (1975).
  • A. Lwoff, Death and transfiguration of a problem. Bacteriol. Rev. 33, 390–403 (1969).

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Humorous Articles in Serious Literature

1. House-organs

  • S. Applezweig, Saga of a new hormone. Drug Cosmet. Ind. (April 1965).
  • W. E. Bard, On the reduction of test error. Southwest. Eng. Scient. (January 1969).
  • W. B. Bean, Omphalosophy and worse verse. Am. Clin, Climatolog. Assoc. (November 1953).
  • J. Beeman, The toxicological significance of levorotatory ice crystals. Bull. Bur. Crim. Invest. NY Police 8(12) (1943).
  • J. B. Caldwallader-Cohen, Zyciczk and R. R. Donelly, The Chaostron. IRE Newsletter (1960).
  • A. E. Cawkell, The fun side of scientific publications. Inf. Sci. (London), 83–85 (June 1974).
  • T. E. Connolly, How to credit the authors. Alum. Bull. Univ. Buffalo, 26, 5–6 (1959).
  • P. A. Crispino, The proper use of mathematical expressions in scientific publications. Percolator 34, 16–17 (1958).
  • K. E. David, New Reading Machine, N, S. Med. Bull, 59 (April 1971).
  • F. F. Ford, Science in a coffee cup. Cheasapeake Chem. 16(12) (1960).
  • A. M. Greely, Conferencemanship. Univ. Chicago Mag. (March/April 1972).
  • T. H. Heald, The equilibrium theory for the meeting paper. Astronaut. Aeronaut, (December 1968).
  • B. V. A. Hors-d’oeuvre, Angelic acid as a precursor of steroids. The Accelerator 51(5 ) (May 1967).
  • L. M. Janifer, Some preliminary notes on FASEG. Analog Sci, 88, 1 (1971).
  • R. E. Meyer, Reports full of gobbtedygook. The Joplin Globe (March 1971).
  • W. S. Minkler, Computer Program Virtually Eliminates Machine Errors, Pittsburgh Section Amer. Nuclear Soc. (January 1965).
  • B. Minkler, On the nature of angels. Analog Sci, 88, No. 1 (1971).
  • N. Nadir, The Isolation and Characterization of plentisillin. Science 103, 267.
  • J. H, Quick, Turboencabulator. Addison Wesley Newsletter 6(3) (1956),
  • N. Stevens, Moleworth Institute revisited, Am. Librar. Assoc. Bull. (1975).
  • S. Shawl, Elephant trunks in the Orion complex. Particle (Berkeley) 4 (1965).
  • R. S. Weyburn, Science and secretaries. Wash. Sci. Trends (9 January 1961).
  • Anon, Angels on a pin. Chem. Eng. 218 (21 September 1970).
  • Anon, Classification system of wildcat wells. California Oil World (August 1944).
  • Anon, Notes on writing scientific papers. J. Inst. Biol. 6, 73 (1959).

2. Established periodicals

  • H. J. Barr, A new genetical particle: the hypotheson, J. Theor. Biol. 3, 514 (1962).
  • D, K. Detterman and S. K. Reed, The Polynomial Law. Am. Psychol. 32(9 ) (September 1977).
  • A. G. Foraker, Minutes of the research conference, Perspect. Biol. Med. 5, 89 (1961).
  • A. G. Foraker, Minutes of the tissue Committee, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 234 (14 March 1964).
  • A. G. Foraker, The rise and decline of a professor—a fable, Perspect. Biol. Med. 11, 71–81 (1967).
  • A. G. Foraker, Project Pookashonoma. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 172, 212 (1962).
  • J. A. Frascino, If my body were a bureaucracy, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 238, 1247 (1977).
  • E. Grand, How I learned to stop worrying and love lecturing. Chem. Eng. 711, 152–154 (1964).
  • D. S. Greenberg, Questions and answers with grant swinger. Science 151, 1201 (1966).
  • R. T. Hersh, Parkinson’s Law, the squid and pU. Am. Sci. 50, 274A (1962).
  • M. Hershkowitz, Penile frostbite, an unforeseen hazard of jogging. N. Engl. J. Med, 178 (20 January 1977).
  • K. F. Heumann, Notes on negative data. Am. Doc. 7, 36 (1956).
  • D. M, Jones, On being blinded with science. New Sci. 465 (24 November 1966).
  • R. V. Jones, The theory of practical joking—an elaboration. Bull. Inst Math. Appl. 11, 10–17 (1975).
  • A. Kohn, It is really irreproducible? Trends Biochem. Sci. 99 (May 1976).
  • A. Kohn, Sex and Money, in Scientific Information Transfer: The Editor’s role, edited by M. Balaban, pp. 249–253. D. Reidel Publ. Co., Dordrecht (1977).
  • S. Levin, The anatomy of the soul. Med. Proc. (SiAfrica) 10, 255–257 (1964).
  • S. Levin, Bobamycin: a clinical appraisal. Med. Proc. (S. Africa) 12, 519–520 (1966).
  • H. R. Lewis, The data enrichment method. Oper. Res. 5, 551 (1957).
  • H. Lynn, How to be a project leader—nine helpful hints. Oper. Res. 4, 484–488 (1956).
  • A. McGlashan, Breakfast breakthrough. Lancet ii, 912 (9 October 1971).
  • R. F. Maier, Maier’s Law. Am. Psychol. (15 March 1960).
  • R. McMillan and R. L. Longmire, Sounding Board Crisis in Oncology. Acute vowel obstruction (with apologies to oncologists everywhere). N. Engl. J. Med. 294, 1288–1289 (1976).
  • L. P. Miller, Life span of chemists, Chem. Eng. News. 42, 7 (1964).
  • D. Michie, Sciencemanship, Discovery 259–260 (June 1959)
  • H. Miner, Body Ritual Among the Nacirema. Am. Anthropol. 58, 504–507 (1956).
  • A. B. Pardee, pU: A new quantity in biochemistry. Am. Sci. 50, 130A (1962).
  • R. W, Payne, Peniswisle. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 172, 206–210 (1960).
  • A. Pelle, Thermowocky. Am. Sci. 48, 116A (1960).
  • J. E. Roberts, The spring Pediatric Research Meetings. A beginner’s guide to successful attendance, Clin. Pediat. 7, 10A–21A (1968).
  • J. E. Roberts, On the lighter side: On marking rounds. Clin. Pediat. 3, 370–373 (1964).
  • S. A. Rudin, Book Reviews: Two typical books from American Psychologist. Psychol. Rep. 5, 113–114 (1959).
  • M. T. Southgate, Writer’s syndrome. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 181, 1124 (1962).
  • R. Strauss, The medical archives of rationalia. Lancet ii. 1182 (1975).
  • R. Strauss, The glossobuccal syndrome. Can. Med. Assoc. J. 84, 38–39, 1961.
  • R. M. Stewart, The widespread adoption of an operational policy and its effect on the world as a whole. Oper. Res. 6(3) (1958).
  • M. Throdahl, The pencil problem—1990. Chem. Eng. News, 5 (21 January 1980).
  • N. Vanserg, How to write geologese. Eeon. Geol. 47, 220–223 (1952).
  • F. N. Young and S. Crowell, The application of gamesmanship in science. AIBS Bull. 6, 13 (1956).
  • 495–36–2278, Specom: A review of our language and our time in 1984, Today’s Speech 20, 3 (1972).
  • 495–36-2278, Last word on the bug battle. New Sci. 28, 111 (1965).
  • R. F., Pessimism, optimism induced in SB-Jr mice, Med. News 4(2), 5 (1956).
  • R. F., The triple blind test. Med. News 7, 43 (1959).

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.