453
Views
5
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review Article

Alternative methods in toxicology: CFU assays application, limitation and future prospective

, , , &
Pages 1-12 | Received 19 Aug 2013, Accepted 30 Nov 2014, Published online: 13 Feb 2015

References

  • Abnosi MH, Jafari Yazdi Z. (2012). Low dose and long term toxicity of sodium arsenite caused caspase dependent apoptosis based on morphology and biochemical character. Cell J 14:161–170
  • Akiyama K, You YO, Yamaza T, et al. (2012). Characterization of bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem cells in suspension. Stem Cell Res Ther 3:1–13
  • Attar EC, Scadden DT. (2004). Regulation of hematopoietic stem cell growth. Leukemia 18:1760–1768
  • Axelrod AA, McLeod OL, Shreeve MM, Heath DS. (1973). Properties of cells that produce erythrocitic colonies in vitro. In: Robinson AW, ed. Proceedings of the second international workshop on haemopoiesis in culture. New York: Grune and Stratton, 226–234
  • Balls M, Blaauboer BJ, Fentem JH, et al. (1995). Practical aspects of the validation of toxicity test procedures – the report and recommendations of Ecvam Workshop-5. ATLA-Alternatives Lab Anim 23:129–147
  • Belle L, Bruck F, Foguenne J, et al. (2012). Imatinib and nilotinib inhibit hematopoietic progenitor cell growth, but do not prevent adhesion, migration and engraftment of human cord blood CD34+ cells. PLoS One 7:e(5256)4
  • Bhatia M. (2007). Hematopoietic development from human embryonic stem cells. Hematol Am Soc Hematol Educ Prog 2007:11–16
  • Brandt J, Briddell RA, Srour EF, et al. (1992). Role of C-Kit ligand in the expansion of human hematopoietic progenitor cells. Blood 79:634–641
  • Bryder D, Jacobsen SE. (2000). Interleukin-3 supports expansion of long-term multilineage repopulating activity after multiple stem cell divisions in vitro. Blood 96:1748–1755
  • Caplan AI. (1991). Mesenchymal stem cells. J Orthop Res 9:641–650
  • Carfi M, Croera C, Ferrario D, et al. (2008). TBTC induces adipocyte differentiation in human bone marrow long term culture. Toxicology 249:11–18
  • Carfi M, Gennari A, Malerba I, et al. (2007). In vitro tests to evaluate immunotoxicity: a preliminary study. Toxicology 229:11–22
  • Casati S, Collotta A, Gribaldo L. (1999). Human umbilical cord blood and bone marrow as a source of CD34+ CD38− cells for the in vitro CFU-MK assay. ATLA-Altern Lab Anim 27:120
  • Casati S, Collotta A, Clothier R, et al (2003). Refinement of the colony-forming unit-megakaryocyte (CFU-MK) assay for its application to pharmaco-toxicological testing. Toxicol In Vitro 17:69–75
  • Castro-Malaspina H, Gay Re, Resnick G, et al. (1980). Characterization of human bone marrow fibroblast colony-forming cells (CFU-F) and their progeny. Blood 56:289–301
  • Chatterjee S, Basak P, Chaklader M, et al. (2013). Pesticide induced marrow toxicity and effects on marrow cell population and on hematopoietic stroma. Exp Toxicol Pathol 65:287–295
  • Chatterjee S, Dutta RK, Basak P, et al. (2010). Alteration in marrow stromal microenvironment and apoptosis mechanisms involved in aplastic anemia: an animal model to study the possible disease pathology. Stem Cells Int 2010:Article ID 932354, doi:10.4061/2010/932354
  • Clarke E, Pereira C, Chaney R, et al. (2007). Toxicity testing using hematopoietic stem cell assays. Regen Med 2:947–956
  • Croera C, Ferrario D, Gribaldo L. (2008). In vitro toxicity of naphthalene, 1-naphthol, 2-naphthol and 1,4-naphthoquinone on human CFU-GM from female and male cord blood donors. Toxicol In Vitro 22:1555–1561
  • Curren RD, Southee JA, Spielmann H, et al. (1995). The role of prevalidation in the development, validation and acceptance of alternative methods. ATLA-Altern Lab Anim 23:211–217
  • Dal Negro G, Bonato M, Gribaldo L. (2001). In vitro bone marrow granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cultures in the assessment of hematotoxic potential of the new drugs. Cell Biol Toxicol 17:95–105
  • Dal Negro G, Vandin L, Bonato M, et al. (2006a). A new experimental protocol as an alternative to the colony-forming unit-granulocyte/macrophage (CFU-GM) clonogenic assay to assess the haematotoxic potential of new drugs. Toxicol In Vitro 20:750–756
  • Dal Negro G, Vandin L, Bonato M, Sciuscio D. (2006b). Toward refinement of the colony-forming unit-granulocyte/macrophage clonogenic assay: inclusion of a metabolic system. Toxicol In Vitro 20:743–749
  • Damen J. (2012). The CFU assay in preclinical toxicity testing: an in vitro tool for predicting in vivo cytopenia. Vancouver, Canada: STEMCELL Technologies Inc
  • Davies C, Yip BH, Fernandez-Mercado M, et al. (2013). Silencing of ASXL1 impairs the granulomonocytic lineage potential of human CD34(+) progenitor cells. Brit J Haematol 160:842–850
  • Denker HW. (1999). Embryonic stem cells: an exciting field for basic research and tissue engineering, but also an ethical dilemma? Cells Tissues Organs 165:246–249
  • Denker HW. (2000). Embryonale Stammzellen und ihre ethische Wertigkeit: Aspekte des Totipotenz-Problems. In: Honnefelder LS, ed. Jahrbuch für Wissenschaft und Ethik. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 291–304
  • Denker HW. (2002). Forschung an embryonalen stammzellen: eine diskussion der begriffe totipotenz und pluripotenz. In: Oduncu FSU, Vossenkuhl W, eds. Stammzellenforschung und therapeutisches Klonen. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 19–35
  • Denker HW. (2009). Induced pluripotent stem cells: how to deal with the developmental potential. Reprod Biomed Online 19:34–37
  • Diodovich C, Bianchi MG, Bowe G, et al. (2004). Response of human cord blood cells to styrene exposure: evaluation of its effects on apoptosis and gene expression by genomic technology. Toxicology 200:145–157
  • Diodovich C, Ferrario D, Casati B, et al. (2005a). Sensitivity of human cord blood cells to tetrachloroethylene: cellular and molecular endpoints. Arch Toxicol 79:508–514
  • Diodovich C, Malerba I, Ferrario D, et al. (2005b). Gene and protein expressions in human cord blood cells after exposure to acrylonitrile. J Biochem Mol Toxicol 19:204–212
  • Erickson-Miller CL, May RD, Tomaszewski J, et al. (1997). Differential toxicity of camptothecin, topotecan and 9-aminocamptothecin to human, canine, and murine myeloid progenitors (CFU-GM) in vitro. Cancer Chemother Pharmacol 39:467–472
  • Ferrari G, Cusella-De Angelis G, Coletta M, et al. (1998). Muscle regeneration by bone marrow derived myogenic progenitors. Science 279:1528–1530
  • Ferrario D, Croera C, Brustio R, et al. (2008). Toxicity of inorganic arsenic and its metabolites on haematopoietic progenitors “in vitro”: comparison between species and sexes. Toxicology 249:102–108
  • Friedenstein AJ, Chailakhyan RK, Gerasimov UV. (1987). Bone marrow osteogenic stem cells: in vitro cultivation and transplantation in diffusion chambers. Cell Tissue Kinet 20:263–272
  • Friedenstein AJ, Chailakhjan RK, Lalykina KS. (1970). The development of fibroblast colonies in monolayer cultures of guinea-pig bone marrow and spleen cells. Cell Tissue Kinet 3:393–403
  • Friedenstein AJ, Gorskaja JF, Kulagina NN. (1976). Fibroblast precursors in normal and irradiated mouse hematopoietic organs. Exp Hematol, 4:267–274
  • Froquet R, Sibiril Y, Parent-Massin D. (2001). Improvement of megakaryocytic progenitor culture for toxicological investigations. Toxicol In Vitro 15:691–699
  • Ghielmini M, Colli E, Bosshard G, et al. (1998). Hematotoxicity on human bone marrow- and umbilical cord blood-derived progenitor cells and in vitro therapeutic index of methoxymorpholinyldoxorubicin and its metabolites. Cancer Chemother Pharmacol 42:235–240
  • Glimm H, Oh IH, Eaves CJ. (2000). Human hematopoietic stem cells stimulated to proliferate in vitro lose engraftment potential during their S/G(2)/M transit and do not reenter G(0). Blood 96:4185–4193
  • Goff JP, Shields DS, Wang H, et al. (2013). Evaluation of potential ionizing irradiation protectors and mitigators using clonogenic survival of human umbilical cord blood hematopoietic progenitor cells. Exp Hematol 41:957–966
  • Gordon MY. (1993a). Human haemopoietic stem cell assays. Blood Rev 7:190–197
  • Gordon MY. (1993b). Origin and development of neutrophils In Immunopharmacology of neutrophils. London (UK): Academic Press, Ltd
  • Grande T, Bueren JA. (1995). Analysis of hematopoiesis in mice irradiated with 500 mGy of X rays at different stages of development. Radiat Res 143:327–333
  • Greenwalt DE, Szabo J, Manchel I. (2001). High throughput cell-based assay of hematopoietic progenitor differentiation. J Biomolec Screen 6:383–392
  • Grever MR, Grieshaber CK. (1997). Chapter 59: Toxicology by organ system. In: Holland JF, Frei E, Bast R, et al., eds. Cancer medicine. 4th ed. Philadelphia (PA): Lea and Fibiger, 891–906
  • Gribaldo L. (2000). Haematotoxicology in drug development: a model of human toxicology. Prog Reduction Refinement Replacement Anim Exp 31:671–677
  • Gribaldo L, Casati S, Figliuzzi L, Marafante E. (1998). In vitro myelotoxicity of environmental contaminants. Environ Toxicol Pharmacol 6:135–141
  • Gribaldo L, Malerba I, Collotta A, et al. (2000). Inhibition of CFU-E/BFU-E by 3′-azido-3′-deoxythymidine, chlorpropamide, and protoporphirin IX zinc (II): a comparison between direct exposure of progenitor cells and long-term exposure of bone marrow cultures. Toxicol Sci 58:96–101
  • Haglund C, Aleskog A, Hakansson LD, et al. (2010). The FMCA-GM assays, high throughput non-clonogenic alternatives to CFU-GM in preclinical hematotoxicity testing. Toxicol Lett 194:102–107
  • Hartmann J, Braulke F, Sinzig U, et al. (2013). Iron overload impairs proliferation of erythroid progenitors cells (BFU-E) from patients with myelodysplastic syndromes. Leukemia Res 37:327–332
  • Heinemann T. (2005). Klonieren beim Menschen. Analyse des Methodenspektrums und internationaler Vergleich der ethischen Bewertungskriterien. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter
  • Holm S. (2004). Stem cell transplantation and ethics: a European overview. Fetal Diagn Ther 19:113–118
  • Holm S. (2005). Embryonic stem cell research and the moral status of human embryos. Reprod Biomed Online 10:63–67
  • Horowitz D, King AG. (2000). Colorimetric determination of inhibition of hematopoietic progenitor cells in soft agar. J Immunol Methods 244:49–58
  • Jing DH, Fonseca AV, Alakel N, et al. (2010). Hematopoietic stem cells in co-culture with mesenchymal stromal cells – modeling the niche compartments in vitro. Haematol Hematol J 95:542–550
  • Kandarova H, Letasiova S. (2011). Alternative methods in toxicology: pre-validated and validated methods. Interdiscip Toxicol 4:107–113
  • Kang L, Gao S. (2012). Pluripotency of induced pluripotent stem cells. J Anim Sci Biotechnol 3:5
  • Lemischka I. (1991). Clonal, in vivo behavior of the totipotent hematopoietic stem cell. Semin Immunol 3:349–355
  • Liu YX, Yue W, Ji L, et al. (2010). Production of erythriod cells from human embryonic stem cells by fetal liver cell extract treatment. BMC Dev Biol 10:85. doi:10.1186/1471-213X-10-85
  • Ma F, Wang D, Hanada S, et al. (2007). Novel method for efficient production of multipotential hematopoietic progenitors from human embryonic stem cells. Int J Hematol 85:371–379
  • Malerba I, Casati S, Diodovich C, et al. (2004). Inhibition of CFU-E/BFU-E and CFU-GM colony growth by cyclophosphamide, 5-fluorouracil and taxol: development of a high-throughput in vitro method. Toxicol In Vitro 18:293–300
  • Malerba I, Castoldi AF, Parent-Massin D, Gribaldo L. (2002). In vitro myelotoxicity of propanil and 3,4-dichloroaniline on murine and human CFU-E/BFU-E progenitors. Toxicol Sci 69:433–438
  • May JE, Morse HR, Xu J, Donaldson C. (2012). Development of a novel, physiologically relevant cytotoxicity model: application to the study of chemotherapeutic damage to mesenchymal stromal cells. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 263:374–389
  • Mets T, Verdonk G. (1981). In vitro aging of human bone marrow derived stromal cells. Mech Ageing Dev 16:81–89
  • Miller CL, Eaves CJ. (1997). Expansion in vitro of adult murine hematopoietic stem cells with transplantable lympho-myeloid reconstituting ability. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94:13648–13653
  • Molyneux G, Gibson FM, Chen CM, et al. (2008). The haemotoxicity of azathioprine in repeat dose studies in the female CD-1 mouse. Int J Exp Pathol 89:138–158
  • Naughton BA, Naughton GK. (1989). Hematopoiesis on nylon mesh templates. Comparative long-term bone marrow culture and the influence of stromal support cells. Ann N Y Acad Sci 554:125–140
  • Naughton BA, Sibanda B, Azar L, San Roman J. (1992). Differential effects of drugs upon hematopoiesis can be assessed in long-term bone marrow cultures established on nylon screens. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 199:481–490
  • Orlovskaya I, Schraufstatter I, Loring J, Khaldoyanidi S. (2008). Hematopoietic differentiation of embryonic stem cells. Methods 45:159–167
  • Outlook Reports. (2010). Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development, TUFTS University, Boston, MA, USA, pp. 1–12
  • Owen ME, Friedenstein AJ. (1998). Stromal stem cells: marrow-derived osteogenic precursors. Cell and molecular biology of vertebrate hard tissues: Ciba Foundation Symposium; Chichester (UK), 42–60
  • Parchment RE. (1998). Alternative testing systems for evaluating noncarcinogenic, hematologic toxicity. Environ Health Perspect 106:541–557
  • Parchment RE, Gordon M, Grieshaber CK, et al. (1998). Predicting hematological toxicity (myelosuppression) of cytotoxic drug therapy from in vitro tests. Ann Oncol 9:357–364
  • Parchment RE, Volpe DA, Lorusso PM, et al. (1994). In vivo-in vitro correlation of myelotoxicity of 9-methoxypyrazoloacridine (NSC-(3661)40, PD(1159)34) to myeloid and erythroid hematopoietic progenitors from human, murine, and canine marrow. J Natl Cancer Inst 86:273–280
  • Parent-Massin D. (1997). Improvement of erythroblastic progenitor culture for toxicological investigations. Toxicol Mech Meth 7:363–380
  • Parent-Massin D. (2000). Relevance of clonogenic assays in food haematotoxicology. In: Balls M, Zeller AM, Halder M, eds. Progress in the reduction, refinement and replacement of animal experimentation, development in animal and veterinary sciences. 3rd, World Congress on Alternatives and Animal Use in the Life Sciences. Elsevier Science, 709–716
  • Parent-Massin D. (2001). Relevance of clonogenic assays in hematotoxicology. Cell Biol Toxicol 17:87–94
  • Parent-Massin D, Hymery N, Sibiril Y. (2010). Stem cells in myelotoxicity. Toxicology 267:112–117
  • Parent-Massin D, Thouvenot D. (1993). In vitro study of pesticide hematotoxicity in human and rat progenitors. J Pharmacol Toxicol Methods 30:203–207
  • Pereira C, Clarke E, Damen J. (2007). Hematopoietic colony-forming cell assays. Methods Mol Biol 407:177–208
  • Pereira RF, O'Hara MD, Laptev AV, et al. (1998). Marrow stromal cells as a source of progenitor cells for nonhematopoietic tissues in transgenic mice with a phenotype of osteogenesis imperfecta. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95:1142–1147
  • Pessina A, Albella B, Bayo M, et al. (2002). In vitro tests for haematotoxicity: prediction of drug-induced myelosuppression by the CFU-GM assay. Altern Lab Anim 30:75–79
  • Pessina A, Albella B, Bayo M, et al. (2003). Application of the CFU-GM assay to predict acute drug-induced neutropenia: an international blind trial to validate a prediction model for the maximum tolerated dose (MTD) of myelosuppressive xenobiotics. Toxicol Sci 75:355–367
  • Pessina A, Albella B, Bueren J, et al. (2001). Prevalidation of a model for predicting acute neutropenia by colony forming unit granulocyte/macrophage (CFU-GM) assay. Toxicol In Vitro 15:729–740
  • Pessina A, Bonomi A. (2007). CFU-GM assay for evaluation of drug myelotoxic activity. In: Maines MD, ed. Current protocols in toxicology. Chapter 20. John Wiley and Sons Inc., Unit 20.2
  • Pessina A, Bonomi A, Baglio C, et al. (2009a). Refinement and optimisation of the rat CFU-GM assay to incorporate the use of cryopreserved bone-marrow cells for in vitro toxicology applications. Altern Lab Anim 37:417–425
  • Pessina A, Bonomi A, Cavicchini L, et al. (2010). Prevalidation of the rat CFU-GM assay for in vitro toxicology applications. Altern Lab Anim 38:105–117
  • Pessina A, Croera C, Bayo M, et al. (2004). A methylcellulose microculture assay for the in vitro assessment of drug toxicity on granulocyte/macrophage progenitors (CFU-GM). Altern Lab Anim 32:17–23
  • Pessina A, Malerba F, Gribaldo L. (2005). Hematotoxicity testing by cell clonogenic assay in drug development and preclinical trials. Curr Pharm Design 11:1055–1065
  • Pessina A, Parent-Massin D, Albella B, et al. (2009b). Application of human CFU-Mk assay to predict potential thrombocytotoxicity of drugs. Toxicol In Vitro 23:194–200
  • Pessina A, Piccirillo M, Mineo E, et al. (1999). Role of SR-(4987) stromal cells in the modulation of doxorubicin toxicity to in vitro granulocyte-macrophage progenitors (CFU-GM). Life Sci 65:513–523
  • Piersma AH, Brockbank KG, Ploemacher RE, et al. (1985). Characterization of fibroblastic stromal cells from murine bone marrow. Exp Hematol 13:237–243
  • Pirson L, Baron F, Meuris N, et al. (2006). Despite inhibition of hematopoietic progenitor cell growth in vitro, the tyrosine kinase inhibitor imatinib does not impair engraftment of human CD133+ cells into NOD/SCIDbeta2mNull mice. Stem Cells 24:1814–1821
  • Pochampally R. (2008). Colony forming unit assays for MSCs. Methods Mol Biol 449:83–91
  • Prockop DJ. (1997). Marrow stromal cells as stem cells for nonhematopoietic tissues. Science (New York, N Y) 276:71–74
  • Rahnama R, Wang M, Dang AC, et al. (2013). Cytotoxicity of local anesthetics on human mesenchymal stem cells. J Bone Joint Surg Am 95:132–137
  • Rajesh D, Chinnasamy N, Mitalipov SM, et al. (2007). Differential requirements for hematopoietic commitment between human and rhesus embryonic stem cells. Stem Cells 25:490–499
  • Reece P, Baatjes AJ, Cyr MM, et al. (2013). Toll-like receptor-mediated eosinophil-basophil differentiation: autocrine signalling by granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor in cord blood haematopoietic progenitors. Immunology 139:256–264
  • Rich IN, Hall KM. (2005). Validation and development of a predictive paradigm for hemotoxicology using a multifunctional bioluminescence colony-forming proliferation assay. Toxicol Sci 87:427–441
  • Rio B, Lautraite S, Parent-Massin D. (1997a). In vitro toxicity of trichothecenes on human erythroblastic progenitors. Hum Exp Toxicol 16:673–679
  • Rio B, Parent-Massin D. (1997). Improvement of erythroblastic progenitor culture for toxicological investigations. Toxicol Methods 7:363–380
  • Rio B, Parent-Massin D, Lautraite S, Hoellinger H. (1997b). Effects of a diphenyl-ether herbicide, oxyfluorfen, on human BFU-E/CFU-E development and haemoglobin synthesis. Hum Exp Toxicol 16:115–122
  • Roda E, Coccini T, Acerbi D, et al. (2010). Comparative in vitro and ex-vivo myelotoxicity of aflatoxins B1 and M1 on haematopoietic progenitors (BFU-E, CFU-E, and CFU-GM): species-related susceptibility. Toxicol In Vitro 24:217–223
  • Scherzed A, Hackenberg S, Froelich K, et al. (2013). Effects of salinomycin on human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells in vitro. Toxicol Lett 218:207–214
  • Schmitt TM, Zuniga-Pflucker JC. (2002). Induction of T cell development from hematopoietic progenitor cells by delta-like-1 in vitro. Immunity 17:749–756
  • Song H, Vita M, Sallam H, et al. (2007). Effect of the Cdk-inhibitor roscovitine on mouse hematopoietic progenitors in vivo and in vitro. Cancer Chemother Pharmacol 60:841–849
  • Spangrude GJ, Smith L, Uchida N, et al. (1991). Mouse hematopoietic stem cells. Blood 78:1395–1402
  • Steinbock B. (2007). The science, policy, and ethics of stem cell research. Reprod BioMed Online 14:130–136
  • Stephenson JR, Axelrad AA, McLeod DL, Shreeve MM. (1971). Induction of colonies of hemoglobin-synthesizing cells by erythropoietin in vitro. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 68:1542–1546
  • Tepperman AD, Curtis JE, McCulloch EA. (1974). Erythropietic colonies in cultures of human marrow. Blood 44:659–669
  • Testa NG, Dexter TM. (1977). Long-term production of erythroid precursor cells (BFU) in bone marrow cultures. Differentiation 9:193–195
  • The President's Council on Bioethics. (2005). The President's Council on Bioethics Alternative sources of human pluripotent stem cells. A White Paper. Washington (DC): The President's Council on Bioethics
  • Tian X, Morris JK, Linehan JL, Kaufman DS. (2004). Cytokine requirements differ for stroma and embryoid body-mediated hematopoiesis from human embryonic stem cells. Exp Hematol 32:1000–1009
  • Van Den Heuvel RL, Leppens H, Schoeters GE. (2001). Use of in vitro assays to assess hematotoxic effects of environmental compounds. Cell Biol Toxicol 17:107–116
  • van Os RP, Dethmers-Ausema B, de Haan G. (2008). In vitro assays for cobblestone area-forming cells, LTC-IC, and CFU-C. Methods Mol Biol 430:143–157
  • Vemuri MC, Chase LG, Rao MS. (2011). Mesenchymal stem cell assays and applications. Methods Mol Biol 698:3–8
  • Verma A, Deb DK, Sassano A, et al. (2002). Activation of the p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase mediates the suppressive effects of type I Interferons and transforming growth factor-beta on normal hematopoiesis. J Biol Chem 277:7726–7735
  • Volpe DA, Warren MK. (2003). Myeloid clonogenic assays for comparison of the in vitro toxicity of alkylating agents. Toxicol In Vitro 17:271–277
  • Whitlock CA, Witte ON. (1982). Long-term culture of B lymphocytes and their precursors from murine bone marrow. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 79:3608–3612
  • Wognum B, Yuan N, Lai B, Miller CL. (2013). Colony forming cell assays for human hematopoietic progenitor cells. Methods Mol Biol 946:267–283
  • Wolf B, Morgan H, Krieg J, et al. (2012). A whole blood in vitro cytokine release assay with aqueous monoclonal antibody presentation for the prediction of therapeutic protein induced cytokine release syndrome in humans. Cytokine 60:828–837

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.