3,837
Views
7
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Article

Fractures in the framework: limitations of classification systems in psychiatry


Fracturas en el armazón: limitaciones de los sistemas de clasificación en psiquiatría

Les limites des systèmes de classification en psychiatrie ou quand le cadre vole en éclats

, &

REFERENCES

  • LempérièreTThe importance of classifications in psychiatryEncephale19952137
  • American Psychiatric AssociationDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders2013 5th ed. Arlington, VA American Psychiatric Publishing
  • World Health OrganizationInternational Classification of Diseases2019World Health Organization
  • ClarkLACuthbertBLewis-FernándezRNarrowWEReedGMThree approaches to understanding and classifying mental disorder: ICD-11, DSM-5, and the National Institute of Mental Health’s Research Domain Criteria (RDoC)Psychol Sci Public Interes201718272145
  • ShorterEThe history of nosology and the rise of the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disordersDialogues Clin Neurosci2015171596725987864
  • KendlerKSFirstMBAlternative futures for the DSM revision process: Iteration v. paradigm shiftBr J Psychiatry2010197426326520884947
  • BhugraDPsychiatry in ancient Indian texts: A reviewHist Psychiatry199231016718611623029
  • CheCTGeorgeVIjinuTPPushpangadanPAndrae-MarobelaKTraditional medicine Pharmacognosy: Fundamentals, Applications and Strategy2016 London, UK Elsevier Inc 1530
  • van BergenLEmil Kraepelin: grandfather of the DSMMed Confl Surviv2015313-415816126708489
  • SeitelbergerFTheodor Meynert (1833-1892), pioneer and visionary of brain researchJ Hist Neurosci19976326427411619863
  • HoutsACFifty years of psychiatric nomenclature: Reflections on the 1943 war Department Technical Bulletin, Medical 203J Clin Psychol200056793596710902952
  • FischerBAA review of American psychiatry through its diagnoses: the history and development of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental DisordersJ Nerv Ment Dis2012200121022103023197117
  • BlashfieldRKKeeleyJWFlanaganEHMilesSRThe cycle of classification: DSM-I through DSM-5Annu Rev Clin Psychol2014101255124679178
  • Hale Jr.NGThe Rise and Crisis of Psychoanalysis in the United States: Freud and the Americans, 1917–19851995 New York, NY Oxford University Press
  • MayesRHorwitzA VDSM-III and the revolution in the classification of mental illnessJ Hist Behav Sci20054124926715981242
  • GurlandBJFleissJLSharpeLet alCross-national study of diagnosis of mental disorders: hospital diagnoses and hospital patients in New York and LondonCompr Psychiatry197011118255411210
  • KendellRECooperJEGourlayJRMAJJRMCopelandJRMSharpeLGurlandBJDiagnostic criteria of american and british psychiatristsArch Gen Psychiatry19712521231305569450
  • FeighnerJPRobinsEGuzeSBWoodruffRAWinokurGMunozRDiagnostic criteria for use in psychiatric researchArch Gen Psychiatry197226157635009428
  • KendlerKSMuñozRAMurphyGThe development of the feighner criteria: A historical perspectiveAm J Psychiatry2010167213414220008944
  • American Psychiatric AssociationDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders19803rd ed.Washington, DCAmerican Psychiatric Association
  • VaillantGEThe disadvantages of DSM-III outweigh its advantagesAm J Psychiatry19841414542545
  • FaustDMinerRAThe empiricist and his new clothes: DSM-III in perspectiveAm J Psychiatry198614389629673728742
  • KesslerRCMcGonagleKAZhaoet alLifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorders in the united states: results from the national comorbidity surveyArch Gen Psychiatry19945118198279933
  • HamiltonSRothbartMDawesRMSex bias, diagnosis, and DSM-IIISex Roles1986155-6269274
  • FordMRWidigerTASex bias in the diagnosis of histrionic and antisocial personality disordersJ Consult Clin Psychol19895723013052708619
  • WakefieldJCDisorder as harmful dysfunction: a conceptual critique of DSM-III-R’s definition of mental disorderPsychol Rev19929922322471594724
  • SurísAHollidayRNorthCSThe evolution of the classification of psychiatric disordersBehav Sci (Basel, Switzerland)201661
  • López-MuñozFGarcía-GarcíaPSáiz-RuizJet alA bibliometric study of the use of the classification and diagnostic systems in psychiatry over the last 25 yearsPsychopathology200841421422518408417
  • SchalockRLLuckassonRAShogrenKAet alThe renaming of mental retardation: Understanding the change to the term intellectual disabilityIntellect Dev Disabil200745211612417428134
  • ReedGMMendonça CorreiaJEsparzaPSaxenaSMajMThe WPA-WHO global survey of psychiatrists’ attitudes towards mental disorders classificationWorld Psychiatry201110211813121633689
  • ChmielewskiMClarkLABagbyRMWatsonDMethod matters: Understanding diagnostic reliability in DSM-IV and DSM-5J Abnorm Psychol2015124376476926098046
  • World Health OrganizationInternational Statistical Classification of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of Death1967Geneva, SwitzerlandWorld Health Organization
  • KeeleyJWReedGMRobertsMCet alDeveloping a science of clinical utility in diagnostic classification systems field study strategies for ICD-11 mental and behavioral disordersAm Psychol201671131626766762
  • FirstMBBhatVAdlerDet alHow do clinicians actually use the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in clinical practice and why we need to know moreJ Nerv Ment Dis20142021284184425390931
  • FirstMBRebelloTJKeeleyJWet alDo mental health professionals use diagnostic classifications the way we think they do? A global surveyWorld Psychiatry201817218719529856559
  • BhugraDEasterAMallarisYGuptaSClinical decision making in psychiatry by psychiatristsActa Psychiatr Scand2011124540341121740401
  • KirmayerLJThe place of culture in psychiatric nosology: Taijin kyofusho and DSM-III-RJ Nerv Ment Dis19911791191985144
  • SomeyaTTakahashiMTakahashiMIs DSM widely accepted by Japanese clinicians?Psychiatry Clin Neurosci200155543745011555338
  • TeoARGawACHikikomori, a Japanese culture-bound syndrome of social withdrawal?: A proposal for DSM-5J Nerv Ment Dis2010198644444920531124
  • Lewis-FernándezRKrishan AggarwalNAggarwalNKCulture and psychiatric diagnosisAdv Psychosom Med201333153023816860
  • KohrtBARasmussenAKaiserBNet alCultural concepts of distress and psychiatric disorders: literature review and research recommendations for global mental health epidemiologyInt J Epidemiol201443236540624366490
  • Tanaka-MatsumiJTaijin Kyofusho: diagnostic and cultural issues in Japanese psychiatryCult Med Psychiatry197933231245520018
  • TsengW-SHandbook of Cultural Psychiatry2001 San Diego, CA Academic Press
  • TsengWSFrom peculiar psychiatric disorders through culture-bound syndromes to culture-related specific syndromesTranscult Psychiatry200643455457617166946
  • BaigBJSocial and transcultural aspects of psychiatry Companion to Psychiatric Studies2010 Elsevier 109119
  • KesslerRCThe World Health Organization International Consortium in Psychiatric Epidemiology (ICPE): initial work and future directions - the NAPE Lecture 1998Acta Psychiatr Scand19999912910066001
  • KesslerRCBrometEJThe epidemiology of depression across culturesAnnu Rev Public Health201334111913823514317
  • JablenskyASartoriusNErnbergGet alSchizophrenia: manifestations, incidence and course in different cultures A World Health Organization Ten-Country StudyPsychol Med Monogr Suppl1992201971565705
  • KhambatyMParikhRMCultural aspects of anxiety disorders in IndiaDialogues Clin Neurosci201719211712628867936
  • FernandoSGlobalization of psychiatry - a barrier to mental health developmentInt Rev Psychiatry201426555155725343630
  • U.S. Department of Health and Human ServicesCulture Counts: The Influence of Culture and Society on Mental Health2001U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
  • VentriglioAAyonrindeOBhugraDRelevance of culture-bound syndromes in the 21st centuryPsychiatry Clin Neurosci20167013626332813
  • CartwrightSReport on the diseases and physical peculiarities of the Negro raceNew-Orleans Med Surg J18517691715
  • Myers IIBE“Drapetomania”: Rebellion, Defiance and Free Black Insanity in the Antebellum United States2014 Los Angeles, CA University of California
  • Van VorenRPolitical abuse of psychiatry - An historical overviewSchizophr Bull2010361333519892821
  • MunroRChina’s Psychiatric Inquisition: Dissent, Psychiatry and the Law in Post-1949 China2006 London, UK Wildy, Simmonds & Hill
  • MunroRJudicial psychiatry in China and its political abusesColumbia J Asian Law2000141128
  • KarandeSSholapurwalaRKulkarniMManaging specific learning disability in schools in IndiaIndian Pediatr201148751552021813921
  • KoegelLMatos-FredenRLangRKoegel RInterventions for children with autism spectrum disorders in inclusive school settingsCogn Behav Pract2012193401412
  • AtladottirHOGyllenbergDLangridgeAet alThe increasing prevalence of reported diagnoses of childhood psychiatric disorders: a descriptive multinational comparisonEur Child Adolesc Psychiatry201524217318324796725
  • MehtaMUse and abuse of specific learning disability certificatesInd Psychiatry J20112027723271859
  • HalleckSLHogeSKMillerRDSadoffRLHalleckNHThe use of psychiatric diagnoses in the legal process: Task force report of the American Psychiatric AssociationBull Am Acad Psychiatry Law19922044815001482801
  • MelleIThe Breivik case and what psychiatrists can learn from itWorld Psychiatry2013121162123471788
  • British Legal Debate: Premenstrual Tension and Criminal BehaviourThe New York Times Published December 29, 1981
  • PressMPPremenstrual Stress Syndrome as a Defense in Criminal CasesDuke Law J198319831176
  • DaltonKCyclical criminal acts in premenstrual syndromeLancet1980316820310701071
  • SolomonLPremenstrual syndrome: the debate surrounding criminal defenseMaryl Law Rev199554571
  • RowanKMcAlpineDDBlewettLAAccess and cost barriers to mental health care, by insurance status, 1999–2010Health Aff2013321017231730
  • BijalASKumarCNManjunathaNGowdaMBasavarajuVMathSBHealth insurance and mental illnessIndian J Psychiatry201961Suppl 4S791S79731040476
  • MasiADeMayoMMGlozierNGuastellaAJAn overview of autism spectrum disorder, heterogeneity and treatment optionsNeurosci Bull201733218319328213805
  • CosgroveLKrimskySA comparison of DSM-IV and DSM-5 panel members’ financial associations with industry: a pernicious problem persistsPLoS Med201293e100119022427747
  • WeyandtLLOsterDRMarracciniMEet alPrescription stimulant medication misuse: Where are we and where do we go from here?Exp Clin Psychopharmacol201624540041427690507
  • BensonKFloryKHumphreysKLLeeSSMisuse of stimulant medication among college students: a comprehensive review and meta-analysisClin Child Fam Psychol Rev2015181507625575768
  • KerstingKAxis II - gets short shriftsMonit Psychol200435350
  • HallerHCramerHLaucheRGassFDobosGJThe prevalence and burden of subthreshold generalized anxiety disorder: a systematic reviewBMC Psychiatry201414112824886240
  • CuijpersPSmitFOostenbrinkJDe GraafRTen HaveMBeekmanAEconomic costs of minor depression: a population-based studyActa Psychiatr Scand2007115322923617302623
  • RegierDANarrowWEClarkeDEet alDSM-5 field trials in the United States and Canada, part II: Test-retest reliability of selected categorical diagnosesAm J Psychiatry20131701597023111466
  • NarrowWEClarkeDEKuramotoJet alDSM-5 field trials in the United States and Canada, part III: Development and reliability testing of a cross-cutting symptom assessment for DSM-5Am J Psychiatry20131701718223111499
  • JonesKDA critique of the DSM-5 field trialsJ Nerv Ment Dis2012200651751922652616
  • RøysambEKendlerKSTambsKet alThe joint structure of DSM-IV Axis I and Axis II disordersJ Abnorm Psychol2011120119820921319931
  • CoxBJPaguraJSteinMBSareenJThe relationship between generalized social phobia and avoidant personality disorder in a national mental health surveyDepress Anxiety200926435436219031488
  • PicchioniMMWalsheMToulopoulouTet alGenetic modelling of childhood social development and personality in twins and siblings with schizophreniaPsychol Med20104081305131619863839
  • RuizMAPincusALSchinkaJAExternalizing pathology and the five-factor model: a meta-analysis of personality traits associated with antisocial personality disorder, substance use disorder, and their co-occurrenceJ Pers Disord200822436538818684050
  • BattleDEDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)CoDAS201325219119224413388
  • KressVEMintonCABAdamsonNAPayloMJPopeVThe removal of the multiaxial system in the DSM-5: implications and practice suggestions for counselorsProf Couns201443191201
  • BoydJHBurkeJDGruenbergEet alExclusion criteria of DSM-III. A study of co-occurrence of hierarchy-free syndromesArch Gen Psychiatry198441109839896477056
  • MöllerHJBandelowBVolzHPBarnikolUBSeifritzEKasperSThe relevance of ‘mixed anxiety and depression’ as a diagnostic category in clinical practiceEur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci2016266872573627002521
  • González-RoblesADíaz-GarcíaAMiguelCGarcía-PalaciosABotellaCComorbidity and diagnosis distribution in transdiagnostic treatments for emotional disorders: A systematic review of randomized controlled trialsPLoS One20181311
  • Hofmeijer-SevinkMKBatelaanNMvan MegenHJGMet alClinical relevance of comorbidity in anxiety disorders: a report from the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA)J Affect Disord20121371-310611222240085
  • GadermannAMAlonsoJVilagutAMZaslavskyAMKesslerRCG Comorbidity and disease burden in the national comorbidity survey replication (NCS-R)Depress Anxiety201229979780622585578
  • KesslerRCAvenevoliSMcLaughlinKAet alLifetime co-morbidity of DSM-IV disorders in the US National Comorbidity Survey Replication Adolescent Supplement (NCS-A)Psychol Med20124291997201022273480
  • KesslerRCChiuWTDemlerOMerikangasKRWaltersEEPrevalence, severity, and comorbidity of 12-month DSM-IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey ReplicationArch Gen Psychiatry200562661762715939839
  • VaswaniMLindaFKRameshSRole of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors in psychiatric disorders: A comprehensive reviewProg Neuro-Psychopharmacology Biol Psychiatry200327185102
  • RobertsRJLohanoKKEl-MallakhRSAntipsychotics as antidepressantsAsia-Pacific Psychiatry20168317918825963405
  • HofmannSGAsnaaniAVonkIJJSawyerATFangAThe efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy: a review of meta-analysesCognit Ther Res2012365427440
  • PienkosEGierschAHansenMet alHallucinations beyond voices: a conceptual review of the phenomenology of altered perception in psychosisSchizophr Bull201945S67S7730715544
  • CarragherNKruegerRFEatonNRet alDisorders without borders: current and future directions in the meta-structure of mental disordersSoc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol201550333935025557024
  • BenazziFClassifying mood disorders by age-at-onset instead of polarityProg Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry2009331869318992784
  • KupferDJRegierDANeuroscience, clinical evidence, and the future of psychiatric classification in DSM-5Am J Psychiatry2011168767267421724672
  • AndiónÓFerrerMCalvoNet alExploring the clinical validity of borderline personality disorder componentsCompr Psychiatry2013541344022794943
  • Galatzer-LevyIRBryantRA636,120 ways to have posttraumatic stress disorderPerspect Psychol Sci20138665166226173229
  • van Heugten-van der KloetDvan HeugtenTThe classification of psychiatric disorders according to DSM-5 deserves an internationally standardized psychological test battery on symptom levelFront Psychol20156110826300808
  • HoeheMRMorris-RosendahlDJThe role of genetics and genomics in clinical psychiatryDialogues Clin Neurosci201820316917730581286
  • PohlKMSabuncuMRA unified framework for MR based disease classification Lecture Notes in Computer Science (Including Subseries Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence and Lecture Notes in Bioinformatics)2009300313
  • FalkaiPSchmittAAndreasenNForty years of structural brain imaging in mental disorders: Is it clinically useful or not?Dialogues Clin Neurosci201820317918630581287
  • ErguzelTOzekesSArtificial intelligence approaches in psychiatric disordersJ Neurobehav Sci20141252
  • JiangFJiangYZhiHet al Artificial intelligence in healthcare: Past, present and futureStroke Vasc Neurol20172423024329507784
  • ZhangTKoutsoulerisNMeisenzahlEDavatzikosCHeterogeneity of structural brain changes in subtypes of schizophrenia revealed using magnetic resonance imaging pattern analysisSchizophr Bull2015411748425261565
  • BorgwardtSKoutsoulerisNAstonJet alDistinguishing prodromal from first-episode psychosis using neuroanatomical single-subject pattern recognitionSchizophr Bull20133951105111422969150
  • KoutsoulerisNDavatzikosCBottlenderRet alEarly recognition and disease prediction in the at-risk mental states for psychosis using neurocognitive pattern classificationSchizophr Bull20123861200121521576280
  • RhebergenDLamersFSpijkerJde GraafRBeekmanATFPenninxBWJHCourse trajectories of unipolar depressive disorders identified by latent class growth analysisPsychol Med20124271383139622053816
  • SchnackHGNieuwenhuisMvan HarenNEMet alCan structural MRI aid in clinical classification? A machine learning study in two independent samples of patients with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and healthy subjectsNeuroimage20148429930624004694
  • OrrùGPettersson-YeoWMarquandAFSartoriGMechelliAUsing Support Vector Machine to identify imaging biomarkers of neurological and psychiatric disease: A critical reviewNeurosci Biobehav Rev20123641140115222305994
  • GrisanzioKAGoldstein-PiekarskiANWangMYRashed AhmedAPSamaraZWilliamsLMTransdiagnostic symptom clusters and associations with brain, behavior, and daily function in mood, anxiety, and trauma disordersJAMA Psychiatry201875220120929197929
  • KambeitzJKambeitz-IlankovicLLeuchtSet alDetecting neuroimaging biomarkers for schizophrenia: A meta-analysis of multivariate pattern recognition studiesNeuropsychopharmacology20154071742175125601228
  • KambeitzJCabralCSacchetMDet alDetecting neuroimaging biomarkers for depression: a meta-analysis of multivariate pattern recognition studiesBiol Psychiatry201782533033828110823
  • Librenza-GarciaDKotzianBJYangJet alThe impact of machine learning techniques in the study of bipolar disorder: A systematic reviewNeurosci Biobehav Rev20178053855428728937
  • BirurBKraguljacNVSheltonRCLahtiACBrain structure, function, and neurochemistry in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder—a systematic review of the magnetic resonance neuroimaging literatureNPJ Schizophr2017311528560261
  • CuthbertBNThe RDoC framework: Facilitating transition from ICD/DSM to dimensional approaches that integrate neuroscience and psychopathologyWorld Psychiatry2014131283524497240
  • CuthbertBNInselTRToward the future of psychiatric diagnosis: the seven pillars of RDoCBMC Med201311112623672542
  • MorrisSECuthbertBNResearch Domain Criteria: cognitive systems, neural circuits, and dimensions of behaviorDialogues Clin Neurosci2012141293722577302
  • KotovRKruegerRFWatsonDet alThe Hierarchical Taxonomy of Psychopathology (HiTOP): A dimensional alternative to traditional nosologiesJ Abnorm Psychol2017126445447728333488
  • KruegerRFKotovRWatsonDet alProgress in achieving quantitative classification of psychopathologyWorld Psychiatry201817328229330229571