6,894
Views
109
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Comprehension of Multiple Documents With Conflicting Information: A Two-Step Model of Validation

&

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (40)

Catharina Tibken, Tobias Richter & Wienke Wannagat. (2024) Metacognitive Comprehension Monitoring: Cognitive Abilities Explain Performance Differences Between Younger and Older Adults. Scientific Studies of Reading 28:3, pages 284-302.
Read now
Alexandra List, Gala S. Campos Oaxaca, Hongcui Du, Hye Yeon Lee & Bailing Lyu. (2024) Critical culturalized comprehension: Exploring culture as learners thinking about texts. Educational Psychologist 59:1, pages 1-19.
Read now
Alexandra List. (2024) The Limits of Reasoning: Students’ Evaluations of Anecdotal, Descriptive, Correlational, and Causal Evidence. The Journal of Experimental Education 92:1, pages 1-31.
Read now
Jason L. G. Braasch, Øistein Anmarkrud, Anette Andresen, Leila E. Ferguson & CarolAnne M. Kardash. (2023) Beliefs about the Malleability of Working Memory Guide College Students’ Evaluations of Belief-Inconsistent and Belief-Consistent Journal Articles. Reading Psychology 44:6, pages 649-671.
Read now
Eric B. Claravall, Elizabeth Isidro & Robin Irey. (2023) Historical Reasoning among Middle School Students with Learning Differences: Exploring the Use of Multiple Sources in Writing. Reading & Writing Quarterly 0:0, pages 1-25.
Read now
Alexandra List. (2023) Social justice reasoning when students learn about social issues using multiple texts. Discourse Processes 60:4-5, pages 244-272.
Read now
Anna E. Mason, Jason L. G. Braasch, Daphne Greenberg, Erica D. Kessler, Laura K. Allen & Danielle S. McNamara. (2023) Comprehending Multiple Controversial Texts about Childhood Vaccinations: Topic Beliefs and Integration Instructions. Reading Psychology 44:4, pages 436-462.
Read now
Colin Lescarret, Julien Magnier, Valérie Le Floch, Jean-Christophe Sakdavong, Jean-Michel Boucheix, André Tricot & Franck Amadieu. (2023) Expert but not persuasive: middle school students’ consideration of source in the processing of conflicting videos (Expertas pero no persuasivas: la consideración de las fuentes por parte de los estudiantes de secundaria en el procesamiento de vídeos contradictorios). Journal for the Study of Education and Development 46:2, pages 285-321.
Read now
Jason L. G. Braasch. (2023) Potential contributions of intellectual humility when reading on the Internet. The Journal of Positive Psychology 18:2, pages 254-258.
Read now
Andreas G. Wertgen & Tobias Richter. (2023) Source credibility and plausibility are considered in the validation of textual information: evidence from a social media context. Journal of Cognitive Psychology 35:2, pages 183-204.
Read now
Johanna Abendroth & Tobias Richter. (2023) Reading perspectives moderate text-belief consistency effects in eye movements and comprehension. Discourse Processes 60:2, pages 119-140.
Read now
Catharina Tibken, Tobias Richter, Wienke Wannagat, Sandra Schmiedeler, Nicole von der Linden & Wolfgang Schneider. (2022) Measuring Comprehension Monitoring with the Inconsistency Task in Adolescents: Stability, Associations with Reading Comprehension Skills, and Differences Between Grade Levels. Discourse Processes 59:5-6, pages 439-461.
Read now
Catherine M. Bohn-Gettler & Matthew T. McCrudden. (2022) Effects of Emotions, Topic Beliefs, and Task Instructions on the Processing and Memory for a Dual-Position Text. Discourse Processes 59:1-2, pages 52-75.
Read now
Christian Tarchi & Ruth Villalón. (2022) Fostering University Students’ Written Argumentation via Recursive Reading: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of College Reading and Learning 52:1, pages 42-63.
Read now
Mohammad N. Karimi & Tobias Richter. (2021) Text-Belief Consistency Effects in L2 Readers. Discourse Processes 58:8, pages 726-742.
Read now
Allison N. Sonia & Edward J. O’Brien. (2021) Text-Based Manipulation of the Coherence Threshold. Discourse Processes 58:5-6, pages 549-568.
Read now
Matthew T. McCrudden, Linh Huynh, Bailing Lyu & Jonna M. Kulikowich. (2021) Bridging Inferences and Learning from Multiple Complementary Texts. Discourse Processes 58:5-6, pages 529-548.
Read now
Jason L. G. Braasch & Erica D. Kessler. (2021) Working toward a theoretical model for source comprehension in everyday discourse. Discourse Processes 58:5-6, pages 449-467.
Read now
Meredith B. Carroll & Paige L. Sanchez. (2021) Decision making with conflicting information: influencing factors and best practice guidelines. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science 22:3, pages 296-316.
Read now
Christian Tarchi. (2021) Prompting Readers to Plan Might Negatively Affect Their Comprehension of Multiple Documents. Journal of College Reading and Learning 51:2, pages 131-152.
Read now
Erica D. Kessler, Jason L. G. Braasch & CarolAnne M. Kardash. (2021) The Contributions of Childhood Vaccination Misconceptions to the Evaluation and Sharing of Information from Multiple Internet Texts. Reading Psychology 42:3, pages 281-301.
Read now
Caroline Leroy, Peter Gerjets, Uwe Oestermeier & Yvonne Kammerer. (2021) Simultaneous Presentation of Multiple Documents and Text-Highlighting: Online Integrative Processes and Offline Integrated Understanding. Scientific Studies of Reading 25:2, pages 179-192.
Read now
Steffen Gottschling, Yvonne Kammerer, Eva Thomm & Peter Gerjets. (2020) How laypersons consider differences in sources’ trustworthiness and expertise in their regulation and resolution of scientific conflicts. International Journal of Science Education, Part B 10:4, pages 335-354.
Read now
Steffen Gottschling, Yvonne Kammerer & Peter Gerjets. (2019) Readers’ Processing and Use of Source Information as a Function of Its Usefulness to Explain Conflicting Scientific Claims. Discourse Processes 56:5-6, pages 429-446.
Read now
Murray Singer. (2019) Challenges in Processes of Validation and Comprehension. Discourse Processes 56:5-6, pages 465-483.
Read now
Vahid Aryadoust. (2019) An Integrated Cognitive Theory of Comprehension. International Journal of Listening 33:2, pages 71-100.
Read now
Cleci Werner da Rosa & José Otero. (2018) Influence of source credibility on students’ noticing and assessing comprehension obstacles in science texts. International Journal of Science Education 40:13, pages 1653-1668.
Read now
Alexandra List & Patricia A. Alexander. (2017) Analyzing and Integrating Models of Multiple Text Comprehension. Educational Psychologist 52:3, pages 143-147.
Read now
Helge I. Strømsø. (2017) Multiple Models of Multiple-Text Comprehension: A Commentary. Educational Psychologist 52:3, pages 216-224.
Read now
Ian Thacker, Hannah French & Shon Feder. Estimating climate change numbers: mental computation strategies that can support science learning. International Journal of Science Education 0:0, pages 1-22.
Read now
Murray Singer. The contributions of Walter Kintsch: Cascading cognitive science. Discourse Processes 0:0, pages 1-6.
Read now
Lisa Pilotek, Mohammad N. Karimi & Tobias Richter. Document language moderates the text-belief consistency effect. Discourse Processes 0:0, pages 1-11.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (69)

Liam W. Hart, Michael B. Wolfe, Todd J. Williams & Gregory M. Russell. (2024) Beliefs influence argumentative essay writing. Instructional Science.
Crossref
Mohammad N. Karimi. (2024) Text-belief consistency effect in L2 students’ integrated written representations based on multiple conflicting sources: Comparisons across summary vs. argumentation task instructions. Contemporary Educational Psychology 76, pages 102239.
Crossref
Alexandra List & Gala S. Campos Oaxaca. (2023) Comprehension and critique: an examination of students’ evaluations of information in texts. Reading and Writing 37:3, pages 641-671.
Crossref
Colin Lescarret, Julien Magnier, Valérie Le Floch, Jean-Christophe Sakdavong, Jean-Michel Boucheix & Franck Amadieu. (2023) “Because I agree with him”: the impact of middle-school students’ prior attitude on the evaluation of source credibility when watching videos. European Journal of Psychology of Education 39:1, pages 77-104.
Crossref
Miikka Kuutila, Carita Kiili, Reijo Kupiainen, Eetu Huusko, Junhao Li, Simo Hosio, Mika Mäntylä, Julie Coiro & Kristian Kiili. (2024) Revealing complexities when adult readers engage in the credibility evaluation of social media posts. Computers in Human Behavior 151, pages 108017.
Crossref
Marius Hans Raab. 2024. Konspiration. Konspiration 143 161 .
Christian Tarchi, Lidia Casado-Ledesma, Giulia Sanna & Margherita Conti. (2023) The relationship between theory of mind and multiple-document comprehension in university students: preliminary research findings. European Journal of Psychology of Education.
Crossref
Pauline Frick & Anne Schüler. (2023) Extending the theoretical foundations of multimedia learning: Activation, integration, and validation occur when processing illustrated texts. Learning and Instruction 87, pages 101800.
Crossref
Alexandra List. (2023) Critique generation when reading two opposing newspaper texts. European Journal of Psychology of Education.
Crossref
Ian Thacker. (2023) Climate change by the numbers: Leveraging mathematical skills for science learning online. Learning and Instruction 86, pages 101782.
Crossref
Carita Kiili, Eija Räikkönen, Ivar Bråten, Helge I. Strømsø & Michelle Schira Hagerman. (2023) Examining the structure of credibility evaluation when sixth graders read online texts. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 39:3, pages 954-969.
Crossref
Qiwei He, Francesca Borgonovi & Javier Suárez‐Álvarez. (2022) Clustering sequential navigation patterns in multiple‐source reading tasks with dynamic time warping method . Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 39:3, pages 719-736.
Crossref
Alexandra List & Yuting Sun. (2023) To Clarity and Beyond: Situating Higher-Order, Critical, and Critical-Analytic Thinking in the Literature on Learning from Multiple Texts. Educational Psychology Review 35:2.
Crossref
Colin Lescarret, Valérie Le Floch, Jean-Christophe Sakdavong, Jean-Michel Boucheix, André Tricot & Franck Amadieu. (2022) The impact of students’ prior attitude on the processing of conflicting videos: a comparison between middle-school and undergraduate students. European Journal of Psychology of Education 38:2, pages 519-544.
Crossref
Nattapat Boonprakong, Xiuge Chen, Catherine Davey, Benjamin Tag & Tilman Dingler. (2023) Bias-Aware Systems: Exploring Indicators for the Occurrences of Cognitive Biases when Facing Different Opinions. Bias-Aware Systems: Exploring Indicators for the Occurrences of Cognitive Biases when Facing Different Opinions.
Mohammad N. Karimi & Tobias Richter. (2021) Belief-biased representations of textual information in bilinguals: Language as a source characteristic. Current Psychology 42:12, pages 9852-9866.
Crossref
Mohammad N. Karimi & Tobias Richter. (2023) Thinking dispositions moderate adolescent readers’ mental models of conflicting sport information. Thinking Skills and Creativity 47, pages 101233.
Crossref
Murray Singer, Jackie Spear & Maria Rodrigo-Tamarit. (2022) Text validation: Overlooking consistency effect discrepancies. Memory & Cognition 51:2, pages 437-454.
Crossref
Matthew T. McCrudden, Ivar Bråten & Ladislao Salmerón. 2023. International Encyclopedia of Education(Fourth Edition). International Encyclopedia of Education(Fourth Edition) 353 363 .
Johanna Abendroth & Tobias Richter. 2023. Digital ist besser?! Psychologie der Online- und Mobilkommunikation. Digital ist besser?! Psychologie der Online- und Mobilkommunikation 139 153 .
Xiaohua Liu & John Read. 2023. Local Language Testing. Local Language Testing 83 102 .
Tobias Richter, Roland Berger, Mirjam Ebersbach, Alexander Eitel, Tino Endres, Rita Borromeo Ferri, Martin Hänze, Andreas Lachner, Detlev Leutner, Frank Lipowsky, Lea Nemeth, Alexander Renkl, Julian Roelle, Ralf Rummer, Katharina Scheiter, Judith Schweppe, Claudia von Aufschnaiter & Andreas Vorholzer. (2022) How to Promote Lasting Learning in Schools. Zeitschrift für Entwicklungspsychologie und Pädagogische Psychologie 54:4, pages 135-141.
Crossref
Rolf A. Zwaan. (2022) Conspiracy thinking as situation model construction. Current Opinion in Psychology 47, pages 101413.
Crossref
Ivar Bråten, Christian Brandmo, Leila E. Ferguson & Helge I. Strømsø. (2022) Epistemic justification in multiple document literacy: A refutation text intervention. Contemporary Educational Psychology 71, pages 102122.
Crossref
Jason L. G. Braasch, Ymkje E. Haverkamp, Natalia Latini, Sabriyya Shaw, Muhammad Safwan Arshad & Ivar Bråten. (2022) Belief bias when adolescents read to comprehend multiple conflicting texts. Reading and Writing 35:8, pages 1759-1785.
Crossref
David J. Franz. (2022) Moral Responsibility for Self-Deluding Beings. Philosophia 50:4, pages 1791-1807.
Crossref
D. Jake Follmer & Joseph Tise. (2022) Effects of an executive function-based text support on strategy use and comprehension–integration of conflicting informational texts. Reading and Writing 35:7, pages 1731-1758.
Crossref
Manuela Glaser, Dominik Lengyel, Catherine Toulouse & Stephan Schwan. (2022) How Do We Deal with Uncertain Information? Effects of Verbal and Visual Expressions of Uncertainty on Learning. Educational Psychology Review 34:2, pages 1097-1131.
Crossref
Øistein Anmarkrud, Ivar Bråten, Elena Florit & Lucia Mason. (2021) The Role of Individual Differences in Sourcing: a Systematic Review. Educational Psychology Review 34:2, pages 749-792.
Crossref
Paul van den Broek & Panayiota Kendeou. 2022. The Science of Reading. The Science of Reading 239 260 .
Johanna Abendroth, Peter Nauroth, Tobias Richter & Mario Gollwitzer. (2022) Non-strategic detection of identity-threatening information: Epistemic validation and identity defense may share a common cognitive basis. PLOS ONE 17:1, pages e0261535.
Crossref
Prateek Mantri, Hariharan Subramonyam, Audrey L. Michal & Cindy Xiong. (2022) How Do Viewers Synthesize Conflicting Information from Data Visualizations?. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, pages 1-11.
Crossref
Cornelia Schoor & Astrid Schütz. (2021) Science-utility and science-trust associations and how they relate to knowledge about how science works. PLOS ONE 16:12, pages e0260586.
Crossref
Reese Butterfuss & Panayiota Kendeou. (2021) KReC-MD: Knowledge Revision with Multiple Documents. Educational Psychology Review 33:4, pages 1475-1497.
Crossref
Christian Tarchi, Costanza Ruffini & Chiara Pecini. (2021) The Contribution of Executive Functions When Reading Multiple Texts: A Systematic Literature Review. Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Crossref
Mohammad N. Karimi & Tobias Richter. (2021) Biased representations of controversial information: Certainty and justification beliefs as moderators. Contemporary Educational Psychology 66, pages 101995.
Crossref
María Pilar Jiménez-Aleixandre & Pablo Brocos. (2021) Emotional Tension as a Frame for Argumentation and Decision-Making: Vegetarian vs. Omnivorous Diets. Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Crossref
Catherine Gunzenhauser & Matthias Nückles. (2021) Training Executive Functions to Improve Academic Achievement: Tackling Avenues to Far Transfer. Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Crossref
Cornelia Schoor, Jean-François Rouet, Cordula Artelt, Nina Mahlow, Carolin Hahnel, Ulf Kroehne & Frank Goldhammer. (2021) Readers' perceived task demands and their relation to multiple document comprehension strategies and outcome. Learning and Individual Differences 88, pages 102018.
Crossref
Alexandra List & Hongcui Du. (2020) Reasoning beyond history: examining students’ strategy use when completing a multiple text task addressing a controversial topic in education. Reading and Writing 34:4, pages 1003-1048.
Crossref
Gaston Saux, Mary Anne Britt, Nicolas Vibert & Jean‐François Rouet. (2021) Building mental models from multiple texts: How readers construct coherence from inconsistent sources. Language and Linguistics Compass 15:3.
Crossref
Christian Tarchi. (2021) Effects of think‐aloud on students' multiple‐documents comprehension . Applied Cognitive Psychology 35:2, pages 526-537.
Crossref
Johanna Abendroth & Tobias Richter. (2021) How to understand what you don't believe: Metacognitive training prevents belief-biases in multiple text comprehension. Learning and Instruction 71, pages 101394.
Crossref
Gaston Saux, Nicolas Vibert, Julien Dampuré, Debora I. Burin, M. Anne Britt & Jean-François Rouet. (2021) From simple agents to information sources: Readers' differential processing of story characters as a function of story consistency. Acta Psychologica 212, pages 103191.
Crossref
Meredith Carroll, Paige Sanchez, Donna Wilt & Summer Rebensky. 2021. Advances in Simulation and Digital Human Modeling. Advances in Simulation and Digital Human Modeling 35 40 .
Helge I. Strømsø, Ivar Bråten & Eva W. Brante. (2020) Profiles of warm engagement and cold evaluation in multiple-document comprehension. Reading and Writing 33:9, pages 2337-2359.
Crossref
Nina Mahlow, Carolin Hahnel, Ulf Kroehne, Cordula Artelt, Frank Goldhammer & Cornelia Schoor. (2020) More Than (Single) Text Comprehension? – On University Students’ Understanding of Multiple Documents. Frontiers in Psychology 11.
Crossref
Sarit Barzilai, Eva Thomm & Talia Shlomi-Elooz. (2020) Dealing with disagreement: The roles of topic familiarity and disagreement explanation in evaluation of conflicting expert claims and sources. Learning and Instruction 69, pages 101367.
Crossref
Gerhard Minnameier & Rico Hermkes. (2020) Learning to Fly Through Informational Turbulence: Critical Thinking and the Case of the Minimum Wage. Frontiers in Education 5.
Crossref
Giovanni Parodi Sweis, Tomás Moreno-de-León & Cristobal Julio. (2020) Comprensión de textos escritos: reconceptualizaciones en torno a las demandas del siglo XXI. Íkala 25:3, pages 775-795.
Crossref
Antoni Meseguer-Artola, Inma Rodríguez-Ardura, Gisela Ammetller & Eva Rimbau-Gilabert. (2020) Academic impact and perceived value of Wikipedia as a primary learning resource in higher education. El profesional de la información.
Crossref
Christian Tarchi & Lucia Mason. (2019) Effects of critical thinking on multiple-document comprehension. European Journal of Psychology of Education 35:2, pages 289-313.
Crossref
Elena Florit, Kate Cain & Lucia Mason. (2019) Going beyond children's single‐text comprehension: The role of fundamental and higher‐level skills in 4 th graders’ multiple‐document comprehension . British Journal of Educational Psychology 90:2, pages 449-472.
Crossref
Cornelia Schoor, Carolin Hahnel, Cordula Artelt, Daniel Reimann, Ulf Kröhne & Frank Goldhammer. (2020) Entwicklung und Skalierung eines Tests zur Erfassung des Verständnisses multipler Dokumente von Studierenden. Diagnostica 66:2, pages 123-135.
Crossref
L. Salmerón, A. Sampietro & P. Delgado. (2020) Using Internet videos to learn about controversies: Evaluation and integration of multiple and multimodal documents by primary school students. Computers & Education 148, pages 103796.
Crossref
Deanna Kuhn. (2019) Why Is Reconciling Divergent Views a Challenge?. Current Directions in Psychological Science 29:1, pages 27-32.
Crossref
Rebecca Weil & Liad Mudrik. (2020) Detecting falsehood relies on mismatch detection between sentence components. Cognition 195, pages 104121.
Crossref
Johanna Abendroth, Lena Feulner & Tobias Richter. 2020. Die Psychologie des Postfaktischen: Über Fake News, „Lügenpresse“, Clickbait & Co.. Die Psychologie des Postfaktischen: Über Fake News, „Lügenpresse“, Clickbait & Co. 141 155 .
H. Münchow, T. Richter & S. Schmid. 2020. Student Learning in German Higher Education. Student Learning in German Higher Education 241 260 .
Raquel Cerdán & Maria del Carmen Marín. (2019) The Role of General and Selective Task Instructions on Students’ Processing of Multiple Conflicting Documents. Frontiers in Psychology 10.
Crossref
Anita Körner, Susann Joffe & Roland Deutsch. (2019) When skeptical, stick with the norm: Low dilemma plausibility increases deontological moral judgments. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 84, pages 103834.
Crossref
Ivar Bråten, Christian Brandmo & Yvonne Kammerer. (2018) A Validation Study of the Internet-Specific Epistemic Justification Inventory With Norwegian Preservice Teachers. Journal of Educational Computing Research 57:4, pages 877-900.
Crossref
Johannes Naumann. (2019) The Skilled, the Knowledgeable, and the Motivated: Investigating the Strategic Allocation of Time on Task in a Computer-Based Assessment. Frontiers in Psychology 10.
Crossref
Panayiota Kendeou, Reese Butterfuss, Jasmine Kim & Martin Van Boekel. (2018) Knowledge revision through the lenses of the three-pronged approach. Memory & Cognition 47:1, pages 33-46.
Crossref
Johanna Maier, Tobias Richter, Peter Nauroth & Mario Gollwitzer. (2017) For me or for them: how in‐group identification and beliefs influence the comprehension of controversial texts. Journal of Research in Reading 41:S1.
Crossref
Liron Primor & Tami Katzir. (2018) Measuring Multiple Text Integration: A Review. Frontiers in Psychology 9.
Crossref
Lucia Mason, Sara Scrimin, Sonia Zaccoletti, Maria Caterina Tornatora & Thomas Goetz. (2018) Webpage reading: Psychophysiological correlates of emotional arousal and regulation predict multiple-text comprehension. Computers in Human Behavior 87, pages 317-326.
Crossref
Lucia Mason, Sara Scrimin, Maria Caterina Tornatora, Caterina Suitner & Angelica Moè. (2018) Internet source evaluation: The role of implicit associations and psychophysiological self-regulation. Computers & Education 119, pages 59-75.
Crossref
Johanna Maier, Tobias Richter & M. Anne Britt. (2018) Cognitive processes underlying the text‐belief consistency effect: An eye‐movement study. Applied Cognitive Psychology 32:2, pages 171-185.
Crossref