117
Views
94
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Consistencies in theoretical and naive evaluations of comforting messages

&
Pages 103-123 | Published online: 02 Jun 2009

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (47)

Xi Tian, Yuwei Li & Denise Haunani Solomon. (2023) How Do Qualities of Supportive Conversations Affect Heart Rate Variability During Conversations About the Death of a Parent?. Health Communication 0:0, pages 1-16.
Read now
Susanne M. Jones, Graham D. Bodie, Lucas Youngvorst, Michael Navarro & Carly Danielson. (2018) Mapping the terrain of person-centered supportive conversations. Communication Monographs 85:4, pages 467-490.
Read now
Erina L. MacGeorge, Lisa M. Guntzviller, Kellie S. Brisini, Loren C. Bailey, Sara K. Salmon, Kaytiann Severen, Sara E. Branch, Helen M. Lillie, Cynthia K. Lindley, Rebekah G. Pastor & Ryan D. Cummings. (2017) The Influence of Emotional Support Quality on Advice Evaluation and Outcomes. Communication Quarterly 65:1, pages 80-96.
Read now
Graham D. Bodie, Kaitlin E. Cannava, Andrea J. Vickery & Susanne M. Jones. (2016) Patterns of Nonverbal Adaptation in Supportive Interactions. Communication Studies 67:1, pages 3-19.
Read now
Shaughan A. Keaton, Graham D. Bodie & Robert V. Keteyian. (2015) Relational Listening Goals Influence How People Report Talking About Problems. Communication Quarterly 63:4, pages 480-494.
Read now
Wendy Samter, Chris R. Morse & Bryan B. Whaley. (2013) Do We Need to Put God into Emotional Support?: A Comparison of Caucasians’ and African-Americans’ Evaluations of Religious versus Non-Religious Comforting Messages. Journal of Intercultural Communication Research 42:2, pages 172-191.
Read now
Erin Donovan-Kicken, Joseph McGlynn & JaneC. H. Damron. (2012) When Friends Deflect Questions about Sensitive Information: Questioners’ Cognitive Complexity and Explanations for Friends’ Avoidance. Western Journal of Communication 76:2, pages 127-147.
Read now
AndrewC. High & James Price Dillard. (2012) A Review and Meta-Analysis of Person-Centered Messages and Social Support Outcomes. Communication Studies 63:1, pages 99-118.
Read now
RenéM. Dailey, Lynsey Kluever Romo & AndreaA. McCracken. (2010) Messages About Weight Management: An Examination of How Acceptance and Challenge Are Related to Message Effectiveness. Western Journal of Communication 74:5, pages 457-483.
Read now
Andrew M. Ledbetter & Kiley A. Larson. (2008) NONVERBAL CUES IN E-MAIL SUPPORTIVE COMMUNICATION. Information, Communication & Society 11:8, pages 1089-1110.
Read now
KatherineI. Miller. (2007) Compassionate Communication in the Workplace: Exploring Processes of Noticing, Connecting, and Responding. Journal of Applied Communication Research 35:3, pages 223-245.
Read now
Nichole Egbert, Lynn Koch, Harriet Coeling & Denise Ayers. (2006) The Role of Social Support in the Family and Community Integration of Right-Hemisphere Stroke Survivors. Health Communication 20:1, pages 45-55.
Read now
Darlene K. Drummond. (2005) Diabetes Management: An Exploration into the Verbal Support Attempts of Relational Others . Qualitative Research Reports in Communication 6:1, pages 69-76.
Read now
Robert Lemieux & M. Rachel Tighe. (2005) A Little Comfort for the Theoretically Distressed: A Follow-Up to Burleson et al.'s Response. Communication Research Reports 22:2, pages 101-105.
Read now
Brant R. Burleson, Wendy Samter, Susanne M. Jones, Adrianne Kunkel, Amanda J. Holmstrom, Steven T. Mortenson & Erina L. MacGeorge. (2005) Which Comforting Messages Really Work Best? A Different Perspective on Lemieux and Tighe's “Receiver Perspective”. Communication Research Reports 22:2, pages 87-100.
Read now
Robert Lemieux, Associates & M. Rachel Tighe. (2004) Attachment styles and the evaluation of comforting responses: A receiver perspective. Communication Research Reports 21:2, pages 144-153.
Read now
Harry Weger$suffix/text()$suffix/text() & LeahE. Polcar. (2002) Attachment style and person‐centered comforting. Western Journal of Communication 66:1, pages 84-103.
Read now
ErinaL. Macgeorge, Ruth Anne Clark & SethJ. Gillihan. (2002) Sex differences in the provision of skillful emotional support: The mediating role of self‐efficacy. Communication Reports 15:1, pages 17-28.
Read now
CraigR. Hullett. (2001) Attributional support: Targeting attributions underlying recipient emotions. Communication Research Reports 18:3, pages 285-294.
Read now
AmyM. Bippus. (2000) Humor usage in comforting episodes: Factors predicting outcomes. Western Journal of Communication 64:4, pages 359-384.
Read now
Ruth Anne Clark, AmyJ. Pierce, Kathleen Finn, Karen Hsu, Adam Toosley & Lionel Williams. (1998) The impact of alternative approaches to comforting, closeness of relationship, and gender on multiple measures of effectiveness. Communication Studies 49:3, pages 224-239.
Read now
AnitaL. Vangelisti & LindaP. Crumley. (1998) Reactions to messages that hurt: The influence of relational contexts. Communication Monographs 65:3, pages 173-196.
Read now
LanceR. Angell. (1998) Communication comforting strategies and social bereavement: Verbal and nonverbal planning and appropriateness. Journal of Personal and Interpersonal Loss 3:3, pages 271-283.
Read now
VincentR. Waldron & JamesL. Applegate. (1998) Person‐centered tactics during verbal disagreements: Effects on student perceptions of persuasiveness and social attraction. Communication Education 47:1, pages 53-66.
Read now
Melissa Winters & MichaelS. Waltman. (1997) Feminine gender identity and interpersonal cognitive differentiation as correlates of person‐centered comforting. Communication Reports 10:2, pages 123-132.
Read now
Ruth Anne Clark & JesseG. Delia. (1997) Individuals' preferences for friends' approaches to providing support in distressing situations. Communication Reports 10:2, pages 115-121.
Read now
JeroldL. Hale, M. Rachel Tighe & PaulA. Mongeau. (1997) Effects of event type and sex on comforting messages. Communication Research Reports 14:2, pages 214-220.
Read now
WilliamE. Arnold & Jill Johnson. (1992) Perceptions of Empathic Messages and Message Sources. International Listening Association. Journal 6:1, pages 83-88.
Read now
TheodoreE. Zorn. (1991) Construct system development, transformational leadership and leadership messages. Southern Communication Journal 56:3, pages 178-193.
Read now
SusanL. Kline & Cathy Hennen Floyd. (1990) On the art of saying no: The influence of social cognitive development on messages of refusal. Western Journal of Speech Communication 54:4, pages 454-472.
Read now
Mike Allen, EdwardA. Mabry, Mary Banski, Marjorie Stoneman & Paul Carter. (1990) A thoughtful appraisal of measuring cognition using the role category questionnaire. Communication Reports 3:2, pages 49-57.
Read now
TimothyG. Plax, Patricia Kearney & Gail Sorensen. (1990) The strategy selection‐construction controversy II: Comparing pre‐and experienced teachers' compliance‐gaining message constructions. Communication Education 39:2, pages 128-141.
Read now
JamesL. Applegate, Kelly Coyle, Joy Hart Seibert & SamuelM. Church. (1989) Interpersonal constructs and communicative ability in a police environment: A preliminary investigation. International Journal of Personal Construct Psychology 2:4, pages 385-399.
Read now
Gail Sorensen, TimothyG. Plax & Patricia Kearney. (1989) The strategy selection‐construction controversy: A coding scheme for analyzing teacher compliance‐gaining message constructions. Communication Education 38:2, pages 102-118.
Read now
DouglasJ. Meyer, FranklinJ. Boster & MichaelL. Hecht. (1988) A model of empathic communication. Communication Research Reports 5:1, pages 19-27.
Read now
Wendy Samter, BrantR. Burleson & Lori Basden Murphy. (1987) Comforting conversations: The effects of strategy type on evaluations of messages and message producers. Southern Speech Communication Journal 52:3, pages 263-284.
Read now
MichaelJ. Beatty. (1987) Erroneous assumptions underlying Burleson's critique. Communication Quarterly 35:4, pages 329-333.
Read now
BrantR. Burleson & Wendy Samter. (1985) Individual differences in the perception of comforting messages: An exploratory investigation. Central States Speech Journal 36:1-2, pages 39-50.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (47)

René M. Dailey. (2023) Confirmation in personal relationships. Current Opinion in Psychology 52, pages 101593.
Crossref
Iva Svačinová. (2022) Consolation Without Religious Topoi: Thematic Analysis of References to “Afterlife” in Secular Eulogies in Communist Czechoslovakia (1948–1989). OMEGA - Journal of Death and Dying, pages 003022282211480.
Crossref
Yu-Cian Huang, Edwinn Gamborino, Yan-Jia Huang, Xiaobei Qian, Li-Chen Fu & Su-Ling Yeh. (2022) Inferring Stressors from Conversation: Towards an Emotional Support Robot Companion. International Journal of Social Robotics 14:7, pages 1657-1671.
Crossref
Nathan P. Kalmoe, P. Brooks Fuller, Martina Santia & Paromita Saha. (2022) Representation and Aggression in Digital Racial Conflict: Analyzing Public Comments during Live-Streamed News of Racial Justice Protests. Perspectives on Politics, pages 1-20.
Crossref
Carme Sanahuges & Hortènsia Curell. (2020) Responding to Trouble: An Interactional Approach to Empathy In Catalan and English. Corpus Pragmatics 4:4, pages 449-472.
Crossref
Randall A. Renstrom & Victor C. Ottati. (2020) “I feel your pain”: The effect of displaying empathy on political candidate evaluation. Journal of Social and Political Psychology 8:2, pages 767-787.
Crossref
Trine N. Sindahl, Louis‐Phillippe Côte, Luc Dargis, Brian L. Mishara & Torben Bechmann Jensen. (2018) Texting for Help: Processes and Impact of Text Counseling with Children and Youth with Suicide Ideation. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 49:5, pages 1412-1430.
Crossref
Shunichi Tahara, Kazushi Ikeda & Keiichiro Hoashi. (2019) Empathic dialogue system based on emotions extracted from tweets. Empathic dialogue system based on emotions extracted from tweets.
Erina L. MacGeorge, Sara E. Branch, Cassandra L. Carlson-Hill, Xi Tian, Emily P. Caldes, Megan N. Miskovsky, Shannon Beatty & David L. Brinker. (2018) Verbal Person Centeredness in Interaction: Connecting Micro- and Macro-Level Operationalization. Journal of Language and Social Psychology 38:2, pages 149-169.
Crossref
Kaitlin E. Cannava, Andrew C. High, Susanne M. Jones & Graham D. Bodie. (2018) The Stuff That Verbal Person-Centered Support Is Made of: Identifying Linguistic Markers of More and Less Supportive Conversations. Journal of Language and Social Psychology 37:6, pages 656-679.
Crossref
Meara H. Faw. (2016) Supporting the supporter. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 35:2, pages 202-223.
Crossref
JOSHUA R. PEDERSON & RACHEL M. MCLAREN. (2017) Indirect effects of supportive communication during conversations about coping with relational transgressions. Personal Relationships 24:4, pages 804-819.
Crossref
Andrew C. High, Jenny L. Crowley & Emily M. Buehler. 2017. The Sourcebook of Listening Research. The Sourcebook of Listening Research 239 245 .
Shaki Asgari. (2015) The Influence of Varied Levels of Received Stress and Support on Negative Emotions and Support Perceptions. Current Psychology 35:3, pages 386-396.
Crossref
Anika Batenburg & Enny Das. (2014) An Experimental Study on the Effectiveness of Disclosing Stressful Life Events and Support Messages: When Cognitive Reappraisal Support Decreases Emotional Distress, and Emotional Support Is Like Saying Nothing at All. PLoS ONE 9:12, pages e114169.
Crossref
Jae Eun Chung. (2013) Social interaction in online support groups: Preference for online social interaction over offline social interaction. Computers in Human Behavior 29:4, pages 1408-1414.
Crossref
Graham D. Bodie, Brant R. Burleson, Amanda J. Holmstrom, Jennifer D. McCullough, Jessica J. Rack, Lisa K. Hanasono & Jennifer G. Rosier. (2011) Effects of Cognitive Complexity and Emotional Upset on Processing Supportive Messages: Two Tests of a Dual-Process Theory of Supportive Communication Outcomes. Human Communication Research 37:3, pages 350-376.
Crossref
Zainab D. Blell, Shahla Alai-Rosales & Jesus Rosales-Ruiz. (2010) The Effects of a Supportive Communication Training Workshop on the Verbal Behavior of Behavior Analysts. Behavior and Social Issues 19:1, pages 144-166.
Crossref
JENNIFER S. PRIEM, DENISE HAUNANI SOLOMON & KELI RYAN STEUBER. (2009) Accuracy and bias in perceptions of emotionally supportive communication in marriage. Personal Relationships 16:4, pages 531-552.
Crossref
Ruth Anne Clark, Erina L. MacGeorge & Lakesha Robinson. (2008) Evaluation of Peer Comforting Strategies by Children and Adolescents. Human Communication Research 34:2, pages 319-345.
Crossref
Scott E. Caplan & Jacob S. Turner. (2007) Bringing theory to research on computer-mediated comforting communication. Computers in Human Behavior 23:2, pages 985-998.
Crossref
Steve Mortenson, Meina Liu, Brant R. Burleson & Yan Liu. (2016) A Fluency of Feeling. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 37:4, pages 366-385.
Crossref
Brant R. Burleson, Meina Liu, Yan Liu & Steven T. Mortenson. (2016) Chinese Evaluations of Emotional Support Skills, Goals, and Behaviors. Communication Research 33:1, pages 38-63.
Crossref
Daena J. Goldsmith. 2010. Communicating Social Support. Communicating Social Support.
Susanne Jones. (2016) Putting the Person into Person-Centered and Immediate Emotional Support. Communication Research 31:3, pages 338-360.
Crossref
Nancy L. Collins & Brooke C. Feeney. (2004) Working Models of Attachment Shape Perceptions of Social Support: Evidence From Experimental and Observational Studies.. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 87:3, pages 363-383.
Crossref
Erina L. MacGeorge, Seth J. Gillihan, Wendy Samter & Ruth Anne Clark. (2016) Skill Deficit or Differential Motivation?. Communication Research 30:3, pages 272-303.
Crossref
Brant R. Burleson & Steven R. Mortenson. (2016) Explaining Cultural Differences in Evaluations of Emotional Support Behaviors. Communication Research 30:2, pages 113-146.
Crossref
Brant R. Burleson. (2003) The experience and effects of emotional support: What the study of cultural and gender differences can tell us about close relationships, emotion, and interpersonal communication. Personal Relationships 10:1, pages 1-23.
Crossref
Susanne M. Jones & Laura K. Guerrero. (2001) The Effects of Nonverbal Immediacy and Verbal Person Centeredness in the Emotional Support Process. Human Communication Research 27:4, pages 567-596.
Crossref
Brant B. Burleson & Sally Planalp. (2000) Producing Emotion(al) Messages. Communication Theory 10:2, pages 221-250.
Crossref
James S. Sass & Marifran Mattson. (2016) When Social Support is Uncomfortable. Management Communication Quarterly 12:4, pages 511-543.
Crossref
ADRIANNE W. KUNKEL & BRANT R. BURLESON. (1999) Assessing Explanations for Sex Differences in Emotional Support A Test of the Different Cultures and Skill Specialization Accounts. Human Communication Research 25:3, pages 307-340.
Crossref
WENDY SAMTER, BRYAN B. WHALEY, STEVEN T. MORTENSON & BRANT R. BURLESON. (2005) Ethnicity and emotional support in same‐sex friendship: A comparison of Asian‐Americans, African‐Americans, and Euro‐Americans. Personal Relationships 4:4, pages 413-430.
Crossref
SUSANNE M. JONES & BRANT R. BURLESON. (2016) The Impact of Situational Variables on Helpers' Perceptions of Comforting Messages. Communication Research 24:5, pages 530-555.
Crossref
Daena J. Goldsmith & Susan A. Dun. (2016) Sex Differences and Similarities in the Communication of Social Support. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 14:3, pages 317-337.
Crossref
CYNTHIA HOFFNER & MARGARET J. HAEFNER. (2016) Children's Comforting of Frightened Coviewers. Communication Research 24:2, pages 136-152.
Crossref
Brian Lakey & Jana Brittain Drew. 1997. Sourcebook of Social Support and Personality. Sourcebook of Social Support and Personality 107 140 .
Tess Byrd O’Brien & Anita DeLongis. 1997. Coping with Chronic Stress. Coping with Chronic Stress 161 190 .
Tess Byrd O'Brien & Anita DeLongis. (2006) The Interactional Context of Problem‐, Emotion‐, and Relationship‐Focused Coping: The Role of the Big Five Personality Factors. Journal of Personality 64:4, pages 775-813.
Crossref
Brant R. Burleson & Daena J. Goldsmith. 1996. Handbook of Communication and Emotion. Handbook of Communication and Emotion 245 280 .
SALLY JACKSON & DALE E. BRASHERS. (1994) M > 1. Human Communication Research 20:3, pages 356-389.
Crossref
DAENA GOLDSMITH. (2016) Managing Conflicting Goals in Supportive Interaction. Communication Research 19:2, pages 264-286.
Crossref
STEPHANIE ZIMMERMANN & JAMES L. APPLEGATE. (2016) Person-Centered Comforting in the Hospice Interdisciplinary Team. Communication Research 19:2, pages 240-263.
Crossref
CHARLES H. TARDY. (2016) Assessing the Functions of Supportive Messages. Communication Research 19:2, pages 175-192.
Crossref
WENDY SAMTER, BRANT R. BURLESON & LORI BASDEN-MURPHY. (1989) Behavioral Complexity Is in the Eye of the Beholder Effects of Cognitive Complexity and Message Complexity on Impressions of the Source of Comforting Messages. Human Communication Research 15:4, pages 612-629.
Crossref
B. R. Burleson. (2016) The Production of Comforting Messages: Social-Cognitive Foundations. Journal of Language and Social Psychology 4:3-4, pages 253-273.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.