4,383
Views
125
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Threshold concepts in research education and evidence of threshold crossing

&
Pages 431-441 | Received 10 Sep 2008, Accepted 20 May 2009, Published online: 14 Jul 2009

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (47)

Ailie McDowall. (2022) Preparing postgraduate research students to research Indigenous topics. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 0:0, pages 1-14.
Read now
Kelly Schrum & Sarah Bogdewiecz. (2022) Cultivating research skills through scholarly digital storytelling. Higher Education Research & Development 41:7, pages 2382-2394.
Read now
Ruth Albertyn. (2022) Making a case for Doctoral Intelligence: Conceptualisation and insights for researcher development. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 59:6, pages 623-633.
Read now
Norman T. Sheehan, Kenneth A. Fox, Mark Klassen & Ganesh Vaidyanathan. (2022) Threshold concepts and ESG performance: teaching accounting students reconceptualized fundamentals to drive future ESG advocacy. Accounting Education 0:0, pages 1-25.
Read now
Nicolette Buirski. (2022) ‘Ways of being’: a model for supportive doctoral supervisory relationships and supervision. Higher Education Research & Development 41:5, pages 1387-1401.
Read now
Nick Pratt & Julie Shaughnessy. (2021) The effects of managerialism in higher education on doctoral theorising: time to think?. British Journal of Sociology of Education 42:8, pages 1123-1138.
Read now
Jo Collins & Nicole Brown. (2021) Where’s the validation? Role of emotion work and validation for doctoral students. Higher Education Research & Development 40:7, pages 1389-1402.
Read now
Ruth Albertyn & Kathy Bennett. (2021) Containing and harnessing uncertainty during postgraduate research supervision. Higher Education Research & Development 40:4, pages 661-675.
Read now
Andrea S. Webb & Anne M. Tierney. (2020) Investigating support for scholarship of teaching and learning; We need SoTL educational leaders. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 57:5, pages 613-624.
Read now
Navé Wald & Ben Kei Daniel. (2020) Enhancing students’ engagement with abstract ideas through conceptual and theoretical frameworks. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 57:4, pages 496-505.
Read now
Crista Weise, Mariela Aguayo–González & Montserrat Castelló. (2020) Significant events and the role of emotion along doctoral researcher personal trajectories. Educational Research 62:3, pages 304-323.
Read now
Juliet Stoltenkamp, Valentino van de Heyde & André Siebrits. (2020) ePedagogy as a threshold concept: a reflection on a programme for Science Teaching Assistants. International Journal for Academic Development 25:2, pages 195-199.
Read now
Takahiro Sato & Cathy McKay. (2020) Japanese physical education graduate students’ learning about research skill development. Curriculum Studies in Health and Physical Education 11:1, pages 34-49.
Read now
Gloria Dall’Alba & Søren Bengtsen. (2019) Re-imagining active learning: Delving into darkness. Educational Philosophy and Theory 51:14, pages 1477-1489.
Read now
Meeta Chatterjee-Padmanabhan, Wendy Nielsen & Sarah Sanders. (2019) Joining the research conversation: threshold concepts embedded in the literature review. Higher Education Research & Development 38:3, pages 494-507.
Read now
John Wei, Susan Carter & Deborah Laurs. (2019) Handling the loss of innocence: first-time exchange of writing and feedback in doctoral supervision. Higher Education Research & Development 38:1, pages 157-169.
Read now
Elizabeth Marquis, Abraham Redda & Louise Twells. (2018) Navigating complexity, culture, collaboration, and emotion: student perspectives on global justice and global justice education. Teaching in Higher Education 23:7, pages 853-868.
Read now
Meeta Chatterjee-Padmanabhan & Wendy Nielsen. (2018) Preparing to cross the research proposal threshold: A case study of two international doctoral students. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 55:4, pages 417-424.
Read now
Kelli Nicola-Richmond, Geneviève Pépin, Helen Larkin & Charlotte Taylor. (2018) Threshold concepts in higher education: a synthesis of the literature relating to measurement of threshold crossing. Higher Education Research & Development 37:1, pages 101-114.
Read now
David F. Feldon, Christopher Rates & Chongning Sun. (2017) Doctoral conceptual thresholds in cellular and molecular biology. International Journal of Science Education 39:18, pages 2574-2593.
Read now
Margaret Kiley. (2017) Career professionals entering doctoral study: Advantages and challenges. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 54:6, pages 550-559.
Read now
Gina Wisker, Gillian Robinson & Søren S. E. Bengtsen. (2017) Penumbra: Doctoral support as drama: From the ‘lightside’ to the ‘darkside’. From front of house to trapdoors and recesses. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 54:6, pages 527-538.
Read now
Sioux McKenna. (2017) Crossing conceptual thresholds in doctoral communities. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 54:5, pages 458-466.
Read now
Susan Carter. (2016) Supervision learning as conceptual threshold crossing: when supervision gets ‘medieval’. Higher Education Research & Development 35:6, pages 1139-1152.
Read now
Susan Camille van Schalkwyk, Deborah Murdoch-Eaton, Ara Tekian, Cees van der Vleuten & Francois Cilliers. (2016) The supervisor’s toolkit: A framework for doctoral supervision in health professions education: AMEE Guide No. 104. Medical Teacher 38:5, pages 429-442.
Read now
Merryn McKinnon & Judith Vos. (2015) Engagement as a Threshold Concept for Science Education and Science Communication. International Journal of Science Education, Part B 5:4, pages 297-318.
Read now
Jeanette Berman & Robyn Smyth. (2015) Conceptual frameworks in the doctoral research process: a pedagogical model. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:2, pages 125-136.
Read now
Jeffrey M. Keefer, Gina Wisker & Margaret Kiley. (2015) Doctoral candidate learning. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:1, pages 1-3.
Read now
Allyson Holbrook, Sid Bourke & Hedy Fairbairn. (2015) Examiner reference to theory in PhD theses. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:1, pages 75-85.
Read now
Gina Wisker. (2015) Developing doctoral authors: engaging with theoretical perspectives through the literature review. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:1, pages 64-74.
Read now
Jeffrey M. Keefer. (2015) Experiencing doctoral liminality as a conceptual threshold and how supervisors can use it. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:1, pages 17-28.
Read now
Margaret Kiley. (2015) ‘I didn’t have a clue what they were talking about’: PhD candidates and theory. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 52:1, pages 52-63.
Read now
Deb Carter & Susan Crichton. (2014) Empowering twenty-first century assessment practices: designing technologies as agents of change. Educational Media International 51:4, pages 295-309.
Read now
Inger Mewburn, Ekaterina Tokareva, Denise Cuthbert, Jennifer Sinclair & Robyn Barnacle. (2014) ‘These are issues that should not be raised in black and white’: the culture of progress reporting and the doctorate. Higher Education Research & Development 33:3, pages 510-522.
Read now
Gina Wisker & Gillian Robinson. (2014) Examiner practices and culturally inflected doctoral theses. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 35:2, pages 190-205.
Read now
Dean Barker, Natalie Barker-Ruchti, Steven Rynne & Jessica Lee. (2014) ‘Just do a little more’: examining expertise in high performance sport from a sociocultural learning perspective. Reflective Practice 15:1, pages 92-105.
Read now
Briana Crotwell Timmerman, David Feldon, Michelle Maher, Denise Strickland & Joanna Gilmore. (2013) Performance-based assessment of graduate student research skills: timing, trajectory, and potential thresholds. Studies in Higher Education 38:5, pages 693-710.
Read now
Rob Abbott. (2013) Crossing thresholds in academic reading. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 50:2, pages 191-201.
Read now
Gina Wisker & Gillian Robinson. (2013) Doctoral ‘orphans’: nurturing and supporting the success of postgraduates who have lost their supervisors. Higher Education Research & Development 32:2, pages 300-313.
Read now
Christine Bruce & Ian Stoodley. (2013) Experiencing higher degree research supervision as teaching. Studies in Higher Education 38:2, pages 226-241.
Read now
Robin Humphrey & Bob Simpson. (2012) Writes of passage: writing up qualitative data as a threshold concept in doctoral research. Teaching in Higher Education 17:6, pages 735-746.
Read now
Gina Wisker & Gillian Robinson. (2009) Encouraging postgraduate students of literature and art to cross conceptual thresholds. Innovations in Education and Teaching International 46:3, pages 317-330.
Read now
Barbara Class. Teaching research methods in education: using the TPACK framework to reflect on praxis. International Journal of Research & Method in Education 0:0, pages 1-21.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (78)

Hatice Nuriler & Søren S.E. Bengtsen. (2023) The entangled becoming in humanities doctoral education. Studies in Graduate and Postdoctoral Education.
Crossref
Xan Y. Goodman & Samantha Ann Godbey. (2023) An explicit approach to liminality as an inclusive approach to librarian support for graduate student researchers. Reference Services Review.
Crossref
Michael D. Schaller, Marieta Gencheva, Michael R. Gunther & Scott A. Weed. (2023) Training doctoral students in critical thinking and experimental design using problem-based learning. BMC Medical Education 23:1.
Crossref
Deborah Tyndall & Shannon Baker Powell. (2023) Good critical friends are hard to find: promoting peer review among doctoral students. Studies in Graduate and Postdoctoral Education 14:2, pages 186-200.
Crossref
Gina Wisker. 2023. Developing Researcher Independence Through the Hidden Curriculum. Developing Researcher Independence Through the Hidden Curriculum 79 91 .
Joan Ball & Maggi Savin-Baden. (2022) Postdigital Learning for a Changing Higher Education. Postdigital Science and Education 4:3, pages 753-771.
Crossref
Austin L. Zuckerman & Stanley M. Lo. (2022) Examining the Variations in Undergraduate Students’ Conceptions of Successful Researchers: A Phenomenographic Study. CBE—Life Sciences Education 21:3.
Crossref
Jina Kang, Ryan Baker, Zhang Feng, Chungsoo Na, Peter Granville & David F. Feldon. (2022) Detecting threshold concepts through Bayesian knowledge tracing: examining research skill development in biological sciences at the doctoral level. Instructional Science 50:3, pages 475-497.
Crossref
Amanda Hay. (2021) Exploring unknowingness in the DBA programme: Possibilities for developing an ‘attitude of wisdom’. Management Learning 53:2, pages 269-290.
Crossref
Manuela Schmidt & Erika Hansson. (2021) “I didn’t want to be a troublemaker” – doctoral students’ experiences of change in supervisory arrangements. Studies in Graduate and Postdoctoral Education 13:1, pages 54-73.
Crossref
Ashley Johnston Wicker, Mindy Crain-Dorough & Adam C. Elder. 2022. Research Anthology on Doctoral Student Professional Development. Research Anthology on Doctoral Student Professional Development 413 430 .
Katherine HoopsJahan FahimiLina KhoeurChristine StudenmundCatherine BarberAmy BarnhorstMarian E. BetzCassandra K. CrifasiJohn A. DavisWilliam DewispelaereLynn FisherPatricia K. HowardAndrew KettererEvie MarcoliniPaul S. NestadtJohn RozelJoseph A. SimonettiSarabeth SpitzerMichael VictoroffBrian H. WilliamsLisa HowleyMegan L. Ranney. (2021) Consensus-Driven Priorities for Firearm Injury Education Among Medical Professionals. Academic Medicine 97:1, pages 93-104.
Crossref
Susan Smith. 2022. Landscapes and Narratives of PhD by Publication. Landscapes and Narratives of PhD by Publication 135 147 .
Heidi Salmento, Mari Murtonen & Margaret Kiley. (2021) Understanding Teacher Education Students’ Research Competence Through Their Conceptions of Theory. Frontiers in Education 6.
Crossref
Tony Bromley & Lorna Warnock. (2021) The practice of the development of researchers: the “state-of-the-art”. Studies in Graduate and Postdoctoral Education 12:2, pages 283-299.
Crossref
Cara Wrigley, Peta Wolifson & Judy Matthews. (2020) Supervising cohorts of higher degree research students: design catalysts for industry and innovation. Higher Education 81:6, pages 1177-1196.
Crossref
Sigrid Westad Brandshaug & Ela Sjølie. (2020) In liminality: interdisciplinary teams learning through challenges. Higher Education, Skills and Work-Based Learning 11:2, pages 406-419.
Crossref
Deborah E. Tyndall, Gina C. Firnhaber & K. Brooke Kistler. (2021) An integrative review of threshold concepts in doctoral education: Implications for PhD nursing programs. Nurse Education Today 99, pages 104786.
Crossref
Nicolette Buirski. (2021) Liminal emotions and mindfulness traits of well-regarded supervisors in highly valued doctoral supervisory relationships. SN Social Sciences 1:2.
Crossref
Ashley Johnston Wicker, Mindy Crain-Dorough & Adam C. Elder. 2021. Handbook of Research on Developing Students’ Scholarly Dispositions in Higher Education. Handbook of Research on Developing Students’ Scholarly Dispositions in Higher Education 132 149 .
Lucy Smout Szablewska. 2021. Navigating the Field. Navigating the Field 131 143 .
Jan Fredrik Hovden & Ole J. Mjøs. (2020) Research Director, Colleague, Schoolmaster? Preferred and Experienced Supervising Styles of PhD-Students at Four Faculties. Uniped 43:3, pages 187-204.
Crossref
Dean Barker, Gunn Nyberg & Hakan Larsson. (2020) Exploring Movement Learning in Physical Education Using a Threshold Approach. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education 39:3, pages 415-423.
Crossref
Gemma Tur, Leo Havemann, J. Dawn Marsh, Jeffrey M. Keefer & Fabio Nascimbeni. (2020) Becoming an open educator: towards an open threshold framework. Research in Learning Technology 28:0.
Crossref
Robert Faff. (2018) Pitching research: ‘qualitative cousins’ and the ‘extended family’. Accounting & Finance 60:1, pages 227-269.
Crossref
Dely L. Elliot, Søren S. E. Bengtsen, Kay Guccione & Sofie KobayashiDely L. Elliot, Søren S. E. Bengtsen, Kay Guccione & Sofie Kobayashi. 2020. The Hidden Curriculum in Doctoral Education. The Hidden Curriculum in Doctoral Education 3 16 .
Susan Carter & Vicky Gunn. (2017) Inspiring desire: A new materialist bent to doctoral education in Arts and Humanities. Arts and Humanities in Higher Education 18:4, pages 296-310.
Crossref
E Marcia Johnson. (2018) Towards an enhanced view of doctoral writing environments: Learning alliances to reconceptualise practice. Policy Futures in Education 17:2, pages 140-152.
Crossref
Eleonora Pantano & Constantinos-Vasilios Priporas. 2019. Evaluating the Gaps and Intersections Between Marketing Education and the Marketing Profession. Evaluating the Gaps and Intersections Between Marketing Education and the Marketing Profession 143 161 .
Gina Wisker. 2019. Redefining Scientific Thinking for Higher Education. Redefining Scientific Thinking for Higher Education 203 232 .
Margaret Kiley. 2019. Redefining Scientific Thinking for Higher Education. Redefining Scientific Thinking for Higher Education 139 155 .
Alison Vincent. 2019. The Doctoral Experience. The Doctoral Experience 25 34 .
S. Hyde, A. Flatau & D. Wilson. (2018) Integrating threshold concepts with reflective practice: Discussing a theory‐based approach for curriculum refinement in dental education. European Journal of Dental Education 22:4.
Crossref
Sadie Geraghty & Kim Oliver. (2018) In the shadow of the ivory tower: Experiences of midwives and nurses undertaking PhDs. Nurse Education Today 65, pages 36-40.
Crossref
Karri A. Holley. (2017) The Role of Threshold Concepts in an Interdisciplinary Curriculum: a Case Study in Neuroscience. Innovative Higher Education 43:1, pages 17-30.
Crossref
Steve Barnes. 2018. Ethnographic Research and Analysis. Ethnographic Research and Analysis 113 125 .
Alejandro Proestakis-Maturana & Walter Terrazas-Núñez. (2017) Formación en investigación y supervisión en programas de doctorados. Magis. Revista Internacional de Investigación en Educación 10:20, pages 85.
Crossref
David F. FeldonSoojeong JeongJames PeughJosipa Roksa, Cathy Maahs-FladungAlok ShenoyMichael Oliva. (2017) Null effects of boot camps and short-format training for PhD students in life sciences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114:37, pages 9854-9858.
Crossref
Brendan Garrett, Avtar S. Matharu & Glenn A. Hurst. (2017) Using Greener Gels To Explore Rheology. Journal of Chemical Education 94:4, pages 500-504.
Crossref
H.H. Wagner, C. Boyd & R. Napper. (2017) How to share the process of graduate advising. FACETS 1:1, pages 263-279.
Crossref
David F. Feldon. 2015. Emerging Trends in the Social and Behavioral Sciences. Emerging Trends in the Social and Behavioral Sciences 1 14 .
Sarah M. Urquhart, Michelle A. Maher, David F. Feldon & Joanna Gilmore. (2016) Factors associated with novice graduate student researchers’ engagement with primary literature. International Journal for Researcher Development 7:2, pages 141-158.
Crossref
David F. Feldon, Kathan D. Shukla & Michelle Anne Maher. (2016) Faculty–student coauthorship as a means to enhance STEM graduate students’ research skills. International Journal for Researcher Development 7:2, pages 178-191.
Crossref
Amanda Hay & Dalvir Samra-Fredericks. (2016) Desperately seeking fixedness: Practitioners’ accounts of ‘becoming doctoral researchers’. Management Learning 47:4, pages 407-423.
Crossref
Barbara Class, Daniel Schneider, Mona Laroussi & François Lombard. (2016) Enseigner la méthodologie de la recherche en technologie éducative : des conceptions aux concepts seuilsFrom students’ conceptions of research to threshold concepts: teaching research methodology. Distances et médiations des savoirs:13.
Crossref
David F. Feldon, Michelle A. Maher, Josipa Roksa & James Peugh. (2016) Cumulative Advantage in the Skill Development of STEM Graduate Students. American Educational Research Journal 53:1, pages 132-161.
Crossref
Merryn Mckinnon & Judith Vos. 2016. Science and Technology Education and Communication. Science and Technology Education and Communication 27 45 .
Terje Berg, Morten Erichsen & Leif M. Hokstad. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 107 118 .
Beth A. White, Taimi Olsen & David Schumann. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 53 63 .
Leif M. Hokstad, Gro Rødne, Bjørn Otto Braaten, Steffen Wellinger & Fredrik Shetelig. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 321 333 .
Andrea S. Webb. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 299 308 .
Gina Wisker. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 165 176 .
Michelle Salmona, Dan Kaczynski & Leigh N. Wood. 2016. Threshold Concepts in Practice. Threshold Concepts in Practice 155 164 .
Elaine Khoo, Jonathan Scott, Mira Peter & Howell Round. (2015) Evaluating flipped classrooms with respect to threshold concepts learning in undergraduate engineering. Evaluating flipped classrooms with respect to threshold concepts learning in undergraduate engineering.
Eva M. Brodin. 2015. The Palgrave Handbook of Critical Thinking in Higher Education. The Palgrave Handbook of Critical Thinking in Higher Education 265 282 .
Susan Page. (2014) Exploring New Conceptualisations of Old Problems: Researching and Reorienting Teaching in Indigenous Studies to Transform Student Learning. The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education 43:1, pages 21-30.
Crossref
Malcolm Tight. 2014. Theory and Method in Higher Education Research II. Theory and Method in Higher Education Research II 249 267 .
Gina Cicco. (2013) Online Course Effectiveness: A Model for Innovative Research in Counselor Education. i-manager's Journal on School Educational Technology 9:1, pages 10-16.
Crossref
Gina Cicco. (2013) Strategic Lesson Planning in Online Courses: Suggestions for Counselor Educators. i-manager's Journal on School Educational Technology 8:3, pages 1-8.
Crossref
Gina Cicco. (2012) Counseling Instruction in the Online Classroom: A Survey of Student and Faculty Perceptions. i-manager's Journal on School Educational Technology 8:2, pages 1-10.
Crossref
Frances Kelly, Marcia Russell & Lee Wallace. (2011) Trouble in mind. Arts and Humanities in Higher Education 11:4, pages 418-433.
Crossref
April L. Wright & Anne Gilmore. (2017) Threshold Concepts and Conceptions. Journal of Management Education 36:5, pages 614-635.
Crossref
Jeffrey Yip & Joseph A Raelin. (2011) Threshold concepts and modalities for teaching leadership practice. Management Learning 43:3, pages 333-354.
Crossref
Gina Cicco. (2012) Designing innovative counseling courses: combining technology, theory, and Practice. i-manager's Journal on School Educational Technology 7:4, pages 1-7.
Crossref
Gina WiskerGina Wisker. 2012. The Good Supervisor. The Good Supervisor 1 25 .
Gina Cicco. (2011) Assessment In Online Courses: How Are Counseling Skills Evaluated?. i-manager's Journal of Educational Technology 8:2, pages 9-15.
Crossref
Pat Gannon‐Leary, Elsa Fontainha & Moira Bent. (2011) The loneliness of the long distance researcher. Library Hi Tech 29:3, pages 455-469.
Crossref
. (2010) GRADUATE AND PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION. Higher Education Abstracts 45:3, pages 177-180.
Crossref
Gina Wisker. 2010. Teaching African American Women’s Writing. Teaching African American Women’s Writing 1 20 .
Gina Wisker & Maggi Savin‐Baden. (2009) Priceless conceptual thresholds: beyond the ‘stuck place’ in writing. London Review of Education 7:3, pages 235-247.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff. (2022) Contribution Matters …!. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff. (2021) Pitching Research®… Evolution into a Programmatic Framework… Self-Reflection and the Story so Far. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff. (2017) Pitching Researchh: A Comprehensive Resource Center Supplement. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff, Karina Honey, Fitri Oktaviani, Suqin Shen, Laura Steele, Mark Tanner, Corinne Unger, Sabrina Wong, Jessica Jia Xu & Sarine Zou. (2017) Fantasy Pitching IV: Batman, Donald Duck, Fast Food, Superpowers, Self-Determination. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff, Robin Carrick, Angel Chen, Marisol Escobar, Bo Xuan Matthew Khong, Bao Hoang Nguyen & William Tunny. (2017) UQ Summer Research Scholar Program: Insights and Reflections from the Pitching Research 'I-TEMPLATES' Team. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff, Robin Carrick, Angel Chen, Marisol Escobar, Bo Xuan Matthew Khong, Bao Hoang Nguyen & William Tunny. (2017) Pitching Research: A Reverse-Engineer 'Sparring' Experiment with UQ Summer Research Scholars. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Robert W. Faff. (2014) Pitching Research. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Jeffrey Yip & Joseph A. Raelin. (2011) Threshold Concepts and Modalities for Teaching Leadership Practice. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.