634
Views
86
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Methodological Problems in Identifying Efficacious Psychotherapies

Pages 21-43 | Published online: 25 Nov 2010

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (11)

Charles L. Cole, Samantha Waterman, Elaine Catherine Margaret Hunter, Vaughan Bell, Neil Greenberg, G. James Rubin & Alison Beck. (2021) Effectiveness of small group cognitive behavioural therapy for anxiety and depression in Ebola treatment centre staff in Sierra Leone. International Review of Psychiatry 33:1-2, pages 189-197.
Read now
Carla J Rash & Nancy M Petry. (2014) Psychological treatments for gambling disorder. Psychology Research and Behavior Management 7, pages 285-295.
Read now
Karen Anne Marie Holowaty & Sandra Clare Paivio. (2012) Characteristics of client-identified helpful events in emotion-focused therapy for child abuse trauma. Psychotherapy Research 22:1, pages 56-66.
Read now
Stephanie Budge, Timothy P. Baardseth, Bruce E. Wampold & Christoph Flűckiger. (2010) Researcher allegiance and supportive therapy: Pernicious affects on results of randomized clinical trials. European Journal of Psychotherapy & Counselling 12:1, pages 23-39.
Read now
MertonS. Krause & Wolfgang Lutz. (2009) What should be used for baselines against which to compare treatments’ effectiveness?. Psychotherapy Research 19:3, pages 358-367.
Read now
Assen Alladin, Linda Sabatini & JonK. Amundson. (2007) What Should We Mean by Empirical Validation in Hypnotherapy: Evidence-Based Practice in Clinical Hypnosis . International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 55:2, pages 115-130.
Read now
AntoonA. Leenaars. (2006) Psychotherapy with Suicidal People: The Commonalities. Archives of Suicide Research 10:4, pages 305-322.
Read now
Kara Brita Wettersten, James W. Lichtenberg & Brent Mallinckrodt. (2005) Associations between working alliance and outcome in Solution-Focused Brief Therapy and brief interpersonal therapy. Psychotherapy Research 15:1-2, pages 35-43.
Read now
Sherwood Waldron, Robert Scharf, James Crouse, Stephen K. Firestein, Anna Burton & David Hurst. (2004) Saying the Right Thing at the Right Time: a View through the Lens of the Analytic Process Scales (Aps). The Psychoanalytic Quarterly 73:4, pages 1079-1125.
Read now
JuliaR. Heima & CindyM. Meston. (1997) Empirically Validated Treatment for Sexual Dysfunction. Annual Review of Sex Research 8:1, pages 148-194.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (75)

Miles Thompson, Holly Parker & Jodie Cave. (2021) Exploring which aspects of a low‐intensity CBT intervention were found to contribute to a successful outcome from the service user point of view: A mixed methods study. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research 22:2, pages 279-291.
Crossref
Thomas Rabeyron. (2021) L’évaluation et l’efficacité des psychothérapies psychanalytiques et de la psychanalyse. L'Évolution Psychiatrique 86:3, pages 455-488.
Crossref
Emilio Fava. (2021) Ricerca clinica e ricerca empirica. Ricerca Psicoanalitica 32:2.
Crossref
Thomas Rabeyron. (2020) Transformational processes and the analytical field: A new paradigm for models and clinical practices. L'Évolution Psychiatrique 85:1, pages e1-e13.
Crossref
Thomas Rabeyron. (2020) Processus transformationnels et champ analytique : un nouveau paradigme pour les modèles et les pratiques cliniques. L'Évolution Psychiatrique 85:1, pages 101-114.
Crossref
Guillermo Bernal, Carmen L. Rivera‐Medina, Eduardo Cumba‐Avilés, Mae Lynn Reyes‐Rodríguez, Emily Sáez‐Santiago, Yovanska Duarté‐Vélez, Lelis Nazario, Natalie Rodríguez‐Quintana & Jeannette Rosselló. (2019) Can Cognitive‐Behavioral Therapy Be Optimized With Parent Psychoeducation? A Randomized Effectiveness Trial of Adolescents With Major Depression in Puerto Rico. Family Process 58:4, pages 832-854.
Crossref
Astrid Beermann. 2019. Veräderungsprozesse professioneller und persölicher Entwicklung. Veräderungsprozesse professioneller und persölicher Entwicklung 191 228 .
Silvia Paola Papini & Emilio Domenico Fava. (2019) L'integrazione nella valutazione diagnostica dei fattori terapeutici correlati agli esiti. Il sistema di diagnosi psicodinamica operazionalizzata (OPD-2). RICERCA PSICOANALITICA:1, pages 37-55.
Crossref
조민경 & 장유진. (2018) The Influence of Counselor Experience on the Working Alliance: The Moderating Effects of Client-Perceived Counselor Characteristics. Korea Journal of Counseling 19:6, pages 129-153.
Crossref
Will W. Dobud & Nevin J. Harper. (2018) Of Dodo birds and common factors: A scoping review of direct comparison trials in adventure therapy. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice 31, pages 16-24.
Crossref
Jürgen Margraf. 2018. Lehrbuch der Verhaltenstherapie, Band 1. Lehrbuch der Verhaltenstherapie, Band 1 3 35 .
José Carlos Santos. 2018. European Psychiatric/Mental Health Nursing in the 21st Century. European Psychiatric/Mental Health Nursing in the 21st Century 441 452 .
Laura S. Hughes, Jodi Clark, Janette A. Colclough, Elizabeth Dale & Dean McMillan. (2017) Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) for Chronic Pain. The Clinical Journal of Pain 33:6, pages 552-568.
Crossref
Thomas Rabeyron. (2017) Médiations thérapeutiques et processus de symbolisation : de l’expérience sensible à la modélisation. L'Évolution Psychiatrique 82:2, pages 351-364.
Crossref
. 2016. Évaluation clinique des psychothérapies psychanalytiques. Évaluation clinique des psychothérapies psychanalytiques 473 492 .
Annie Jaimes, Katharine Larose-Hébert & Nicolas Moreau. (2015) Current Trends in Theoretical Orientation of Psychologists: The Case of Quebec Clinicians. Journal of Clinical Psychology 71:10, pages 1042-1048.
Crossref
Jeffrey T. Guterman. 2015. Mastering the Art of Solution‐Focused Counseling. Mastering the Art of Solution‐Focused Counseling 241 275 .
Marine Jaeken, Lesley L. Verhofstadt & Nady Van Broeck. (2015) Qu’est-ce qui détermine l’efficacité d’une psychothérapie ? Brève mise à jour scientifique. Bulletin de psychologie Numéro 537:3, pages 237-242.
Crossref
Anne Ward, Barbara Wood & Masud Awal. (2013) A Naturalistic Psychodynamic Psychotherapy Study: Evaluating Outcome with a Patient Perspective. British Journal of Psychotherapy 29:3, pages 292-314.
Crossref
Michael A. Diamond. 2012. The Wiley‐Blackwell Handbook of the Psychology of Coaching and Mentoring. The Wiley‐Blackwell Handbook of the Psychology of Coaching and Mentoring 365 384 .
Per Høglend, Glen O. Gabbard & Glen O. Gabbard. 2012. Psychodynamic Psychotherapy Research. Psychodynamic Psychotherapy Research 449 467 .
Marc Serfaty, Emese Csipke, Deborah Haworth, Shahed Murad & Michael King. (2011) A talking control for use in evaluating the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 49:8, pages 433-440.
Crossref
John W. Seymour. 2011. Integrative Play Therapy. Integrative Play Therapy 1 19 .
Richard A. Young & Ladislav Valach. (2009) Evaluating the processes and outcomes of vocational counselling: An action theory perspective. L’Orientation scolaire et professionnelle:38/3, pages 281-306.
Crossref
Stijn Vanheule. (2009) PSYCHOTHERAPY AND RESEARCH: A RELATION THAT NEEDS TO BE REINVENTED. British Journal of Psychotherapy 25:1, pages 91-109.
Crossref
Jürgen Margraf. 2009. Lehrbuch der Verhaltenstherapie. Lehrbuch der Verhaltenstherapie 3 45 .
Jürgen Margraf. 2009. Kosten und Nutzen der Psychotherapie. Kosten und Nutzen der Psychotherapie 151 165 .
G.S. (Jeb) Brown, Joanne Cameron & Lindsey Brown. (2008) In Search of the Active Ingredient: What Really Works in Mental Health Care?. Perspectives on Fluency and Fluency Disorders 18:2, pages 53-59.
Crossref
Mary Gianakis & Timothy A. Carey. (2008) A review of the experience and explanation of psychological change. Counselling Psychology Review 23:3, pages 27-38.
Crossref
Rachel E. Maddux & Lawrence P. Riso. (2007) Promoting the Scientist–practitioner Mindset in Clinical Training. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy 37:4, pages 213-220.
Crossref
David N. Elkins. (2007) Empirically Supported Treatments: the Deconstruction of a Myth. Journal of Humanistic Psychology 47:4, pages 474-500.
Crossref
G. Parker & K. Fletcher. (2007) Treating depression with the evidence-based psychotherapies: a critique of the evidence. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 115:5, pages 352-359.
Crossref
Elizabeth Schmitt Freire. (2016) Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial in Psychotherapy Research: An Epistemological Controversy. Journal of Humanistic Psychology 46:3, pages 323-335.
Crossref
Stefanía Ægisdóttir, Michael J. White, Paul M. Spengler, Alan S. Maugherman, Linda A. Anderson, Robert S. Cook, Cassandra N. Nichols, Georgios K. Lampropoulos, Blain S. Walker, Genna Cohen & Jeffrey D. Rush. (2016) The Meta-Analysis of Clinical Judgment Project: Fifty-Six Years of Accumulated Research on Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction. The Counseling Psychologist 34:3, pages 341-382.
Crossref
Bruce E. Wampold, Takuya Minami, Sandra Callen Tierney, Thomas W. Baskin & Kuldhir S. Bhati. (2005) The placebo is powerful: Estimating placebo effects in medicine and psychotherapy from randomized clinical trials. Journal of Clinical Psychology 61:7, pages 835-854.
Crossref
Peter Fonagy, Anthony Roth & Anna Higgitt. (2005) The outcome of psychodynamic psychotherapy for psychological disorders. Clinical Neuroscience Research 4:5-6, pages 367-377.
Crossref
Bruce E. Wampold, James W. Lichtenberg & Charles A. Waehler. (2005) A Broader Perspective: Counseling Psychology?s Emphasis on Evidence. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy 35:1, pages 27-38.
Crossref
Alvin R. Mahrer. (2005) Empirically Supported Therapies and Therapy Relationships: What are the Serious Problems and Plausible Alternatives?. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy 35:1, pages 3-25.
Crossref
Michael J Mackenzie, Linda E Carlson & Michael Speca. (2005) Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) in Oncology. Evidence-Based Integrative Medicine 2:3, pages 139-145.
Crossref
Peter Fonagy, Anthony Roth & Anna Higgitt. (2005) Psychodynamic psychotherapies: Evidence-based practice and clinical wisdom. Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic 69:1, pages 1-58.
Crossref
Roelf Jan Takens. (2004) Richtlijnen en denkwijzen. Tijdschrift voor Psychotherapie 30:1, pages 23-30.
Crossref
Bruce E. Wampold & Kuldhir S. Bhati. (2004) Attending to the Omissions: A Historical Examination of Evidence-Based Practice Movements.. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 35:6, pages 563-570.
Crossref
Drew Westen, Catherine M. Novotny & Heather Thompson-Brenner. (2004) The Empirical Status of Empirically Supported Psychotherapies: Assumptions, Findings, and Reporting in Controlled Clinical Trials.. Psychological Bulletin 130:4, pages 631-663.
Crossref
Kathleen Chwalisz. (2016) Evidence-Based Practice:. The Counseling Psychologist 31:5, pages 497-528.
Crossref
Darcy Haag Granello & Laura Hill. (2003) Assessing Outcome in Practice Settings: A Primer and Example from an Eating Disorders Program. Journal of Mental Health Counseling 25:3, pages 218-232.
Crossref
S. Mark Kopta. (2003) The dose—effect relationship in psychotherapy: A defining achievement for Dr. Kenneth Howard. Journal of Clinical Psychology 59:7, pages 727-733.
Crossref
Thomas W. Baskin, Sandy Callen Tierney, Takuya Minami & Bruce E. Wampold. (2003) Establishing Specificity in Psychotherapy: A Meta-Analysis of Structural Equivalence of Placebo Controls.. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71:6, pages 973-979.
Crossref
Larry E. Beutler, Carla Moleiro & Hani Talebi. (2002) How practitioners can systematically use empirical evidence in treatment selection. Journal of Clinical Psychology 58:10, pages 1199-1212.
Crossref
Herbert C Schulberg, Patrick J Raue & Bruce L Rollman. (2002) The effectiveness of psychotherapy in treating depressive disorders in primary care practice: clinical and cost perspectives. General Hospital Psychiatry 24:4, pages 203-212.
Crossref
Bruce E Wampold, Takuya Minami, Thomas W Baskin & Sandra Callen Tierney. (2002) A meta-(re)analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy versus ‘other therapies’ for depression. Journal of Affective Disorders 68:2-3, pages 159-165.
Crossref
Bruce E. Wampold, James W. Lichtenberg & Charles A. Waehler. (2016) Principles of Empirically Supported Interventions in Counseling Psychology. The Counseling Psychologist 30:2, pages 197-217.
Crossref
Lester Luborsky, Robert Rosenthal, Louis Diguer, Tomasz P. Andrusyna, Jeffrey S. Berman, Jill T. Levitt, David A. Seligman & Elizabeth D. Krause. (2006) The Dodo Bird Verdict Is Alive and Well-Mostly. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 9:1, pages 2-12.
Crossref
Karen Callan Stoiber & Gregory A. Waas. (2002) A contextual and methodological perspective on the evidence-based intervention movement within school psychology in the United States. Educational and Child Psychology 19:3, pages 7-21.
Crossref
Joel R. Levin. (2002) How to evaluate the evidence of evidence-based interventions?. School Psychology Quarterly 17:4, pages 483-492.
Crossref
Nathan B. Hansen, Michael J. Lambert & Evan M. Forman. (2002) The psychotherapy dose-response effect and its implications for treatment delivery services.. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 9:3, pages 329-343.
Crossref
Barry L. Duncan. (2002) The legacy of Saul Rosenzweig: The profundity of the dodo bird.. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration 12:1, pages 32-57.
Crossref
Cas Schaap. (2001) Psychotherapie als placebo. Dth 21:4, pages 166-173.
Crossref
Ann‐Louise Ellwood, Linda E. Carlson & Barry D. Bultz. (2001) Empirically supported treatments: will this movement in the field of psychology impact the practice of psychosocial oncology?. Psycho-Oncology 10:3, pages 199-205.
Crossref
Kathleen Chwalisz. (2001) A common factors revolution: Let's not "cut off our discipline's nose to spite its face.". Journal of Counseling Psychology 48:3, pages 262-267.
Crossref
Hyun-nie Ahn & Bruce E. Wampold. (2001) Where oh where are the specific ingredients? A meta-analysis of component studies in counseling and psychotherapy.. Journal of Counseling Psychology 48:3, pages 251-257.
Crossref
M.J. Lambert & E.J. Hawkins. 2001. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences 12372 12377 .
E. Fava, E. Pazzi, L. Arduini, C. Masserini, M. Lammoglia, L. Lomazzi, S. Landra, P. Pazzaglia & I. Carta. (2016) The Effects of Psychotherapies: a Study On Patients' Perception of Results in an Italian Public Setting. International Journal of Social Psychiatry 46:4, pages 290-305.
Crossref
M. J. Patton. (2000) Counseling Psychology Training: A Matter of Good Teaching. The Counseling Psychologist 28:5, pages 701-711.
Crossref
C. A. Waehler, C. R. Kalodner, B. E. Wampold & J. W. Lichtenberg. (2000) Empirically Supported Treatments (ESTs) in Perspective: Implications for Counseling Psychology Training. The Counseling Psychologist 28:5, pages 657-671.
Crossref
Michael Speca, Linda E. Carlson, Eileen Goodey & Maureen Angen. (2000) A Randomized, Wait-List Controlled Clinical Trial: The Effect of a Mindfulness Meditation-Based Stress Reduction Program on Mood and Symptoms of Stress in Cancer Outpatients. Psychosomatic Medicine 62:5, pages 613-622.
Crossref
Thomas R. Kratochwill, Karen Callan Stoiber & Terry B. Gutkin. (2000) Empirically supported interventions in school psychology: The role of negative results in outcome research. Psychology in the Schools 37:5, pages 399-413.
Crossref
David Mark Allen, Charlotte L. Kennedy, William R. Veeser & Trusa Grosso. (2014) Teaching the Integration of Psychotherapy Paradigms in a Psychiatric Residency Seminar. Academic Psychiatry 24:1, pages 6-13.
Crossref
Peter E. Nathan, Scott P. Stuart & Sara L. Dolan. (2000) Research on psychotherapy efficacy and effectiveness: Between Scylla and Charybdis?. Psychological Bulletin 126:6, pages 964-981.
Crossref
Heidi Möller & Michael Märtens. 2000. Supervision und Organisationsentwicklung. Supervision und Organisationsentwicklung 104 122 .
Ybe Meesters & Wies Rombouts. (1999) Effectmetingen op een afdeling voor (deeltijd)klinische gedragstherapie. Dth 19:2, pages 58-68.
Crossref
Kathleen M. Carroll, Charla Nich, A.Thomas McLellan, James R. McKay & Bruce J. Rounsaville. (1999) ‘Research’ versus ‘real-world’ patients: representativeness of participants in clinical trials of treatments for cocaine dependence. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 54:2, pages 171-177.
Crossref
S. Mark KoptaRobert J. Lueger, Stephen M. Saunders & Kenneth I. Howard. (1999) INDIVIDUAL PSYCHOTHERAPY OUTCOME AND PROCESS RESEARCH: Challenges Leading to Greater Turmoil or a Positive Transition?. Annual Review of Psychology 50:1, pages 441-469.
Crossref
Darcy Haag Granello, Paul F. Granello & Fred Lee. (1999) Measuring treatment outcomes and client satisfaction in a partial hospitalization program. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research 26:1, pages 50-63.
Crossref
Heidi Möller & Michael Märtens. 1999. Supervision und Organisationsentwicklung. Supervision und Organisationsentwicklung 104 122 .
Ann R. FischerLaRae M. Jome & Donald R. Atkinson. (2016) Reconceptualizing Multicultural Counseling. The Counseling Psychologist 26:4, pages 525-588.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.