Beyond the ‘green bling’: Identifying contradictions encountered in school sustainability programmes and teachers’ responses to them

Abstract

As schools seek to implement frameworks of education for sustainable development it is inevitable that they will encounter contradictions between their own aspirations and external demands. To analyse these contradictions through the lens of teachers-in-context, this research uses Cultural-historical Activity Theory that views schools as activity systems and reveals contradictions within those systems. Interviews with teachers and headteachers from a sample of twelve schools (primary, middle and secondary level) in England highlight contradictions that occur at different strategic levels in the school. A perspective document, comprising contradictory statements gathered from interview transcripts, reveals the extent to which these contradictions are shared among interviewees. A striking feature of the data is that teachers do not recognise these contradictions themselves. Analysis of the data reveals how teachers respond to contradictory situations. Responses include a sense of powerlessness, varying degrees of accommodation and a reframing of contradictions through ‘expansive learning’. This paper proposes a process for identifying and assessing contradictions in schools and suggests that, by making their responses to contradictions explicit, teachers can present learners with authentic examples of contextualised learning.

Keywords:

• education for sustainable development
• Activity Theory
• contradictions
• teachers
• schools

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes

1 This is not necessarily the case in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland.

2 Tesco is a leading supermarket. Working on night shifts in Tesco is popularly seen as a job that is readily available to anyone who finds themselves unemployed.