517
Views
15
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research report

The effective use of fear appeals in persuasive immunization: An analysis of national immunization intervention messages

Pages 264-292 | Published online: 21 May 2009

References

  • Aho , W. R. 1979 . Participation of senior citizens in the Swine Flu inoculation program: An analysis of health belief model variables in preventive health behavior. . Journal of Gerontology , 34 : 201 – 208 .
  • Allman , W. F. 1985 . Staying alive in the 20th century. . Science , October : 31 – 37 .
  • Anderson , R. 1989 . “ Reassessing the odds against finding meaningful behavioral change in mass media health promotion campaigns. ” . In Public relations theory , Edited by: Botan , C. H. and Hazelton , V. 309 – 321 . Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Andersen , K. and Clevenger , T. 1963 . A summary of experimental research in ethos. . Speech Monographs , 30 : 59 – 78 .
  • Aristotle . 1941 . The basic works of Aristotle. , Edited by: McKeon , R. New York : Random House . 4th C. B.C.)
  • Arnston , P. 1985 . Future research in health communication. . Journal of Applied Communication Research , 13 : 118 – 130 .
  • Atkin , C. and Freimuth , V. 1989 . “ Formative evaluation research in campaign design. ” . In Public communication campaigns , (2nd ed. , Edited by: Rice , R. and Atkin , C. 131 – 150 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Bales , S. N. 1994 . Informing the public and educating parents background paper 1994–1996 immunization initiative. , Washington, DC : Prepared for The Knight Foundation by the Benton Foundation .
  • Bandura , A. 1977 . Self‐efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. . Psychological Review , 84 : 191 – 215 .
  • Bandura , A. 1992 . “ Exercise of personal agency through the self‐efficacy mechanism. ” . In Self‐efficacy: Thought control of action , Edited by: Schwarzer , R. 3 – 38 . Washington, DC : Hemisphere .
  • Beck , K. H. and Frankel , A. 1981 . A conceptualization of threat communications and protective health behavior. . Social Psychology Quarterly , 44 : 204 – 217 .
  • Becker , M. H. 1974 . The health belief model and personal health behavior. . Health Education Monographs , 2 : 324 – 508 .
  • Bennett , P. and Smith , C. 1992 . Parents attitudinal and social influences on childhood vaccination. . Health Education Research Theory and Practice , 7 : 341 – 348 .
  • Bivins , T. 1991 . Handbook for public relations writing. , Chicago, IL : NTC Business Books .
  • Bobo , J. , Gale , J. , Thapa , P. and Wassilak , S. 1993 . Risk factors for delayed immunization in a random sample of 1163 children from Oregon and Washington. . Pediatrics , 91 : 308 – 314 .
  • Bocchino , C. 1992 . Childhood immunization: Opportunities to improve immunization rates at lower cost. . Pediatric Nursing , 18 : 536
  • Botan , C. H. 1989 . “ Theory development in public relations. ” . In Public relations theory , Edited by: Botan , C. H. and Hazelton , V. 99 – 110 . Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Brink , S. 1989 . Provider reminders changing information format to increase infant immunizations. . Medical Care , 27 : 648 – 653 .
  • Burgoon , J. K. 1976 . The ideal source: A reexamination of source credibility measurement. . Central States Speech Journal , 27 : 200 – 206 .
  • Burleson , B. R. 1984 . “ Comforting communication. ” . In Communication by children and adults: Social cognitive and strategic processes , Edited by: Sypher , H. E. and Applegate , J. L. 63 – 104 . Beverly Hills, CA : Sage .
  • Burleson , B. R. 1992 . Taking communication seriously. . Communication Monographs , 59 : 79 – 86 .
  • Campbell , R. 1993 . Social support, health knowledge, race, and income as predictors of fetal health locus of control among female teens: Test of a conceptual model. , West Lafayette, IN, , U.S.A. : Purdue University . Unpublished master's thesis
  • Campbell , R. Medium or message? A problem‐solving approach to assessing effectiveness in public health campaigns. Paper presented at the annual convention of the Speech Communication Association . New Orleans, LA.
  • Centers for Disease Control . 1989 . Recommendations of the Immunization Practices Advisory Committee (ACIP): General recommendations on immunization. . Morbidity 6‐ Mortality Weekly Report , 38 : 205 – 214 . 219 – 227 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1991a . Measles vaccination levels among preschool‐aged children in 8 selected cities, United States. . Mortality and Morbidity Weekly Report , 40 : 36 – 39 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1991b . Estimated percentage of children two years of age not up to date for immunization United States. , Atlanta, GA : National Health Interview Survey .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1992a . Early childhood vaccination levels among urban children—Connecticut, 1990 and 1991. . Mortality and Morbidity Weekly Report , 40 : 888 – 891 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1992b . Retrospective assessment of vaccination coverage among school‐aged children—Selected U.S. cities, 1991. . Mortality and Morbidity Weekly Report , 41 : 103 – 107 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1993 . Standards for pediatric immunization practices. . Journal of the American Medical Association , 269 : 1817 – 1822 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1994a . Vaccination coverage of 2‐year‐old children—United States, 1991–1992. . Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report , 42 : 985 – 988 .
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . 1994b . Vaccination coverage of 2‐year‐old children—United States, 1992–1993. . Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report , 43 : 282 – 284 .
  • Children's Program of the Benton Foundation . 1994 . Informing the public and educating parents background paper 1994–1996 immunization initiative. , Chicago, IL : Susan Nall Bales (Director) .
  • Clark , R. A. 1979 . The impact of self interest and desire for liking on the selection of communicative strategies. . Communication Monographs , 46 : 257 – 273 .
  • Clark , R. A. 1984 . Persuasive message units. , New York : Harper & Row .
  • Clark , R. A. and Delia , J. 1979 . Topoi and rhetorical competence. . The Quarterly Journal of Speech , 65 : 187 – 206 .
  • Colombo , T. J. , Saward , E. E. and Greenlick , M. R. 1969 . The integration of an OEO health program into a prepaid comprehensive group practice plan. . American Journal of Public Health , 59 : 641 – 650 .
  • Committee on Finance . May 6 1993 . Child immunization initiative hearing before the subcommittee on health for families and the uninsured. , United States Senate One Hundred Third Congress First Session on S. 733 (S. HRG. 103–252) May 6 , Washington, DC : U.S. Government Printing Office .
  • Cummings , K. M. , Jette , A. M. and Brock . 1979 . Psychosocial determinants of immunization behavior in a Swine Influenza campaign. . Medical Care , 17 : 639 – 649 .
  • Cutts , F. T. , Orenstein , W. A. and Bernier , R. H. 1992 . Causes of low preschool immunization coverage in the United States. . Annual Review of Public Health , 13 : 385 – 398 .
  • Department of Health and Human Services . Feb. 12 1993 . Statement of the President. , Feb. 12 , Arlington, VA : Arlington County Department of Human Services Clinic . Press release
  • Department of Health and Human Services . 1994 . “ New year brings new immunization goals. ” . In Immunization Action News , Atlanta, GA : Centers for Disease Control and Prevention .
  • Feigelman , S. , Stanton , B. , Rubin , J. D. and Cartelli , N. A. 1993 . Effectiveness of family notification efforts and compliance with measles post‐exposure prophylaxis. . Journal of Community Health , 18 : 83 – 93 .
  • Fishbein , M. and Ajzen , I. 1975 . Belief, attitude, intention, and behavior: An introduction to theory and research. , Reading, MA : Addison‐Wesley .
  • Flay , B. R. 1981 . “ On improving the chances of mass media health promotion programs causing meaningful changes in behavior. ” . In Communication & research broadcasting health education by television and radio , Edited by: Meyer , M. 56 – 91 . Munich : K. G. Saur .
  • Flay , B. R. and Cook , T. D. 1989 . “ Three models for summative evaluation of prevention campaigns with a mass media component. ” . In Public communication campaigns , Edited by: Rice , R. E. and Atkin , C. K. 175 – 196 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Fosu , G. B. 1991–2 . Maternal influences on preventive health behavior in children. . International Quarterly of Community Health Education , 12 : 1 – 19 .
  • Francis , D. P. , Pope , R. S. and Pasternak , E. J. 1978 . Measles control in Oregon. . Public Health Reports , 93 : 216 – 220 .
  • Goleman , D. 1994 . Hidden rules often distort ideas of risk. . The New York Times , February 1 : C1 – C10 .
  • Grunig , J. and Hunt , T. 1984 . Managing public relations. , New York : Holt, Rinehart & Winston .
  • Harvard Center for Health Communications & Johns Hopkins University Center for Communication Programs . 1994 . Immunization attitudes and knowledge. , Baltimore, MD : Project for the National Immunization Outreach Campaign .
  • Henning , K. J. , Pollack , D. M. and Friedman , S. M. 1992 . A neonatal Hepatitis B surveillance and vaccination program: New York City, 1987 to 1988. . American Journal of Public Health , 82 : 885 – 888 .
  • Hinman , A. R. 1990 . Immunizations in the United States. , Atlanta, GA : Center for Prevention Services, Centers for Disease Control .
  • Hinman , A. R. 1991 . What will it take to fully protect all American children with vaccines? . American Journal of Diseases of Children , 145 : 559 – 562 .
  • Igoe , J. B. and Goodwin , L. D. 1991 . Meeting the challenge of immunizing the nation's children. . Pediatric Nursing , 17 : 583 – 585 .
  • Jackson , B. M. , Payton , T. , Horst , G. , Halpin , T. and Mortensen , B. 1993 . An epidemiologic investigation of a rubella outbreak among the Amish of Northeastern Ohio. . Public Health Reports , 108 : 436 – 439 .
  • Jackson , S. 1993 . How to do things to words: The experimental manipulation of message variables. . The Southern Communication Journal , 58 : 103 – 113 .
  • Janis , I. L. and Feshbach , S. 1953 . Effects of fear‐arousing communications. . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 48 : 78 – 92 .
  • Janz , N. K. and Becker , M. H. 1984 . The health belief model: A decade later. . Health Education Quarterly , 11 : 1 – 47 .
  • Job , R. F. 1988 . Effective and ineffective use of fear in health promotion campaigns. . American Journal of Public Health , 78 : 163 – 167 .
  • Johns Hopkins University and The University of Maryland, Baltimore . 1993 . The Baltimore Immunization Study: Immunization coverage and causes of under‐immunization among inner‐city children in Baltimore. , Baltimore, MD : the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention . For
  • Jurgrau , A. 1990 . Why aren't we protecting our children? . RN , November : 30 – 35 .
  • Kennamer , J. D. 1988 . News values and the vividness of information. . Written Communication , 5 : 108 – 123 .
  • Kerner , J. F. , Dusenbury , L. and Mandelblatt , J. 1993 . Poverty and cultural diversity: Challenges for health promotion among medically underserved. . Annual Review of Public Health , 14 : 355 – 377 .
  • Kirscht , J. P. 1974 . The health belief model and illness behavior. . Health Education Monographs , 2 : 387 – 408 .
  • Kirscht , J. P. , Becker , M. H. and Eveland , J. P. 1976 . Psychological and social factors as predictors of medical behavior. . Medical Care , 14 : 422 – 431 .
  • Kline , K. L. 1994 . Applying Witte's extended parallel process model to pamphlets urging women to engage in BSE: Where are the efficacy message units? , Athens, GA : University of Georgia . Unpublished manuscript
  • Kreps , G. L. 1988 . “ The pervasive role of information in health and health care: Implications for health communication policy. ” . In Communication yearbook 11 , Edited by: Anderson , J. 238 – 276 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Krippendorff , K. 1980 . Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology. , Newbury Park, CA : Sage .
  • Krone , K. J. , Jablin , F. M. and Putnam , L. L. 1987 . “ Communication theory and organizational communication: Multiple perspectives. ” . In Handbook of organizational communication an interdisciplinary perspective , Edited by: Jablin , F. M. , Putnam , L. L. , Roberts , K. H. and Porter , L. W. 18 – 40 . Newbury Park, CA : Sage .
  • Larson , E. B. , Olsen , E. and Cole , W. 1979 . The relationship of health beliefs and a postcard reminder to influenza vaccination. . Journal of Family Practice , 8 : 1207 – 1211 .
  • Larson , E. B. , Bergman , J. , Heidrich , F. , Alvin , B. L. and Schneeweiss , R. 1982 . Do postcard reminders improve influenza vaccination compliance? A prospective trial of different postcard “cues.” . Medical Care , 10 : 639 – 648 .
  • Lee , C. V. , McDermott , S. W. and Elliott , C. 1990 . The delayed immunization of children of migrant farm workers in South Carolina. . Public Health Reports , 105 : 317 – 320 .
  • Leventhal , H. , Safer , M. A. and Panagis , D. M. 1983 . The impact of communications on the self‐regulation of health beliefs, decisions, and behavior. . Health Education Quarterly , 10 : 3 – 29 .
  • Littlejohn , S. W. 1983 . “ Theory in the process of inquiry. ” . In Theories of human communication , Edited by: Littlejohn , S. W. 9 – 25 . Belmont, CA : Wadsworth .
  • Maibach , E. , Flora , J. A. and Nass , C. 1991 . Changes in self‐efficacy and health behavior in response to a minimal contact community health campaign. . Health Communication , 3 : 1 – 15 .
  • Maiman , L. A. and Becker , M. H. 1974 . The health belief model: Origins and correlates in psychological theory. . Health Education Monographs , 2 : 336 – 353 .
  • Marcuse , E. K. 1979 . Pediatricians’ immunization consent practice, Washington State. . Pediatrics , 63 : 419 – 422 .
  • McCormick , M. C. , Shapiro , S. and Starfield , B. H. 1981 . The association of patient‐held records and completion of immunizations. . Clinical Pediatrician , 22 : 270 – 274 .
  • McGrath , J. C. 1991 . Evaluating national health communication campaigns: Formative and summative research issues. . American Behavioral Scientist , 34 : 652 – 665 .
  • McGuire , W. J. 1989 . “ Theoretical foundations of campaigns. ” . In Public communication campaigns , (2nd ed. , Edited by: Rice , R. E. and Atkin , C. K. 43 – 65 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • McGuire , W. J. 1984 . Public communication as a strategy for inducing health‐promoting behavioral change. . Preventive Medicine , 13 : 299 – 319 .
  • Mendelsohn , H. 1973 . Some reasons why information campaigns can succeed. . Public Opinion Quarterly , 37 : 50 – 61 .
  • Minear , R. E. and Guyer , B. 1979 . Assessing immunization services at a neighborhood health center. . Pediatrics , 63 : 416 – 419 .
  • Mitchell , V. S. , Philipose , N. M. and Sanford , J. P. , eds. 1993 . The children's vaccine initiative achieving the vision. , Washington, DC : National Academy Press .
  • Moore , B. J. , Morris , D. W. , Burton , B. and Kilcrease , D. T. 1981 . Measuring effectiveness of service aides in infant immunization surveillance program in north central Texas. . American Journal of Public Health , 71 : 634 – 636 .
  • National Vaccine Advisory Committee . 1991 . The measles epidemic: The problems, barriers, and recommendations. . Journal of the American Medical Association , 266 : 1547 – 1552 .
  • Ochs , J. and Trocchio , J. 1992 . Protecting children's health: CHA's immunization program helps organizations increase vaccination in their communities. . Health Progress , Sept. : 28 – 32 .
  • Orenstein , W. , Atkinson , W. , Mason , D. and Bernier , R. 1990 . Barriers to vaccinating preschool children. . Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved , 1 : 315 – 330 .
  • Peterson , L. 1987 . Prevention and community compliance to immunization schedules. . Prevention in Human Services , 5 : 79 – 95 .
  • Petty , R. E. and Cacioppo , J. T. 1986 . Communication and persuasion: Central and peripheral routes to attitude change. , New York : Springer/Verlag .
  • Prentice‐Dunn , S. and Rogers , R. W. 1986 . Protection motivation theory and preventive health: Beyond the health belief model. . Health Education Research , 1 : 153 – 161 .
  • Rice , J. M. and Lutzker , J. R. 1984 . Reducing noncompliance to follow‐up appointment keeping at a family practice center. . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis , 17 : 303 – 311 .
  • Richardson , S. F. 1988 . Child health promotion practices. . Journal of Pediatric Health Care , 2 : 73 – 78 .
  • Riegle , Sen. D. W. Jr. May 6 1993 . Opening Statement to the Hearing before the Subcommittee on Health for Families and the Uninsured of the Committee on Finance. , United States Senate May 6 , Washington, DC : U.S. Government Printing Office . (MI)
  • Roberts , M. C. and Peterson , L. 1984 . “ Prevention models theoretical and practical implications. ” . In Prevention of problems in childhood psychological research and applications , Edited by: Roberts , M. C. and Peterson , L. 1 – 39 . New York : John Wiley & Sons .
  • Robinson , C. A. , Sepe , S. J. and Lin , K. F. 1993 . The President's child immunization initiative—A summary of the problem and the response. . Public Health Reports , 108 : 419 – 425 .
  • Rogers , E. M. and Storey , J. D. 1987 . “ Communication campaigns. ” . In Handbook of communication science , Edited by: Berger , R. and Chaffee , S. 817 – 846 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Rogers , R. W. 1975 . A protection motivation theory of fear appeals and attitude change. . Journal of Psychology , 91 : 93 – 114 .
  • Roghmann , K. J. , Hoekelman , R. A. and McInerny , T. K. 1984 . The changing pattern of primary pediatric care: Update for one community. . Pediatrics , 73 : 363 – 374 .
  • Rosenstock , I. M. 1974a . Historical origins of the health belief model. . Health Education Monographs , 2 : 328 – 335 .
  • Rosenstock , I. M. 1974b . The health belief model and preventive health behavior. . Health Education Monographs , 2 : 354 – 386 .
  • Rowan , K. E. 1991 . Goals, obstacles, and strategies in risk communication: A problem‐solving approach to improving communication about risks. . Journal of Applied Communication Research , 19 : 300 – 329 .
  • Rowan , K. E. 1994 . Why rules for risk communication are not enough: A problem‐solving approach to risk communication. . Risk Analysis , 14 : 365 – 374 .
  • Rundall , T. G. and Wheeler , J. R. 1979 . Factors associated with utilization of the swine flu vaccination program among senior citizens. . Medical Care , 17 : 191 – 200 .
  • Saliterman , L. S. 1980 . Immunization outreach program in health maintenance organization. . Pediatrics , 65 : 338 – 339 .
  • Scherer , C. and Juanillo , N. Jr. 1992 . “ Bridging theory and praxis: Reexamining public health communication. ” . In Communication yearbook 15 , Edited by: Deetz , S. 312 – 345 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Schoch , E. 1994 . A big boost for immunization: Computerized county records may help raise low shot rates. . Indianapolis Star , April 19 : A1 – A2 .
  • Sellars , M. L. , Geertsen , H. R. and Gray , R. M. 1971 . Religion, alienation and immunization participation. . The Rocky Mountain Social Science Journal , 8 : 119 – 126 .
  • Shalala , D. E. 1993a . Giving pediatric immunizations the priority they deserve. . Journal of the American Medical Association , 269 April 14 : 1844 – 1845 .
  • Shalala , D. E. May 6 1993b . Prepared statement, hearing before the subcommittee on health for families and the uninsured of the committee on finance. , May 6 , 70 – 76 . Washington, DC : United States Senate. U.S. Government Printing Office .
  • Singleton , R. A. , Straits , B. C. and Straits , M. M. 1993 . “ Research using available data. ” . In Approaches to social research , 354 – 390 . New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Stanger , L. 1987 . Immunization mobile brings protection to children in southeastern Idaho. . Public Health Reports , 102 : 543 – 545 .
  • Stehr‐Green , P. A. , Dini , E. F. and Patriarca , P. A. 1993 . Evaluation of telephoned computer‐generated reminders to improve immunization coverage at inner‐city clinics. . Public Health Reports , 108 : 426 – 430 .
  • Szilagyi , P. , Rodewald , L. , Humiston , S. , Raubertas , R. , Cove , L. , Doane , C. , Lind , P. , Tobin , M. , Roghmann , K. and Hall , C. 1993 . Missed opportunities for childhood vaccinations in office practices and the effect on vaccination status. . Pediatrics , 91 : 1 – 7 .
  • Szilagyi , P. G. , Roghmann , K. J. , Campbell , J. R. , Humiston , S. G. , Winter , N. L. , Raubertas , R. F. and Rodewald , L. E. 1994 . Immunization practices of primary care practitioners and their relation to immunization levels. . Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine , 148 : 158 – 166 .
  • Thompson , T. L. 1984 . The invisible helping hand: The role of communication in the health and social service professions. . Communication Quarterly , 32 : 148 – 163 .
  • Weick , K. and Browning , L. 1991 . Fixing with the voice: A research agenda for applied communication. . Journal of Applied Communication Research , 19 : 1 – 19 .
  • Wiener , J. and Trocchio , J. 1992 . Protecting children's health CHA's immunization program helps organizations increase vaccination rates in their communities. . Health Progress , 24 : 28 – 32 .
  • Williams , B. 1990 . Immunization coverage among preschool children: The United States and selected European countries. . Pediatrics , : 1052 – 1056 . From the Department of Maternal and Child Health, University of North Carolina School of Public Health, Chapel Hill, NC, 27599–7400
  • Witte , K. 1992a . The role of threat and efficacy in aids prevention. . International Quarterly of Community Health Education , 12 : 225 – 249 .
  • Witte , K. 1992b . Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended parallel process model. . Communication Monographs , 59 : 329 – 349 .
  • Witte , K. 1992c . Preventing tractor‐related injuries and deaths in rural populations: Using a persuasive health message framework in formative evaluation research. . International Quarterly of Community Health Education , 13 : 219 – 241 .
  • Witte , K. 1993 . Message and conceptual confounds in fear appeals: The role of threat, fear, and efficacy. . Southern Communication Journal , 58 : 147 – 154 .
  • Witte , K. 1994a . Fear control and danger control: A test of the extended parallel process model. . Communication Monographs , 61 : 113 – 134 .
  • Witte , K. 1994b . “ How scary should fear appeals be? A formula‐based guide for public health practitioners. ” . In Communication yearbook 18 , Edited by: Burleson , B. 229 – 254 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage .
  • Woods , D. R. and Mason , D. D. 1992 . Six areas lead national early immunization drive. . Public Health Reports , 107 : 252 – 256 .
  • Yokan , C. and D'Onofrio , C. 1978 . Application of health education methods to achieve higher immunization rates. . Public Health Reports , 93 : 211 – 215 .
  • Yokley , J. M. and Glenwick , D. S. 1984 . Increasing the immunization of preschool children: An evaluation of applied community interventions. . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis , 17 : 313 – 325 .
  • Young , S. A. , Halpin , T. J. , Johnson , D. A. , Irvin , J, J. and Marks , J. S. 1980 . Effectiveness of a mailed reminder on the immunization levels of infants at high risk of failure to complete immunizations. . American Journal of Public Health , 70 : 422 – 424 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.