Governing through ambiguity in the normalizing society: The lesson from Chinese transnational higher education regulation

References

• Abbott, K. W., and D. Snidal. 2000. “Hard and Soft Law in International Governance.” International Organization 54 (3): 421–456. doi:10.1162/002081800551280.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Allen, A. 2014. Benign Violence: Education in and Beyond the Age of Reason. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
   Google Scholar
• Altbach, P. G., and J. Knight. 2007. “The Internationalization of Higher Education: Motivations and Realities.” Journal of Studies in International Education 11 (3–4): 290–305. doi:10.1177/1028315307303542.
   Google Scholar
• Althusser, L. 1977. “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses (Notes Towards an Investigation).” In Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, edited by L. Althusser, 127–186. London: New Left Books.
   Google Scholar
• Anderson, K. T., and J. Holloway. 2020. “Discourse Analysis as Theory, Method, and Epistemology in Studies of Education Policy.” Journal of Education Policy 35 (2): 188–221. doi:10.1080/02680939.2018.1552992.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Apple, M. 1999. “Between Neo and Post: Critique and Transformation in Critical Educational Studies.” In Multicultural Research, edited by C. A. Grant, 54–67. London: Falmer Press.
   Google Scholar
• Apter, D. E., and T. Saich. 1994. Revolutionary Discourse in Mao’s Republic. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C. 2009. Analyzing Policy: What’s the Problem Represented to Be?. Frenchs Forest, NSW: Pearson.
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C. 2010. “Foucault, Policy and Rule: Challenging the Problem­solving Paradigm” In Feminist Research Centre in Aalborg (FREIA), Institute for History, International and Social Studies, Aalborg University. Accessed. http://vbn.aau.dk/files/33190050/FREIA_wp_74.pdf
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C. 2012. “Why Study Problematizations? Making Politics Visible.” Open Journal of Political Science 2 (1): 1–8. doi:10.4236/ojps.2012.21001.
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C. 2015. “The Turn to Problematization: Political Implications of Contrasting Interpretive and Poststructural Adaptations.” Open Journal of Political Science 5 (01): 1–12. doi:10.4236/ojps.2015.51001.
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C. 2020. “Problem-Solving as a Governing Knowledge: “Skills”-Testing in PISA and PIAAC.” Open Journal of Political Science 10 (01): 82–105. doi:10.4236/ojps.2020.101007.
   Google Scholar
• Bacchi, C., and S. Goodwin. 2016. Poststructural Policy Analysis: A Guide to Practice. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 1990. “Power, Conflict, Micropolitics and All That!.” In Doing the Sociology of Education, edited by G. Walford, 166–92. 2 Vols. London: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 1993. “What is Policy? Texts, Trajectories and Toolboxes.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 13 (2): 10–17. doi:10.1080/0159630930130203.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 2006. Education Policy and Social Class: The Selected Works of Stephen J Ball. Abingdon: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 2012a. Foucault, Power, and Education. New York: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 2012b. Politics and Policy Making in Education: Explorations in Sociology. Abingdon: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 2015. “What is Policy? 21 Years Later: Reflections on the Possibilities of Policy Research.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 36 (3): 306–313. doi:10.1080/01596306.2015.1015279.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J. 2016. “Subjectivity as a Site of Struggle: Refusing Neoliberalism?” British Journal of Sociology of Education 37 (8): 1129–1146. doi:10.1080/01425692.2015.1044072.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J., and C. Junemann. 2012. Networks, New Governance and Education. Bristol: Policy Press.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J., M. M. Maguire, and A. Braun. 2012. How Schools Do Policy: Policy Enactments on Secondary Schools. London: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Ball, S. J., M. Maguire, A. Braun, and K. Hoskins. 2011. “Policy Subjects and Policy Actors in Schools: Some Necessary but Insufficient Analyses.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 32 (4): 611–624. doi:10.1080/01596306.2011.601564.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Belsey, C. 1980. Critical Practice. London: Methuen.
   Google Scholar
• Best, J. 2008. “Ambiguity, Uncertainty, and Risk: Rethinking Indeterminacy 1.” International Political Sociology 2 (4): 355–374. doi:10.1111/j.1749-5687.2008.00056.x.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Best, J. 2012a. “Ambiguity and Uncertainty in International Organizations: A History of Debating IMF Conditionality 1.” International Studies Quarterly 56 (4): 674–688. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2478.2012.00744.x.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Best, J. 2012b. “Bureaucratic Ambiguity.” Economy and Society 41 (1): 84–106. doi:10.1080/03085147.2011.637333.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bian, Y. 2002. “Chinese Social Stratification and Social Mobility.” Annual Review of Sociology 28 (1): 91–116. doi:10.1146/annurev.soc.28.110601.140823.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bourdieu, P. 1977. “The Economics of Linguistic Exchanges.” Social Science Information 16 (6): 645–668. doi:10.1177/053901847701600601.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Braun, A., S. J. Ball, M. Maguire, and K. Hoskins. 2011. “Taking Context Seriously: Towards Explaining Policy Enactments in the Secondary School.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 32 (4): 585–596. doi:10.1080/01596306.2011.601555.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Britzman, D. 2000. “‘The Question of Belief’: Writing Poststructural Ethnography.” In Working the Ruins: Feminist Poststructural Theory and Methods in Education, edited by E. A. Pierre St and W. Pillow, 27–40. New York: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Cai, H., and D. Treisman. 2006. “Did Government Decentralization Cause China’s Economic Miracle?” World Politics 58 (4): 505–535. doi:10.1353/wp.2007.0005.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• China Daily. 2011. “New York University Shanghai: Two Suspenses for a New University? (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/dfpd/shehui/2011-03/31/content_12253655_2.htm
   Google Scholar
• China Education Association for International Exchange. 2016. “One Hundred Questions About Transnational Higher Education in China (In Chinese)” Accessed https://international.bfsu.edu.cn/info/1185/1203.htm
   Google Scholar
• China News. 2016. “Financial Support from Guangdong Province into the Guangdong Technion-Israel Institute of Technology (In Chinese)” Accessed https://www.chinanews.com.cn/gn/2016/12-07/8086007.shtml
   Google Scholar
• Chun, Y. H., and H. G. Rainey. 2005. “Goal Ambiguity in US Federal Agencies.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 15 (1): 1–30. doi:10.1093/jopart/mui001.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Codd, J. A. 1988. “The Construction and Deconstruction of Educational Policy Documents.” Journal of Education Policy 3 (3): 235–247. doi:10.1080/0268093880030303.
   Google Scholar
• Cohen, A., J. C. Timmons, and S. L. Fesko. 2005. “The Workforce Investment Act: How Policy Conflict and Policy Ambiguity Affect Implementation.” Journal of Disability Policy Studies 15 (4): 221–230. doi:10.1177/10442073050150040401.
   Google Scholar
• Cook, G. 1989. Discourse. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Council, State. 1996. “Notice on Strengthening the Management of Degree-Granting in Chinese-Foreign Cooperation in Running Schools (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.jsj.edu.cn/n2/1/1002/33.shtml
   Google Scholar
• Davidson, A. 2001. “In Praise of Counter-Conduct.” History of the Human Sciences 24 (4): 25–41. doi:10.1177/0952695111411625.
   Google Scholar
• Dean, M. 1991. The Constitution of Poverty: Toward a Genealogy of Liberal Governance. London: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• Dean, M. 2002. “Liberal Government and Authoritarianism.” Economy and Society 31 (1): 37–61. doi:10.1080/03085140120109240.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dean, M. 2010. Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society. London: Sage.
   Google Scholar
• Edwards, R. 2002. “Mobilizing Lifelong Learning: Governmentality in Educational Practices.” Journal of Education Policy 17 (3): 353–365. doi:10.1080/02680930210127603.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fairclough, N. 2009. “A Dialectical-Relational Approach to Critical Discourse Analysis in Social Research.” Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis 2: 162–187.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1981a. The History of Sexuality: An Introduction. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1981b. “The Order of Discourse.” In Untying the Text: A Post-Structuralist Reader, edited by R. Young, 48–78. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1983. “The Subject and Power.” In Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics, edited by H. L. Dreyfus and P. Rabinow, 208–226. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1985. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. London: Penguin Books.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1988. Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason. New York: Vintage Books.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1991a. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. London: Penguin Books.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1991b. “Governmentality.” In The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality, edited by G. Burchell, C. Gordon, and P. Miller, 87–104. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 1994. “Two Lectures.” In Critique and Power: Recasting the Foucault/Habermas Debate, edited by M. Kelly, 17–46. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 2002. The Archaeology of Knowledge. London: Tavistock.
   Google Scholar
• Foucault, M. 2004. Society Must Be Defended. London: Penguin Books.
   Google Scholar
• Gao, J. 2015. “Pernicious Manipulation of Performance Measures in China’s Cadre Evaluation System.” The China Quarterly 223 (223): 618–637. doi:10.1017/S0305741015000806.
   Google Scholar
• Gordon, C. 1991. “Government Rationality: An Introduction.” In The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality, edited by G. Burchell, C. Gordon, and P. Miller, 1–51. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
   Google Scholar
• Grimaldi, E. 2012. “Analysing Policy in the Context(s) of Practice: A Theoretical Puzzle.” Journal of Education Policy 27 (4): 445–465. doi:10.1080/02680939.2011.647926.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Guo, G. 2009. “China’s Local Political Budget Cycles.” American Journal of Political Science 53 (3): 621–632. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5907.2009.00390.x.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Guo, Y., S. Guo, L. Yochim, and X. Liu. 2022. “Internationalization of Chinese Higher Education: Is It Westernization?” Journal of Studies in International Education 26 (4): 436–453. doi:10.1177/1028315321990745.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hacking, I. 1990. The Taming of Chance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Han, X. 2019. “Cross-Field Effect and Institutional Habitus Formation: Self-Reinforcing Inequality in Chinese Higher Education System.” Journal of Education Policy 34 (2): 267–294. doi:10.1080/02680939.2018.1456676.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Han, X. 2021. “Disciplinary Power Matters: Rethinking Governmentality and Policy Enactment Studies in China.” Journal of Education Policy 38 (3): 408–431. Online first. doi:10.1080/02680939.2021.2014570.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Han, X. 2022. “Subjectivity as the Site of Struggle: Students’ Perspectives Toward Sino-Foreign Cooperation Universities in the Era of Discursive Conflicts.” Higher Education, online first: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10734-022-00840-w
   Google Scholar
• Hayden, M. C., B. A. Rancic, and J. J. Thompson. 2000. “Being International: Student and Teacher Perceptions from International Schools.” Oxford Review of Education 26 (1): 107–123. doi:10.1080/030549800103890.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Heberer, T., G. Schubert, and “County and Township Cadres as a Strategic Group. 2012. “A New Approach to Political Agency in China’s Local State.”.” Journal of Chinese Political Science 17 (3): 221–249.
   Google Scholar
• Heberer, T., and R. Trappel. 2013. “Evaluation Processes, Local Cadres’ Behaviour and Local Development Processes.” Journal of Contemporary China 22 (84): 1048–1066. doi:10.1080/10670564.2013.795315.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Heilmann, S. 2008. “Policy Experimentation in China’s Economic Reform.” Studies in Comparative International Development 43 (1): 1–26. doi:10.1007/s12116-007-9014-4.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Heilmann, S. 2009. “Maximum Tinkering Under Uncertainty: Unorthodox Lessons from China.” Modern China 35 (4): 450–462.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hoffman, L. 2006. “Autonomous Choices and Patriotic Professionalism: On Governmentality in Late-Socialist China.” Economy and Society 35 (4): 550–570. doi:10.1080/03085140600960815.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Huang, F. 2007. “Internationalization of Higher Education in the Developing and Emerging Countries: A Focus on Transnational Higher Education in Asia.” Journal of Studies in International Education 11 (3–4): 421–432. doi:10.1177/1028315307303919.
   Google Scholar
• Joseph, J. 2007. “Neo-Liberalism, Governmentality, and Social Regulation” Accessed http://www.saidworkshop.org/joseph.paper.doc
   Google Scholar
• Kipnis, A. 2006. “Suzhi: A Keyword Approach.” The China Quarterly 186: 295–313. doi:10.1017/S0305741006000166.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kipnis, A. B. 2011. “Subjectification and Education for Quality in China.” Economy and Society 40 (2): 289–306. doi:10.1080/03085147.2011.548950.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Knight, J. 2004. “Internationalization Remodeled: Definition, Approaches, and Rationales.” Journal of Studies in International Education 8 (1): 5–31. doi:10.1177/1028315303260832.
   Google Scholar
• Kostka, G., and J. Nahm. 2017. “Central–Local Relations: Recentralization and Environmental Governance in China.” The China Quarterly 231: 567–582. doi:10.1017/S0305741017001011.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Li, H., and L. L. Gore. 2018. “Merit-Based Patronage: Career Incentives of Local Leading Cadres in China.” Journal of Contemporary China 27 (109): 85–102.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lim, L. 2016. “Globalization, the Strong State and Education Policy: The Politics of Policy in Asia.” Journal of Education Policy 31 (6): 711–726. doi:10.1080/02680939.2016.1181790.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lingard, B., S. Rawolle, and S. Taylor. 2005. “Globalizing Policy Sociology in Education: Working with Bourdieu.” Journal of Education Policy 20 (6): 759–777. doi:10.1080/02680930500238945.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lowi, T. J. 1969. The End of Liberalism. New York: Norton.
   Google Scholar
• Marginson, S. 2018. “National/Global Synergy in the Development of Higher Education and Science in China Since 1978.” Frontiers of Education in China 13 (4): 486–512.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Matland, R. E. 1995. “Synthesizing the Implementation Literature: The Ambiguity-Conflict Model of Policy Implementation.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 5 (2): 145–174.
   Google Scholar
• McCarthy, M., and R. Carter. 1994. Language as Discourse: Perspectives for Language Teaching. London: Longman.
   Google Scholar
• Ministry of Education (MOE).2004. “The Implementation Measures of the Regulations of the People’s Republic of China on Chinese-Foreign Cooperation in Running Schools (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.MoE.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/MoE/MoE_162/200408/2544.html.
   Google Scholar
• Ministry of Education (MOE). 2006. “The Advice on Current Situation of TNHE (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.crs.jsj.edu.cn/index.php/default/news/index/1
   Google Scholar
• Ministry of Education (MOE). 2013. “The Recent Development of TNHE After 3 Years’ Release of 2010 Outline (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.moe.edu.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/s7598/201309/156992.html
   Google Scholar
• Nathan, A. J. 2003. “Authoritarian Resilience.” Journal of Democracy 14 (1): 6–17.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Naughton, B. 2017. “Is China Socialist?” Journal of Economic Perspectives 31 (1): 3–24.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nevis, E. 1983. “Using an American Perspective in Understanding Another Clture: Toward a Hierarchy of Needs for the People’s Republic of China.” The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 19 (3): 249–264. doi:10.1177/002188638301900304.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Olssen, M. 2003. “Structuralism, Post-Structuralism, Neo-Liberalism: Assessing Foucault’s Legacy.” Journal of Education Policy 18 (2): 189–202.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Olssen, M., J. Codd, and A. M. O’Neill. 2004. Education Policy: Globalization, Citizenship and Democracy. London: Sage.
   Google Scholar
• The Party Branch of MOE. 2017. “The Implementation Summary of Promoting Political Education in Chinese Higher Education Institutions (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A12/s7060/201712/t20171206_320698.html
   Google Scholar
• Perryman, J., S. J. Ball, A. Braun, and M. Maguire. 2017. “Translating Policy: Governmentality and the Reflective Teacher.” Journal of Education Policy 32 (6): 745–756. doi:10.1080/02680939.2017.1309072.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pun, N., and A. Koo. 2019. “Double Contradiction of Schooling: Class Reproduction and Working-Class Agency at Vocational Schools in China.” British Journal of Sociology of Education 40 (1): 50–64.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ritchie, J., and S. Liz. 2002. “Qualitative Data Analysis for Applied Policy Research.” In The Qualitative Research Companion, edited by A. M. Huberman and B. M. Miles, 305–329. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
   Google Scholar
• Rizvi, F., and B. Lingard. 2011. “Social Equity and the Assemblage of Values in Australian Higher Education.” Cambridge Journal of Education 41 (1): 5–22.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rose, N. 1999. Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Saarinen, T. 2008. “Position of Text and Discourse Analysis in Higher Education Policy Research.” Studies in Higher Education 33 (6): 719–728. doi:10.1080/03075070802457090.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Saussure, F. de. 1974. Course in General Linguistics. Originally published in French, 1916. London: Fontana/Collins.
   Google Scholar
• Schoenhals, M. 1992. Doing Things with Words in Chinese Politics: Five Studies. Berkeley: University of California.
   Google Scholar
• Sharma, Y. 2015. “Campus ‘Will Close’ if Academic Freedom is Threatened” Accessed http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20150626134954290
   Google Scholar
• Singh, P., S. Thomas, and J. Harris. 2013. “Recontextualising Policy Discourses: A Bernsteinian Perspective on Policy Interpretation, Translation, Enactment.” Journal of Education Policy 28 (4): 465–480.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• State Council. 2003. “Regulations of the People’s Republic of China on Chinese-Foreign Cooperation in Running Schools (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.jsj.edu.cn
   Google Scholar
• State Council. 2016. “Notice of the General Office of the State Council on Increasing Incentives and Support to the Places Where the Effectiveness of Real Work is Obvious (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2016-11/17/content_5133748.htm
   Google Scholar
• State Council. 2021. “The Regulation on the Implementation of the Non-State Education Promotion Law of the People’s Republic of China (In Chinese)” Accessed http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_sjzl/sjzl_zcfg/zcfg_jyxzfg/202110/t20211029_575965.html
   Google Scholar
• Tian, G., and W. H. Tsai. 2020. “The Policy Implementation Strategies of County Cadres: Political Instrument and Flexible Local Governance.” China Information 36 (1): 23–45. doi:10.1177/0920203X20968230.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• UNESCO. 2022. “Global Flow of Tertiary-Level Students” Accessed http://data.uis.unesco.org
   Google Scholar
• UNESCO and Council of Europe. 2001. The UNESCO-CEPES/Council of Europe Code of Good Practice for the Provision of Transnational Education. Paris: UNES. Accessed https://rm.coe.int/090000168097c674
   Google Scholar
• University World News. 2011. China: Shanghai Reaches out to America’s Ivy League. Accessed https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20110218224513470
   Google Scholar
• Weber, M. 1976. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology Vol. 1. Berkeley: University of California Press.
   Google Scholar
• Widmaier, W. W., and L. Glanville. 2015. “The Benefits of Norm Ambiguity: Constructing the Responsibility to Protect Across Rwanda, Iraq and Libya.” Contemporary Politics 21 (4): 367–383. doi:10.1080/13569775.2015.1014178.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wilson, J. Q., ed., 1980. The Politics of Regulation. New York: Basic Books.
   Google Scholar
• Wright, A. 2012. “Fantasies of Empowerment: Mapping Neoliberal Discourse in the Coalition Government’s Schools Policy.” Journal of Education Policy 27 (3): 279–294. doi:10.1080/02680939.2011.607516.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Yang, R. 2016. “Internationalization of Higher Education in China: An Overview.” In Spot Light on China: Chinese Education in the Globalized World, edited by S. Guo and Y. Guo, 35–49. Rotterdam: Sense.
   Google Scholar
• Yu, J. 2021. “Consuming UK Transnational Higher Education in China: A Bourdieusian Approach to Chinese Students’ Perceptions and Experiences.” Sociological Research Online 26 (1): 222–239. doi:10.1177/1360780420957040.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zeng, J. 2015. “Did Policy Experimentation in China Always Seek Efficiency? A Case Study of Wenzhou Financial Reform in 2012.” Journal of Contemporary China 24 (92): 338–356. doi:10.1080/10670564.2014.932517.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zheng, J., and D. Kapoor. 2021. “State Formation and Higher Education Policy: An Analytical Review of Policy Shifts and the Internationalization of Higher Education in China Between 1949 and 2019.” Higher Education 81 (2): 179–195. doi:10.1007/s10734-020-00517-2.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar