3,491
Views
109
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
ARTICLES

Effects of Civility and Reasoning in User Comments on Perceived Journalistic Quality

, &

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (40)

Fangcao Lu, Yanqing Sun & Jeffry Oktavianus. (2023) Resistance to Masks During the COVID-19 Pandemic: How User Comments Drive Psychological Reactance to Health Campaigns. Health Communication 38:14, pages 3193-3206.
Read now
Myiah J Hutchens, Ekaterina Romanova & Brittany Shaughnessy. (2023) The Good, the Bad, and the Evil Media: Influence of Online Comments on Media Trust. Journalism Studies 24:11, pages 1440-1457.
Read now
Caroline Murray, Martin J. Riedl & Natalie J. Stroud. (2023) Using Facebook Messenger versus Groups for News Engagement. Digital Journalism 0:0, pages 1-19.
Read now
Anke Stoll, Lena Wilms & Marc Ziegele. (2023) Developing an Incivility Dictionary for German Online Discussions – a Semi-Automated Approach Combining Human and Artificial Knowledge. Communication Methods and Measures 17:2, pages 131-149.
Read now
Inyoung Park, Hyungbo Shim, Jang Hyun Kim, Changjun Lee & Daeho Lee. (2023) The effects of popularity metrics in news comments on the formation of public opinion: Evidence from an internet portal site. The Social Science Journal 60:2, pages 367-382.
Read now
Huai-Kuan Zeng, Tai-Yee Wu & David J. Atkin. (2023) Check the Report and Comments: The Veracity Assessment of Unfamiliar News on Social Media. Digital Journalism 11:1, pages 161-180.
Read now
Inyoung Park, Daeho Lee & Young June Sah. (2022) Under watching eyes in news comment sections: effects of audience cue on self-awareness and commenting behaviour. Behaviour & Information Technology 0:0, pages 1-17.
Read now
Gina M. Masullo, Alexander L. Curry, Kelsey N. Whipple & Caroline Murray. (2022) The Story Behind the Story: Examining Transparency About the Journalistic Process and News Outlet Credibility. Journalism Practice 16:7, pages 1287-1305.
Read now
Gina M. Masullo, Martin J. Riedl & Q. Elyse Huang. (2022) Engagement Moderation: What Journalists Should Say to Improve Online Discussions. Journalism Practice 16:4, pages 738-754.
Read now
Gina M. Masullo, Marc Ziegele, Martin J. Riedl, Pablo Jost & Teresa K. Naab. (2022) Effects of A High-Person-Centered Response to Commenters Who Disagree on Readers’ Positive Attitudes toward A News Outlet’s Facebook Page. Digital Journalism 10:3, pages 493-515.
Read now
Hyunmi Baek, Moonkyoung Jang & Seongcheol Kim. (2022) Who Leaves Malicious Comments on Online News? An Empirical Study in Korea. Journalism Studies 23:4, pages 432-447.
Read now
M. Rosie Jahng, Elizabeth Stoycheff & Annisa Rochadiat. (2021) They Said It’s “Fake“: Effects of Discounting Cues in Online Comments on Information Quality Judgments and Information Authentication. Mass Communication and Society 24:4, pages 527-552.
Read now
Michael Koliska, Neil Thurman, Sally Stares & Jessica Kunert. (2021) Exploring Audience Perceptions of, and Preferences for, Online News Videos. Journalism Studies 22:9, pages 1161-1180.
Read now
Ji Won Kim & Gina Masullo Chen. (2021) Exploring the Influence of Comment Tone and Content in Response to Misinformation in Social Media News. Journalism Practice 15:4, pages 456-470.
Read now
Nayla Fawzi, Nina Steindl, Magdalena Obermaier, Fabian Prochazka, Dorothee Arlt, Bernd Blöbaum, Marco Dohle, Katherine M. Engelke, Thomas Hanitzsch, Nikolaus Jackob, Ilka Jakobs, Tilman Klawier, Senja Post, Carsten Reinemann, Wolfgang Schweiger & Marc Ziegele. (2021) Concepts, causes and consequences of trust in news media – a literature review and framework. Annals of the International Communication Association 45:2, pages 154-174.
Read now
Sujin Choi, Hyopil Shin & Seung-Shik Kang. (2021) Predicting Audience-Rated News Quality: Using Survey, Text Mining, and Neural Network Methods. Digital Journalism 9:1, pages 84-105.
Read now
Justin D. Martin & Fouad Hassan. (2020) News Media Credibility Ratings and Perceptions of Online Fake News Exposure in Five Countries. Journalism Studies 21:16, pages 2215-2233.
Read now
Christina Peter & Thomas Zerback. (2020) Ordinary Citizens in the News: A Conceptual Framework. Journalism Studies 21:8, pages 1003-1016.
Read now
Kathleen Searles, Sophie Spencer & Adaobi Duru. (2020) Don’t read the comments: the effects of abusive comments on perceptions of women authors’ credibility. Information, Communication & Society 23:7, pages 947-962.
Read now
Sai Wang & Ki Joon Kim. (2020) Restrictive and Corrective Responses to Uncivil User Comments on News Websites: The Influence of Presumed Influence. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 64:2, pages 173-192.
Read now
Teresa K. Naab, Dominique Heinbach, Marc Ziegele & Marie-Theres Grasberger. (2020) Comments and Credibility: How Critical User Comments Decrease Perceived News Article Credibility. Journalism Studies 21:6, pages 783-801.
Read now
Logan Molyneux & Mark Coddington. (2020) Aggregation, Clickbait and Their Effect on Perceptions of Journalistic Credibility and Quality. Journalism Practice 14:4, pages 429-446.
Read now
John R. Gallagher, Yinyin Chen, Kyle Wagner, Xuan Wang, Jingyi Zeng & Alyssa Lingyi Kong. (2020) Peering into the Internet Abyss: Using Big Data Audience Analysis to Understand Online Comments. Technical Communication Quarterly 29:2, pages 155-173.
Read now
T. Franklin Waddell. (2020) The Authentic (And Angry) Audience. Digital Journalism 8:2, pages 249-266.
Read now
Senja Post & Hans Mathias Kepplinger. (2019) Coping with Audience Hostility. How Journalists’ Experiences of Audience Hostility Influence Their Editorial Decisions. Journalism Studies 20:16, pages 2422-2442.
Read now
Jaume Suau, Pere Masip & Carlos Ruiz. (2019) Missing the Big Wave: Citizens’ Discourses Against the Participatory Formats Adopted by News Media. Journalism Practice 13:10, pages 1316-1332.
Read now
Xialing Lin, Renee Kaufmann, Patric R. Spence & Kenneth A. Lachlan. (2019) Agency Cues in Online Comments: Exploring Their Relationship with Anonymity and Frequency of Helpful Posts. Southern Communication Journal 84:3, pages 183-195.
Read now
Jana Laura Egelhofer & Sophie Lecheler. (2019) Fake news as a two-dimensional phenomenon: a framework and research agenda. Annals of the International Communication Association 43:2, pages 97-116.
Read now
Victoria A. Dounoucos, D. Sunshine Hillygus & Caroline Carlson. (2019) The message and the medium: an experimental evaluation of the effects of Twitter commentary on campaign messages. Journal of Information Technology & Politics 16:1, pages 66-76.
Read now
Marc Ziegele, Christina Koehler & Mathias Weber. (2018) Socially Destructive? Effects of Negative and Hateful User Comments on Readers’ Donation Behavior toward Refugees and Homeless Persons. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 62:4, pages 636-653.
Read now
Klaus Meier, Daniela Kraus & Edith Michaeler. (2018) Audience Engagement in a Post-Truth Age. Digital Journalism 6:8, pages 1052-1063.
Read now
João Gonçalves. (2018) Aggression in news comments: how context and article topic shape user-generated content. Journal of Applied Communication Research 46:5, pages 604-620.
Read now
Marco Dohle. (2018) Recipients’ Assessment of Journalistic Quality. Digital Journalism 6:5, pages 563-582.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (69)

William D. Schreckhise, John C. Pierce, Francis A. Benjamin, Nicholas P. Lovrich & Eric Button. (2023) Legislative Civility, Gridlock, Polarization, and Productivity. State Politics & Policy Quarterly, pages 1-22.
Crossref
Sherice Gearhart, Ioana A. Coman, Alexander Moe & Sydney E. Brammer. (2023) Public thoughts on incentivizing COVID-19 vaccine uptake in the United States: testing hostile media bias with user-generated comments. Frontiers in Sociology 8.
Crossref
Marcela Campos-Rueda. (2023) Predictores de Interacción Online y Medios Públicos: quiénes comentan y comparten el contenido de TVE en Redes Sociales. Revista de la Asociación Española de Investigación de la Comunicación 10:20, pages raeic102010.
Crossref
Chen Min & Fei Shen. (2023) Online incivility, argument quality and public expression in China: Exploring the moderating role of education level and opinion congruency. Telematics and Informatics 82, pages 102010.
Crossref
Alena Kluknavská, Vlastimil Havlík & Jan Hanzelka. (2023) Unleashing the Beast: Exploring Incivility and Intolerance in Facebook Comments Under Populist and Non-populist Politicians’ Social Media Posts About Migration. Human Affairs 0:0.
Crossref
Mario Haim & Kim Maurus. (2021) Stereotypes and sexism? Effects of gender, topic, and user comments on journalists’ credibility. Journalism 24:7, pages 1442-1461.
Crossref
Dena Yadin, Inbal Yahav, Lior Zalmanson & Nira Munichor. (2023) Resolving the Ethical Tension Between Creating a Civil Environment and Facilitating Free Expression Online: Comment Reordering as an Alternative to Comment Moderation. Journal of Business Ethics.
Crossref
Teresa K Naab, Hanna-Sophie Ruess & Constanze Küchler. (2023) The influence of the deliberative quality of user comments on the number and quality of their reply comments. New Media & Society, pages 146144482311721.
Crossref
Gina M Masullo, Ori Tenenboim & Shuning Lu. (2021) “Toxic atmosphere effect”: Uncivil online comments cue negative audience perceptions of news outlet credibility. Journalism 24:1, pages 101-119.
Crossref
Aleksi H. Syrjämäki, Mirja Ilves, Poika Isokoski, Joel Kiskola, Anna Rantasila, Thomas Olsson, Gary Bente & Veikko Surakka. (2023) Emotionally Toned Online Discussions Evoke Subjectively Experienced Emotional Responses. Journal of Media Psychology 35:1, pages 55-61.
Crossref
Yating Pan & Zhan Shu. (2022) How Can Pro-regime Online Comments Influence Chinese Netizens’ Attitudes and Opinion Expressions? Normative or Informational Social Influence?. International Journal of Public Opinion Research 34:4.
Crossref
Rūta Sutkutė. (2022) Political participation in the context of contemporary media: the case of refugees in Lithuania. EUREKA: Social and Humanities:6, pages 79-91.
Crossref
Andrew Otis. (2022) The effects of transparency cues on news source credibility online: An investigation of ‘opinion labels’. Journalism, pages 146488492211290.
Crossref
Florian Wintterlin, Klara Langmann, Svenja Boberg, Lena Frischlich, Tim Schatto-Eckrodt & Thorsten Quandt. (2021) Lost in the stream? Professional efficacy perceptions of journalists in the context of dark participation. Journalism 23:9, pages 1846-1863.
Crossref
Arthur D. Santana & Toby Hopp. (2022) Seeing red: Reading uncivil news comments guided by personality characteristics. Newspaper Research Journal 43:2, pages 196-216.
Crossref
Yeweon Kim & Amy L. Gonzales. (2022) When we tolerate online incivility: Dual-Process Effects of Argument Strength and Heuristic Cues in Uncivil User Comments. Computers in Human Behavior 131, pages 107235.
Crossref
Ursula Kristin Schmid, Anna Sophie Kümpel & Diana Rieger. (2022) How social media users perceive different forms of online hate speech: A qualitative multi-method study. New Media & Society, pages 146144482210911.
Crossref
Emilie Bossens, David Geerts, Elias Storms, Michiel Nuytemans & Jan Boesman. (2022) RHETORiC: an Audience Conversation Tool that Restores Civility in News Comment Sections. RHETORiC: an Audience Conversation Tool that Restores Civility in News Comment Sections.
Patrícia Rossini. (2020) Beyond Incivility: Understanding Patterns of Uncivil and Intolerant Discourse in Online Political Talk. Communication Research 49:3, pages 399-425.
Crossref
Ine Goovaerts. (2022) Highlighting Incivility: How the News Media’s Focus on Political Incivility Affects Political Trust and News Credibility. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, pages 107769902210846.
Crossref
Ines Engelmann, Hanna Marzinkowski & Klara Langmann. (2022) Salient deliberative norm types in comment sections on news sites. New Media & Society, pages 146144482110681.
Crossref
Philipp Bachmann, Mark Eisenegger & Diana Ingenhoff. (2021) Defining and Measuring News Media Quality: Comparing the Content Perspective and the Audience Perspective. The International Journal of Press/Politics 27:1, pages 9-37.
Crossref
Katharine Heyl & Felix Ekardt. (2022) Barriers and methodology in transitioning to sustainability: Analysing web news comments concerning animal-based diets. Journal of Cleaner Production 330, pages 129857.
Crossref
Lena Frischlich. 2022. Hate Speech. Hate Speech 99 131 .
Annika Sehl, Maximilian Eder & Sonja Kretzschmar. 2022. Journalismus und Instagram. Journalismus und Instagram 45 58 .
Marc Ziegele & Christopher Niederelz. 2022. Handbuch Politische Kommunikation. Handbuch Politische Kommunikation 633 648 .
Renee BarnesRenee Barnes. 2022. Fandom and Polarisation in Online Political Discussion. Fandom and Polarisation in Online Political Discussion 37 59 .
María-Ángeles Chaparro-Domínguez, Marta Pérez-Pereiro & Ruth Rodríguez-Martínez. (2021) Media accountability in the age of social media: Participatory transparency of the audience in Spain. Global Media and Communication 17:3, pages 281-296.
Crossref
Manu Bhandari, Matthew Emery, Sarah Scott & David Wolfgang. (2021) Effects of online commenter sex cues and news receiver sex on commenter credibility. Newspaper Research Journal 42:4, pages 526-542.
Crossref
Laura D Allen, Idalina Z Odziemczyk, Jolanta Perek-Białas & Liat Ayalon. (2021) “We Should Be at the Back of the Line”: A Frame Analysis of Old Age Within the Distribution Order of the COVID-19 Vaccine. The Gerontologist 61:8, pages 1317-1325.
Crossref
Gina M Masullo, Shuning Lu & Deepa Fadnis. (2020) Does online incivility cancel out the spiral of silence? A moderated mediation model of willingness to speak out . New Media & Society 23:11, pages 3391-3414.
Crossref
Anna Kochigina, Katerina Tsetsura & Maureen Taylor. (2021) Together in crisis: A comparison of organizational and faith-holders’ crisis communication. Public Relations Review 47:4, pages 102086.
Crossref
Jana Laura Egelhofer, Loes Aaldering & Sophie Lecheler. (2021) Delegitimizing the media?. Journal of Language and Politics 20:5, pages 653-675.
Crossref
Manuel Goyanes, Juan Pablo Artero & Lara Zapata. (2018) The effects of news authorship, exclusiveness and media type in readers’ paying intent for online news: An experimental study. Journalism 22:7, pages 1720-1738.
Crossref
Marlene Kunst. (2021) Assessments of User Comments With “Alternative Views” as a Function of Media Trust. Journal of Media Psychology 33:3, pages 113-124.
Crossref
Myojung Chung, Young Nam Seo, Younbo Jung & Doohwang Lee. (2021) Agenda-setting in social TV: How and when user comments influence perceived issue importance. New Media & Society, pages 146144482110207.
Crossref
Claudia Wilhelm, Helena Stehle & Hanne Detel. (2020) Digital visibility and the role of mutual interaction expectations: Reframing the journalist–audience relationship through the lens of interpersonal communication. New Media & Society 23:5, pages 1004-1021.
Crossref
Daniel Cardoso, Ana Rosa & Marisa Torres da Silva. (2021) (De)Politicizing Polyamory: Social Media Comments on Media Representations of Consensual Non-Monogamies. Archives of Sexual Behavior 50:4, pages 1325-1340.
Crossref
Spencer Williams & Gary Hsieh. (2021) The Effects of User Comments on Science News Engagement. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 5:CSCW1, pages 1-29.
Crossref
Ayodeji O. Awobamise & Yosra Jarrar. (2021) The use of user-generated comments and their effects on the perception of news: An experimental study. Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies 13:1, pages 83-100.
Crossref
Jiawei Liu & Douglas M. McLeod. (2019) Pathways to news commenting and the removal of the comment system on news websites. Journalism 22:4, pages 867-881.
Crossref
Gerret Von Nordheim & Katharina Kleinen-von Königslöw. (2021) Uninvited Dinner Guests: A Theoretical Perspective on the Antagonists of Journalism Based on Serres’ Parasite. Media and Communication 9:1, pages 88-98.
Crossref
Christiane Eilders & Christopher Niederelz. 2021. Politische Partizipation. Politische Partizipation 373 392 .
Ulrike Schwertberger & Diana Rieger. 2021. Hate Speech - Multidisziplinäre Analysen und Handlungsoptionen. Hate Speech - Multidisziplinäre Analysen und Handlungsoptionen 53 77 .
Yan Xia, Haiyi Zhu, Tun Lu, Peng Zhang & Ning Gu. (2020) Exploring Antecedents and Consequences of Toxicity in Online Discussions. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 4:CSCW2, pages 1-23.
Crossref
Ki Deuk Hyun, Nakwon Jung & Mihye Seo. (2020) Examining the Effects of Perceived Partisan Slants of News and User Comments from Portal News Sites on Portal News Trust, Third Person Perception and Selective Exposure : Comparisons of Conservative and Progressive Users. Korean Journal of Journalism & Communication Studies 64:4, pages 247-288.
Crossref
Marc Ziegele, Oliver Quiring, Katharina Esau & Dennis Friess. (2018) Linking News Value Theory With Online Deliberation: How News Factors and Illustration Factors in News Articles Affect the Deliberative Quality of User Discussions in SNS’ Comment Sections. Communication Research 47:6, pages 860-890.
Crossref
Marc Ziegele & Pablo B. Jost. (2016) Not Funny? The Effects of Factual Versus Sarcastic Journalistic Responses to Uncivil User Comments. Communication Research 47:6, pages 891-920.
Crossref
Pablo Jost, Marc Ziegele & Teresa K. Naab. (2020) Klicken oder tippen? Eine Analyse verschiedener Interventionsstrategien in unzivilen Online-Diskussionen auf FacebookClick or type? An analysis of different intervention strategies in uncivil online discussions on Facebook. Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft 30:2, pages 193-217.
Crossref
Orge Castellano Parra, Koldobika Meso Ayerdi & Simón Peña Fernández. (2020) Behind the Comments Section: The Ethics of Digital Native News Discussions. Media and Communication 8:2, pages 86-97.
Crossref
Anna S. Kümpel & Julian Unkel. (2020) Negativity Wins at Last. Journal of Media Psychology 32:2, pages 89-99.
Crossref
Yu-Leung Ng, Yunya Song, K. Hazel Kwon & Yu Huang. (2020) Toward an integrative model for online incivility research: A review and synthesis of empirical studies on the antecedents and consequences of uncivil discussions online. Telematics and Informatics 47, pages 101323.
Crossref
Sherice Gearhart, Alexander Moe & Bingbing Zhang. (2020) Hostile media bias on social media: Testing the effect of user comments on perceptions of news bias and credibility. Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies 2:2, pages 140-148.
Crossref
Diana Rieger, Josephine B. Schmitt, Julian Ernst, Peter Vorderer, Gary Bente & Hans-Joachim Roth. 2020. Propaganda und Prävention. Propaganda und Prävention 3 27 .
Marc Ziegele & Christopher Niederelz. 2020. Handbuch Politische Kommunikation. Handbuch Politische Kommunikation 1 17 .
Tobias Eberwein. (2019) “Trolls” or “warriors of faith”?. Journal of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society 18:4, pages 575-587.
Crossref
Arthur D. Santana. (2019) Toward quality discourse: Measuring the effect of user identity in commenting forums. Newspaper Research Journal 40:4, pages 467-486.
Crossref
Brendan R Watson, Zhao Peng & Seth C Lewis. (2019) Who will intervene to save news comments? Deviance and social control in communities of news commenters. New Media & Society 21:8, pages 1840-1858.
Crossref
Gina Masullo Chen, Ashley Muddiman, Tamar Wilner, Eli Pariser & Natalie Jomini Stroud. (2019) We Should Not Get Rid of Incivility Online. Social Media + Society 5:3, pages 205630511986264.
Crossref
Folker Hanusch & Edson C TandocJrJr. (2017) Comments, analytics, and social media: The impact of audience feedback on journalists’ market orientation. Journalism 20:6, pages 695-713.
Crossref
Marc Ziegele. 2019. The International Encyclopedia of Journalism Studies. The International Encyclopedia of Journalism Studies 1 8 .
T. J. Thomson. (2019) In Front of the Lens: The Expectations, Experiences, and Reactions of Visual Journalism’s Subjects. Journalism & Communication Monographs 21:1, pages 4-65.
Crossref
Michael Sülflow, Svenja Schäfer & Stephan Winter. (2018) Selective attention in the news feed: An eye-tracking study on the perception and selection of political news posts on Facebook. New Media & Society 21:1, pages 168-190.
Crossref
Patrick Weber, Fabian Prochazka & Wolfgang Schweiger. (2019) Why User Comments Affect the Perceived Quality of Journalistic Content. Journal of Media Psychology 31:1, pages 24-34.
Crossref
Dominique Heinbach, Marc Ziegele & Oliver Quiring. (2018) Sleeper effect from below: Long-term effects of source credibility and user comments on the persuasiveness of news articles. New Media & Society 20:12, pages 4765-4786.
Crossref
Karen Verswijvel, Wannes Heirman, Kris Hardies & Michel Walrave. (2018) Designing and validating the friendship quality on social network sites questionnaire. Computers in Human Behavior 86, pages 289-298.
Crossref
Jisu Kim, Seth C. Lewis & Brendan R. Watson. (2018) The Imagined Audience for and Perceived Quality of News Comments: Exploring the Perceptions of Commenters on News Sites and on Facebook. Social Media + Society 4:1, pages 205630511876574.
Crossref
Nina Springer & Anna Sophie Kümpel. 2018. Journalismus im Internet. Journalismus im Internet 241 271 .
Antonis Kalogeropoulos, Samuel Negredo, Ike Picone & Rasmus Kleis Nielsen. (2017) Who Shares and Comments on News?: A Cross-National Comparative Analysis of Online and Social Media Participation. Social Media + Society 3:4, pages 205630511773575.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.