4,466
Views
100
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
PAPERS

Planners' Role: Torn between Dialogical Ideals and Neo-liberal Realities

Pages 65-84 | Received 01 May 2006, Accepted 01 Apr 2007, Published online: 15 Dec 2008

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (55)

Pia Bäcklund, Vesa Kanninen & Tomas Hanell. (2023) Accepting Depoliticisation? Council Members’ Attitudes Towards Public-Public Contracts in Spatial Planning. Planning Theory & Practice 24:2, pages 173-189.
Read now
Florencia Franzini, Sami Berghäll, Anne Toppinen & Ritva Toivonen. (2023) Planning for wooden multistorey construction – insights from Finland's municipal civil servants. European Planning Studies 31:1, pages 168-188.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Martin Westin & Hanna Mattila. (2023) Public Planner – A Deliberative Authority. Planning Theory & Practice 24:1, pages 11-29.
Read now
Camilo Calderon, Amelia Mutter, Martin Westin & Andrew Butler. (2022) Navigating swift and slow planning: planners’ balancing act in the design of participatory processes. European Planning Studies 0:0, pages 1-20.
Read now
Jill L. Grant. (2022) “A Difficult Balancing Act”: What Planning Involves. Planning Theory & Practice 23:5, pages 724-740.
Read now
Erik Eriksson, Amira Fredriksson & Josefina Syssner. (2022) Opening the black box of participatory planning: a study of how planners handle citizens’ input. European Planning Studies 30:6, pages 994-1012.
Read now
John Jackson. (2020) What do mid-career Melbourne planners profess?. International Planning Studies 25:4, pages 393-408.
Read now
Keyang Li, Perrine Dethier, Anders Eika, D. Ary A. Samsura, Erwin van der Krabben, Berit Nordahl & Jean-Marie Halleux. (2020) Measuring and comparing planning cultures: risk, trust and co-operative attitudes in experimental games. European Planning Studies 28:6, pages 1118-1138.
Read now
Miloš N. Mladenović & Susa Eräranta. (2020) Hear the Rime of the Fellow Mariner? A Letter to the Next Generation of Emphatic Co-Creators in Planning. Planning Theory & Practice 21:1, pages 164-174.
Read now
Mickey Lauria & Mellone F. Long. (2019) Ethical Dilemmas in Professional Planning Practice in the United States. Journal of the American Planning Association 85:4, pages 393-404.
Read now
María José Piñeira Mantiñán, Rubén C. Lois González & Jesús M. González Pérez. (2019) New models of urban governance in Spain during the post-crisis period: the fight against vulnerability on a local scale. Territory, Politics, Governance 7:3, pages 336-364.
Read now
Andrew Martel, Carolyn Whitzman & Alexander Sheko. (2019) Private Developers and the Public Good: Can a Socially Constructed Market Deliver Quality Affordable Housing for Australian Cities?. Urban Policy and Research 37:2, pages 170-184.
Read now
Hanna Mattila. (2018) Public participation and legitimacy management in planning. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 100:4, pages 309-328.
Read now
Łukasz Damurski & Marcin Oleksy. (2018) Communicative and participatory paradigm in the European territorial policies. A discourse analysis. European Planning Studies 26:7, pages 1471-1492.
Read now
Pia Bäcklund, Liisa Häikiö, Helena Leino & Vesa Kanninen. (2018) Bypassing Publicity for Getting Things Done: Between Informal and Formal Planning Practices in Finland. Planning Practice & Research 33:3, pages 309-325.
Read now
Christophe Demazière. (2018) Strategic Spatial Planning in a Situation of Fragmented Local Government: The Case of France. disP - The Planning Review 54:2, pages 58-76.
Read now
Kristian Olesen. (2018) Teaching planning theory as planner roles in urban planning education. Higher Education Pedagogies 3:1, pages 302-318.
Read now
Gavin Parker, Tessa Lynn & Matthew Wargent. (2017) Contestation and conservatism in neighbourhood planning in England: reconciling agonism and collaboration?. Planning Theory & Practice 18:3, pages 446-465.
Read now
Eero Valtonen, Heidi Falkenbach & Kauko Viitanen. (2017) Development-led planning practices in a plan-led planning system: empirical evidence from Finland. European Planning Studies 25:6, pages 1053-1075.
Read now
Enza Lissandrello, Robert Hrelja, Aud Tennøy & Tim Richardson. (2017) Three performativities of innovation in public transport planning. International Planning Studies 22:2, pages 99-113.
Read now
Bonnie J. Johnson, Mary Kay Peck & Steven A. Preston. (2017) City Managers Have Ethics Too? Comparing Planning and City Management Codes of Ethics. Journal of the American Planning Association 83:2, pages 183-201.
Read now
Sari Puustinen, Raine Mäntysalo, Jonne Hytönen & Karoliina Jarenko. (2017) The “deliberative bureaucrat”: deliberative democracy and institutional trust in the jurisdiction of the Finnish planner. Planning Theory & Practice 18:1, pages 71-88.
Read now
Sofia Cele. (2015) Childhood in a neoliberal utopia: planning rhetoric and parental conceptions in contemporary stockholm. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 97:3, pages 233-247.
Read now
Kirralie Houghton, Marcus Foth & Evonne Miller. (2015) Urban Acupuncture: Hybrid Social and Technological Practices for Hyperlocal Placemaking. Journal of Urban Technology 22:3, pages 3-19.
Read now
Michael Tanko & Matthew Burke. (2015) Why busways? Styles of planning and mode-choice decision-making in Brisbane's transport networks. Australian Planner 52:3, pages 229-240.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Karoliina Jarenko, Kristina L. Nilsson & Inger-Lise Saglie. (2015) Legitimacy of Informal Strategic Urban Planning—Observations from Finland, Sweden and Norway. European Planning Studies 23:2, pages 349-366.
Read now
Amir Hefetz, Mildred Warner & Eran Vigoda-Gadot. (2014) Professional Management and Local Government Service Delivery: Strategic Decisions Across Alternative Markets. Public Performance & Management Review 38:2, pages 261-283.
Read now
Pia Bäcklund, Kirsi Pauliina Kallio & Jouni Häkli. (2014) Residents, customers or citizens? Tracing the idea of youthful participation in the context of administrative reforms in Finnish public administration. Planning Theory & Practice 15:3, pages 311-327.
Read now
Gro Sandkjaer Hanssen & Eva Irene Falleth. (2014) Market-Oriented Urban Planning – Constraining Citizen Participation. Local Government Studies 40:3, pages 403-428.
Read now
Katie MCClymont. (2014) Stuck in the Process, Facilitating Nothing? Justice, Capabilities and Planning for Value-Led Outcomes. Planning Practice & Research 29:2, pages 187-201.
Read now
Sander Lenferink, Wim Leendertse, Jos Arts & Taede Tillema. (2014) Public–Private Plan Development: Can Early Private Involvement Strengthen Infrastructure Planning?. European Planning Studies 22:2, pages 323-344.
Read now
John T. Jackson. (2014) Planning for Social Inclusion? What Planners from Glasgow, Melbourne and Toronto Say. International Planning Studies 19:1, pages 45-76.
Read now
Bas Waterhout, Frank Othengrafen & Olivier Sykes. (2013) Neo-liberalization Processes and Spatial Planning in France, Germany, and the Netherlands: An Exploration. Planning Practice & Research 28:1, pages 141-159.
Read now
Robert Bügl, Michael Stauffacher, Ulrich Kriese, Daniel Lehmann Pollheimer & Roland W. Scholz. (2012) Identifying Stakeholders' Views on Sustainable Urban Transition: Desirability, Utility and Probability Assessments of Scenarios. European Planning Studies 20:10, pages 1667-1687.
Read now
MildredE. Warner & Amir Hefetz. (2012) Insourcing and Outsourcing. Journal of the American Planning Association 78:3, pages 313-327.
Read now
Patsy Healey. (2012) Re-enchanting democracy as a mode of governance. Critical Policy Studies 6:1, pages 19-39.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Inger-Lise Saglie & Göran Cars. (2011) Between Input Legitimacy and Output Efficiency: Defensive Routines and Agonistic Reflectivity in Nordic Land-Use Planning. European Planning Studies 19:12, pages 2109-2126.
Read now
Jonna Kangasoja, Mikko Mälkki, Sari Puustinen, Jukka Hirvonen & Raine Mäntysalo. (2010) Architectural Education as a Basis for Planning Work — The Pros and Cons of Professional Enculturation. Journal for Education in the Built Environment 5:2, pages 25-38.
Read now
John Jackson. (2009) Neo-liberal or Third Way? What Planners from Glasgow, Melbourne and Toronto Say. Urban Policy and Research 27:4, pages 397-417.
Read now
Bianka Plüschke-Altof, Bradley Loewen, Anni Müüripeal & Helen Sooväli-Sepping. Balancing participatory planning and planning for resilience in nature-based solutions. A case of transformative agency?. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 0:0, pages 1-19.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (45)

Janice Barry & Crystal Legacy. (2022) Between virtue and profession: Theorising the rise of professionalised public participation practitioners. Planning Theory 22:1, pages 85-105.
Crossref
. (2023) Land-Use Planning in Municipalities as a Driver for Sustainable Residential Building in Finland: A Regional Innovation System Approach. Journal of Sustainability Research.
Crossref
Małgorzata Barbara Havel. (2022) Neoliberalization of urban policy-making and planning in post-socialist Poland – A distinctive path from the perspective of varieties of capitalism. Cities 127, pages 103766.
Crossref
Laura Nkula-Wenz, Gilbert Siame & Dieter Zinnbauer. 2022. Localizing the SDGs in African Cities. Localizing the SDGs in African Cities 153 168 .
Patrick Collins. (2021) People-Powered Planning: Planning from the bottom up in a top-down system. European Spatial Research and Policy 28:2, pages 227-250.
Crossref
Germaine R. Halegoua & Bonnie J. Johnson. (2020) Seeing Like a Neighbor: Rethinking Neighborhoods as Service-oriented Communities. Urban Affairs Review 57:6, pages 1730-1758.
Crossref
Tomer Dekel. (2021) Critique and Progress: Production of Knowledge and the Planning of Bedouin Settlements in Israel. Journal of Planning Education and Research, pages 0739456X2098684.
Crossref
Ståle Holgersen. (2020) On Spatial Planning and Marxism: Looking Back, Going Forward. Antipode 52:3, pages 800-824.
Crossref
Ayobami Abayomi Popoola & Hangwelani Hope Magidimisha. (2020) The Dilemmas of Rural Planning and Planners in Oyo State, Nigeria. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series 47:47, pages 75-93.
Crossref
Geoffrey A. Battista & Kevin Manaugh. (2017) My way or the highway? Framing transportation planners’ attitudes in negotiating professional expertise and public insight. Transportation 46:4, pages 1271-1290.
Crossref
Alexander Woestenburg, Erwin van der Krabben & Tejo Spit. (2019) Legitimacy Dilemmas in Direct Government Intervention: The Case of Public Land Development, an Example from the Netherlands. Land 8:7, pages 110.
Crossref
Christian Lamker. (2019) Leadership roles in local land-use planning for noise control. Town Planning Review 90:3, pages 275-297.
Crossref
Christian Lamker & Meike Levin-Keitel. (2019) Planning and transition – on role interpretations and self-conceptions. Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning 77:2, pages 107-113.
Crossref
Markus Leibenath. (2019) Berufliche Identitäten von Regionalplanern im Kontext der Windenergienutzung: eine poststrukturalistische Perspektive. Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning 77:2, pages 165-180.
Crossref
Łukasz DamurskiCDFMRCDFMR, Jacek PlutaCDMRCDMR, Karel MaierDMRDMR & Hans Thor AndersenDMRDMR. (2019) Stakeholders in the local service centre: who should be involved in the planning process? Insights from Poland, Czech Republic and Denmark. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series 43:43, pages 91-106.
Crossref
Esin Özdemir & Tuna Tasan-Kok. (2017) Planners’ role in accommodating citizen disagreement: The case of Dutch urban planning. Urban Studies 56:4, pages 741-759.
Crossref
Markus Leibenath. 2019. Handbuch Landschaft. Handbuch Landschaft 407 417 .
Alexander K. Woestenburg, Erwin van der Krabben & Tejo J.M. Spit. (2018) Land policy discretion in times of economic downturn: How local authorities adapt to a new reality. Land Use Policy 77, pages 801-810.
Crossref
Bonnie J. Johnson. (2018) Planners as leaders: finding their comfort zone. International Journal of Public Leadership 14:3, pages 155-178.
Crossref
Eduardo Oliveira & Anna M. Hersperger. (2018) Governance arrangements, funding mechanisms and power configurations in current practices of strategic spatial plan implementation. Land Use Policy 76, pages 623-633.
Crossref
Jill L Grant, Amanda Taylor & Christina Wheeler. (2017) Planners' perceptions of the influence of leadership on coordinating plans. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 36:4, pages 669-688.
Crossref
Marcus Foth. (2018) Participatory urban informatics: towards citizen- ability . Smart and Sustainable Built Environment 7:1, pages 4-19.
Crossref
Jonne Hytönen. (2014) The problematic relationship of communicative planning theory and the Finnish legal culture. Planning Theory 15:3, pages 223-238.
Crossref
David A. King & Lauren Ames Fischer. (2016) Streetcar projects as spatial planning: A shift in transport planning in the United States. Journal of Transport Geography 54, pages 383-390.
Crossref
Luuk Boelens & Gert de Roo. (2014) Planning of undefined becoming: First encounters of planners beyond the plan. Planning Theory 15:1, pages 42-67.
Crossref
Linda Fox-Rogers & Enda Murphy. (2015) Self-perceptions of the role of the planner. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 43:1, pages 74-92.
Crossref
Gavin Parker & Emma Street. (2015) Planning at the neighbourhood scale: localism, dialogic politics, and the modulation of community action. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 33:4, pages 794-810.
Crossref
Parama Roy. (2015) Collaborative planning – A neoliberal strategy? A study of the Atlanta BeltLine. Cities 43, pages 59-68.
Crossref
Maria Kylin & Stina Bodelius. (2015) A Lawful Space for Play: Conceptualizing Childhood in Light of Local Regulations. Children, Youth and Environments 25:2, pages 86.
Crossref
Michael Gunder. 2015. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences 255 260 .
Maija Faehnle, Pia Bäcklund, Liisa Tyrväinen, Jari Niemelä & Vesa Yli-Pelkonen. (2014) How can residents’ experiences inform planning of urban green infrastructure? Case Finland. Landscape and Urban Planning 130, pages 171-183.
Crossref
Kristian Olesen. (2013) The neoliberalisation of strategic spatial planning. Planning Theory 13:3, pages 288-303.
Crossref
Valeria Fedeli. 2013. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone 37 55 .
Raine Mäntysalo, Alessandro Balducci & Jonna K. Kangasoja. 2013. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone 7 21 .
Ludger Gailing. 2013. Neue Energielandschaften – Neue Perspektiven der Landschaftsforschung. Neue Energielandschaften – Neue Perspektiven der Landschaftsforschung 207 215 .
Gro Sandkjær Hanssen. (2011) Negotiating Urban Space: The Challenge of Political Steering in Market‐ and Network‐oriented Urban Planning. Scandinavian Political Studies 35:1, pages 22-47.
Crossref
Tore Sager. (2012) Comment Adapting planners' professionalism for inclusive processes in neo-liberal environments. Town Planning Review 83:5, pages 619-624.
Crossref
Susannah Gunn & Geoff Vigar. (2012) Reform processes and discretionary acting space in English planning practice, 1997-2010. Town Planning Review 83:5, pages 533-552.
Crossref
Patsy Healey. 2012. The Argumentative Turn Revisited. The Argumentative Turn Revisited 58 82 .
Tore Sager. (2011) Neo-liberal urban planning policies: A literature survey 1990–2010. Progress in Planning.
Crossref
Raine Mäntysalo, Alessandro Balducci & Jonna Kangasoja. (2011) Planning as agonistic communication in a trading zone: Re-examining Lindblom’s partisan mutual adjustment. Planning Theory 10:3, pages 257-272.
Crossref
C. J. Lawless. (2011) Policing Markets: The Contested Shaping of Neo-Liberal Forensic Science. British Journal of Criminology 51:4, pages 671-689.
Crossref
Peter Ache. (2011) ‘Creating futures that would otherwise not be’ – Reflections on the Greater Helsinki Vision process and the making of metropolitan regions. Progress in Planning 75:4, pages 155-192.
Crossref
Marie Stenseke & Michael Jones. 2011. The European Landscape Convention. The European Landscape Convention 295 309 .
Gro S Hanssen. (2010) Ensuring Local Community Interests in Market-Oriented Urban Planning? The Role of Local Politicians. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 28:4, pages 714-732.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.