Advanced search
Publication Cover
Local Government Studies Volume 42, 2016 - Issue 3
Submit an article Journal homepage
6,374
Views
119
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Local governance under the Conservatives: super-austerity, devolution and the ‘smarter state’

Vivien LowndesUniversity of Birmingham, Birmingham, UKCorrespondence[email protected]
View further author information
&
Alison GardnerUniversity of Nottingham, Nottingham, UKView further author information
Pages 357-375 | Received 26 Oct 2015, Accepted 04 Jan 2016, Published online: 29 Feb 2016

Citations (119)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (51)

Mildred E. Warner & Paige M. Kelly. (2024) Proceed with caution: US local governments and the American Rescue Plan. Local Government Studies 50:3, pages 573-595.
Read now
Steve Rolfe & Isobel Anderson. (2024) Meeting the housing needs of military veterans: exploring collaboration and governance. Housing Studies 39:2, pages 438-458.
Read now
Kevin Muldoon-Smith & Mark Sandford. (2023) Grasping the nettle: the central–local constraints on local government funding in England. Territory, Politics, Governance 11:8, pages 1709-1726.
Read now
Stephen Kwamena Aikins. (2023) Effects of intergovernmental revenue on local government draw on fiscal reserves: evidence from COVID-19 fiscal stress. Local Government Studies 49:6, pages 1198-1217.
Read now
Ben Clifford & Janice Morphet. (2023) Local authorities doing it for themselves: austerity, the direct provision of housing and changing central-local relations in England. Local Government Studies 49:6, pages 1218-1240.
Read now
Jacqui Moore, Ian C. Elliott & Hannah Hesselgreaves. (2023) Collaborative Leadership in Integrated Care Systems; Creating Leadership for the Common Good. Journal of Change Management 23:4, pages 358-373.
Read now
Connor Sheffield & Dave Valler. (2023) ‘Dealing’ with Governance and Planning? The Limits of Urban Intrapreneurialism. Planning Theory & Practice 24:4, pages 453-472.
Read now
Kate Mori, Haydn Morgan, Andrew Parker & Christopher Mackintosh. (2023) Examining the Impact of Austerity on Community Sport Development Workers and Their Professional Environment. Journal of Global Sport Management 8:3, pages 557-572.
Read now
Joe Herbert & Gareth Powells. (2023) Contested geographies of localization(s): towards open-locales. Globalizations 20:4, pages 548-563.
Read now
Cristian Gherhes, Charlotte Hoole & Tim Vorley. (2023) The ‘imaginary’ challenge of remaking subnational governance: regional identity and contested city-region-building in the UK. Regional Studies 57:1, pages 153-167.
Read now
Annette Hastings & Maria Gannon. (2022) Absorbing the shock of austerity: the experience of local government workers at the front line. Local Government Studies 48:5, pages 887-906.
Read now
Yi Yang. (2022) Explaining the reorganization of political space in local governance reform: would critical realism help?. Journal of Critical Realism 21:4, pages 416-433.
Read now
Temidayo Eseonu. (2022) Co-creation as social innovation: including ‘hard-to-reach’ groups in public service delivery. Public Money & Management 42:5, pages 306-313.
Read now
Claire Copeland, Gordon MacKerron & Timothy J. Foxon. (2022) Regional energy futures as decision support in the transition to net zero emissions: North of Tyne case study. Local Environment 27:6, pages 747-766.
Read now
Stephen Gibb, Mohammed Ishaq, Ian Elliott & Asifa Maaria Hussain. (2021) Fair and decent work in Scotland’s local authorities: evidence and challenges. Public Money & Management 41:8, pages 615-625.
Read now
Ian Mell. (2021) ‘But who’s going to pay for it?’ Contemporary approaches to green infrastructure financing, development and governance in London, UK. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 23:5, pages 628-645.
Read now
Robert Richardson & James T. White. (2021) Design Governance, Austerity and the Public Interest: Planning and the Delivery of ‘Well-Designed Places’ in West Dunbartonshire, Scotland. Planning Theory & Practice 22:4, pages 572-594.
Read now
Amelia Hadfield & Christian Turner. (2021) Risky business? Analysing the challenges and opportunities of Brexit on English local government. Local Government Studies 47:4, pages 657-678.
Read now
Nick Vlahos. (2021) Bringing democracy down to scale: subnational democratic struggle in Britain. Studies in Political Economy 102:2, pages 140-160.
Read now
Pekka Valkama & Lasse Oulasvirta. (2021) How Finland copes with an ageing population: adjusting structures and equalising the financial capabilities of local governments. Local Government Studies 47:3, pages 429-452.
Read now
Andy Jolly & Jacob Lind. (2021) Firewalls as a resource for resistance: separating border policing from social service provision in Sweden and the UK. Nordic Social Work Research 11:2, pages 183-196.
Read now
Julian Dobson & Nicola Dempsey. (2021) Known but not done: how logics of inaction limit the benefits of urban green spaces. Landscape Research 46:3, pages 390-402.
Read now
Kate Harrison. (2021) Can’t, Won’t and What’s the Point? A Theory of the UK Public’s Muted Response to Austerity. Representation 57:2, pages 159-174.
Read now
David Simon, Angeles Arano, Mariana Cammisa, Beth Perry, Sara  Pettersson, Jan Riise, Sandra Valencia, Michael Oloko, Tarun Sharma, Yutika Vora & Warren Smit. (2021) Cities coping with COVID-19. City 25:1-2, pages 129-170.
Read now
Yunji Kim & Mildred E. Warner. (2021) Pragmatic municipalism or austerity urbanism? Understanding local government responses to fiscal stress. Local Government Studies 47:2, pages 234-252.
Read now
Kate Broadhurst, Jennifer Ferreira & Nigel Berkeley. (2021) Place leadership: developing a model to guide regional partnerships. Regional Studies 55:3, pages 556-567.
Read now
Joanna McIntyre & Christine Hall. (2020) Barriers to the inclusion of refugee and asylum-seeking children in schools in England. Educational Review 72:5, pages 583-600.
Read now
Cristian Gherhes, Chay Brooks & Tim Vorley. (2020) Localism is an illusion (of power): the multi-scalar challenge of UK enterprise policy-making. Regional Studies 54:8, pages 1020-1031.
Read now
Neil Barnett, Steven Griggs & Helen Sullivan. (2020) Guest editors’ introduction: the power of now. Reimagining the future of local government through studies of ‘actually existing’ practice. Local Government Studies 46:4, pages 505-523.
Read now
Allan Cochrane. (2020) In and beyond local government: making up new spaces of governance. Local Government Studies 46:4, pages 524-541.
Read now
Robin Hambleton. (2020) Debate: Researching directly elected mayors—key questions to address. Public Money & Management 40:1, pages 3-4.
Read now
Marieke Van Genugten, Sandra Van Thiel & Bart Voorn. (2020) Local governments and their arm’s length bodies. Local Government Studies 46:1, pages 1-21.
Read now
Daniel Parnell, Anthony May, Paul Widdop, Ed Cope & Richard Bailey. (2019) Management strategies of non-profit community sport facilities in an era of austerity. European Sport Management Quarterly 19:3, pages 312-330.
Read now
Robin Hambleton. (2019) The New Civic Leadership: Place and the co-creation of public innovation. Public Money & Management 39:4, pages 271-279.
Read now
Laurence Ferry, Thomas Ahrens & Rihab Khalifa. (2019) Public value, institutional logics and practice variation during austerity localism at Newcastle City Council. Public Management Review 21:1, pages 96-115.
Read now
Amanda Fitzgerald. (2018) Querying the resilient local authority: the question of ‘resilience for whom?’. Local Government Studies 44:6, pages 788-806.
Read now
John Fenwick & Howard Elcock. (2018) Devolution and federalism in England. Public Money & Management 38:3, pages 175-184.
Read now
Gavin Reid. (2018) Managing budget cuts in Edinburgh’s sport and recreation services: progressive localism in a resilient local authority?. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics 10:1, pages 113-129.
Read now
Mark Panton & Geoff Walters. (2018) ‘It’s just a Trojan horse for gentrification’: austerity and stadium-led regeneration. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics 10:1, pages 163-183.
Read now
Christopher Brown & Athanasios (Sakis) Pappous. (2018) The organisational performance of national disability sport organisations during a time of austerity: a resource dependence theory perspective. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics 10:1, pages 63-78.
Read now
Catherine M Walker & John W. Hayton. (2018) An analysis of third sector sport organisations in an era of ‘super-austerity’. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics 10:1, pages 43-61.
Read now
Peter Eckersley. (2018) Who shapes local climate policy? Unpicking governance arrangements in English and German cities. Environmental Politics 27:1, pages 139-160.
Read now
Yunji Kim. (2018) Can alternative service delivery save cities after the Great Recession? Barriers to privatisation and cooperation. Local Government Studies 44:1, pages 44-63.
Read now
Jonathan Morris, John Harrison, Andrea Genovese, Liam Goucher & S. C. L. Koh. (2017) Energy policy under austerity localism: what role for local authorities?. Local Government Studies 43:6, pages 882-902.
Read now
Joe Penny. (2017) Between coercion and consent: the politics of “Cooperative Governance” at a time of “Austerity Localism” in London. Urban Geography 38:9, pages 1352-1373.
Read now
Germà Bel, Marc Esteve, Peter Matthews & Tamara Metze. (2017) Editorial statement. Local Government Studies 43:2, pages 139-141.
Read now
Alison Gardner. (2017) Big change, little change? Punctuation, increments and multi-layer institutional change for English local authorities under austerity. Local Government Studies 43:2, pages 150-169.
Read now
Laurence Ferry & Peter Eckersley. (2017) Debate: Freedom, power and capacity—analysing the fallout from the UK’s ‘Brexit’ referendum. Public Money & Management 37:1, pages 2-3.
Read now
Daniel Parnell, Karl Spracklen & Peter Millward. (2017) Sport management issues in an era of austerity. European Sport Management Quarterly 17:1, pages 67-74.
Read now
Allan Cochrane. (2016) Thinking about the ‘Local’ of Local Government: a Brief History of Invention and Reinvention. Local Government Studies 42:6, pages 907-915.
Read now
Antoine Grandclement, Ludovic Halbert, Félix Adisson, Vincent Lasserre-Bigorry & Françoise Navarre. The geographies of local austerity policies: a quantitative analysis of local budgets in France. Regional Studies 0:0, pages 1-15.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (68)

José M. Alonso & Rhys Andrews. (2023) Can City Deals Improve Economic Performance? Evidence from England. Urban Affairs Review 60:3, pages 835-863.
Crossref
Brian Dollery, Subba Reddy Yarram & Carolyn-Thi Thanh Dung Tran. (2024) The Impact of Population Growth on Local Community Satisfaction in the Victorian Local Government System. Public Administration Quarterly.
Crossref
Manon Laugaa, Gilles Pinson & Andy Smith. (2024) Les strates de la smart city. Réseaux N° 243:1, pages 103-142.
Crossref
Alistair Sheldrick. (2024) Where Asylum and Austerity Meet: Deservingness and In/Exclusion in Rochdale. Antipode.
Crossref
Asa Thomas. 2024. Cycling Through the Pandemic. Cycling Through the Pandemic 19 43 .
Claire Copeland. (2023) Participatory energy futures as decision support on subnational scales. Environmental Policy and Governance.
Crossref
David VallerPhil AllmendingerJen Nelles. (2023) The sinking of the Oxford-Cambridge Arc: strategic planning in England at a nadir?. Town Planning Review 94:6, pages 611-633.
Crossref
Thomas Ahrens, Laurence Ferry & Rihab Khalifa. (2023) The critical potential of institutional theory revisited — a field study of the rationalisation of budget fairness through agentic actorhood. Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management 20:5, pages 593-620.
Crossref
Manon Laugaa, Gilles Pinson & Andy Smith. (2023) Les strates de la smart city. Réseaux Pub. anticipées:0, pages I1-XXXVI.
Crossref
Alexander Nurse & Olivier Sykes. (2023) Levelling Up and The Privileging of sub-national governance in England in the inter-Brexit space . ZFW – Advances in Economic Geography 67:2-3, pages 161-171.
Crossref
Andrew Smith, Meredith Whitten & Marion Ernwein. (2023) De‐municipalisation? Legacies of austerity for England's urban parks. The Geographical Journal.
Crossref
Tamás Kaiser. (2023) Understanding Narratives in Governance: Naming and Framing Regional Inequality in the United Kingdom. Social Sciences 12:4, pages 246.
Crossref
Juliet Carpenter & David Valler. 2023. Urban Policy in the Framework of the 2030 Agenda. Urban Policy in the Framework of the 2030 Agenda 181 196 .
David Etherington, Martin Jones & Luke Telford. (2023) COVID crisis, austerity and the ‘Left Behind’ city: Exploring poverty and destitution in Stoke-on-Trent. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit 37:8, pages 692-707.
Crossref
Hilary Coyle & Laurence Ferry. (2022) Financial resilience! A comparative study of three lower tier authorities in England. Financial Accountability & Management 38:4, pages 686-702.
Crossref
Yuanshuo Xu, Yiwen Zhu, Yan Wu, Xiaoliang Wang & Weiwen Zhang. (2022) The Population Flow under Regional Cooperation of “City-Helps-City”: The Case of Mountain-Sea Project in Zhejiang. Land 11:10, pages 1816.
Crossref
Stephen Hincks & Ryan Powell. (2022) Territorial stigmatisation beyond the city: Habitus, affordances and landscapes of industrial ruination. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 54:7, pages 1391-1410.
Crossref
Paula Saukko & Amie Weedon. (2020) Self-tracking of/and time: From technological to biographical and political temporalities of work and sitting. New Media & Society 24:8, pages 1813-1829.
Crossref
Hannah HickmanJohn Sturzaker. (2022) Ethical principles in an increasingly diverse planning profession: the potential impact of different types of planners. Town Planning Review 93:3, pages 241-249.
Crossref
Laura Dixon & Lindsey Gaston. 2022. Events Mismanagement. Events Mismanagement.
Robin Hambleton, David Sweeting & Thom Oliver. (2021) Place, power and leadership: Insights from mayoral governance and leadership innovation in Bristol, UK. Leadership 18:1, pages 81-101.
Crossref
Justine Gangneux & Simon Joss. (2022) Crisis as driver of digital transformation? Scottish local governments’ response to COVID-19. Data & Policy 4.
Crossref
Giliberto Capano, Anthony R. Zito, Federico Toth & Jeremy RaynerGiliberto Capano, Anthony R. Zito, Federico Toth & Jeremy Rayner. 2022. Trajectories of Governance. Trajectories of Governance 45 74 .
Carlos Solar & Martin Smith. (2020) Decentralisation and central-local relations: the case of policing and mental health in England. British Politics 16:3, pages 254-271.
Crossref
Thomas Montgomery & Micaela Mazzei. (2021) Two paths of social innovation in the post-pandemic world. Social Enterprise Journal 17:3, pages 450-458.
Crossref
Andrew Smith. (2020) Sustaining municipal parks in an era of neoliberal austerity: The contested commercialisation of Gunnersbury Park. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 53:4, pages 704-722.
Crossref
Samantha Fletcher & William McGowan. (2020) The State of the UK funeral industry. Critical Social Policy 41:2, pages 249-269.
Crossref
Edward Yates & Ian Clark. (2018) The strategic economic governance of Greater Manchester’s local labour market by the local state: Implications for young workers. Economic and Industrial Democracy 42:1, pages 27-49.
Crossref
Julian Dobson, Jo Birch, Paul Brindley, John Henneberry, Kirsten McEwan, Meghann Mears, Miles Richardson & Anna Jorgensen. (2021) The magic of the mundane: The vulnerable web of connections between urban nature and wellbeing. Cities 108, pages 102989.
Crossref
Janice Morphet. 2021. Public Value Management, Governance and Reform in Britain. Public Value Management, Governance and Reform in Britain 227 257 .
Patria Román-Velázquez & Jessica RetisPatria Román-Velázquez & Jessica Retis. 2021. Narratives of Migration, Relocation and Belonging. Narratives of Migration, Relocation and Belonging 31 62 .
Alistair Jones & Colin Copus. 2021. Close Ties in European Local Governance. Close Ties in European Local Governance 105 115 .
Catherine Needham, Catherine Mangan, Karin Bottom & Steven Parker. 2021. The Palgrave Handbook of the Public Servant. The Palgrave Handbook of the Public Servant 955 973 .
Charlotte Hoole & Stephen Hincks. (2020) Performing the city-region: Imagineering, devolution and the search for legitimacy. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 52:8, pages 1583-1601.
Crossref
Thomas Ahrens, Laurence Ferry & Rihab Khalifa. (2020) Governmentality and counter-conduct: A field study of accounting amidst concurrent and competing rationales and programmes. Management Accounting Research 48, pages 100686.
Crossref
Yunji Kim, Austin M. Aldag & Mildred E. Warner. (2020) A Balanced View: Us Local Government Managers’ Perceptions of Fiscal Stress. Public Administration Quarterly 44:2, pages 172-200.
Crossref
Will Mason, Kate Morris, Calum Webb, Brigid Daniels, Brid Featherstone, Paul Bywaters, Nughmana Mirza, Jade Hooper, Geraldine Brady, Lisa Bunting & Jonathon Scourfield. (2019) Toward Full Integration of Quantitative and Qualitative Methods in Case Study Research: Insights From Investigating Child Welfare Inequalities. Journal of Mixed Methods Research 14:2, pages 164-183.
Crossref
Caroline Kuzemko & Jess Britton. (2020) Policy, politics and materiality across scales: A framework for understanding local government sustainable energy capacity applied in England. Energy Research & Social Science 62, pages 101367.
Crossref
Alexander NursePeter North. (2020) A place for climate in a time of capitalist crisis? A case study of low-carbon urban policy making in Liverpool, England. Town Planning Review 91:2, pages 155-178.
Crossref
Davina Cooper & Didi Herman. (2019) Doing activism like a state: Progressive municipal government, Israel/Palestine and BDS. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 38:1, pages 40-59.
Crossref
Ian Mell. (2020) The impact of austerity on funding green infrastructure: A DPSIR evaluation of the Liverpool Green & Open Space Review (LG&OSR), UK. Land Use Policy 91, pages 104284.
Crossref
Graham Pycock. (2020) London governance and the politics of neighbourhood planning: a case for investigation. Town Planning Review 91:1, pages 1-20.
Crossref
Julian Dobson & Nicola Dempsey. 2020. Naturally Challenged: Contested Perceptions and Practices in Urban Green Spaces. Naturally Challenged: Contested Perceptions and Practices in Urban Green Spaces 143 165 .
Meredith Whitten. 2020. Naturally Challenged: Contested Perceptions and Practices in Urban Green Spaces. Naturally Challenged: Contested Perceptions and Practices in Urban Green Spaces 87 116 .
Catherine Needham, Catherine Mangan, Karin Bottom & Steven Parker. 2020. The Palgrave Handbook of the Public Servant. The Palgrave Handbook of the Public Servant 1 19 .
Matthew Keeble, Jean Adams, Martin White, Carolyn Summerbell, Steven Cummins & Thomas Burgoine. (2019) Correlates of English local government use of the planning system to regulate hot food takeaway outlets: a cross-sectional analysis. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 16:1.
Crossref
Julian Dobson & Nicola Dempsey. (2019) Working out What Works: The Role of Tacit Knowledge Where Urban Greenspace Research, Policy and Practice Intersect. Sustainability 11:18, pages 5029.
Crossref
Edward TaylorFrédéric SantamariaJohn Sturzaker. (2019) Localism: a planning panacea?. Town Planning Review 90:5, pages 481-496.
Crossref
Alexander Nurse & Olivier Sykes. (2019) It’s more complicated than that!: Unpacking ‘Left Behind Britain’ and some other spatial tropes following the UK’s 2016 EU referendum. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit 34:6, pages 589-606.
Crossref
Colin Lorne, Ruth McDonald, Kieran Walshe & Anna Coleman. (2019) Regional assemblage and the spatial reorganisation of health and care: the case of devolution in Greater Manchester, England. Sociology of Health & Illness 41:7, pages 1236-1250.
Crossref
Gemma Lord. (2019) Profit, poverty and public care: austerity’s charity work. Journal of Organizational Ethnography 8:1, pages 68-81.
Crossref
Mark Sandford. (2019) Money talks: The finances of English Combined Authorities. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit 34:2, pages 106-122.
Crossref
Maximilian Lemprière & Vivien Lowndes. (2019) Why did the North East Combined Authority fail to achieve a devolution deal with the UK government?. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit 34:2, pages 149-166.
Crossref
Alexander Wilson, Mark Tewdwr-Jones & Rob Comber. (2017) Urban planning, public participation and digital technology: App development as a method of generating citizen involvement in local planning processes. Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science 46:2, pages 286-302.
Crossref
Liz Richardson, Catherine Durose & Rikki J. Dean. (2018) Why decentralize decision making? English local actors' viewpoints. Governance 32:1, pages 159-176.
Crossref
Alison Gardner. (2018) An Idea Whose Time Has Come? Modern Slavery, Multiple Streams Approach and Multilayer Policy Implementation. Journal of Human Rights Practice.
Crossref
Gerard Turley, Stephen McNena & Geraldine Robbins. (2018) Austerity and Irish local government expenditure since the Great Recession. Administration 66:4, pages 1-24.
Crossref
Crispian Fuller. (2018) Entrepreneurial urbanism, austerity and economic governance. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 11:3, pages 565-585.
Crossref
Christopher Brown & Athanasios (Sakis) Pappous. (2018) “The Legacy Element . . . It Just Felt More Woolly”: Exploring the Reasons for the Decline in People With Disabilities’ Sport Participation in England 5 Years After the London 2012 Paralympic Games. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 42:5, pages 343-368.
Crossref
Andrew Cumbers, Deirdre Shaw, John Crossan & Robert McMaster. (2017) The Work of Community Gardens: Reclaiming Place for Community in the City. Work, Employment and Society 32:1, pages 133-149.
Crossref
Vivien Lowndes & Maximilian Lemprière. (2017) Understanding Variation in Processes of Institutional Formation. Political Studies 66:1, pages 226-244.
Crossref
Rachael Coker. 2018. International Migrations and Local Governance. International Migrations and Local Governance 133 149 .
Phil Higson. (2017) From customer service to customer-driven services: Practitioner perspectives on a strategy for dealing with local authority austerity budgets. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit 32:7, pages 778-795.
Crossref
Annette Hastings, Nick Bailey, Glen Bramley & Maria Gannon. (2017) Austerity urbanism in England: The ‘regressive redistribution’ of local government services and the impact on the poor and marginalised. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 49:9, pages 2007-2024.
Crossref
Keith Shaw & Mark Tewdwr-Jones. (2017) “Disorganised Devolution”: Reshaping Metropolitan Governance in England in a Period of Austerity. Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning 75:3.
Crossref
Peter Eckersley. (2016) Cities and climate change: How historical legacies shape policy-making in English and German municipalities. Politics 37:2, pages 151-166.
Crossref
Crispian Fuller. (2016) City government in an age of austerity: Discursive institutions and critique. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 49:4, pages 745-766.
Crossref
Simon Bailey, Kath Checkland, Damian Hodgson, Anne McBride, Rebecca Elvey, Stephen Parkin, Katy Rothwell & Dean Pierides. (2017) The policy work of piloting: Mobilising and managing conflict and ambiguity in the English NHS. Social Science & Medicine 179, pages 210-217.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.