Advanced search
Publication Cover
European Planning Studies Volume 19, 2011 - Issue 12
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,833
Views
54
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Between Input Legitimacy and Output Efficiency: Defensive Routines and Agonistic Reflectivity in Nordic Land-Use Planning

Raine Mäntysalo Centre for Urban and Regional Studies, Aalto University, PO Box 2200, FIN-02015 TKK, Finland
,
Inger-Lise Saglie Department of Landscape Architecture and Spatial Planning, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, PO Box 5003, NO – 1432, Ås, NorwayCorrespondence[email protected]
&
Göran Cars Urban Planning and Environment, Royal Institute of Technology, Drottning Kristinas väg 30, 10044, Stockholm, Sweden
Pages 2109-2126 | Received 01 Oct 2009, Accepted 01 Aug 2010, Published online: 09 Dec 2011

Citations (54)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (30)

Kaisa Schmidt-Thomé & Johanna Lilius. (2023) Smart shrinkage and multi-locality – The appeal of hope, illustrated through Puolanka, a rural municipality in Finland. Urban, Planning and Transport Research 11:1.
Read now
Kristian Olesen. (2023) Reviving strategic spatial planning for the challenges ahead. European Planning Studies 31:11, pages 2318-2326.
Read now
Pia Bäcklund, Vesa Kanninen & Tomas Hanell. (2023) Accepting Depoliticisation? Council Members’ Attitudes Towards Public-Public Contracts in Spatial Planning. Planning Theory & Practice 24:2, pages 173-189.
Read now
Florencia Franzini, Sami Berghäll, Anne Toppinen & Ritva Toivonen. (2023) Planning for wooden multistorey construction – insights from Finland's municipal civil servants. European Planning Studies 31:1, pages 168-188.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Martin Westin & Hanna Mattila. (2023) Public Planner – A Deliberative Authority. Planning Theory & Practice 24:1, pages 11-29.
Read now
Camilo Calderon, Amelia Mutter, Martin Westin & Andrew Butler. (2022) Navigating swift and slow planning: planners’ balancing act in the design of participatory processes. European Planning Studies 0:0, pages 1-20.
Read now
John Pløger. (2021) Politics, planning, and ruling: the art of taming public participation. International Planning Studies 26:4, pages 426-440.
Read now
Abbas Ziafati Bafarasat, Eduardo Oliveira & Mark Baker. (2021) From concrete to abstract regional planning strategies in North West England: building and legitimizing discourses and mobilizing actors for spatial transformation?. Space and Polity 25:3, pages 283-305.
Read now
Jan Bröchner, Joanna Gregorowicz-Kipszak, Mathias Gustafsson & Anders Hagson. (2021) Accelerated planning for urban housing infills: coordination strategies. European Planning Studies 29:6, pages 1113-1131.
Read now
Susa Eräranta & Miloš N. Mladenović. (2021) Networked dynamics of knowledge integration in strategic spatial planning processes: a social network approach. Regional Studies 55:5, pages 870-882.
Read now
Terje Holsen. (2020) Negotiations Between Developers and Planning Authorities in Urban Development Projects. disP - The Planning Review 56:3, pages 34-46.
Read now
Sara Gustafsson, Sofia Päivärinne & Olof Hjelm. (2019) Strategic spatial planning – a missed opportunity to facilitate district heating systems based on excess heat. European Planning Studies 27:9, pages 1709-1726.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Johanna Tuomisaari, Kaisa Granqvist & Vesa Kanninen. (2019) The Strategic Incrementalism of Lahti Master Planning: Three Lessons. Planning Theory & Practice 20:4, pages 555-572.
Read now
Sara Gustafsson, Brita Hermelin & Lukas Smas. (2019) Integrating environmental sustainability into strategic spatial planning: the importance of management. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 62:8, pages 1321-1338.
Read now
Willem K. Korthals Altes. (2019) Multiple land use planning for living places and investments spaces. European Planning Studies 27:6, pages 1146-1158.
Read now
Sofie Storbjörk, Mattias Hjerpe & Erik Glaas. (2019) Using Public–Private Interplay to Climate-Proof Urban Planning? Critical Lessons from Developing a new Housing District in Karlstad, Sweden. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 62:4, pages 568-585.
Read now
Hanna Mattila. (2018) Public participation and legitimacy management in planning. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 100:4, pages 309-328.
Read now
Matti Fritsch & Heikki Eskelinen. (2018) Planning Strategically or by the Book?—Contentious Land Use Planning in South-eastern Finland. Planning Practice & Research 33:2, pages 137-153.
Read now
Reetta Salo & Raine Mäntysalo. (2017) Path dependencies and defensive routines in Finnish city-regional land-use policy cooperation: case Ristikytö. International Planning Studies 22:2, pages 128-144.
Read now
Bonnie J. Johnson, Mary Kay Peck & Steven A. Preston. (2017) City Managers Have Ethics Too? Comparing Planning and City Management Codes of Ethics. Journal of the American Planning Association 83:2, pages 183-201.
Read now
Sari Puustinen, Raine Mäntysalo, Jonne Hytönen & Karoliina Jarenko. (2017) The “deliberative bureaucrat”: deliberative democracy and institutional trust in the jurisdiction of the Finnish planner. Planning Theory & Practice 18:1, pages 71-88.
Read now
Niels Heeres, Taede Tillema & Jos Arts. (2016) Dealing with interrelatedness and fragmentation in road infrastructure planning: an analysis of integrated approaches throughout the planning process in the Netherlands. Planning Theory & Practice 17:3, pages 421-443.
Read now
Crystal Legacy, Gethin Davison & Edgar Liu. (2016) Delivering Social Housing: Examining the Nexus between Social Housing and Democratic Planning. Housing, Theory and Society 33:3, pages 324-341.
Read now
Jean-David Gerber. (2016) The managerial turn and municipal land-use planning in Switzerland – evidence from practice. Planning Theory & Practice 17:2, pages 192-209.
Read now
Terje Skjeggedal, Kjell Overvåg & jan åge Riseth. (2016) Land-Use Planning in Norwegian Mountain Areas: Local Development or Nature Protection?. European Planning Studies 24:2, pages 344-363.
Read now
R. Hrelja, M. Hjerpe & S. Storbjörk. (2015) Creating Transformative Force? The Role of Spatial Planning in Climate Change Transitions Towards Sustainable Transportation. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 17:5, pages 617-635.
Read now
Vitnarae Kang & Willem K. Korthals Altes. (2015) Flexibility and Public Accountability in Public Land Development Projects in Progress. European Planning Studies 23:8, pages 1609-1626.
Read now
Johanna Liljenfeldt. (2015) Legitimacy and Efficiency in Planning Processes—(How) Does Wind Power Change the Situation?. European Planning Studies 23:4, pages 811-827.
Read now
Raine Mäntysalo, Karoliina Jarenko, Kristina L. Nilsson & Inger-Lise Saglie. (2015) Legitimacy of Informal Strategic Urban Planning—Observations from Finland, Sweden and Norway. European Planning Studies 23:2, pages 349-366.
Read now
Håkan T. Sandersen & Ingrid Kvalvik. (2014) Sustainable Governance of Norwegian Aquaculture and the Administrative Reform: Dilemmas and Challenges. Coastal Management 42:5, pages 447-463.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (24)

Kriselda Sulcaj Gura, Elvira Nica, Tomas Kliestik & Félix Puime-Guillén. (2023) Circular economy in territorial planning strategy: Incorporation in cluster activities and economic zones. Environmental Technology & Innovation 32, pages 103357.
Crossref
Josje Bouwmeester, Jean-David Gerber, Thomas Hartmann & Deniz Ay. (2023) Non-compliance and non-enforcement: An unexpected outcome of flexible soft densification policy in the Netherlands. Land Use Policy 126, pages 106525.
Crossref
. (2023) Land-Use Planning in Municipalities as a Driver for Sustainable Residential Building in Finland: A Regional Innovation System Approach. Journal of Sustainability Research.
Crossref
Eirik Mikkelsen, Patrick Berg Sørdahl & Ann-Magnhild Solås. (2022) Transparent and consistent? Aquaculture impact assessments and trade-offs in coastal zone planning in Norway. Ocean & Coastal Management 225, pages 106150.
Crossref
John Pløger. (2021) Conflict, consent, dissensus: The unfinished as challenge to politics and planning. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 39:6, pages 1294-1309.
Crossref
Bozena Guziana. (2021) Only for Citizens? Local Political Engagement in Sweden and Inclusiveness of Terms. Sustainability 13:14, pages 7839.
Crossref
Hasan Muhammad Baniamin. (2020) Citizens’ inflated perceptions of the extent of democracy in different African countries: are individuals’ notions of the state an answer to the puzzle?Überhöhte Wahrnehmungen der Demokratiequalität in verschiedenen afrikanischen Ländern: Sind variierende Staatsverständnisse eine Antwort auf das Rätsel?. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft 14:4, pages 321-343.
Crossref
Fred Saunders, Michael Gilek, Anda Ikauniece, Ralph Voma Tafon, Kira Gee & Jacek Zaucha. (2020) Theorizing Social Sustainability and Justice in Marine Spatial Planning: Democracy, Diversity, and Equity. Sustainability 12:6, pages 2560.
Crossref
Roar Amdam. (2019) Strukturelle vilkår for medverking i kommunalplanlegging og politikk under tre ulike styringssystem. Kart og Plan 112:4, pages 282-298.
Crossref
Alexander Woestenburg, Erwin van der Krabben & Tejo Spit. (2019) Legitimacy Dilemmas in Direct Government Intervention: The Case of Public Land Development, an Example from the Netherlands. Land 8:7, pages 110.
Crossref
Johannes Klein & Sirkku Juhola. (2018) The Influence of Administrative Traditions and Governance on Private Involvement in Urban Climate Change Adaptation. Review of Policy Research 35:6, pages 930-952.
Crossref
Bonnie J. Johnson. (2018) Planners as leaders: finding their comfort zone. International Journal of Public Leadership 14:3, pages 155-178.
Crossref
Eduardo Oliveira & Anna M. Hersperger. (2018) Governance arrangements, funding mechanisms and power configurations in current practices of strategic spatial plan implementation. Land Use Policy 76, pages 623-633.
Crossref
Kristina Grange. (2016) Planners – A silenced profession? The politicisation of planning and the need for fearless speech. Planning Theory 16:3, pages 275-295.
Crossref
Jonne Hytönen. (2014) The problematic relationship of communicative planning theory and the Finnish legal culture. Planning Theory 15:3, pages 223-238.
Crossref
Johannes Klein, Raine Mäntysalo & Sirkku Juhola. (2015) Legitimacy of urban climate change adaptation: a case in Helsinki. Regional Environmental Change 16:3, pages 815-826.
Crossref
Jonne Hytönen, Raine Mäntysalo, Lasse Peltonen, Vesa Kanninen, Petteri Niemi & Miska Simanainen. (2013) Defensive routines in land use policy steering in Finnish urban regions. European Urban and Regional Studies 23:1, pages 40-55.
Crossref
Hege Hofstad. (2015) Handling Tensions in the ‘Everyday Landscape’: Moving beyond the Development—Conservation Conflict?. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 33:2, pages 358-375.
Crossref
Crystal Legacy & Ryan van den Nouwelant. (2015) Negotiating Strategic Planning's Transitional Spaces: The Case of ‘Guerrilla Governance’ in Infrastructure Planning. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 47:1, pages 209-226.
Crossref
Tor Håkon Inderberg, Knut Bjørn Stokke & Marte Winsvold. 2015. Handbook of Climate Change Adaptation. Handbook of Climate Change Adaptation 1287 1304 .
Kaisa Schmidt-Thomé & Raine Mäntysalo. (2013) Interplay of power and learning in planning processes: A dynamic view. Planning Theory 13:2, pages 115-135.
Crossref
Tor Håkon Inderberg, Knut Bjørn Stokke & Marte Winsvold. 2021. Handbook of Climate Change Adaptation. Handbook of Climate Change Adaptation 1 15 .
Hege Hofstad. (2013) Planning Models in Sweden and Norway: Nuancing the Picture. Scandinavian Political Studies 36:3, pages 270-292.
Crossref
Vesa Kanninen, Pia Bäcklund & Raine Mäntysalo. 2013. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone. Urban Planning as a Trading Zone 159 177 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.